Causes of Police Behavior: the Current State of Quantitative Research

Abstract

This paper is a first attempt to organize and codify the findings of quantitative research on four aspects of police behavior: detection, arrest, service, and violence. A framework of five explanatory approaches is used to organize the findings: individual characteristics of police officers; situational, organizational, and community characteristics; and legal variables. The findings generally show weak relationships between a wide range of the hypothesized causes and police behavior, the implica tions of which for building a substantive theory of policing are briefly considered.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aaronson, D.E. , C.T. Dienes , and M. Musheno 1978

"Changing the Public Drunkeness Laws: The Impact of Decriminalization."

Law and Society Review 12 (3): 405-436

. Banton, M. 1964 The Policeman in the Community New York: Basic Books.

Bartell Associates n.d.

"The Study of Police Women Competency in the Performance of Sector Police Work in the City of Philadelphia."

Report submitted to the Philadelphia Police Department.

Black, D. 1970

"The Production of Crime Rates."

American Sociological Review 35 (August) : 733-748

. 1971

"The Social Organization of Arrest."

Stanford Law Review 23 (June): 1087-1111

.1976 The Behavior of Law New York: Academic Press.

1979 "Dispute Settlement by the Police." New Haven, Conn.: Yale University.

Black, D. , and A.J. Reiss, JR. 1967 Studies of Crime and Law Enforcement in Major Metropolitan Areas, Vol. 2, Field Surveys III. Section I: "Patterns of Behavior in Police and Citizen Transactions." Washington, D.C.: Govt. Printing Office.

1970

"Police Control of Juveniles."

American Sociological Review 35 (February) : 63-77

10.

. Bloch, P. , and D. Anderson 1974 Policewomen on Patrol: Final Report Washington, D.C.: Police Foundation.

11.

Bogomolny, R. 1976

"Street Patrol: The Decision to Stop a Citizen."

Criminal Law Bulletin 12 (5): 544-582

12.

. Boydstun, J.E. , and M.E. Sherry 1975 San Diego Community Profile: Final Report Washington, D.C.: Police Foundation.

13.

Boydstun, J. , M. Sherry , and N.P. Moelter 1977 Patrol Staffing in San Diego: One- or Two-Officer Units Washington, D.C.: Police Foundation.

14.

Bozza, C.M. 1973

"Motivations Guiding Policemen in the Arrest Process."

Journal of Police Science and Administration 1 (4): 468-476

15.

. Campbell, D.T. , and J.C. Stanley 1963 Experimental and Quasi-Experimental Designs for Research Chicago: Rand-McNally.

16.

Cascio, W.F. 1977

"Formal Education and Police Officer Performance."

Journal of Police Science and Administration 5 (1): 89-96

17.

. Cohen, B. , and J.M. Chaiken 1972 Police Background Characteristics and Performance: Summary New York: Rand Institute.

18.

Cruse, D. , and J. Rubin n.d. "Determinants of Police Behavior." The Psychiatric Institute.

19.

Davis J.A. 1975 "On the Remarkable Absence of Nonacademic Implications in Academic Research: An Example from Ethnic Studies." In Social Policy and Sociology, N. J. Demerath, O. Larsen, and K. F. Schuessler, eds. New York: Academic Press. Pp. 233-241.

20.

Ferdinand, T. , and E.G. Luchterhand 1970

"Inner City Youth, the Police, the Juvenile Court, and Justice."

Social Problems 17 (4): 510-526

21.

. Fogelson, R.M. 1977 Big City Police Cambridge, Mass. : Harvard University Press.

22.

Forst, B. , J. Lucianovic , and S.J. Cox 1977 What Happens after Arrest? A Court Perspective of Police Operations in the District of Columbia Washington, D.C.: Institute for Law and Social Research.

23.

Friedrich, R.J. 1977 "The Impact of Organizational, Individual, and Situational Factors on Police Behavior." Ph.D. diss, Department of Political Science, University of Michigan.

24.

Fyfe, J.J. 1978 "Shots Fired: An Examination of New York City Police Firearms Discharges." Ph.D. diss, School of Criminal Justice, State University of New York at Albany.

25.

Gardiner, J.A. 1969 Traffic and the Police Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.

26.

Gay, W. , H.T. Day , and J.P. Woodward 1977 Neighborhood Team Policing Washington, D.C.: National Institute of Law Enforcement and Criminal Justice.

27.

Goldman, N. 1963 The Differential Selection of Juvenile Offenders for Court Appearance Hackensack, N.J.: National Council on Crime and Delinquency.

28.

Hale, C.D. , and W.R. Wilson 1974 Personal Characteristics of Assaulted and Non-Assaulted Officers Norman, Okla.: Bureau of Government Research, University of Oklahoma.

29.

HEAPHY, J. F., ed. 1978 Police Practices: The General Administrative Survey. Washington, D.C.: Police Foundation.

30.

Hindelang, M.J. 1978

"Race and Involvement in Common Law Personal Crimes."

American Sociological Review 43 (February): 93-109

31.

. Hoobler, R.L. , and J.A. McQueeney 1973

"A Question of Height."

The Police Chief (November): 42-48

32.

. Jacobs, D. , and D. Britt 1979

"Inequality and Police Use of Deadly Force: An Empirical Assessment of a Conflict Hypothesis."

Social Problems 26 (4): 403-412

33.

. Kania, R.E. , and W.C. Mackey 1977

"Police Violence as a Function of Community Characteristics."

Criminology 15 (1): 27-48

34.

. Kansas City, Missouri, Police Department 1977 Response Time Analysis Kansas City, Mo.: Board of Police Commissioners.

35.

Kelling, G.L., et al. 1974 The Kansas City Preventive Patrol Experiment Summary Report. Washington, D.C.: Police Foundation.

36.

Knoohuizen, R. , R. Fahey , and D.J. Palmer 1972 The Police and Their Use of Fatal Force in Chicago Chicago: Chicago Law Enforcement Study Group.

37.

Kobler, A. 1975

"Figures (and Perhaps Some Facts) on Police Killing of Citizens in the United States."

Journal of Social Issues 31: 185-191

38.

. Lipton, D. , R. Martinson , and J. Wilks 1975 The Effectiveness of Correctional Treatment New York: Praeger.

39.

Lundman, R. 1974

"Routine Police Arrest Practices: A Commonweal Perspective."

Social Problems 22 (October): 127-141

40.

. Lundman, R. , R.E. Sykes , and J.P. Clark 1978

"Police Control of Juveniles."

Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 15 (1): 74-91

41.

. Manning, P. , and J. Van Maanen 1978 Policing: A View From the Street Santa Monica, Calif.: Goodyear.

42.

McEachern, A.W. , and R. Bauzer 1967 "Factors Related to Disposition in Juvenile Police Contacts." In Juvenile Gangs in Context , M. W. Klein and B. G. Myerhoff, eds. Englewood Cliffs, N.J. : Prentice-Hall. Pp. 148-160.

43.

44.

Melchionne, T.M. 1974

"The Changing Role of Policewomen."

Police Journal 47 (4): 340-358

45.

. Merton, R.K. 1968 Social Theory and Social Structure New York: Free Press.

46.

Milner, N. 1970

"Comparative Analysis of Patterns of Compliance with Supreme Court Decisions: Miranda and the Police in Four Communities."

Law and Society Review 4 (August): 119-134

47.

. Milton, C.M., et al. 1977 Police Use of Deadly Force Washington, D.C.: Police Foundation.

48.

Muir, W.K., JR. 1977 Police: Streetcorner Politicians Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

49.

Pate, T. , R.A. Bowers , and R. Parks 1976 Three Approaches to Criminal Apprehension in Kansas City: An Evaluation Report Washington, D.C.: Police Foundation.

50.

Pate, T., et al. 1976a Police Response Time: Its Determinants and Effects Washington, D.C.: Police Foundation .

51.

Pate, T., et al. 1976b Kansas City Peer Review Panel: An Evaluation Report Washington, D.C.: Police Foundation.

52.

Petersen, D.M. 1972

"Police Disposition of the Petty Offender."

Sociology and Social Research 56 (3): 320-330

53.

. Piliavin, J. , and S. Briar 1964

"Police Encounters with Juveniles."

American Journal of Sociology 70 (September): 206-214

54.

. Reiss, A.J., JR. 1971a The Police and the Public New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press.

55.

1971 b "Systematic Observation of Natural Social Phenomena." In Sociological Methodology 1971, H. L. Costner, ed. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. Pp. 3-33.

56.

1972 "Police Brutality." In The Criminal in the Arms of the Law, Vol. 2, Crime and Justice, L. Radzinowicz and M. E. Wolfgang, eds. Pp. 293-308.

57.

Reiss, A.J., JR. , and D.J. Bordua 1967 "Environment and Organization: A Perspective on the Police." In The Police: Six Sociological Essays , D. J. Bordua, ed. New York: John Wiley. Pp. 25-55.

58.

Reppetto, T.A. 1975

"The Influence of Police Organizational Style on Crime Control Effectiveness."

Journal of Police Science and Administration 3 (3): 274-279

59.

. Robin, G.D. 1963

"Justifiable Homicides by Police."

Journal of Criminal Law, Criminology and Police Science 54 (2): 225-231

60.

. Rossi, P.H. , R.A. Berk , and B.K. Eidson 1974 The Roots of Urban Discontent: Public Policy, Municipal Institutions, and the Ghetto New York: John Wiley.

61.

Scott, R.A. , and A. Shore 1974

"Sociology and Policy Analysis."

The American Sociologist 9: 51-58

62.

. Sherman, L.J. 1973

"A Psychological View of Women in Policing."

Journal of Police Science and Administration 1 (4): 383-394

63.

. 1975

"An Evaluation of Policewomen on Patrol in a Suburban Police Department."

Journal of Police Science and Administration 3 (4): 434-438

64.

. Sherman, L.W. 1979

"College Education for Police: The Reform That Failed?"

Police Studies: The International Review of Police Development 1 (4): 32-38

65.

. 1980

"Execution without Trial: Police Homicide and the Constitution."

Vanderbilt Law Review.

66.

Sherman, L.W. , C.H. Milton , and T. Kelley 1973 Team Policing: Seven Case Studies Washington, D.C.: Police Foundation.

67.

Sichel, J., et al. 1977 Women on Patrol: A Pilot Study of Police Performance in New York City Washington, D.C.: Govt. Printing Office.

68.

Smith, D.C. 1978 Empirical Studies of Higher Education and Police Performance Washington, D.C.: Police Foundation.

69.

Swanson, C. 1978

"The Influence of Organization and Environment on Arrest Policies in Major U.S. Cities."

Policy Studies Journal 7: 390-398

70.

. Swanson, C. , and C.D. Hale 1975

"A Question of Height Revisited: Assaults on Police."

Journal of Police Science and Administration 3 (2): 183-188

71.

. Sykes, R.E. 1972

"Police III: A Code for the Study of Police-Citizen Interaction."

Observations 3 (November): 20-40

72.

. Sykes, R.E. , and J.P. Clark 1975

"A Theory of Deference Exchange in Police-Civilian Encounters."

American Journal of Sociology 81 (3): 584-600

73.

. Sykes, R.E. , J.C. Fox , and J.P. Clark 1976 "A Socio-Legal Theory of Police Discretion." The Ambivalent Force: Perspectives on the Police , 2d ed., A. Blumberg and A. Niederhoffer, eds. Hinsdale, Ill.: Dryden Press. Pp. 171-183.

74.

Terry, R.M. 1967a "The Screening of Juvenile Offenders." Journal of Criminal Law, Criminology and Police Science 58 (2): 173-181

75.

. 1967b "Discrimination in the Handling of Juvenile Offenders by Social Control Agencies." Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 4 (2): 218-230

76.

. Toch, H. , D. Grant , and R. Galvin 1975 Agents of Change: A Study in Police Reform Cambridge, Mass.: Schenkman.

77.

Wald, M., et al. 1967

"Interrogations in New Haven: The Impact of Miranda."

Yale Law Journal 76 (8): 1519-1616

78.

. Wasby, S. 1976 Small Town Police and the Supreme Court Lexington, Mass.: D. C. Heath.

79.

Webb, K.W., et al. 1977 Specialized Patrol Projects Washington, D.C.: National Institute of Law Enforcement and Criminal Justice.

80.

Weiner, N.L. , and C.V. Willie 1971

"Decisions by Juvenile Officers."

American Journal of Sociology 77 (2): 199-210

81.

. White, T.W. , and P.B. Bloch 1975 Police Officer Height and Selected Aspects of Performance Washington, D.C.: Police Foundation.

82.

Williams, J.R. , and M. Gold 1972

"From Delinquent Behavior to Official Delinquency."

Social Problems 20: 209-229

83.

. Wilson, J.Q. 1967 "The Police and the Delinquent in Two Cities." In Controlling Delinquents, S. Wheeler and H. M. Hughes, eds. New York: John Wiley . Pp. 9-30.

84.

1968 Varieties of Police Behavior Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.

85.

Wilson, J.Q. , and B. Boland 1978

"The Effect of the Police on Crime."

Law and Society Review 12 (3): 367-390

86.

. Wilson, O.W. 1963

"One Man Patrol Cars."

The Police Chief (May): 18-24

87.

. Wolfgang, M.E. , R.M. Figlio , and T. Sellin 1972 Delinquency in a Birth Cohort Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

88.

Wycoff, M.A. , and G.L. Kelling 1978 Organizational Reform, Vol. 1, The Dallas Experience Washington, D.C.: Police Foundation.