An initial investigation by the Department of Justice (DOJ) found that the Newark Police Department (NPD) had engaged in a “pattern or practice” of constitutional violations with regard to stop and arrest practices, prompting the city to enter a consent decree.
Methods:
This study draws on official event-level data on FIs recorded by NPD officers (N = 50,322) and uses random effects panel regression models to examine how socioeconomic characteristics interact with the implementation of the consent decree at micro places in the short term.
Results:
Spatial analyses indicate a concentration of FI encounters. The implementation of the consent decree coincided with improvements in the quality of data collected by officers conducting FIs of citizens. It was also associated with decreased rates of reported FIs for the city’s Black and Latino citizens relative to their share of the local population, and patterns of FI encounters.
Conclusions:
Newark’s consent decree improved the quality of data collection. However, the spatial concentration of reported FIs and subsequent arrest of Black and Latino individuals have not experienced the same effect as they presumably require a culture change that is likely to necessitate a longer time frame to manifest.
AlpertGeoffrey P.DunhamRoger G.SmithMichael R.. 2007. “Investigating Racial Profiling by the Miami-Dade Police Department: A Multimethod Approach.” Criminology & Public Policy6:25–55.
2.
AlpertGeoffrey P.McLeanKyleWolfeScott. 2017. “Consent Decrees: An Approach to Police Accountability and Reform.” Police Quarterly20:239–49.
3.
AnselinLuc. 1995. “Local indicators of spatial association—LISA.” Geographical Analysis27:93–115.
4.
AzarovaValeriyaMierMathias. 2021. “Market Stability Reserve under Exogenous Shock: The case of COVID-19 pandemic.” Applied Energy283:116351.
BragaAnthony A.BrunsonRod K.DrakulichKevin M.. 2019. “Race, Place, and Effective Policing.” Annual Review of Sociology45:535–55.
8.
BragaAnthony A.HureauDavid M.PapachristosAndrew V.. 2011. “The Relevance of Micro Places to Citywide Robbery trends: A Longitudinal Analysis of Robbery Incidents at Street Corners and Block Faces in Boston.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency48:7–32.
9.
BragaAnthony A.TurchanBrandon S.PapachristosAndrew V.HureauDavid M.. 2019. “Hot Spots Policing and Crime Reduction: An Update of an Ongoing Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.” Journal of Experimental Criminology15:289–311.
10.
BrayneSarah. 2014. “Surveillance and System Avoidance: Criminal Justice Contact and Institutional Attachment.” American Sociological Review79:367–91.
11.
BrunsonRod K.2007. “Police don’t like Black People”: African-American young men’s Accumulated Police Experiences.” Criminology & Public Policy6:71–101.
12.
BrunsonRod K.WadeBrian A.. 2019. “Oh hell no, we don't talk to police” Insights on the lack of cooperation in police investigations of urban gun violence.” Criminology & Public Policy18:623–648.
13.
BrunsonRod K.WeitzerRonald. 2009. “Police relations with black and white youths in different urban neighborhoods.” Urban Affairs Review44:858–885.
14.
Cabrera-BaronaPablo F.JimenezGualdemarMeloPablo. 2019. “Types of Crime, Poverty, Population Density and Presence of Police in the Metropolitan District of Quito.” ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information8:558.
15.
CampbellDonald T.StanleyJulian C.. 1967. Experimental and Quasi Experimental Designs for Research. Chicago: Rand Mc Nally and Co.
16.
CarterJeremy G.PizaEric L.. 2018. “Spatiotemporal Convergence of Crime and Vehicle Crash Hotspots: Additional Consideration for Policing Places.” Crime & Delinquency64:1795–819.
17.
CesarioJosephJohnsonDavid J.TerrillWilliam. 2019. “Is there Evidence of Racial Disparity in Police use of Deadly force? Analyses of Officer-involved Fatal Shootings in 2015–2016.” Social Psychological and Personality Science10:586–95.
18.
ChaineySpencer. 2010. “Advanced Hotspot Analysis: Spatial Significance Mapping using Gi*.” UCL Jill Dando Institute of Crime Science, University College London, London.
19.
ChanJanet. 1996. “Changing Police Culture.” The British Journal of Criminology36:109–34.
20.
ChaninJoshua. 2014. “On the Implementation of Pattern or Practice Police Reform.” Criminology, Criminal Justice, Law & Society15:38.
21.
ChaninJoshua. 2015. “Examining the Sustainability of Pattern or Practice Police Misconduct Reform.” Police Quarterly18:163–92.
22.
ChaninJoshua. 2017. “Early Stages of Pattern or Practice Police Misconduct Reform: An Examination of the Department of Justice’s Investigation and Negotiation Processes.” Police Quarterly20:250–74.
ChengTaoAdepejuMonsuru. 2014. “Modifiable Temporal Unit Problem (MTUP) and its Effect on Space-Time Cluster Detection.” PloS One9:e100465.
25.
ChoiIn. 2001. “Unit Root Tests for Panel Data.” Journal of International Money and Finance20: 249–72.
26.
DavisRobert CarlHendersonNicole J.OrtizChristopher W.. 2005. Can Federal Intervention Bring Lasting Improvement in Local Policing?: The Pittsburgh Consent Decree. New York: Vera Institute of Justice.
27.
DavisRobert C.OrtizChristopher W.HendersonNicole J.MillerJoelMassieMichelle K.. 2002. Turning Necessity Into Virtue: Pittsburgh’s Experience with a Federal Consent Decree. New York: Vera Institute of Justice.
28.
DeviTanayaFryerRoland G.Jr. 2020. “Policing the Police: The Impact of” Pattern-or Practice” Investigations on Crime.” Working Paper No. w27324National Bureau of Economic Research, Chicago.
29.
D’SouzaAmandaWeitzerRonaldBrunsonRod K.. 2019. “Federal Investigations of Police Misconduct: A Multi-City Comparison.” Crime, Law and Social Change71:461–82.
30.
EckJohnChaineySpencerCameronJamesWilsonRonald. 2005. Mapping crime: Understanding Hotspots. Scotts Valley, CA: Create Space Independent Pub.:1–71.
31.
EdwardsFrankLeeHedwigEspositoMichael. 2019. “Risk of Being Killed by Police use of Force in the United States by Age, Race–Ethnicity, and Sex.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences116:16793–98.
32.
EngelRobin S.2000. “The Effects of Supervisory Styles on Patrol Officer Behavior.”Police Quarterly3:262–93.
33.
EngelRobin S.SmithMichael R.CullenFrancis T.. 2012. “Race, Place, and Drug Enforcement: Reconsidering the Impact of Citizen Complaints and Crime Rates on Drug Arrests.” Criminology & Public Policy11:603.
FaganJeffreyBragaAnthony A.BrunsonRod K.PattavinaApril. 2016. “Stops and Stares: Street Stops, Surveillance, and Race in the New Policing.” Fordham Urban Law Journal43:539.
36.
FavaraGiovanniImbsJean. 2015. “Credit Supply and the Price of Housing.” American Economic Review105:958–92.
37.
FerrandinoJoseph. 2015. “Minority Threat Hypothesis and NYPD Stop and Frisk Policy.” Criminal Justice Review40:209–29.
38.
GastonShytierra. 2019. “Enforcing Race: A Neighborhood-Level Explanation of Black–White Differences in Drug Arrests.” Crime & Delinquency65:499–526.
39.
GastonShytierraBrunsonRod K.. 2018. “Reasonable Suspicion in the Eye of the Beholder: Routine Policing in Racially Different Disadvantaged Neighborhoods.” Urban Affairs Review56:188–227.
40.
GastonShytierraBrunsonRod K.GrossmanLeigh S.. 2020. “Are Minorities Subjected to, or Insulated from, Racialized Policing in Majority–minority Community Contexts?.” The British Journal of Criminology60:1416–37.
41.
GellerAmandaGoffPhillip AtibaLloydTraceyHavilandAmeliaObermarkDeanGlaserJack. 2020. “Measuring Racial Disparities in Police Use of Force: Methods Matter.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology1–31.
42.
GelmanAndrewFaganJeffreyKissAlex. 2007. “An Analysis of the New York City Police Department’s “Stop-and-Frisk” Policy in the Context of Claims of Racial Bias.” Journal of the American Statistical Association102:813–23.
43.
GelmanAndrewHillJennifer. 2006. Data analysis using regression and multilevel/hierarchical models. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
44.
GerellManne. 2016. “Hot spot Policing with Actively Monitored CCTV Cameras: Does it Reduce Assaults in Public Places?” International Criminal Justice Review26:187–201.
45.
GetisArthurOrdJ. K.. 1992. “The Analysis of Spatial Association by Use of Distance Statistics.” Geographical Analysis24:189–206.
46.
GetisArthurOrdJ. K.. 1996. Spatial Analysis and Modeling in a GIS Environment. A Research Agenda for Geographic Information Science 157-196. Boca Raton, FLCRC Press
47.
GohLi Sian. 2020. “Going Local: Do Consent Decrees and other Forms of Federal Intervention in Municipal Police Departments Reduce Police Killings?.” Justice Quarterly37:900–29.
48.
HabermanCory P.StiverWendy H.. 2019. “The Dayton Foot Patrol Program: An Evaluation of Hot Spots Foot Patrols in a Central Business District.” Police Quarterly22:247–77.
49.
HarmonRachel A.2017. “Evaluating and Improving Structural Reform in Police Departments.” Criminology & Public. Policy16:617.
50.
HarrellErika.DavisElizabeth. 2020. Contacts Between Police and the Public 2018. US Department of Justice Office of Justice Programs Bureau of Justice Statistics Special Report: 1–14.
51.
HarrisAlexes. 2016. A Pound of Flesh: Monetary Sanctions as Punishment for the Poor. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
52.
HausmanJerry A.1978. “Specification Tests in Econometrics.” Econometrica: Journal of the Econometric Society46:1251–71.
53.
HsiaoChang. 1986. Analysis of Panel Data. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
54.
IngramJason R.2007. “The Effect of Neighborhood Characteristics on Traffic Citation Practices of the Police.” Police Quarterly10:371–93.
55.
IngramJason R.EugeneA. Paoline, IIITerrillWilliam. 2013. “A Multilevel Framework for Understanding Police Culture: The Role of the Workgroup.” Criminology51: 365–97.
56.
JohnsonShane D.BowersKate J.BirksDan J.PeaseKen. 2009. “Predictive Mapping of Crime by ProMap: Accuracy, Units of Analysis, and the Environmental backcloth.” Pp. 171–98 in Putting Crime In Its Place, edited by WeisburdD.BruinsmaG.BernascoW.. New York: Springer.
57.
KirkDavid S.MatsudaMauri. 2011. “Legal cynicism, collective efficacy, and the ecology of arrest.” Criminology49:443–472.
58.
KlingerDavid A.1997. “Negotiating Order in Patrol Work: An Ecological Theory of Police Response to Deviance.” Criminology35:277–306.
59.
Kohler-HausmannIssa. 2018. Misdemeanorland: Criminal Courts and Social Control in an Age of Broken Windows PolicingPrinceton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
60.
KramerRoryRemsterBrianna. 2018. “Stop, Frisk, and Assault? Racial Disparities in Police Use of Force During Investigatory Stops.” Law & Society Review52:960–93.
61.
KupferbergNoah. 2008. “Transparency: A New Role for Police Consent Decrees.” Columbia Journal of Law and Social Problems 42:129.
62.
LegewieJoscha. 2016. “Racial Profiling and Use of Force in Police Stops: How Local Events Trigger Periods of Increased Discrimination.” American Journal of Sociology122:379–424.
63.
LipskyMichael. 1983. Street-Level Bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Service. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
64.
MacDonaldJohnBragaAnthony A.. 2019. “Did post-Floyd et al. Reforms Reduce Racial disparities in NYPD stop, Question, and Frisk Practices? An Exploratory Analysis using External and Internal Benchmarks.” Justice Quarterly36:954–83.
65.
MaguireEdward R.JohnsonDevonKuhnsJoseph B.ApostolosRobert. 2017. “The Effects of Community Policing on Fear of Crime and perceived Safety: Findings from a Pilot Project in Trinidad and Tobago.”Policing and Society. 29491–510
66.
MitchellOjmarrh. 2009. “Is the war on drugs racially biased?.” Journal of Crime and Justice32:49–75.
MorrowWeston J.WhiteMichael D.FradellaHenry F.. 2017. “After the Stop: Exploring the Racial/Ethnic Disparities in Police use of force During Terry Stops.” Police Quarterly20:367–96.
69.
MuirWilliam K.1979. Police: Streetcorner PoliticiansChicagoUniversity of Chicago Press
PetrocelliMatthewPiqueroAlex R.SmithMichael R.. 2003. “Conflict Theory and Racial Profiling: An Empirical Analysis of Police Traffic Stop Data.” Journal of Criminal Justice, 31:1–11.
73.
PhillipsJulie A.GreenbergDavid F.. 2008. “A Comparison of Methods for Analyzing Criminological Panel Data.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology24:51–72.
74.
PiatkowskaSylwia J.MessnerSteven F.GrunerColinBaumerEric P.. 2020. “The “New Fiscal Criminology”: State-Level Changes in Crime Rates and the Structure of Tax Systems.” Justice Quarterly1–23.
75.
PizaEric L.ChillarVijay F.. 2020. “The Effect of Police Layoffs on Crime: A Natural Experiment Involving New Jersey’s Two Largest Cities.” Justice Evaluation Journal1–19.
76.
PizaEric L.GilchristAndrew M.. 2018. “Measuring the Effect Heterogeneity of Police Enforcement Actions across Spatial Contexts.” Journal of Criminal Justice54:76–87.
77.
Police Executive Research Forum. 2016. “Guiding Principles on Use of Force.” Pp. 1–136 in Critical Issues in Policing Series. Retreived April 2, 2020, fromhttp://www.policeforum.org/assets/30%20guiding%20principles.pdf. Washington, DC: Police Executive Research Forum.
78.
PowellZachary A.MeitlMichele BisacciaWorrallJohn L.. 2017. “Police Consent Decrees and Section 1983 Civil Rights Litigation.” Criminology & Public Policy16:575–605.
79.
QuillianLincolnPagerDevah. 2001. “Black Neighbors, Higher Crime? The Role of Racial Stereotypes in Evaluations of Neighborhood Crime.” American Journal of Sociology107:717–67.
80.
RameyDavid M.ShriderEmily A.. 2014. “New parochialism, sources of community investment, and the control of street crime.” Criminology & Public Policy13:193–216.
81.
RatcliffeJerry H.McCullaghMichael J.. 1999. “Hotbeds of Crime and the Search for Spatial Accuracy.” Journal of Geographical Systems1:385–98.
82.
RatcliffeJerry. 2010. “Crime Mapping: Spatial and Temporal Challenges.” Pp. 5–24 in Handbook of Quantitative Criminology, edited by PiqueroA. R.WeisburdD.. New York: Springer.
83.
ReissAlbert J. 1971. The Police and the Public. Vol. 39. New Haven, CTYale University Press
84.
RengifoAndres F.FowlerKurt. 2016. “Stop, question, and Complain: Citizen Grievances Against the NYPD and the Opacity of police Stops Across New York City Precincts, 2007 2013.” Journal of Urban Health93:32–41.
85.
RengifoAndres F.PaterMorgan. 2017. “Close call: Race and Gender in Encounters with the Police by Black and Latino/a Youth in New York City.” Sociological Inquiry87:337–61.
86.
RengifoAndres F.SlocumLee Ann. 2020. “The Identity Prism: How Racial Identification Frames Perceptions of Police Contact, Legitimacy, and Effectiveness.” Law & Social Inquiry45:590–617.
87.
RengifoAndres F.SlocumLee AnnChillarVijay. 2019. “From Impressions to Intentions: Direct and Indirect Effects of Police Contact on Willingness to Report Crimes to Law Enforcement.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency56:412–50.
88.
RengifoAndres F.StemenDonAmidonEthan. 2017. “When Policy comes to town: Discourses and Dilemmas of Implementation of a Statewide Reentry Policy in Kansas.” Criminology55:603–30.
89.
Reuss-IanniElizabeth. 1983. Two Cultures of Policing: Street Cops and Management Cops. Piscataway, NJ: Transaction Publishers.
90.
RidgewayGreg. 2017. “Stop-and-Frisk is Essential…and Requires Restraint.” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management36:683–689.
91.
RobinsonLaurie O.2020. Five Years after Ferguson: Reflecting on Police Reform and What’s Ahead. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 687:228–39.
92.
RobinsonW. S.1950. “Ecological Correlations and Individual Behavior.” American Sociological Review15:351–57.
93.
RojekJeffRosenfeldRichardDeckerScott. 2012. “Policing Race: The Racial Stratification of Searches in Police Traffic Stops.” Criminology50:993–1024.
94.
RosenbaumDennis P.SchuckAmie M.CostelloSandra K.HawkinsDarnell F.RingMarianne K.. 2005. “Attitudes Toward the Police: The Effects of Direct and Vicarious Experience.” Police Quarterly8:343–65.
95.
RubinsteinJonathan. 1980. City policeNew YorkMacmillan
96.
RushinStephen. 2014. “Structural reform Litigation in American Police Departments.” Minnesota Law Review99:1343.
97.
SampsonRobert J.BartuschDawn Jeglum. 1998 “Legal Cynicism and (subcultural?) Tolerance of Deviance: The Neighborhood Context of Racial Differences.” Law and Society Review32:777–804.
98.
SampsonRobert J.RaudenbushStephen W.EarlsFelton. 1997. “Neighborhoods and Violent Crime: A Multilevel Study of Collective Efficacy.” Science277:918–24.
99.
ShermanLawrence. 2018. “Reducing Fatal Police Shootings as System Crashes: Research, Theory, and Practice.” Annual Review of Criminology1:421–49.
100.
Sierra-ArévaloMichael. 2019. “The Commemoration of Death, Organizational Memory, and Police Culture.” Criminology57:632–58.
101.
Sierra‐ArévaloMichael. 2021. “American policing and the danger imperative.” Law & Society Review55:70–103.
SkolnickJerome H. 1994. Justice without Trial: Law Enforcement in Democratic Society. New Orleans, LA: Quid pro books.
106.
SmithDouglas A.1986. “The Neighborhood Context of Police Behavior.” Crime and Justice8:313–341.
107.
SmithMichael R.MakariosMatthewAlpertGeoffrey P.. 2006. “Differential Suspicion: Theory Specification and Gender Effects in the Traffic Stop Context.” Justice Quarterly23:271–95.
108.
StoneChristopherFoglesongTodd S.ColeChristine M.. 2009. Policing Los Angeles Under a Consent Decree: The Dynamics of Change at the LAPD. Cambridge, MA: Program in Criminal Justice Policy and Management, Harvard Kennedy School.
Torres-ReynaOscar. 2007. Panel Data Analysis Fixed and Random Effects using Stata (v. 4.2). Data & Statistical Services, Princeton University, pp. 1–40.
116.
TurchanBrandon. 2020. “A High-Profile Police-Involved Shooting, Civil Unrest, and Officers’ Perceptions of Legitimacy: Insights from a Natural Experiment.” Journal of Experimental Criminology:1–12.
117.
TylerTom R.2003. “Procedural Justice, Legitimacy, and the Effective Rule of Law.” Crime and Justice30:283–357.
118.
Van MaanenJohn.1979. “The Fact of Fiction in Organizational Ethnography.” Administrative Science Quarterly24:539–50.
119.
WeisburdDavid. 2015. “The Law of Crime Concentration and the Criminology of Place.” Criminology53:133–57.
120.
WeisburdDavidMajmundarMalay K.. 2018. Proactive Policing: Effects on Crime and Communities. Committee on Proactive Policing: Effects on Crime, Communities, and Civil Liberties. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.
121.
WerthmanCarlPiliavinIrving. 1967. Gang Members and the Police. Office of Juvenile Delinquency and Youth Development, Welfare Administration, Department of Health, Education and Welfare.
122.
WestleyWilliam A.1970. Violence and the Police. Cambridge, MA: MIT press.
123.
WillisJames J.MastrofskyStephen D.WeisburdDavid. 2007. Making sense of COMPSTAT: A Theory-based Analysis of Organizational Change in three Police Departments. Law & Society Review41:147–88.
124.
WuXiaoyunLumCynthia. 2017. “Measuring the Spatial and Temporal Patterns of Police Proactivity.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology33:915–34.
125.
United States v. City of Newark (2016). consent decree, No.2:16-cv-01731-MCA-MAH.
126.
Terry v. Ohio, 392 U.S. 1 (1968).
127.
Floyd et al. v. City of New York, 959 F. Supp. 2d 540 (SDNY 2013).
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
