An Aggregate-Level Study of Inmate Suicides and Deaths Due to Natural Causes in U.S. Jails

Abstract

This research note presents findings from cross-sectional and longitudinal analyses of possible influences on the numbers of inmate suicides and natural deaths in 204 U.S. jails. Results revealed that both inmate suicides and natural deaths became less prevalent over time in larger facilities and in jails where medical tests of inmates on intake were added. Inmate suicides also became less prevalent in jails where the ratio of staff to inmates increased. Inmate deaths due to natural causes also declined in jails where standards of humane confinement are implemented, in facilities that experienced a decline in the degree of inmate crowding, and in jails where infirmaries designed for overnight stays were added. The implications of these results are discussed.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

American Medical Association . 1981. American Medical Association Standards for Health Services in Jails. Chicago: Author.

Austin, W. T. and C. M. Unkovic . 1977. “Prison Suicide.” Criminal Justice Review 2:66-76.

Bamonte, T. J. 1981. “Eighth Amendment - A Significant Limit on Federal Court Activism in Ameliorating State Prison Conditions.” Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 72(4):1345-1373.

Beigel, A. and H. Russell . 1973. “Suicidal Behavior in Jail: Prognostic Consideration.” In Jail House Blues, edited by B. Danto . Orchard Lake, MI: Epic Publications.

Bolduc, A. 1985. “Jail Crowding.” Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 478:47-57.

Champion, D. 1991. “Inmate Litigation in the 1990s.” In American Jails: Public Policy and Issues, edited by J. A. Thompson and G. L. Mays . Chicago: Nelson-Hall.

Danto, B. , ed. 1973. Jail House Blues. Orchard Lakes, MI: Epic Publications.

Flynn, E. E. 1989. “Police Detention and Jail Suicides.” Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Society of Criminology, Reno, NV.

Guynes, R. 1988. Nation's Jail Managers Assess Their Problems. Rockville, MD: National Institute of Corrections.

10.

Hayes, L. M. 1983. “And Darkness Closes In...A National Study of Jail Suicides.” Criminal Justice and Behavior 10:461-484.

11.

Heilig, S. 1973. “Suicide in Jails: A Preliminary Study in Los Angeles County.” Pp. 47-56, in Jail House Blues, edited by B. Danto . Orchard Lakes, MI: Epic Publications.

12.

Husson, P. and J. D. Butts . 1979. “Jail and Prison Deaths: A Five Year Statewide Survey of 223 Deaths in Police Custody, North Carolina, 1972-1976.” Popular Government (Spring).

13.

Kennedy, D. B. 1983. “Transition to Custody as a Factor in Suicides.” Corrections and Social Psychiatry 30:88-91.

14.

Kennedy, D. B. 1984. “A Theory of Suicide While in Police Custody.” Journal of Police Science and Administration 12:191-198.

15.

Kennedy, D. B. and R. J. Homant . 1988. “Predicting Custodial Suicides: Problems With the Use of Profiles.” Justice Quarterly 5:441-456.

16.

Malcolm, B. J. 1975. “Today's Problems in Penology.” New York State Journal of Medicine 75:1812-1814.

17.

Martin, S. 1971. “Prison Suicide Study” (Interdepartment Memorandum). New York: Health Services Administration.

18.

Mays, G. L. and J. A. Thompson . 1991. “The Political and Organizational Context of American Jails.” In American Jails: Public Policy and Issues, edited by J. A. Thompson and G. L. Mays . Chicago: Nelson-Hall.

19.

Mueller, C. W. 1983. “Environmental Stressors and Aggressive Behaviors.” In Aggression: Theoretical and Empirical Reviews, edited by R. G. Green and E. I. Donnerstein . New York: Academic Press.

20.

Payne, F. C. 1985. “Medical Emergencies: Health-Trained Officers Needed.” Corrections Today, July, pp. 20-22.

21.

Reynolds, W. J. and M. H. Tonry . 1981. “Professional Mediation Services for Prisoner Complaints.” American Bar Association Journal 67:294-297.

22.

Rossett, R. N. 1959. “A Statistical Model of Friction in Economics.” Econometrica 27:263-267.

23.

Rossett, R. N. and F. D. Nelson . 1975. “Estimation of the Two-Limit Probit Regression Model.” Econometrica 43:141-146.

24.

Sigurdson, H. 1985. The Manhattan House of Detention: A Study of Podular Direction Supervision. Washington, DC: National Institute of Corrections.

25.

Sigurdson, H. 1987. Pima County Detention Center: A Study of Podular Direction Supervision. Washington, DC: National Institute of Corrections.

26.

Spector, P. E. 1981. Research Designs. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.

27.

Tobin, J. 1958. “Estimation in Relationships for Limited Dependent Variables.” Econometrica 26:24-36.

28.

Welch, M. 1991. “The Expansion of Jail Capacity: Makeshift Jail and Public Policy.” In American Jails: Public Policy and Issues, edited by J. A. Thompson and G. L. Mays . Chicago: Nelson-Hall.

29.

Winfree, L. T. 1987. “Toward Understanding State-Level Jail Mortality: Correlates of Death by Suicide and by Natural Causes, 1977 and 1982.” Justice Quarterly 4:51-71.

30.

Winfree, L. T. and J. D. Wooldredge . 1991. “Exploring Suicides and Deaths by Natural Causes in America's Large Jails: A Panel Study of Institutional Change, 1978 and 1983.” In American Jails: Public Policy and Issues, edited by J. A. Thompson and G. L. Mays . Chicago: Nelson-Hall.

31.

Wrigley, E. A. 1979. Population and History. New York: McGraw-Hill.

32.

Zimring, F. E. and G. Hawkins . 1991. The Scale of Imprisonment. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

33.

Zupan, L. L. 1991. Jails: Reform and the New Generation Philosophy. Cincinnati, OH: Anderson.

34.

Zupan, L. L. and M. K. Stohr-Gillmore . 1988. “Doing Time in the New Generation Jail: Inmate Perceptions of Gains and Losses.” Policy Studies Review 7:626-640.