Objectives: Despite abundant evidence of deviant peer influence, it remains unclear precisely how adolescents try to exert such influence. What do adolescents do or say to actively encourage or discourage deviance among their peers? The aim of the current study is to explore the different ways in which adolescents talk each other into—or out of—such behaviors. Methods: We analyzed narratives about delinquency (N = 37), substance use (N = 131), and other deviance (N = 107), which were written by adolescents (ages 14–18) in secondary schools. The study combines criminological perspectives on situational group processes (i.e., instigation, reinforcement, and provocation) with insights on compliance-gaining from other disciplines to inform a qualitative investigation of key influence tactics. Results: Our results demonstrate that adolescents use a number of tactics to encourage and discourage deviance. Many of these same tactics are used to promote prosocial behavior, though provocation-like tactics are largely used to encourage deviance. Conclusions: The range of reported compliance tactics extends well beyond what is captured in typical studies of peer influence, largely revolving around the broader themes of instigation and attempts to impact the anticipated risks, costs, and rewards of behavior. Ultimately, this study underscores the multi-faceted, socially interactive nature of peer influence.
AgnewRobert.1992. “Foundation for a General Strain Theory of Crime and Delinquency.” Criminology: an Interdisciplinary Journal30(1):47–87.
2.
AkersRonald L.KrohnMarvin D.Lanza-KaduceLonnRadosevichMarcia. 1979. “Social Learning and Deviant Behavior: A Specific Test of a General Theory.” American Sociological Review44(4):636–55.
3.
AlbertsJess K.HechtMichael L.Miller-RassuloMichelleKrizekRobert L.. 1992. “The Communicative Process of Drug Resistance among High School Students.” Adolescence27(105):203–26.
4.
AlbertsJess K.Miller-RassuloMichelleHechtMichael L.. 1991. “A Typology of Drug Resistance Strategies.” Journal of Applied Communication Research19(3):129–51.
5.
AndersonElijah.1999. Code of the Street: Decency, Violence, and the Moral Life of the Inner City. New York: Norton.
BarnumTimothy C.PogarskyGreg. 2022. “Situational Peer Dynamics and Crime Decisions.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency59(5):535–73.
8.
BernburgJón GunnarThorlindssonThorolfur. 2001. “Routine Activities in Social Context: A Closer Look at the Role of Opportunity in Deviant Behavior.” Justice Quarterly18:543–67.
9.
BerndtThomas J.2002. “Friendship Quality and Social Development.” Current Directions in Psychological Science11(1):1–10.
10.
BotSander M.EngelsRutger C.M.E.KnibbeRonald A.MeeusWim H.J.. 2005. “Friend’s Drinking Behaviour and Adolescent Alcohol Consumption: The Moderating Role of Friendship Characteristics.” Addictive Behaviors30:929–47.
11.
BrechwaldWhitney A.PrinsteinMitchell J.. 2011. “Beyond Homophily: A Decade of Advances in Understanding Peer Influence Processes.” Journal of Research on Adolescence21(1):166–79.
12.
BurgessRobert L.AkersRonald L.. 1966. “A Differential Association-Reinforcement Theory of Criminal Behavior.” Social Problems14(2):128–47.
13.
CampbellJohn L.QuincyCharlesOssermanJordanPedersenOve K.. 2013. “Coding In-Depth Semistructured Interviews: Problems of Unitization and Intercoder Reliability and Agreement.” Sociological Methods and Research42(3):294–320.
14.
ChectonMaria G.GreeneKathryn. 2011. “College Students’ Use of Compliance-Gaining Strategies to Obtain Prescription Stimulant Medications for Illicit Use.” Health Education Journal70(3):260–73.
15.
CollinsRandall.2008. Violence: A Micro-Sociological Theory. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
16.
CostelloBarbara J.HopeTrina L. 2016. Peer Pressure, Peer Prevention: The Role of Friends in Crime and Conformity. New York: Routledge.
17.
CostelloBarbara J.ZozulaChristine. 2018. “Peer Influence: Mechanisms and Motivations.” Deviant Behavior39(1):94–110.
18.
CrickNicki R.DodgeKenneth A.. 1994. “A Review and Reformulation of Social Information-Processing Mechanisms in Children’s Social Adjustment.” Psychological Bulletin115:74–101.
19.
DishionThomas J.AndrewsDavid W.CrosbyLynn. 1995. “Antisocial Boys and Their Friends in Early Adolescence: Relationship Characteristics, Quality, and Interactional Process.” Child Development66:139–51.
20.
DishionThomas J.SpracklenKathleen M.AndrewsDavid W.PattersonGerald R.. 1996. “Deviancy Training in Male Adolescent Friendships.” Behavior Therapy27(3):373–90.
21.
EnglefieldAshleyArielBarak. 2017. “Searching for Influential Actors in Co-offending Networks: The Recruiter.” International Journal of Social Science Studies5(5):24–45.
22.
FrenchJohn R. PRavenBertram. 1959 “The Bases of Social Power.” Pp. 151–64 in in Group Dynamics, edited by CartwrightD.ZanderA.. New York: Harper and Row.
23.
GallupeOwenMcLeveyJohnBrownSarah. 2019. “Selection and Influence: A Meta-Analysis of the Association between Peer and Personal Offending.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology35:313–35.
24.
GallupeOwenNguyenHollyBouchardMartinSchulenbergJennifer L.ChenierAllisonCookKatie D.. 2016. “An Experimental Test of Deviant Modeling.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency53(4):482–505.
25.
GardnerMargoSteinbergLaurence. 2005. “Peer Influence on Risk Taking, Risk Preference, and Risky Decision Making in Adolescence and Adulthood: An Experimental Study.” Developmental Psychology41(4):625–35.
26.
GassRobert H.SeiterJohn S.. 2014. Persuasion: Social Influence and Compliance Gaining. New York: Routledge.
27.
GerstnerDominikOberwittlerDietrich. 2018. “Who’s Hanging Out and What’s Happening? A Look at the Interplay Between Unstructured Socializing, Crime Propensity and Delinquent Peers Using Social Network Data.” European Journal of Criminology15(1):111–29.
28.
GiordanoPeggy C.2003. “Relationships in Adolescence.” Annual Review of Sociology29:257–81.
29.
GlueckSheldonGlueckEleanor T.. 1950. Unraveling Juvenile Delinquency. New York: Harvard University Press.
30.
GottfredsonMichael R.HirschiTravis. 1990. A General Theory of Crime. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
31.
GranovetterMark.1978. “Threshold Models of Collective Behavior.” American Journal of Sociology83:1420–43.
32.
GreeneJohn O.SmithSandi W.LindseyA. E.. 1990. “Memory Representations of Compliance-Gaining Strategies and Tactics.” Human Communication Research17(2):195–231.
33.
HaynieDana L.OsgoodD. Wayne. 2005. “Reconsidering Peers and Delinquency: How Do Peers Matter?” Social Forces84(2):1109–30.
34.
HechtMichaelTrostMelanie R.BatorRenée J.MacKinnonDavid. 1997. “Ethnicity and Sex Similarities and Differences in Drug Resistance.” Journal of Applied Communication Research25(2):75–97.
35.
HoebenEvelien M.MeldrumRyan C.WalkerD’AndreYoungJacob T.N.. 2016. “The Role of Peer Delinquency and Unstructured Socializing in Explaining Delinquency and Substance Use: A State-of-the-Art Review.” Journal of Criminal Justice47:108–22.
36.
HoebenEvelien M.ThomasKyle J.. 2019. “Peers and Offender Decision-Making.” Criminology and Public Policy18(4):759–84.
37.
HughesLorine A.ShortJames F.Jr. 2005. “Disputes Involving Youth Street Gang Members: Micro-Social Contexts.” Criminology: an Interdisciplinary Journal43(1):43–76.
38.
HughesLorine A.ShortJames F.Jr. 2014. “Partying, Cruising, and Hanging in the Streets: Gangs, Routine Activities, and Delinquency and Violence in Chicago, 1959–1962.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology30:415–51.
39.
Jackson-JacobsCurtis.2013. “Constructing Physical Fights: An Interactionist Analysis of Violence among Affluent, Suburban Youth.” Qualitative Sociology36:23–52.
40.
JacobsBruce A.WrightRichard. 1999. “Stick-Up, Street Culture, and Offender Motivation.” Criminology: an Interdisciplinary Journal37(1):149–73.
41.
JacquinKristine. M.HarrisonMelissa L.AlfordSarah M.. 2006. “Gender and Peer Presence in Influence Responses to Aggressive Provocation.” American Journal of Forensic Psychology24(3):29–44.
42.
KatzJack.1988. Seductions of Crime: Moral and Sensual Attractions in Doing Evil. New York: Basic Books.
43.
KellermannKathyColeTim. 1994. “Classifying Compliance Gaining Messages: Taxonomic Disorder and Strategic Confusion.” Communication Theory4(1):3–60.
44.
KittsJames A.LealDiego F.. 2021. “What Is(n’t) a Friend? Dimensions of the Friendship Concept among Adolescents.” Social Networks66:161–70.
45.
KrippendorffKlaus.2004. “Reliability in Content Analysis: Some Common Misconceptions and Recommendations.” Human Communication Research30(3):411–33.
46.
LaursenBrettVeenstraD. René. 2021. “Toward Understanding the Functions of Peer Influence: A Summary and Synthesis of Recent Empirical Research.” Journal of Research on Adolescence31(4):889–907.
47.
MarwellGeraldSchmittDavid R.. 1967. “Dimensions of Compliance-Gaining Behavior: An Empirical Analysis.” Sociometry30(4):350–64.
48.
MatsuedaRoss L.KreagerDerek A.HuizingaDavid. 2006. “Deterring Delinquents: A Rational Choice Model of Theft and Violence.” American Sociological Review71(1):95–122.
49.
MatsuedaRoss L.LanfearCharles C.. 2020. “Collective Action, Rational Choice, and Gang Delinquency: Appreciating Short and Strodtbeck ([1965] 1974).” Pp. 151–68 in Social Bridges and Contexts in Criminology and Sociology: Reflections on the Intellectual Legacy of James F. Short, Jr edited by HughesL.BroidyL.. London, UK: Routledge.
50.
MazefskyCarla A.FarrellAlbert D.. 2005. “The Role of Witnessing Violence, Peer Provocation, Family Support, and Parenting Practices in the Aggressive Behavior of Rural Adolescents.” Journal of Child and Family Studies14(1):71–85.
McGloinJean MarieNguyenHolly. 2012. “It Was My Idea: Considering the Instigation of Co-offending.” Criminology: an Interdisciplinary Journal50(2):463–94.
53.
McGloinJean MarieRowanZachary R.. 2015. “A Threshold Model of Collective Crime.” Criminology: an Interdisciplinary Journal53(3):484–512.
54.
McGloinJean MarieThomasKyle J.. 2013 “Experimental Tests of Criminological Theory.” Pp. 15–42 in in Experimental Criminology: Prospects for Advancing Science and Public Policy, edited by WelshB. C.BragaA. A.BruinsmaG. J. N.. New York: Cambridge University Press.
55.
McGloinJean MarieThomasKyle J.. 2019. “Peer Influence and Delinquency.” Annual Review of Criminology2:241–64.
56.
MegensKim C. I. M.WeermanFrank M. 2012. “The Social Transmission of Delinquency: Effects of Peer Attitudes and Behavior Revisited.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency49(3):420–43.
57.
OlynickJannaIliopulosAlexandraLiHan Z.. 2017. “Physician Verbal Compliance-Gaining Strategies and Patient Satisfaction.” Health Education117(6):551–65.
58.
OsgoodD. WayneFeinbergMark E.RaganDaniel T.. 2015. “Social Networks and the Diffusion of Adolescent Problem Behavior: Reliable Estimates of Selection and Influence from Sixth through Ninth Grades.” Prevention Science16:832–43.
59.
OsgoodD. WayneWilsonJanet K.O’MalleyPatrick M.BachmanJerald G.JohnstonLloyd D.. 1996. “Routine Activities and Individual Deviant Behavior.” American Sociological Review61(4):635–55.
60.
ParkerJeffrey G.MasseyKatelyn E.. 2018 “When Friends Differ: How Imbalances Between Partners Influence Young Adolescents’ Friendship Rivalry and Competition.” Pp. 163–97 in The Psychology of Rivalry edited by HartS. L.JonesN. A.. Hauppauge, NY: Nova Science Publishers.
61.
ParsonsTalcott.1963. “On the Concept of Influence.” The Public Opinion Quarterly27(1):37–62.
62.
PaternosterRayMcGloinJean MarieNguyenHollyThomasKyle J.. 2013. “The Causal Impact of Exposure to Deviant Peers: An Experimental Investigation.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency50(4):476–503.
63.
PiqueroAlex R.FarringtonDavid P.BlumsteinAlfred. 2007. Key Issues in Criminal Career Research: New Analyses of the Cambridge Study in Delinquent Development.Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
64.
PogarskyGregPiqueroAlex R.PaternosterRay. 2004. “Modeling Change in Perceptions about Sanction Threats: The Neglected Linkage in Deterrence Theory.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology20(4):343–69.
65.
PrattTravis C.CullenFrancis T.SellersChristine S.WinfreeThomasJrMadensenTamera D.DaigleLeah E.FearnNoelle E.GauJacinta M.. 2010. “The Empirical Status of Social Learning Theory: A Meta-Analysis.” Justice Quarterly27(6):765–802.
66.
PresserLoisSandbergSveinung. 2015 “Introduction: What is the Story?” Pp. 1–20 in Narrative Criminology: Understanding Stories of Crime, edited by PresserL.SandbergS.. New York: New York University Press.
67.
PytlakMarissa. A.HouserMarian L.. 2014. “Because I’m the Teacher and I Said So: GTA Use of Behavior Alteration Techniques to Establish Power and Credibility in the College Classroom.” Western Journal of Communication78(3):287–309.
68.
RaganDaniel T.2014. “Revisiting ‘What They Think’: Adolescent Drinking and the Importance of Peer Beliefs.” Criminology: an Interdisciplinary Journal52(3):488–513.
69.
RaganDaniel T.2020. “Similarity between Deviant Peers: Developmental Trends in Influence and Selection.” Criminology: an Interdisciplinary Journal58(2):336–69.
70.
ReissAlbert J.Jr. 1988. “Co-Offending and Criminal Careers.” Pp. 117–70in Crime and Justice, vol 10, edited by MorrisN.TonryM.H.. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
71.
ReissAlbert J.Jr. and FarringtonDavid P.. 1991. “Advancing Knowledge About Co-offending: Results from a Prospective Longitudinal Survey of London Males.” Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology82:360–95.
72.
RowanZachary R.KanEmilyFrickPaul J.CauffmanElizabeth. 2022. “Not (Entirely) Guilty: The Role of Co-offenders in Diffusing Responsibility for Crime.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency59(4):415–48.
73.
RubinKenneth. H.BukowskiWilliam M.LaursenBrett. 2009. Handbook of Peer Interactions, Relationships, and Groups. New York: The Guilford Press.
74.
RyanAshley L.2023. Pressuring Others: Examining the Motivations Behind Deviant Instigation and the Strategies that Accompany Them.Thesis at the University of Waterloo, Ontario, Canada.
75.
ShawClifford R.1931. The Natural History of a Delinquent Career. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
76.
ShawClifford R.1966. The Jack-Roller: A Delinquent Boy’s Own Story. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
77.
ShortJames F.Jr. and StrodtbeckFred L.. 1965. Group Process and Gang Delinquency. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
78.
SijtsemaJelle J.LindenbergSiegwart M.. 2018. “Peer Influence in the Development of Adolescent Antisocial Behavior: Advances from Dynamic Social Network Studies.” Developmental Review50:140–54.
79.
SkinnerBurrhus F.1953. Science and Human Behavior. New York: McMillan.
80.
StaffordMark C.WarrMark. 1993. “A Reconceptualization of General and Specific Deterrence.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency30(2):123–35.
81.
SutherlandEdwin H.1947. Principles of Criminology. 4th ed.Chicago, IL: J.B. Lippincott.
82.
SykesGresham M.MatzaDavid. 1957. “Techniques of Neutralization: A Theory of Delinquency.” American Sociological Review22(6):664–70.
83.
ThibautJohn W.KelleyHarold H.. 1959. The Social Psychology of Groups.New York: Routledge.
84.
ThomasKyle J.McCuddyTimothy. 2019. “Affinity, Affiliation, and Guilt: Examining Between- and Within-Person Variability in Delinquent Peer Influence.” Justice Quarterly37(4):715–38.
85.
ThomasKyle J.NguyenHolly. 2020. “Status Gains Versus Status Losses: Loss Aversion and Deviance.” Justice Quarterly39(4):871–96.
86.
ThrasherFrederic M.1927. The Gang: A Study of 1,313 Gangs in Chicago. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
87.
TrostMelanie R.LanganEmily J.Kellar-GuentherYvonne. 1999. “Not Everyone Listens When You ‘Just Say No’: Drug Resistance in Relational Context.” Journal of Applied Communication Research27(2):120–38.
88.
Van der LaanAndré M.BlomMartine. 2011. Jeugdcriminaliteit in de Periode 1996–2010: Ontwikkelingen in Zelfgerapporteerde Daders, Door de Politie Aangehouden Verdachten en Strafrechtelijke Daders op Basis van de Monitor Jeugdcriminaliteit 2010.Den Haag, the Netherlands: WODC.
89.
Van GelderJean-Louis.2023. “Virtual Reality for Criminologists: A Road Map.” Crime and Justice52(1):1–49.
90.
Van LaarMargriet W.van Ooyen-HoubenMarianne M. J.CrutsGuus A.A.N.MeijerR. F.CroesEsther A.KetelaarsA. P. M.van der PolPeggy M.. 2014. Nationale Drug Monitor: Jaarbericht 2013/2014. Utrecht and Den Haag, The Netherlands: Trimbos-instituut/WODC.
91.
Von NeumannJohnMorgensternOskar. 1944. Theory of Games and Economic Behavior.Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
92.
WadeT. JoelMogilskiJustinSchoenbergRachel. 2018. “Sex Differences in Reconciliation Behavior after Romantic Conflict.” Evolutionary Psychological Science4:1–7.
93.
WarrMark.1996. “Organization and Instigation in Delinquent Groups.” Criminology: an Interdisciplinary Journal34(1):11–37.
94.
WarrMark.2002. Companions in Crime: The Social Aspects of Criminal Conduct. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
95.
WarrMarkStaffordMark C.. 1991. “The Influence of Delinquent Peers: What They Think or What They Do?” Criminology: an Interdisciplinary Journal29(4):851–66.
96.
WhyteWilliam F.1943. Street Corner Society. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
97.
WikströmPer-Olof H.OberwittlerDietrichTreiberKyleHardieBeth. 2012. Breaking Rules: The Social and Situational Dynamics of Young People's Urban Crime. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
