Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2018-11
Is Exposure to Violence a Persistent Risk Factor for Offending across the Life Course? Examining the Contemporaneous,Acute,Enduring,and Long-term Consequences of Exposure to Violence on Property Crime,Violent Offending,and Substance Use
To examine the contemporaneous (cross-sectional), acute (1 year), enduring (5–7 years), and long-term (12–13 years) effects of exposure to violence on offending behaviors.
Methods:
We analyze four waves of data from the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent to Adult Health (N = 7,706). Exposure to violence captures direct (interpersonal victimization and violent threats) and indirect (witnessing violence) experiences with violence. Outcome measures include property crime, violent offending, and substance use. A series of logistic regression models examine the acute, enduring, and long-term effects of exposure to violence on the offending outcomes at each study wave, controlling for exposure to violence, lagged dependent variables, and baseline covariates at all previous waves.
Results:
The effects of exposure to violence on violent offending persist over time, with effects attenuating over time. However, exposure to violence only has contemporaneous and acute effects on property crime and drug use.
Conclusions:
Long-term effects of exposure to violence on violent offending are not an artifact of confounding with more recent experiences with violence. Both distal and proximate effects of exposure to violence should be addressed in order to adequately disrupt the overlap between exposure to violence and violent offending.
AgnewRobert. 1992. “Foundation for a General Strain Theory of Crime and Delinquency.” Criminology30(1):47–88.
2.
AgnewRobert. 2001. “Building on the Foundation of General Strain Theory: Specifying the Types of Strain Most Likely to Lead to Crime and Delinquency.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency38(4):319–61.
3.
AgnewRobert. 2002. “Experienced, Vicarious, and Anticipated Strain: An Exploratory Study on Physical Victimization and Delinquency.” Justice Quarterly19(4):603–32.
4.
AkersRonald L.JensenGary F., eds. 2003. Social Learning Theory and the Explanation of Crime: A Guide for the New Century. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction.
5.
AndersonElijah. 1999. Code of the Street: New York: Norton.
6.
ApelRobertBurrowJohn D.. 2011. “Adolescent Victimization and Violent Self-help.” Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice9(2):112–33.
7.
BakerJoseph O.2010. “The Expression of Low Self-control as Problematic Drinking in Adolescents: An Integrated Control Perspective.” Journal of Criminal Justice38(3):237–44.
8.
BaronStephen W.2004. “General Strain, Street Youth and Crime: A Test of Agnew’s Revised Theory.” Criminology42(2):457–84.
BrameRobertBushwayShawnPaternosterRaymond. 1999. “On the Use of Panel Research Designs and Random Effects Models to Investigate Static and Dynamic Theories of Criminal Offending.” Criminology37(3):599–642.
11.
BrezinaTimothyAgnewRobertCullenFrancis T.WrightJohn Paul. 2004. “The Code of the Street: A Quantitative Assessment of Elijah Anderson’s Subculture of Violence Thesis and Its Contribution to Youth Violence Research.” Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice2(4):303–28.
12.
BriereJohnRuntzMarsha. 1990. “Differential Adult Symptomatology Associated with Three Types of Child Abuse Histories.” Child Abuse & Neglect14(3):357–64.
13.
BrownJocelynCohenPatriciaJohnsonJeffrey G.SmailesElizabeth M.. 1999. “Childhood Abuse and Neglect: Specificity of Effects on Adolescent and Young Adult Depression and Suicidality.” Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry38(12):1490–96.
14.
BrowningSarahEricksonPatricia. 2009. “Neighborhood Disadvantage, Alcohol Use, and Violent Victimization.” Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice7(4):331–49.
15.
BukaStephen L.StichickTheresa L.BirdthistleIsoldeEarlsFelton J.. 2001. “Youth Exposure to Violence: Prevalence, Risks, and Consequences.” American Journal of Orthopsychiatry71(3):298.
16.
ChenPingChantalaKim. 2014. Guidelines for Analyzing Add Health Data. Carolina Population Center, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill1–53.
17.
ClearySean D.2000. “Adolescent Victimization and Associated Suicidal and Violent Behaviors.” Adolescence35(140):671.
18.
CohenJudith A.DeblingerEstherMannarinoAnthony P.SteerRobert A.. 2004. “A Multisite, Randomized Controlled Trial for Children with Sexual Abuse–related PTSD Symptoms.” Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry43(4):393–402.
19.
CollinsLinda M.2006. “Analysis of Longitudinal Data: The Integration of Theoretical Model, Temporal Design, and Statistical Model.” Annual Review of Psychology57:505–28.
20.
CraigJessica M.2016. “Which Bond Matters More? Assessing the Differential Strengths of Parental Bonding Measures on Adolescent Delinquency over Time.” Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice14(3):225–42.
21.
CuevasCarlos A.FinkelhorDavidCliffordCynthiaOrmrodRichard K.TurnerHeather A.. 2010. “Psychological Distress as a Risk Factor for Re-victimization in Children.” Child Abuse & Neglect34(4):235–43.
22.
DadayJerry K.BroidyLisa M.CrandallCameron S.SklarDavid P.. 2005. “Individual, Neighborhood, and Situational Factors Associated with Violent Victimization and Offending.” Criminal Justice Studies18(3):215–35.
23.
DaigleLeah E.BeaverKevin M.HartmanJennifer L.. 2008. “A Life-course Approach to the Study of Victimization and Offending Behaviors.” Victims and Offenders3(4):365–90.
24.
DavisJames A.1985. The Logic of Causal Order, Vol. 55. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
25.
EitleDavidJay TurnerR.. 2002. “Exposure to Community Violence and Young Adult Crime: The Effects of Witnessing Violence, Traumatic Victimization, and Other Stressful Life Events.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency39(2):214–37.
26.
FaganAbigail A.2003. “The Short- and Long-term Effects of Adolescent Violent Victimization Experienced within the Family and Community.” Violence and Victims18(4):445–59.
27.
FaganAbigail A.WrightEmily M.PinchevskyGillian M.. 2014. “The Protective Effects of Neighborhood Collective Efficacy on Adolescent Substance Use and Violence Following Exposure to Violence.” Journal of Youth and Adolescence43(9):1498–512.
28.
FarrellChelsea. 2017. “Exploring the Overlap between Sexual Victimization and Offending among Young Women across Neighborhoods: Does the Type of Force and Type of Offending Matter?” Journal of Interpersonal Violence1–29. doi:10.1177/0886260516689778.
29.
FarrellChelseaZimmermanGregory M.. 2017. “Does Offending Intensify as Exposure to Violence Aggregates? Reconsidering the Effects of Repeat Victimization, Types of Exposure to Violence, and Poly-victimization on Property Crime, Violent Offending, and Substance Use.” Journal of Criminal Justice53:25–33.
30.
FergussonDavid M.John HorwoodL.. 1998. “Exposure to Interparental Violence in Childhood and Psychosocial Adjustment in Young Adulthood.” Child Abuse & Neglect22(5):339–57.
31.
FinkelhorDavidOrmrodRichard K.TurnerHeather A.. 2007. “Poly-victimization: A Neglected Component in Child Victimization.” Child Abuse & Neglect31(1):7–26.
32.
FinkelhorDavidOrmrodRichard K.TurnerHeather A.HambySherry L.. 2005. “Measuring Poly-victimization Using the Juvenile Victimization Questionnaire.” Child Abuse & Neglect29(11):1297–312.
33.
FinkelhorDavidTurnerHeatherOrmrodRichardHambySherry L.. 2009. “Violence, Abuse, and Crime Exposure in a National Sample of Children and Youth.” Pediatrics124(5):1411–23.
34.
FinkelhorDavidTurnerHeather A.ShattuckAnneHambySherry L.. 2013. “Violence, Crime, and Abuse Exposure in a National Sample of Children and Youth: An Update.” JAMA Pediatrics167(7):614–21.
35.
FordJulian D.ElhaiJon D.ConnorDaniel F.Christopher FruehB.. 2010. “Poly-Victimization and Risk of Posttraumatic, Depressive, and Substance Use Disorders and Involvement in Delinquency in a National Sample of Adolescents.” Journal of Adolescent Health46(6):545–52.
36.
FowlerPatrick J.TompsettCarolyn J.BraciszewskiJordan M.Jacques-TiuraAngela J.BaltesBoris B.. 2009. “Community Violence: A Meta-analysis on the Effect of Exposure and Mental Health Outcomes of Children and Adolescents.” Development and Psychopathology21(1):227–59.
37.
GlenbergArthur M.BradleyMargaret M.StevensonJennifer A.KrausThomas A.TkachukMarilyn J.GretzAnn L.FishJoel H.TurpinBetty Ann M.. 1980. “A Two-process Account of Long-term Serial Position Effects.” Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory6(4):355.
38.
GottfredsonMichael R.HirschiTravis. 1990. A General Theory of Crime. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
39.
Halliday-BoykinsColleen A.GrahamSandra. 2001. “At Both Ends of the Gun: Testing the Relationship between Community Violence Exposure and Youth Violent Behavior.” Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology29(5):383–402.
40.
HambySherry L.FinkelhorDavid. 2001. Choosing and Using Child Victimization Questionnaires. Juvenile Justice Bulletin—NCJ186027, 1–15Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
41.
HarrisKathleen M.HalpernCarolyn T.WhitselEricHusseyJonTaborJoyceEntzelPamelaRichard UdryJ.. 2009. “The National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health: Research Design.” Retrieved on February 1, 2018. (http://www.cpc.unc.edu/projects/addhealth/design).
42.
HickmanLaura J.JaycoxLisa H.SetodjiClaude M.KofnerAaronSchultzDanaBarnes-ProbyDionneHarrisRacine. 2013. “How Much Does “How Much” Matter? Assessing the Relationship between Children’s Lifetime Exposure to Violence and Trauma Symptoms, Behavior Problems, and Parenting Stress.” Journal of Interpersonal Violence28(6):1338–62.
43.
HindelangMichael J.1976. Criminal Victimization in Eight American Cities: A Descriptive Analysis of Common Theft and Assault. Cambridge, MA: Ballinger Publishing Company.
44.
HirschiTravis. 1969. Causes of Delinquency. Berkeley: University of California Press.
45.
JenningsWesley G.HigginsGeorge E.TewksburyRichardGoverAngela R.PiqueroAlex R.. 2010. “A Longitudinal Assessment of the Victim-offender Overlap.” Journal of Interpersonal Violence25(12):2147–74.
46.
JenningsWesley G.ParkMiRangTomsichElizabeth A.GoverAngela R.AkersRonald L.. 2011. “Assessing the Overlap in Dating Violence Perpetration and Victimization Among South Korean College Students: The Influence of Social Learning and Self-control.” American Journal of Criminal Justice36(2):188–206.
47.
JenningsWesley G.PiqueroAlex R.ReingleJennifer M.. 2012. “On the Overlap between Victimization and Offending: A Review of the Literature.” Aggression and Violent Behavior17(1):16–26.
48.
Jonson-ReidMelissa. 1998. “Youth Violence and Exposure to Violence in Childhood: An Ecological Review.” Aggression and Violent Behavior3(2):159–79.
49.
KalsbeekWilliam D.YangJuanAgansRobert P.. 2002. “Predictors of Nonresponse in a Longitudinal Survey of Adolescents.” Pp. 1740–45 in Proceedings of the American Statistical Association (Survey Research Methods Section). Alexandria, VA: American Statistical Association.
50.
KilpatrickDean G.AciernoRonSaundersBenjaminResnickHeidi S.BestConnie L.SchnurrPaula P.. 2000. “Risk Factors for Adolescent Substance Abuse and Dependence: Data from a National Sample.” Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology68(1):19.
51.
LauritsenJanet L.LaubJohn H.. 2007. “Understanding the Link between Victimization and Offending: New Reflections on an Old Idea.” Crime Prevention Studies22:55.
52.
LauritsenJanet L.SampsonRobert J.LaubJohn H.. 1991. “The Link between Offending and Victimization among Adolescents.” Criminology29(2):265–92.
53.
LongJ. ScottFreeseJeremy. 2014. Regression Models for Categorical Dependent Variables Using Stata. College Station, TX: Stata Press.
54.
LynchJames P.AddingtonLynn A.. 2010. “Identifying and Addressing Response Errors in Self-report Surveys.” Pp. 251–72 in Handbook of Quantitative Criminology, edited by PiqueroAlex and WeisburdDavid. New York: Springer.
MatjaskoJennifer L.NeedhamBelinda L.GrundenLeslie N.FarbAmy Feldman. 2010. “Violent Victimization and Perpetration during Adolescence: Developmental Stage Dependent Ecological Models.” Journal of Youth and Adolescence39(9):1053–66.
57.
MaughanBarbaraRutterMichael. 1997. “Retrospective Reporting of Childhood Adversity: Issues in Assessing Long-term Recall.” Journal of Personality Disorders11(1):19–33.
58.
MaxfieldMichael G.WidomCathy Spatz. 1996. “The Cycle of Violence: Revisited 6 Years Later.” Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine150(4):390–95.
59.
McCabeKristen M.HoughRichard L.YehMayLucchiniSara E.HazenAndrea. 2005. “The Relation between Violence Exposure and Conduct Problems among Adolescents: A Prospective Study.” American Journal of Orthopsychiatry75(4):575–84.
60.
MenardScott. 2002. Short- and Long-term Consequences of Adolescent VictimizationOJJDP Youth Violence Research Bulletin, February 2002. Washington, DCDepartment of Justice
61.
MischelWalter. 1968. Personality and Assessment. New York: Wiley.
62.
MohammadEsror TamimShapiroEster R.WainwrightLaurel D.CarterAlice S.. 2015. “Impacts of Family and Community Violence Exposure on Child Coping and Mental Health.” Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology43(2):203–15.
63.
MuftićLisa R.FinnMary A.MarshErin A.. 2015. “The Victim-offender Overlap, Intimate Partner Violence, and Sex: Assessing Differences among Victims, Offenders, and Victim-offenders.” Crime & Delinquency61:899–926.
64.
NeedhamBelinda L.2007. “Gender Differences in Trajectories of Depressive Symptomatology and Substance Use during the Transition from Adolescence to Young Adulthood.” Social Science & Medicine65(6):1166–79.
65.
NofzigerStaceyKurtzDon. 2005. “Violent Lives: A Lifestyle Model Linking Exposure to Violence to Juvenile Violent Offending.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency42(1):3–26.
66.
O’NeilMadeline. 2016. “Does the School Day Matter? The Association between Adolescent School Attachment and Involvement and Adult Criminal Behavior.” Doctoral dissertation, Portland State University.
67.
PerkinsSuzanneGraham-BermannSandra. 2012. “Violence Exposure and the Development of School-related Functioning: Mental Health, Neurocognition, and Learning.” Aggression and Violent Behavior17(1):89–98.
68.
PinchevskyGillian M.WrightEmily M.FaganAbigail A.. 2013. “Gender Differences in the Effects of Exposure to Violence on Adolescent Substance Use.” Violence and Victims28(1):122.
69.
PiqueroAlex R.MacDonaldJohnDobrinAdamDaigleLeah E.CullenFrancis T.. 2005. “Self-control, Violent Offending, and Homicide Victimization: Assessing the General Theory of Crime.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology21(1):55–71.
70.
PosickChad. 2014. “Victimization and Reporting to the Police: The Role of Negative Emotionality.” Psychology of Violence4(2):210.
71.
RemsterBrianna. 2014. “Self-control and the Depression–Delinquency Link.” Deviant Behavior35(1):66–84.
72.
RichtersJohn E.MartinezPedro. 1993. “The NIMH Community Violence Project: I. Children as Victims of and Witnesses to Violence.” Psychiatry56(1):7–21.
73.
RobertsJenniferMulveyEdward P.HorneyJulieLewisJohnArterMichael L.. 2005. “A Test of Two Methods of Recall for Violent Events.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology21(2):175–93.
74.
SavageJoannePalmerJane E.MartinAlison B.. 2014. “Intergenerational Transmission: Physical Abuse and Violent vs. Nonviolent Criminal Outcomes.” Journal of Family Violence29(7):739–48.
75.
ShafferJennifer N.Barry RubackR.. 2002. Violent Victimization as a Risk Factor for Violent Offending among Juveniles. Juvenile Justice Bulletin. Rockville, MD: Juvenile Justice Clearinghouse.
76.
SpriggsAubrey L.HalpernCarolyn TuckerMartinSandra L.. 2009. “Continuity of Adolescent and Early Adult Partner Violence Victimization: Association with Witnessing Violent Crime in Adolescence.” Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health63(9):741–48.
77.
SuttonJames E.2010. “A Review of the Life-events Calendar Method for Criminological Research.” Journal of Criminal Justice38(5):1038–44.
78.
TomsichElizabethJenningsWesley G.RichardsTara N.GoverAngela R.PowersRáchael A.. 2017. “Childhood Physical Maltreatment and Young Adult Dating Violence: A Propensity Matching Approach.” Journal of Interpersonal Violence32(22):3475–496.
79.
TurnerHeather A.FinkelhorDavidOrmrodRichard. 2010. “Poly-victimization in a National Sample of Children and Youth.” American Journal of Preventive Medicine38(3):323–30.
80.
TurnerHeather A.ShattuckAnneFinkelhorDavidHambySherry. 2017. “Effects of Poly-victimization on Adolescent Social Support, Self-concept, and Psychological Distress.” Journal of Interpersonal Violence32(5):755–80.
81.
TylerKimberly A.MelanderLisa A.. 2015. “Child Abuse, Street Victimization, and Substance Use among Homeless Young Adults.” Youth & Society47(4):502–19.
82.
VanderWeeleTyler J.2009. “Marginal Structural Models for the Estimation of Direct and Indirect Effects.” Epidemiology20(1):18–26.
83.
VanderWeeleTyler J.JacksonJohn W.LiShanshan. 2016. “Causal Inference and Longitudinal Data: A Case Study of Religion and Mental Health.” Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology51(11):1457–466.
84.
ListenbeeRobert L.TorreJoe. 2012. Report of the Attorney General’s National Task Force on Children Exposed to Violence. Project Report U.S. Department of Justice
85.
WattsStephen J.McNultyThomas L.. 2013. “Childhood Abuse and Criminal Behavior: Testing a General Strain Theory Model.” Journal of Interpersonal Violence28(15):3023–40.
86.
WidomCathy Spatz. 1989. “The Cycle of Violence.” Science244(4901):160.
87.
WolfgangMartin F.1957. “Victim Precipitated Criminal Homicide.” Journal of Criminal Law, Criminology and Police Science48:1.
88.
WrightEmily M.FaganAbigail A.PinchevskyGillian M.. 2013. “The Effects of Exposure to Violence and Victimization across Life Domains on Adolescent Substance Use.” Child Abuse & Neglect37(11):899–909.
89.
ZimmermanGregory M.FarrellChelseaPosickChad. 2017. “Does the Strength of the Victim-offender Overlap Depend on the Relationship between the Victim and Perpetrator?” Journal of Criminal Justice48:21–29.
90.
ZimmermanGregory M.PosickChad. 2016. “Risk Factors for and Behavioral Consequences of Direct Versus Indirect Exposure to Violence.” American Journal of Public Health106(1):178–88.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
