Upstream and Downstream Racial Disparities in Prison Rule Violation Processes

Abstract

Objectives

To advance research on racial disparities in processing prison rule violators, we examined disparities at citation, “conviction,” and sanctioning to assess cascading race effects on sanctions via harsher upstream decisions.

Methods

Black and White persons admitted to Ohio prisons in a 5-year period and cited for rule violations were examined (N = 39,356). Outcomes included total cited charges, total convicted charges, and sanctions. Path analysis was used to estimate direct and indirect race effects on dispositions, controlling for covariates of convicted charges and sanction severity.

Results

Black individuals were cited for more rule violations but convicted on fewer violations (controlling counts cited) than White individuals, had lower odds of placement in disciplinary segregation, and served less time in segregation. Indirect race effects on convicted counts and sanctions were statistically significant.

Conclusions

Rule infraction boards may serve as a downstream correction to upstream racial disparities in the prison infraction process. Despite a significant cascading race effect on convicted charges via cited charges, cascading race effects on prison sanctions via convicted charges were refuted, where correctional officers’ decisions did not culminate in harsher sanctions for Black individuals at rule infraction hearings. These hearings may constitute an important check on upstream decisions.

Keywords

racial disparities prison rule violations disciplinary segregation prison discipline

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adams

Kenneth

. 1986. “The Disciplinary Experiences of Mentally Disordered Inmates.” Criminal Justice and Behavior 13:297–316.

Albonetti

Celesta

. 1991. “An Integration of Theories to Explain Judicial Discretion.” Social Problems 38:247–66.

Anderson

Elijah

. 1999. Code of the Street: Decency, Violence, and the Moral Life of the Inner City. New York: WW Norton.

Bourdieu

2005 “Habitus.” Pp. 133–61 in Habitus: A Senes of Place, edited by Hillier

Rooksby

. London: Routledge.

Bridges

George

Steen

Sara

. 1998. “Racial Disparities in Official Assessments of Juvenile Offenders: Attributional Stereotypes as Mediating Mechanisms.” American Sociological Review 63:554–70.

Butler

Harry

Steiner

Benjamin

. 2017. “Examining the Use of Disciplinary Segregation Within and Across Prisons.” Justice Quarterly 34:248–71.

Cloud

David

Garcia-Grossman

Ilana

Armstrong

Andrea

Williams

Brie

. 2023. “Public Health and Prisons: Priorities in the Age of Mass Incarceration.” Annual Review of Public Health 4:407–28.

Cochran

Joshua

Toman

Elisa

Mears

Daniel

Bales

William

. 2018. “Solitary Confinement as Punishment: Examining In-Prison Sanctioning Disparities.” Justice Quarterly 35:381–411.

Cochran

Joshua

Wooldredge

John

. 2021. Examining the Use and Impact of Restrictive Housing: Final Report. Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice.

10.

Comprehensive Adult Student Assessment Systems. 2015. https://www.casas.org.

11.

Crouch

Ben

. 1985. “The Significance of Minority Status to Discipline Severity in Prison.” Sociological Focus 18:221–33.

12.

Decker

Scott

Pyrooz

David

. 2019. “Activism and Radicalism in Prison: Measurement and Correlates in a Large Sample of Inmates in Texas.” Justice Quarterly 36:787–815.

13.

Feagin

Joe

. 1972. “Poverty: We Still Believe That God Helps Those Who Help Themselves.” Psychology Today 6:101–29.

14.

Gomez

Brad

Wilson

J. Matthew

. 2006. “Rethinking Symbolic Racism: Evidence of Attribution Bias.” The Journal of Politics 68:611–25.

15.

Hagan

John

Albonetti

Celesta

. 1982. “Race, Class, and the Perception of Criminal Injustice in America.” American Journal of Sociology 88:329–55.

16.

Hagan, John, John Hewitt, and Duane Alwain. 1979. “Ceremonial Justice: Crime and Punishment in a Loosely Coupled System.” Social Forces 58:506–27.

17.

Haggerty

Kevin

Bucerius

Sandra

. 2021. “Picking Battles: Correctional Officers, Rules, and Discretion in Prison.” Criminology; An Interdisciplinary Journal 59:137–57.

18.

Harer

Miles

Steffensmeier

Darryl

. 1996. “Race and Prison Violence.” Criminology; An Interdisciplinary Journal 34:323–55.

19.

Hunt

Matthew

. 1996. “The Individual, Society, or Both? A Comparison of Black, Latino, and White Beliefs About the Causes of Poverty.” Social Forces 75:293–322.

20.

Institute of Behavioral Research. 2007. Texas Christian University Drug Screen II. Fort Worth: Texas Christian University, Institute of Behavioral Research.

21.

Kline

Rex

. 2023. Principles and Practice of Structural Equation Modeling. 5th edition. New York: The Guilford Press.

22.

Kluegel

James

Smith

Eliot

. 1986. Beliefs About Inequality: Americans’ Views on What Is and What Ought to Be. New York: Aldine de Gruyter.

23.

Krivo

Lauren

Peterson

Ruth

. 1996. “Extremely Disadvantaged Neighborhoods and Urban Crime.” Social Forces 75:619–48.

24.

Kurlychek

Megan

Johnson

Brian

. 2019. “Cumulative Disadvantage in the American Criminal Justice System.” Annual Review of Criminology 2:291–319.

25.

Kutateladze

Besiki

Andiloro

Nancy

Johnson

Brian

. 2016. “Opening Pandora’s Box: How Does Defendant Race Influence Plea Bargaining?” Justice Quarterly 33:398–426.

26.

Latessa

Edward

Lugo

Melissa

Pompoco

Amanda

Sullivan

Carrie

Wooldredge

John

. 2015. Evaluation of Ohio‘s Prison Programs. Cincinnati, OH: University of Cincinnati Corrections Institute.

27.

Logan

Matthew

Dulisse

Brandon

Peterson

Samuel

Morgan

Mark

Olma

Tayte

Pare

Paul-Philippe

. 2017. “Correctional Shorthands: Focal Concerns and the Decision to Administer Solitary Confinement.” Journal of Criminal Justice 52:90–100.

28.

McCloskey

Herbert

. 1964. “Consensus and Ideology in American Politics.” American Political Science Review 58:361–82.

29.

Moskalenko

McCauley

. 2009. “Measuring Political Mobilization: The Distinction Between Activism and Radicalism.” Terrorism and Political Violence 21:239–60.

30.

Muthén

Bengt

. 1984. “A General Structural Equation Model with Dichotomous, Ordered Categorical, and Continuous Latent Variable Indicators.” Psychometrika 49:115–32.

31.

Nur

Alexandra

. 2025. “An Examination of Racial and Ethnic Disparity in Prison Misconduct Punishment.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 62:199–238.

32.

Palmieri

Michael

McNeeley

Susan

. 2025. “Examining Facility-Level Differences in the Early Decisions of the Disciplinary Process and Use of Disciplinary Segregation.” Journal of Criminal Justice 99:1–10.

33.

Rose

Dina

Clear

Todd

. 1998. “Incarceration, Social Capital, and Crime: Implications for Social Disorganization Theory.” Criminology; An Interdisciplinary Journal 36:441–79.

34.

Sampson

Robert

Bartusch

Dawn

. 1998. “Legal Cynicism and (Subcultural?) Tolerance of Deviance: The Neighborhood Context of Racial Differences.” Law and Society Review 32:777–804.

35.

Sampson

Robert

Laub

John

. 1997 “A Life-Course Theory of Cumulative Disadvantage and the Stability of Delinquency.” Pp. 133–61 in Developmental Theories of Crime and Delinquency. 7, Thornberry

. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishing.

36.

Sampson

Robert

Wilson

William

. 1995 “Toward a Theory of Race, Crime, and Urban Inequality.” Pp. 37–54 in Crime and Inequality, edited by Hagan

John

Peterson

Ruth

. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.

37.

Sniderman

Paul

Brody

Richard

Tetlock

Philip

. 1991. Reasoning and Choice: Explorations in Political Psychology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

38.

Spohn

Cassia

. 2009. “Race, Sex, and Pretrial Detention in Federal Court: Indirect Effects and Cumulative Disadvantage.” Kansas Law Review 57:879–901.

39.

Steiner

Benjamin

Butler

H. Daniel

Ellison

Jared

. 2014. “Causes and Correlates of Prison Inmate Misconduct: A Systematic Review of the Evidence.” Journal of Criminal Justice 42:462–70.

40.

Steiner

Benjamin

Wooldredge

John

. 2009. “The Relevance of Inmate Race/Ethnicity Versus Population Composition for Understanding Prison Rule Violations.” Punishment and Society 11:459–89.

41.

Steiner

Benjamin

Wooldredge

John

. 2014. “Comparing Self-Report to Official Measures of Inmate Misconduct.” Justice Quarterly 31:1074–101.

42.

Steiner

Benjamin

Wooldredge

John

. 2015. “Racial (In)Variance in Prison Rule Breaking.” Journal of Criminal Justice 43:175–85.

43.

Stolzenberg

Lisa

D’Alessio

Stewart

Eitle

David

. 2013. “Race and Cumulative Discrimination in the Prosecution of Criminal Defendants.” Race and Justice 3:1–25.

44.

Sutton

John

. 2013. “Structural Bias in the Sentencing of Felony Defendants.” Social Science Research 42:1207–21.

45.

Wacquant

Loïc

. 2001. “Deadly Symbiosis: When Ghetto and Prison Meet and Mesh.” Punishment and Society 3:95–134.

46.

Wilson

William

. 1987. The Truly Disadvantaged: The Inner City, The Underclass, and Public Policy. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

47.

Wooldredge

John

Cochran

Joshua

. 2023. “How Do Racial and Ethnic Disparities Emerge in the Use of Restrictive Housing for Prison Rule Violations?” Journal of Quantitative Criminology 39:769–803.

48.

Wooldredge

John

Griffin

Timothy

Pratt

Travis

. 2001. “The Relevance of Hierarchical Models for Empirical Research on Inmate Behavior.” Justice Quarterly 11:901–29.

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.00 MB

0.06 MB