A modified version of Sampson and Laub's integrative conflict perspective, which emphasizes structural contingencies, racial stereotyping, and punitiveness, is used to understand the influence of race on diversionary decision making at intake in three juvenile courts in the state of Iowa. The authors hypothesized that in a jurisdiction that has greater economic and racial inequality and personnel that adhere to beliefs in racial differences and retribution, African Americans, particularly those charged with drug offenses, would receive greater social control than similarly situated whites. The results provide partial support for the hypothesis. The discussion focuses on the need to broaden the scope of the search for the contingencies of decision making, to employ multiple research methodologies, and to refine conflict theory to account for the differential treatment of African American youth.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Agresti, A.1989. “Tutorial on Modeling Ordered Categorical Response Data.”Psychologist Bulletin105:290-301.
2.
Albonetti, C.1991. “An Integration of Theories to Explain Judicial Discretion.”Social Problems38:247-266.
3.
Albonetti, C.
and J. Hepburn. 1996. “Prosecutorial Discretion to Defer Criminalization: The Effects of Defendant's Ascribed and Achieved Status Characteristics.”Journal of Quantitative Criminology12 (1): 63-81.
4.
Anderson, E.
1990. Street Wise: Race, Class, and Change in an Urban Community. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
5.
Arneil, J. 1993. “The Influence of Race on Juvenile Justice Decision Making in Iowa: An Analysis of Involvement in Diversionary Programs at the Intake Stage.” Master's thesis, University of Nebraska at Omaha.
6.
Bailey, F.
1996. “The Tangle of Pathology and the Lower Class African-American Family: Historical and Social Science Perspectives.” P. 49 in Justice with Prejudice, edited by M. Lynch and E. Britt Patterson. New York: Harrow and Heston.
7.
Beasley, D.
, E. Kuh, and R. Welsch. 1980. Regression Diagnostics Identifying Influential Data and Source of Collinearity. New York: John Wiley.
8.
Bell, D.
and K. Lang. 1985. “The Intake Dispositions of Juvenile Offenders.”Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency22:309-328.
9.
Bishop, D.
and C. Frazier. 1988. “The Influence of Race in Juvenile Justice Processing.”Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency25:242-263.
10.
Blomberg, T. G.1983. “Diversion's Disparate Results and Unresolved Questions: An Integrative Evaluation Perspective.”Crime & Delinquency20:24-38.
Bortner, M.
and W. Reed. 1985. “Race and the Impact of Juvenile Deinstitutionalization.”Crime & Delinquency31:35-46.
13.
Bridges, G.
and R. Crutchfield. 1988. “Law, Social Standing and Racial Disparities in Imprisonment.”Social Forces66:699-724.
14.
Bryk, A.
and S. Raudenbush. 1992. Hierarchical Linear Models. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
15.
Bureau of the Census
. 1990. 1990 Census of Population: General Population Characteristics. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
16.
Carroll, J.1978. “Casual Attributions in Expert Parole Decisions.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology36:1501.
17.
Carter, T. J.
and D. Clelland. 1979. “A Neo-Marxian Critique: Formulation and Test of Juvenile Dispositions as a Function of Social Class.”Social Problems27:96.
18.
Chambliss, W.
and R. Seidman. 1971. Law, Order and Power. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
19.
Cicourel, A.
1968. The Social Organization of Juvenile Justice. New York: John Wiley.
20.
Cohen, L.
and J. Kleugel. 1979. “Selecting Delinquents for Adjudication: An Analysis of Intake Screening Decisions in Two Metropolitan Juvenile Courts.”Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency10:143-163.
21.
Conley, D.1994. “Adding Color to a Black and White Picture: Using Qualitative Data to Explain Racial Disproportionality in the Juvenile Justice System.”Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency31:135-148.
22.
Crew, B. K.1991. “Race Differences in Felony Charging and Sentencing: Toward an Integration of Decision Making and Negotiation Models.”Journal of Crime and Justice14:99-122.
23.
Dannefer, S.
and R. Schutt. 1982. “Race and Juvenile Justice Processing in Court and Police Agencies.”American Journal of Sociology87:1113.
24.
Davis, T. L.
, L. Severy, S. Kraus, and J. Whitaker. 1993. “Predictors of Sentencing Decisions: The Beliefs, Personality Variables, and Demographic Factors of Juvenile Justice Personnel.”Journal of Applied Social Psychology23:451.
25.
Equality in the Courts Task Force
. 1993. “Final Report of the Equality in the Courts Task Force.” Paper prepared by the Supreme Court of Iowa, Des Moines, Iowa.
26.
Fagan, J.
, E. Slaughter, and E. Hartstone. 1987. “Blind Justice? The Impact of Race on the Juvenile Justice Process.”Crime & Delinquency33:224-254.
27.
Farnworth, M.
and P. Horan. 1980. “Separate Justice: An Analysis of Race Differences in Court Processes.”Social Science Research9:381-399.
28.
Farnworth, M.
, R. Teske, and G. Thurman. 1991. “Ethnic and Minority Disparity in Felony Court Processing.” Pp. 54-70 in Race and Criminal Justice, edited by M. Lynch and B. B. Patterson. New York: Harrow and Heston.
29.
Feld, B.1991. “Justice by Geography: Urban, Suburban, and Rural Variations in Juvenile Justice Administration.”Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology82:156-210.
30.
Fenwick, C. R.1982. “Juvenile Court Intake Decision Making: The Importance of Family Affiliation.”Journal of Criminal Justice10:443-453.
31.
Frazier, C.
, D. Bishop, and J. Henretta. 1992. “The Social Context of Race Differentials in Juvenile Justice Dispositions.”Sociology Quarterly33:447-458.
32.
Frazier, C.
, P. Richards, and R. H. Potter. 1983. “Juvenile Diversion and Net Widening: Toward a Clarification of Assessment Strategies.”Human Organization42:115-121.
33.
Georges-Abeiye, D.1989. “William Wilbanks: The Myth of a Racist Criminal Justice System.”The Critical Criminologist1:4-5.
34.
Gottfredson, M.
and T. Hirschi. 1990. A General Theory of Crime. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
35.
Hampariaran, Donna
and Michael J. Leiber. 1997. “Disproportionate Confinement of Minority Juveniles in Secure Facilities: 1996 National Report.” Prepared for the Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention, Champaign, Illinois, Community Research Associates.
36.
Hasenfeld, Y.
and P. Cheung. 1985. “The Juvenile Court as a People-Processing Organization: A Political Economy Perspective.”American Journal of Sociology90:801-824.
37.
Hirschi, T.
1969. The Causes of Delinquency. Berkeley: University of California Press.
38.
Humphrey, J.
and T. Fogarty. 1987. “Race and Plea Bargains.”Social Forces6:176-182.
39.
Jackson, P. I.
1992. “Minority Group Threat, Social Context, and Policing.” Pp. 89-102 in Social Threat and Social Control, edited by A. E. Liska. Albany: State University of New York Press.
40.
Kuker, D.
1991. “The Disproportionate Overrepresentation of Minority Youth in Secure Facilities.” Paper prepared by the Department of Human Rights, Criminal and Juvenile Justice Planning Statistical Analysis Center, Des Moines, Iowa.
41.
LaFree, G.1980. “The Effect of Sexual Stratification by Race on Official Reactions to Rape.”American Sociological Review45:842-854.
42.
Latessa, E. J.
, L. Travis, and G. Wilson. 1984. “Juvenile Diversion: Factors Related to Decision Making and Outcome.” Pp. 145-165 in Juvenile Justice Policy, edited by S. H. Decker. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
43.
Leiber, M.
1993. “The Disproportionate Overrepresentation of Minority Youth in Secure Facilities: A Survey of Decision Makers and Delinquents.” Paper prepared for the State Juvenile Advisory Group of Iowa and the Office of Criminal and Juvenile Justice Planning, Des Moines, Iowa, and the Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention.
44.
Leiber, M.1994. “A Comparison of Juvenile Court Outcomes for Native Americans, African Americans and Whites.”Justice Quarterly11:257-279.
45.
Leiber, M.1995. “Toward Clarification of the Concept of Minority Status and Decision Making in Juvenile Court Proceedings.”Journal of Crime and Justice18:79-108.
46.
Leiber, M.
and K. Jamieson. 1995. “Race and Decision Making within Juvenile Justice: The Importance of Context.”Journal of Quantitative Criminology11:363.
47.
Leiber, M.
, M. Nalla, and M. Farnworth. 1998. “Explaining Juvenile Attitudes Toward the Police.”Justice Quarterly15:151-174.
48.
Leiber, M.
and A. Woodrick. 1995. “Theoretical and Empirical Developments in the Study of Race and Juvenile Court Processing.”Journal of Social Pathology1:149-164.
49.
Leiber, M.
and A. Woodrick. 1997. “Religious Beliefs, Attribution Styles, and Adherence to Correctional Orientations.”Criminal Justice and Behavior24 (4): 4495-4511.
50.
Leiber, M.
, A. Woodrick, and E. M. Roudebush. 1995. “Religion, Discriminatory Attitudes and the Orientations of Juvenile Justice Personnel: A Research Note.”Criminology33:431-449.
51.
Liska, A.1987. “A Critical Examination of Macro Perspectives on Crime Control.”Annual Review of Sociology13:67-88.
52.
Liska, A.
and M. Tausig. 1979. “Theoretical Interpretations of Social Class and Racial Differences in Legal Decision Making for Juveniles.”Sociology Quarterly20: 197-207.
53.
Mann, Coramae Richey
. 1993. Unequal Justice: A Question of Color. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
54.
McCarthy, B.
and B. Smith. 1986. “The Conceptualization of Discrimination in the Juvenile Justice Process: The Impact of Administrative Factors and Screening Decisions on Juvenile Court Decisions.”Criminology24:41-64.
55.
McGarrell, E.1993. “Trends in Racial Disproportionality in Juvenile Court Processing: 1985-1989.”Crime & Delinquency39:29-48.
56.
Moore, R.
and D. Kuker. 1993. “A Description and Discussion of Minority Overrepresentation in Iowa's Juvenile Justice System.” Paper prepared by the Division of Criminal and Juvenile Justice Planning, Des Moines, Iowa.
57.
Myers, M.1989. “Symbolic Policy and the Sentencing of Drug Offenders.”Law and Society23:295.
58.
Myers, M.
and S. Talarico. 1986. “The Social Contexts of Racial Discrimination in Sentencing.”Social Problems33:237-250.
59.
Nalla, M.
, M. Lynch, and M. Leiber. 1997. “Determinants of Police Growth in Phoenix, 1950-1988.”Justice Quarterly14(1):115-141.
60.
Peterson, R.
and J. Hagan. 1984. “Changing Conceptions of Race: Toward an Account of Anomalous Findings of Sentencing Research.”American Sociological Review49:56-70.
61.
Platt, A.
1977. The Child Savers: The Invention of Delinquency. 2d ed.Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
62.
Pope, C.1978. “Post-Arrest Release Decisions: An Empirical Examination of Social and Legal Criteria.”Journal of Research and Delinquency15:35-53.
63.
Pope, C.
1995. “Equity within the Juvenile Justice System: Directions for the Future.” Pp. 201-216 in Minorities in Juvenile Justice, edited by K. Leonard, C. Pope, and W. Feyerherm. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
64.
Pope, C.
and W. Feyerherm. 1990. “Minority Status and Juvenile Justice Processing: An Assessment of the Research Literature (Parts I and II).”Criminal Justice AbstractsJune, 327-385; September, 527-542.
65.
Popper, K.
1968. The Logic of Scientific Knowledge. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
66.
Quinney, R.
1970. The Social Reality of Crime. Boston: Little, Brown.
67.
Sampson, R.1986. “Effects of Socioeconomic Context on Official Reaction to Juvenile Delinquency.”American Sociological Review51:876-886.
68.
Sampson, R.
and J. Laub. 1993. “Structural Variations in Juvenile Court Processing: Inequality, the Underclass, and Social Control.”Law and Sociology Review27:285-311.
69.
Schneider, P.
, W. Griffith, and A. Schneider. 1982. “Juvenile Restitution as a Sole Sanction or Condition of Probation: An Empirical Analysis.”Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency19:47-65.
70.
Snyder, H.
1990. Growth in Minority Detentions Attributed to Drug Law Violators. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention.
71.
Snyder, H.
and M. Sickmund. 1995. Juvenile Offenders and Victims: A Focus on Violence. Washington, DC: Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention.
72.
Spohn, C.
1994. “Crime and the Social Control of Black Offender/Victim Race and the Sentencing of Violent Offenders.” Pp. 249-268 in Inequality, Crime & Social Control, edited by G. Bridges and M. Meyers. Boulder, CO: Westview.
73.
Spohn, C.
, J. Gruhl, and S. Welch. 1981-82. “The Effect of Race on Sentencing Disparities: A Reexamination of an Unsettled Question.”Law and Sociology Review16:71-88.
74.
Spohn, C.
, J. Gruhl, and S. Welch. 1987. “The Impact of the Ethnicity and Gender of Defendants on the Decision to Reject or Dismiss Felony Charges.”Criminology25:175-192.
75.
Thornberry, T.1979. “Sentencing Disparities in the Juvenile Justice System.”Journal of Law and Criminology64:163-171.
76.
Tittle, C.
and D. Curran. 1988. “Contingencies for Dispositional Disparities in Juvenile Justice.”Social Forces67:23-58.
77.
Tomkins, A.1990. “Dispositional Decision Making in the Juvenile Justice System: An Empirical Study of the Use of Offence and Offender Information.”Nebraska Law Review69:298-345.
78.
Tonry, M.
1995. Malign Neglect: Race, Crime and Punishment in America. New York: Oxford University Press.
79.
Weber, M.
1969. Max Weber on Law in Economy and Society. Translated by M. Rheinstein. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
80.
Welch, S.
, C. Spohn, and J. Gruhl. 1985. “Convicting and Sentencing: Differences among Black, Hispanic and White Males in Six Localities.”Justice Quarterly2:67-77.
81.
Wilbanks, W.
1987. The Myth of a Racist Criminal Justice System. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.
82.
Willie, C. F.
1991. A New Look at Black Families. 4th ed.New York: General Hall.
83.
Wilson, W.
1987. The Truly Disadvantaged: The Inner City, the Underclass, and Public Policy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
84.
Wilson, W.
1997. When Work Disappears: The World of the New Urban Poor. New York: Knopf.
85.
Zatz, M.1987. “The Changing Forms of Racial/Ethnic Biases in Sentencing.”Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency24:69-92.
