Increasing evidence shows great diversity in the effects of the criminal sanction. Legal punishment either reduces, increases, or has no effect on future crimes, depending on the type of offenders, offenses, social settings, and levels of analysis. A theory of “defiance” helps explain the conditions under which punishment increases crime. Procedural justice (fairness or legitimacy) of experienced punishment is essential for the acknowledgment of shame, which conditions deterrence; punishment perceived as unjust can lead to unacknowledged shame and defiant pride that increases future crime. Both “specific” defiance by individuals and “general” defiance by collectivities results from punishment perceived as unfair or excessive, unless deterrent effects counterbalance defiance and render the net effect of sanctions irrelevant. By implication, crime might be reduced more by police and courts treating all citizens with fairness and respect than by increasing punishments. A variety of research designs can be used to test, refine, or reject the theory.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Adams, Stuart
. 1962. “The PICO Project.” In The Sociology of Punishment and Correction, edited by Norman Johnston, Leonard Savitz, and Marvin Wolfgang. New York: Wiley.
2.
Anderson, Elijah
. 1978. A Place on the Corner. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
3.
Apospori, Eleni
, Geoffrey P. Alpert, and Raymond Paternoster. 1992. “The Effect of Involvement with the Criminal Justice System: A Neglected Dimension of the Experience and Perceptions Relationship.”Justice Quarterly9:379-392.
4.
Beccaria, Cesare
. [1764] 1963. On Crime and Punishments. Translated by H. Paolucci.
5.
Berk, Richard A.
, Alec Campbell, Ruth Klap, and Bruce Western. 1992. “The Deterrent Effect of Arrest in Incidents of Domestic Violence: A Bayesian Analysis of Four Field Experiments.”American Sociological Review57:698-708.
6.
Binder, Arnold
and Martha Newkirk. 1977. “A Program to Extend Police Service Capability.”Crime Prevention Review4:26-32.
7.
Black, Donald
. 1983. “Crime as Social Control.”American Sociological Review48:34-45.
8.
Blumstein. Alfred
. 1993. “Making Rationality Relevant.”Criminology31:1-16.
9.
Blumstein, Alfred
, Jacqueline Cohen, Jeffrey Roth, and Christy A. Visher. 1986. Criminal Careers and “Career Criminals.”Washington, DC: National Academy of Sciences.
10.
Booth, Alan
and D. Wayne Osgood. 1993. “The Influence of Testosterone on Deviance in Adulthood: Assessing and Explaining the Relationship.”Criminology31:93-118.
11.
Bowers, William J.
1988. “The Effect of Executions Is Brutalization, Not Deterrence.” In Challenging Capital Punishment: Legal and Social Science Approaches, edited by Kenneth C. Haas and James A. Inciardi. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
12.
Braithwaite, John
. 1985. To Punish or Persuade: Enforcement of Coal Mine Safety. Albany: SUNY.
13.
Braithwaite, John
. 1989. Crime, Shame and Reintegration. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
14.
Braithwaite, John
. 1991. “Foreword.” In Emotions and Violence: Shame and Rage in Destructive Conflicts, Thomas J. Scheff and Suzanne M. Retzinger. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
15.
Bridgeforth, Carol A. 1990. “Predicting Domestic Violence From Post-Arrest Suspect Interviews.” Unpublished master's thesis, Institute of Criminal Justice and Criminology, University of Maryland.
16.
Brown, DeNeen L.
1993. “It's About Respect, Say Students Who Curse Teachers.”Washington Post, April 18, p. A1.
17.
Cleaver, Eldridge
. 1968. Soul on Ice. New York: Dell.
18.
Clements, Mark
. 1993. National Survey on Law and Order. Parade Magazine, April 4, pp. 4-7.
19.
Cohen, Albert K.
1955. Delinquent Boys: The Culture of the Gang. New York: Free Press.
20.
Currie, Elliott
. 1985. Confronting Crime. New York: Pantheon.
21.
Davies, James C.
1969. “The J-Curve of Rising and Declining Satisfactions as a Cause of Some Great Revolutions and a Contained Rebellion.” In The History of Violence in America, edited by Hugh Davis Graham and Ted Robert Gurr. New York: Bantam.
22.
Dunford, Franklyn
, David Huizinga, and Delbert S. Elliott. 1990. “The Role of Arrest in Domestic Assault: The Omaha Police Experiment.”Criminology28:183-206.
23.
Falkowski, Carol
. 1984. The Impact of Two-Day Jail Sentences for Drunk Drivers in Hennepin County, Minnesota. Final Report. Washington, DC: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.
24.
Farrington, David P.1977. “The Effects of Public Labeling.”British Journal of Criminology17:112-125.
25.
Farrington, David P.
1979. “Longitudinal Research on Crime and Delinquency.” In Crime and Justice. Vol. 1, edited by Norval Morris and Michael Tonry. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
26.
Farrington, David P.
1983. “Randomized Experiments on Crime and Justice.” In Crime and Justice. Vol. 4, edited by Michael Tonry and Norval Morris. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
27.
Farrington, David P.
and Patrick Langan. 1992. “Changes in Crime and Punishment in England and America in the 1980s.”Justice Quarterly9:5-46.
28.
Farrington, David P.
, S. G. Osborn, and D. J. West. 1978. “The Persistence of Labeling Effects.”British Journal of Criminology18:277-284.
29.
Felson, Marcus
. 1986. “Linking Criminal Choices, Routine Activities, Informal Control, and Criminal Outcomes.” In The Reasoning Criminal, edited by Derek B. Cornish and Ronald Clarke. New York: Springer-Verlag.
30.
Felson, Marcus
. 1987. “Routine Activities and Crime Prevention in the Developing Metropolis.”Criminology25:911-932.
31.
Glaser, Daniel
. 1974. “Remedies for the Key Deficiency in Criminal Justice Evaluation Research.”Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency11:144-153.
32.
Gold, Martin
and Jay Williams. 1970. “National Study of the Aftermath of Apprehension.”Prospectus3:3-12.
33.
Grasmick, Harold G.
and Robert J. Bursik, Jr.1990. “Conscience, Significant Others, and Rational Choice: Extending the Deterrence Model.”Law & Society Review24:837-861.
34.
Henley, William E.
[1875] 1954. “Invictus.” In The Victorian Age: Prose, Poetry, and Drama. 2nd ed., edited by John W. Bowyer and John L. Brooks. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts.
35.
Hirschi, Travis
. 1986. “On the Compatibility of Rational Choice and Social Control Theories of Crime.” In The Reasoning Criminal: Rational Choice Perspectives on Offending, edited by Derek B. Cornish and Ronald V. Clarke. New York: Springer-Verlag.
36.
Hood, Roger
and Richard Sparks. 1970. Key Issues in Criminology. London: Weidenfield and Nicolson.
37.
Huizinga, David
and Finn Esbensen. 1992. School Safety15:15-17.
38.
Katz, Jack
. 1988. Seductions of Crime: Moral and Sensual Attractions in Doing Evil. New York: Basic Books.
39.
Kinsey, Karyl
. 1992. “Deterrence and Alienation Effects of IRS Enforcement: An Analysis of Survey Data.” In Why People Pay Taxes, edited by Joel Slemrod. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
40.
Klein, Malcolm
. 1986. “Labeling Theory and Delinquency Policy: An Empirical Test.”Criminal Justice and Behavior13:47-79.
41.
Kotkin, Joel
. 1993. “How Not To Lose L. A.”Washington Post, April 18, p. C1.
42.
Lemert, Edwin
. 1972. Human Deviance, Social Problems and Social Control. New York: Prentice-Hall.
43.
Lerman, Paul
. 1975. Community Treatment and Social Control. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
44.
Majors, Richard
and Janet Mancini Billson. 1992. Cool Pose: The Dilemmas of Black Manhood in America. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
45.
Makkai, Toni
and John Braithwaite. 1993. “Reintegrative Shaming and Compliance With Regulatory Standards.”Research School of Social Sciences, Australian National University. Unpublished manuscript.
46.
Martin, Susan
, Sampson Annan, and Brian Forst. 1986. Deterring the Drunk Driver. Washington, DC: Police Foundation.
47.
McDowall, David
, Colin Loftin, and Brian Wiersema. 1992. “A Comparative Study of the Preventive Effects of Mandatory Sentencing Laws for Gun Crimes.”Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology83:378-394.
48.
McFarland, S. G.1983. “Is Capital Punishment a Short-Term Deterrent to Homicide? A Study of the Effect of Four Recent Executions.”Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology74:1014-1031.
49.
Merton, Robert K.1938. “Social Structure and Anomie.”American Sociological Review3:672-682.
50.
Morris, Norval
. 1966. “Impediments to Penal Reform.”University of Chicago Law Review33:627-656.
51.
Myrdal, Gunnar
. 1941. An American Dilemma: The Negro Problem and Modern Democracy. New York: Harper & Brothers.
52.
National Advisory Commission on Civil Disorders
. 1986. Report. New York: Bantam.
53.
National Public Radio
. 1993. “All Things Considered.”Los Angeles segment, April 17.
Pate, Antony M.
and Edwin E. Hamilton. 1992. “Formal and Informal Deterrents to Domestic Violence: The Dade County Spouse Assault Experiment.”American Sociological Review57:691-697.
56.
Petersilia, Joan
. 1980. “Criminal Career Research: A Review of Recent Evidence.” In Crime and Justice. Vol. 2, edited by Norval Morris and Michael Tonry. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
57.
Reiss, Albert J., Jr.
1968. “Police Brutality: Answers to Key Questions.”Trans-action July-August 12.
58.
Reiss, Albert J., Jr.
1971. The Police and the Public. New Haven: Yale University Press.
59.
Robbins, Lee
1992. “Sutherland Award Lecture.”American Society of Criminology, New Orleans.
60.
Ross, H. Laurence
. 1992. Confronting Drunk Driving: Social Policy for Saving Lives. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
61.
Scheff, Thomas J.
and Suzanne M. Retzinger. 1991. Emotions and Violence: Shame and Rage in Destructive Conflicts. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
62.
Schneider, Anne L.
1990. Deterrence and Juvenile Crime. New York: Springer-Verlag.
63.
Sechrest, Lee
, Susan O. White, and Elizabeth Brown. 1979. The Rehabilitation of Criminal Offenders: Problems and Prospects. Washington, DC: National Academy of Sciences.
64.
Severy, L. J.
and J. M. Whitaker. 1982. “Juvenile Diversion: An Experimental Analysis of Effectiveness.”Evaluation Review6:753-774.
65.
Severy, L. J.
and J. M. Whitaker. 1984. “Memphis-Metro Youth Diversion Project:Final Report.”Child Welfare63:269-277.
66.
Sherman, Lawrence W.
(1980). “Causes of Police Behavior: The Current State of Quantitative Research.”Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency17:69-100.
67.
Sherman, Lawrence W.
1992. Policing Domestic Violence: Experiments and Dilemmas. New York: Free Press.
68.
Sherman, Lawrence W.
and Ellen G. Cohn. 1989. “The Impact of Research on Legal Policy: The Minneapolis Domestic Violence Experiment.”Law & Society Review23:117-144.
69.
Sherman, Lawrence W.
and Patrick R. Gartin. 1986. “Differential Recidivism: A Field Experiment on the Specific Sanction Effects of Arrest for Shoplifting.” Paper presented to the American Society of Criminology, Atlanta.
70.
Sherman, Lawrence W.
and Douglas A. Smith, 1992. “Crime, Punishment and Stake in Conformity: Legal and Informal Control of Domestic Violence.”American Sociological Review57:680-690.
71.
Skolnick, Jerome H.
and James J. Fyfe. 1993. Above the Law: Police and the Excessive Use of Force. New York: Free Press.
72.
Smith, Douglas A.
and Patrick R. Gartin. 1989. “Specifying Specific Deterrence: The Influence of Arrest on Future Criminal Activity.”American Sociological Review54:94-105.
73.
Smith, Douglas A.
and Raymond Paternoster. 1990. “Formal Processing and Future Delinquency: Deviance Amplification As Selection Artifact.”Law & Society Review24:1109-1131.
74.
Smith, Douglas A.
and Christy A. Visher. 1981. “Street-Level Justice: Situational Determinants of Police Arrest Decisions.”Social Problems29:167-178.
75.
Tittle, Charles
. 1980. “Labelling and Crime: An Empirical Examination” In The Labelling of Deviance: Evaluating a Perspective, edited by W. R. Gove. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
76.
Tyler, Tom R.
1990. Why People Obey the Law. New Haven: Yale University Press.
77.
van Andel, Henk
. 1989. “Crime Prevention That Works: The Case of Public Transport in the Netherlands.”British Journal of Criminology29:47-56.
78.
Weinstein, Gerald S.
and Bruce Levin. 1989. “Effect of Crossover on the Statistical Power of Randomized Studies.”Annals of Thoracic Surgery48:490-495.
79.
Weisburd, David
. 1989. “Jewish Settler Violence.”University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press.
80.
Weisburd, David
. Forthcoming. “Design Sensitivity in Criminal Justice Experiments: Reassessing the Relationship Between Sample Size and Statistical Power.” In Crime and Justice: A Review of Research, edited by Michael Tonry and Norval Morris. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
81.
Wellford, Charles
and Ruth Triplett. 1992. “The Future of Labeling Theory: Foundations and Promises.” Paper presented to the American Society of Criminology, New Orleans, November.
82.
Westin, Alan F.
1981. Whistle-Blowing: Loyalty and Dissent in the Corporation. New York: McGraw-Hill.
83.
Whitaker, J.M.
, L.J. Severy, and D. S. Morton. 1984. “A Comprehensive Community-Based Youth Diversion Program.”Child Welfare63:175-181.
84.
Williams, Kirk R.
and Richard Hawkins. 1986. “Perceptual Research on General Deterrence: A Critical Review.”Law & Society Review20:545-572.
85.
Wilson, James Q.
1983. Thinking About Crime. Rev. ed.New York: Basic Books.
86.
Wolfgang, Marvin E.
, Robert M. Figlio, and Thorsten Sellin. 1972. Delinquency in a Birth Cohort. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
87.
Zeisel, Hans
. 1982. “Disagreement Over the Evaluation of a Controlled Experiment.”American Journal of Sociology88:378-389.
