The Interethnic Generalizability of Social Control Theory: An Empirical Test

Abstract

Social control theory is used to model the self-reported delinquency in a sample of 788 Surinamese, Moroccan, Turkish, and Dutch boys (all living in the Netherlands). Four hypotheses are tested: (a) social bonding variables predict variations in general delinquent involvement among Turkish, Surinamese, Moroccan, and Dutch male youths; (b) social bonding variables predict variations in a variety of types of delinquency involvement and deviance among Turkish, Moroccan, Surinamese, and Dutch male youths; (c) delinquent friends play the same role in the causation of general delinquency among Turkish, Moroccan, Surinamese, and Dutch male youths; and (d) the dimensions of the social bond are interrelated in the same way among all four ethnic groups. The multivariate analyses support the key propositions. The variables most consistently related to delinquency among the four samples are beliefs in conventional values, virtual (family) supervision, (school) conflict, and participation in unconventional leisure activities.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Agnew, Robert . 1991. “The Interactive Effect of Peer Variables on Delinquency.” Criminology 29:47-72.

Agnew, Robert and David Petersen . 1989. “Leisure and Delinquency.” Social Problems 36:332-348.

Akers, Ronald L. 1994. Criminological Theories: Introduction and Evaluation. Los Angeles: Roxbury.

Albrecht, Hans-Jorg . 1987. “Foreign Minorities and the Criminal Justice System in the Federal Republic of Germany.” Howard Journal of Criminal Justice 6:172-186.

Amdur, Richard L. 1989. “Testing Causal Models of Delinquency: A Methodological Critique.” Criminal Justice and Behavior 16:35-62.

Austin, Roy L. 1978. “Race, Father Absence and Female Delinquency.” Criminology 15:487-504.

Bonger, Willem A. 1943. Race and Crime. New York: Columbia University Press.

Brennan, Patricia , Sarnoff Mednick , and Richard John . 1989. “Specialisation in Violence: Evidence of a Criminal Subgroup.” Criminology 27:437-454.

Bruinsma, Gerben J. N. 1992. “Differential Association Theory Reconsidered: An Extension and Its Empirical Test.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology 8:29-50.

10.

Campfens, Hubert . 1979. The Integration of Ethno-Cultural Minorities—A Pluralist Approach: The Netherlands and Canada—A Comparative Analysis of Policy and Programme. The Hague, Netherlands: Ministry of Cultural Affairs, Recreation, and Social Welfare.

11.

Centraal Bureau von de Statistiek . 1996. Statistisch Jaarboek, 1996. The Hague, Netherlands: CBS publikaties.

12.

Cernkovitch, Stephen A. and Peggy C. Giordano . 1987. “Family Relationships and Delinquency.” Criminology 25:295-321.

13.

Cernkovitch, Stephen A. and Peggy C. Giordano . 1992. “School Bonding, Race, and Delinquency.” Criminology 30 (2): 261-291.

14.

Curran, Daniel J. and Claire M Renzetti . 1994. Theories of Crime. Boston: Allyn & Bacon.

15.

Dembo, Richard , Linda Williams , Werner Wothke , James Schmeidler , Alan Getreau , Estrellita Berry , and Eric D. Wish . 1992. “The Generality of Deviance: Replication of a Structural Model Among High-Risk Youths.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 29:200-216.

16.

Donovan, John E. and Richard Jessor . 1985. “Structure of Problem Behavior in Adolescence and Young Adulthood.” Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 53:890-904.

17.

Donovan, John E. Richard Jessor , and Frances M. Costa . 1988. “Syndrome of Problem Behavior in Adolescence: A Replication.” Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 56:762-765.

18.

Edwards, Willie J. 1993. “Predicting Juvenile Delinquency: A Review of Correlates and a Confirmation by Recent Research Based on an Integrated Theoretical Model.” Justice Quarterly 9:553-586.

19.

Elliott Delbert S. , David Huizinga , and Suzanne S. Ageton . 1985. Explaining Delinquency and Drug Use. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.

20.

Eve, Raymond . 1978. “A Study of the Efficacy and Interactions of Several Theories for Explaining Rebelliousness Among High School Students.” Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 69:115-125.

21.

Fagan, Jeffrey and Sandra Wexler . 1987. “Family Origins of Violent Delinquents.” Criminology 25:643-669.

22.

Farrington, David P. , Howard N. Snyder , and Terrence A. Finnegan . 1988. “Specialization in Juvenile Court Careers.” Criminology 26:461-488.

23.

FitzGerald, M. 1995. “Minorities, Crime and Criminal Justice in Britain.” Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Society of Criminology, Boston.

24.

Friedman, Jennifer and Dennis Rosenbaum . 1988. “Social Control Theory: The Salience of Components by Age, Gender, and Type of Crime.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology 4:363-381.

25.

Georges-Abeyie, Daniel E. 1989. “Race, Ethnicity, and the Spatial Dynamic: Towards a Realistic Study of Black Crime, Crime Victimization, and Criminal Justice Processing of Blacks.” Social Justice 16 (4): 35-54.

26.

Gottfredson, Michael R. and Travis Hirschi . 1990. A General Theory of Crime. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.

27.

de Haan, Willem . 1995. “Minorities, Crime and Criminal Justice in the Netherlands.” Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Society of Criminology, Boston.

28.

Hacker, Andrew . 1992. Two Nations, Black and White, Separate, Hostile, Unequal. New York: Ballantine Books.

29.

Hagan, John . 1992. “The Poverty of a Classless Criminology.” Criminology 30:1-20.

30.

Harris, Anthony R. and Lisa Meidlinger . 1995. “Criminal Behavior: Race and Class.” In Criminology, edited by Joseph F. Sheley . Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.

31.

Hawkins, Darnell F. 1986. Homicide Among Black Americans. Lanham, MD: University Press of America.

32.

Hindelang, Michael J. , T. Hirschi , and J. G. Weis . 1981. Measuring Delinquency. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.

33.

Hirschi, Travis . 1969. Causes of Delinquency. Berkeley: University of California Press.

34.

Huizinga, David and Delbert S. Elliott . 1986. “Reassessing the Reliability and Validity of Self-Report Delinquency Measures.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology 2:293-327.

35.

Huizinga, David , Finn-Aage Esbensen , and Anne Wylie Weiher . 1991. “Are There Multiple Paths to Delinquency?” Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 82:83-118.

36.

Johnson, Richard E. 1979. Juvenile Delinquency and Its Origins. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.

37.

Junger, Marianne . 1989. “Discrepancies Between Police and Self-Report Data for Dutch Racial Minorities.” British Journal of Criminology 29:273-283.

38.

Junger, Marianne . 1990. Delinquency and Ethnicity: An Investigation on Social Factors Relating to Delinquency Among Moroccan, Turkish, Surinamese and Dutch Boys. Deventer, Netherlands: Kluwer Law and Taxation.

39.

Junger, Marianne and Wim Polder . 1992. “Some Explanations of Crime Among Four Ethnic Groups in the Netherlands.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology 8:51-79.

40.

Junger, Marianne and Wim Polder . 1993. “Religiosity Among Ethnic Groups in the Netherlands.” British Journal of Criminology 33:416-435.

41.

Junger-Tas, Josine . 1977. “Hidden Delinquency and Judicial Selection in Belgium.” In Youth Crime and Juvenile Justice, edited by Paul C. Friday and V. Lorne Stewart . New York: Praeger.

42.

Junger-Tas, Josine . 1985. “Allochtonen in Nederland: Een Inleiding” [Immigrants in the Netherlands: An Introduction]. Justitiële Verkenningen 11 (3): 1-33.

43.

Junger-Tas, Josine . 1988. “Causal Factors: Social Control Theory.” In Juvenile Delinquency in the Netherlands, edited by J. Junger-Tas and R. L. Block . Amstelveen, Netherlands: Kugler.

44.

Kandel, Denise and Mark Davies . 1991. “Friendship Networks, Intimacy, and Illicit Drug Use in Adulthood: A Comparison of Two Competing Theories.” Criminology 29:441-471.

45.

Kempf, Kimberly L. 1993. “The Empirical Status of Hirschi's Social Control Theory.” In New Directions in Criminological Research, Vol. 4, edited by Freda Adler and William S. Lauder . New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction.

46.

Kornhauser, Ruth R. 1978. Social Sources of Delinquency: An Appraisal of Analytic Models. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

47.

Leblanc, Marc . 1994. “Family, School, Delinquency and Criminality: The Predictive Power of an Elaborated Social Control Theory for Males.” Criminal Behavior and Mental Health 4 (2): 101-117.

48.

LeGrande, Gardner and Donald J. Shoemaker . 1989. “Social Bonding and Delinquency.” Sociological Quarterly 30:481-500.

49.

Liska, Allen E. and Mark D. Reed . 1985. “Ties to Conventional Institutions and Delinquency: Estimating Reciprocal Effects.” American Sociological Review 50:547-560.

50.

Loeber, Rolf and Danette Waller . 1988. “Artefacts in Delinquency Specialisation and Generalisation Studies.” British Journal of Criminology 28:461-477.

51.

Mak, Anita S. 1990. “Testing a Psychosocial Control Theory of Delinquency.” Criminal Justice and Behavior 17:215-230.

52.

Mak, Anita S. 1991. “Psychosocial Control Characteristics of Delinquents and Non-Delinquents.” Criminal Justice and Behavior 18:287-303.

53.

Mann, Coramae Richey . 1993. Unequal Justice: A Question of Color. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.

54.

Marshall, Ineke Haen . 1996. “De methode van zelfrapportage: Aanzet tot een rationele benadering” [The Self-Report Method: Toward a Rational Approach]. Tijdschrift voor Criminologie 38:2-20.

55.

Maxfield, Michael G. and Earl Babbie . 1995. Research Methods for Criminal Justice and Criminology. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.

56.

Meloen, J. D. and J. Veenman . 1990. Het is maar de vraag: Onderzoek naar responseffecten bij minderhedensurveys [Research on Response Effects in Minority Surveys]. Lelystad, Netherlands: Koninklijke Vermande BV.

57.

Merton, Robert K. 1976. Social Theory and Social Structure. New York: Macmillan.

58.

Muus, P. J. 1987. Migration, Minorities, and Policy in the Netherlands: Recent Trends and Developments. Amsterdam, Netherlands: Institute for Social Geography.

59.

Naroll, Raoul , Gary L. Michik , and Frada Naroll . 1974. “Hologeistic Theory Testing.” In Comparative Studies by Harold E. Driver and Essays in His Honor, edited by Joseph G. Jorgensen . New Haven, CT: Human Relations Area Files Press.

60.

O'Brien, Robert M. 1985. Crime and Victimization Data. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.

61.

Osgood, Wayne D. 1990. “Covariation Among Adolescent Problem Behaviours.” Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Society of Criminology, Baltimore, MD.

62.

Osgood, Wayne D. , Lloyd D. Johnston , Patrick M. O'Malley , and Jerald G. Bachman . 1988. “The Generality of Deviance in Late Adolescence and Early Adulthood.” American Sociological Review 53:81-93.

63.

Paternoster, Raymond and Ruth Triplett . 1988. “Disaggregating Self-Reported Delinquency and Its Implications for Theory.” Criminology 26:591-626.

64.

Penninx, Rinus . 1988. Minderheidsvorming en Emancipatie: Balans van Kennisverwerving ten Aanzien van Immigranten en Woonwagenbewoners [Minority Formation and Emancipation: An Evaluation of Knowledge With Respect to Immigrants and Caravan Dwellers]. Alphen aan den Rijn, Netherlands: Samsom.

65.

Quinney, Richard . 1980. Class, State, and Crime, 2nd ed. New York: Longman.

66.

Rodriguez, Orlando and David Weisburd . 1991. “The Integrated Social Control Model and Ethnicity.” Criminal Justice and Behavior 18:464-479.

67.

Rooduijn, Jeroen M. and Jan J. Latten . 1986. De Leefstituatie van Turken en Marokkanen in Nederland [The Situation of Turks and Moroccans in the Netherlands]. The Hague, Netherlands: Staatsuitgeverij, CBS publikaties.

68.

Rosen, Lawrence . 1985. “Family and Delinquency: Structure or Function.” Criminology 23:553-571.

69.

Rowe, David C. , Wayne D. Osgood , and Allan W. Nicewander . 1990. “A Latent Trait Approach to Unifying Criminal Careers.” Criminology 28:237-300.

70.

Rowe, David C. , Alexander T. Vazsonyi , and Daniel J. Flannery . 1994. “No More Than Skin Deep: Ethnic and Racial Similarity in Developmental Process.” Psychological Review 101:396-413.

71.

Sampson, Robert J. and John H. Laub . 1993. Crime in the Making: Pathways and Turning Points Through Life. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

72.

Scientific Council for Government Policy . 1989. Allochtonenbeleid [Policy on Immigrants]. Report No. 36. The Hague, Netherlands: Staatsuitgeverij.

73.

Shaw, Clifford and Robert McKay . 1942. Juvenile Delinquency and Urban Areas. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

74.

Siegel, Larry . 1995. Criminology, 5th ed. Minneapolis, MN: West.

75.

Silberman, Charles E. 1978. Criminal Violence, Criminal Justice. New York: Random House.

76.

Sociaal Cultureel Planbureau . 1995. Rapportage minderheden 1995 [Overview of Ethnic Minorities 1995]. Rijswijk, Netherlands: Sociaal Cultureel Planbureau.

77.

Stander, Julian , David P. Farrington , Gillain Hill , and Patricia M. E. Altham . 1989. “Markov Chain Analysis and Specialization in Criminal Careers.” British Journal of Criminology 29:317-335.

78.

Stitt, Grant B. and David J. Giacopassi . 1992. “Trends in the Connectivity of Theory and Research in Criminology.” The Criminologist 17:3-6.

79.

Sutherland, Edwin H. and Donald R. Cressey . 1974. Criminology. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott.

80.

Teilman, K. S. 1976. “Sources of Bias in Self-Reported Delinquency.” Ph.D. dissertation, University of Southern California.

81.

Thornberry, Terence P. 1987. “Towards an Interactional Theory of Delinquency.” Criminology 25:863-892.

82.

Thornberry, Terence P. , Alan J. Lizotte , Marvin D. Krohn , Margaret Farnworth , and Sung Joon Lang . 1994. “Delinquent Peers, Beliefs and Delinquent Behavior: A Longitudinal Test of Interactional Theory.” Criminology 32:47-83.

83.

Tonry, Michael . 1995. Malign Neglect: Race, Crime and Punishment in America. Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.

84.

van der Erf, R. F. 1989. “Beleidsrelevante migranten groepen demografisch gezien” [Policy Relevant Migrants From a Demographical Point of View]. Migrantenstudies 5:11-24.

85.

van Imhoff, Evert , Jeanette Schoorl , Rob van der Erf , and Nicole van der Gaag . 1994. Regionale prognose bevolking van Turkse, Marokkaanse, Surinaamse of Antilliaanse afkomst, 1992-2000 [Regional Prognosis of the Population of Turkish, Moroccan, Surinamese or Antillian Descent, 1992-2000]. Report No. 33. The Hague, Netherlands: Netherlands Interdisciplinary Demographic Institute.

86.

von Hofer, H. and H. Tham . 1991. Foreign Citizens and Crime: The Swedish Case. Stockholm: Statistics Sweden.

87.

Wallace, John H. and Jerald G. Bachman . 1991. “Explaining Racial/Ethnic Differences in Adolescent Drug Use: The Impact of Background and Lifestyle.” Social Problems 38:333-357.

88.

Wardak, Ali . 1995. “Social Control Theory: An Empirical Test Among Deviant and Non-Deviant Boys in Edinburgh.” Paper presented at the British Criminology Conference, Loughborough, England.

89.

Warr, Mark . 1993. “Age, Peers and Delinquency.” Criminology 31:17-40.

90.

Wells, Edward L. and Joseph H. Rankin . 1988. “Direct Parental Controls and Delinquency.” Criminology 26:263-285.

91.

Werdmólder, Hans and Peter Meel . 1993. “Jeugdige allochtonen en criminaliteit” [Ethnic Minority Youth and Crime]. Tijdschrift voor Criminologie 35:252-276.

92.

Wiatrowski, Michael D. , David B. Griswold , and Mary K. Roberts . 1981. “Social Control Theory and Delinquency.” American Sociological Review 46:525-541.