This article examines the effects of item order on the perceived seriousness of crime. Previous research that addressed this question rotated only one offense to three locations on a questionnaire and concluded that item order had no effect. This research rotates several offenses, including violent, property, white-collar, and morals offenses. The perceived seriousness of an item was hypothesized to shift toward the severity of the preceding offense. The results substantiate this effect. In fact, item order was found to explain approximately the same amount of variation in the perceived seriousness of an offense as did respondents' demographic characteristics.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Akman, D. D.
, A. Normandeau, and S. Turner1967“The measurement of delinquency in Canada.”J. of Criminal Law, Criminology and Police Science58: 330-337.
2.
Al-Thakeb, F.
and J. E. Scott1981“The perceived seriousness of crime in the Middle East.”Int. J. of Comparative and Applied Criminal Justice5, 2: 129-143.
3.
Cullen, F. T.
, B. G. Link, and C. W. Polanzi1982“The seriousness of crime revisited.”Criminology20: 83-102.
4.
Devlin, P.
1959 The Enforcement of Morals. Oxford: Oxford Univ. Press.
5.
Evans, S. S. 1981 “Measuring the seriousness of crime: methodological issues and a cross-cultural comparison.” Ph.D. dissertation, Ohio State University.
6.
Evans, S. S.
and J. E. Scott 1982a “Analyzing the perceived seriousness of crime cross culturally: the impact of respondent characteristics.” Presented at the Tenth World Congress of Sociology, Mexico City, August 15-20.
7.
Evans, S. S.
and J. E. Scott 1982b “The seriousness of crime cross culturally.” Presented at the annual meeting of the American Sociological Association, San Francisco, September.
8.
Evans, S. S.
and J. E. Scott1984“The seriousness of crime cross culturally: the impact of religiosity.”Criminology22: 39-59.
9.
Figlio, R. M.1975“The seriousness of offenses: an evaluation by offenders and nonoffenders.”J. of Criminal Law and Criminology66: 189-200.
10.
Green, E.1968“The effect of stimulus arrangements on normative judgment in the award of penal sanctions.”Sociometry31: 125-137.
11.
Hsu, M.1973“Cultural and sexual differences on the judgment of criminal offenses: a replication study of the measurement of delinquency.”J. of Criminal Law and Criminology64: 348-353.
12.
McConnell, J.
and J. Martin1969“Judicial attitudes and public morals.”Amer. Bar Assn. J.55: 1129-1133.
13.
Newman, G.
1976 Comparative Deviance: Perception and Law in Six Cultures. New York: Elsevier.
14.
Reidel, M.1975“Perceived circumstances, inferences of intent and judgments of offense seriousness.”J. of Criminal Law and Criminology66: 201-208.
15.
Rose, A. M.
and A. E. Prell1955“Does the punishment fit the crime? A study of social valuation.”Amer. J. of Sociology61: 247-259.
16.
Rossi, P.
, E. Waite, C. Rose, and R. Berk1974“The seriousness of crimes: normative structure and individual differences.”Amer. Soc. Rev.39: 224-237.
17.
Scott, J. E.
and F. Al-Thakeb 1977 “The public's perception of crime: Scandinavia, Western Europe, the Middle East, and the United States,” in C. R. Huff (ed.) Contemporary Corrections. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
18.
Scott, J. E.
and F. Al-Thakeb 1980 “Crime statistics and the perception of crime,” in G. R. Newman (ed.) Crime and Deviance: A Comparative Perspective. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
19.
Sellin, T.
and M. E. Wolfgang 1964 The Measurement of Delinquency. New York: John Wiley.
20.
Sheley, J. F.1980“Crime seriousness ratings: the impact of survey questionnaire form and item context.”British J. of Criminology20: 123-135.
21.
Thomas, C. W.
, R. J. Cage, and S. C. Foster1976“Public opinion of criminal law and legal sanctions: an examination of two conceptual models.”J. of Criminal Law and Criminology67: 110-116.
22.
Velez-Diaz, A.
and E. I. Megargee1970“An investigation of differences in value judgments between youthful offenders and non-offenders in Puerto Rico.”J. of Criminal Law, Criminology and Police Science61: 549-553.
23.
Wellford, C. F.
and M. Wiatrowski1975“On the measurement of delinquency.”J. of Criminal Law and Criminology66: 175-188.
24.
White, G.1975“Public responses to hypothetical crimes: effect of offender and victim's status and seriousness of the offense on punitive reactions.”Social Forces53: 411-419.
