The widespread use of camera surveillance in public places offers criminologists the opportunity to systematically and unobtrusively observe crime, their main subject matter. The purpose of this essay is to inform the reader of current developments in research on crimes caught on camera.
Methods:
We address the importance of direct observation of behavior and review criminological studies that used observational methods, with and without cameras, including the ones published in this issue. We also discuss the uses of camera recordings in other social sciences and in biology.
Results:
We formulate six key insights that emerge from the literature and make recommendations for future research.
Conclusions:
Camera recordings of real-life crime are likely to become part of the criminological tool kit that will help us better understand the situational and interactional elements of crime. Like any source, it has limitations that are best addressed by triangulation with other sources.
AluvihareRuwanBrömmelstroetMarco teHorstIris van der. 2014. “Cycling Policy and Design. Putting Practice into Knowledge.” Plan Amsterdam20:8.
2.
AndersonElijah. 1999. Code of the Street. New York, NY: Norton.
3.
BaranekGrace T.1999. “Autism During Infancy: A Retrospective Video Analysis of Sensory-motor and Social Behaviors at 9–12 Months of Age.” Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders29:213–24.
4.
BeattieGeoffrey. 1983. Talk: An Analysis of Speech and Non-Verbal Behaviour in Conversation. Milton Keynes, UK: Open University Press.
5.
BeauregardEricLeclercBenoit. 2007. “An Application of the Rational Choice Approach to the Offending Process of Sex Offenders: A Closer Look at the Decision-making.” Sexual Abuse19:115–33.
6.
BeijerDaanSmileyAlisonEizenmanMoshe. 2004. “Observed Driver Glance Behavior at Roadside Advertising Signs.” Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board1899:96–103.
7.
BennettMaxwell R.HattonSeanHermensDaniel F.LagopoulosJim. 2016. “Behavior, Neuropsychology and fMRI.” Progress in Neurobiology145–146:1–25.
8.
BernascoWimJacquesScott. 2015. “Where Do Dealers Solicit Customers and Sell Them Drugs? A Micro-level Multiple Method Study.” Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice31:376–408.
9.
BirdwhistellRay L.1970. Kinesics and Context: Essays on Body Motion Communication. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
10.
BuckleAbigailFarringtonDavid P.. 1984. “An Observational Study of Shopliting.” The British Journal of Criminology24:63–73.
11.
BuckleAbigailFarringtonDavid P.. 1994. “Measuring Shoplifting by Systematic Observation: A Replication Study.” Psychology, Crime & Law1:133–41.
12.
CaseyB. J.2002. “Windows into the Human Brain.” Science296:1408–09.
13.
ClarkeRonald V. 1995. “Situational Crime Prevention.” Crime and Justice19: 91–150.
14.
CollinsRandall. 2008. Violence: A Micro-sociological Theory. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
15.
CopesHeithBrownAnastasiaTewksburyRichard. 2011. “A Content Analysis of Ethnographic Research Published in Top Criminology and Criminal Justice Journals from 2000 to 2009.” Journal of Criminal Justice Education22:341–59.
16.
DabneyDean A.HollingerRichard C.DuganLaura. 2004. “Who Actually Steals? A Study of Covertly Observed Shoplifters.” Justice Quarterly21:693–728.
17.
DattaAnkurShahMubarakDa Vitoria LoboN.. 2002. “Person-on-person Violence Detection in Video Data.” Pp. 433–38 in Proceedings 16th International Conference on Pattern Recognition, Vol. 1, edited byKasturiR.LaurendeauD.SuenC.Los Alamitos, CA: IEEE Computer Society.
18.
GanpatSoenita MinakoemarieLeunJoanne van derNieuwbeertaPaul. 2013. “The Influence of Event Characteristics and Actors’ Behaviour on the Outcome of Violent Eventscomparing Lethal with Non-lethal Events.” British Journal of Criminology53:685–704.
19.
GeW.CollinsR. T.RubackR. B.. 2012. “Vision-based Analysis of Small Groups in Pedestrian Crowds.” IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence34:1003–16.
20.
GillMartinMatthewsRoger. 1994. “Robbers on Robbery: Offenders’ Perspectives.” Pp. 11–28 in Crime at Work. Studies in Security and Crime Prevention, Vol. 1, edited byGillM.. Leicester, UK: Perpetuity Press.
21.
GoffmanAlice. 2014. On the Run: Fugitive Life in an American City. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
GoffmanIrving. 1971. Relations in Public: Microstudies of the Public Order. New York: Basic Books.
24.
GonzalezMarta C.HidalgoCesar A.BarabasiAlbert-Laszlo. 2008. “Understanding Individual Human Mobility Patterns.” Nature453:779–82.
25.
GrahamKathrynBernardsSharonOsgoodWayne D.AbbeyAntoniaParksMichaelFlynnAndreaDumasTaraWellsSamantha. 2014. ““Blurred Lines?” Sexual Aggression and Barroom Culture.” Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research38:1416–24.
26.
GrahamKathrynHomelRoss. 2008. Raising the Bar: Preventing Aggression in and around Bars, Clubs and Pubs. Cullompton, UK: Willan.
27.
GrahamKathrynRocqueLinda LaYetmanRhodaJames RossT.GuistraEnrico. 1980. “Aggression and Barroom Environments.” Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs41:277–92.
28.
GrahamKathrynTremblayPaul F.WellsSamanthaPernanenKaiPurcellJohnJelleyJennifer. 2006. “Harm, Intent, and the Nature of Aggressive Behavior.” Assessment13:280–96.
29.
HumphreysLaud. 1970. Tearoom Trade: Impersonal Sex in Public Places. London, UK: Duckworth.
30.
JacobsBruce A.WrightRichard. 1999. “Stick-up, Street Culture, and Offender Motivation.” Criminology37:149–74.
31.
JacquesScottWrightRichard. 2010. “Right or Wrong? Toward a Theory of Irbs’ (Dis)Approval of Research.” Journal of Criminal Justice Education21:42–59.
32.
JacquesScottWrightRichard. 2015. Code of the Suburb: Inside the World of Young Middle-class Drug Dealers. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
33.
JobardFabienLévyRené. 2011. “Racial Profiling: The Parisian Police Experience.” Canadian Journal of Criminology and Criminal Justice53:87–93.
34.
KlusemannStefan. 2012. “Massacres as Process: A Micro-sociological Theory of Internal Patterns of Mass Atrocities.” European Journal of Criminology9:468–80.
35.
KnoblauchHubertSchnettlerBernt. 2012. “Videography: Analysing Video Data as a ‘Focused’ Ethnographic and Hermeneutical Exercise.” Qualitative Research12:334–56.
36.
KnoblauchSteven H.2005. “Body Rhythms and the Unconscious: Toward an Expanding of Clinical Attention.” Psychoanalytic Dialogues15:807–27.
37.
KuceraThomas E.BarrettReginald H.. 2011. “A History of Camera Trapping.” Pp. 9–26 in Camera Traps in Animal Ecology; Methods and Analyses, edited byO’ConnellA. F.NicholsJ. D.KaranthK. U.. New York: Springer.
38.
LevineMarkTaylorPaul J.BestRachel. 2011. “Third Parties, Violence, and Conflict Resolution: The Role of Group Size and Collective Action in the Microregulation of Violence.” Psychological Science22:406–12.
39.
LindegaardMarie Rosenkrantz. 2009. “Navigating Terrains of Violence: How South African Male Youngsters Negotiate Social Change.” Social Dynamics35:19–35.
40.
LindegaardMarie Rosenkrantz. 2010. “Method, Actor and Context Triangulations: Knowing What Happened During Criminal Events and the Motivations for Getting Involved.” Pp. 109–29 in Offenders on Offending; Learning About Crime from Criminals, edited byBernascoW.Cullompton, UK: Willan.
41.
LindegaardMarie RosenkrantzBernascoWimVriesTom De. 2016. Overvallen in Beeld: Gedrag Van Daders, Slachtoffers En Omstanders. Apeldoorn: Elsevier/Politie & Wetenschap.
42.
LindegaardMarie RosenkrantzHeithCopes. 2017. “Observational Methods of Offender Decision Making.” Pp. 498–521 in The Oxford Handbook of Offender Decision Making, edited by BernascoW.Van GelderJ.-L.ElffersH.Oxford: Oxford University Press.
43.
LindegaardMarie RosenkrantzLiebstLasse SuonperäBernascoWimHeinskouMarie BruvikPhilpotRichardLevineMarkVerbeekPeter. 2017. “Consolation in the Aftermath of Robberies Resembles Post-aggression Consolation in Chimpanzees.” PLoS ONE12:e0177725.
44.
LjungbergTomasWestlundKarolinaForsbergAnna Johanna Lindqvist. 1999. “Conflict Resolution in 5-year-old Boys: Does Postconflict Affiliative Behaviour Have a Reconciliatory Role?”. Animal Behaviour58:1007–16.
45.
LuckenbillDavid F.1977. “Criminal Homicide as a Situated Transaction.” Social Problems25:176–86.
46.
LuckenbillDavid F.1981. “Generating Compliance: The Case of Robbery.” Urban Life10:25–46.
47.
LumCynthiaKoperChristopher S.MerolaLaura M.SchererAmberReiouxAmanda. 2015. Existing and Ongoing Body Worn Camera Research: Knowledge Gaps and Opportunities. Report for the Laura and John Arnold Foundation. Fairfax, VA: Center for Evidence-Based Crime Policy, George Mason University.
48.
MalinowskiBronislaw. 1948. Magic, Science, and Religion. Glencoe, IL: The Free Press.
49.
MastrofskiStepehn D.ParksRoger B.McCluskeyJohn D.. 2010. “Systematic Social Observation in Criminology.” Pp. 225–47 in Handbook of Quantitative Criminology, edited byPiqueroA. R.WeisburdD.. New York: Springer.
50.
McPhailClarkWohlsteinRonald T.. 1982. “Using Film to Analyze Pedestrian Behavior.” Sociological Methods & Research10:347–75.
51.
MehanHugh. 1979. Learning Lessons: Social Organization in the Classroom. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
52.
MillerJody. 2005. “The Status of Qualitative Research in Criminology.” Pp. 69–75 in Workshop on Interdisciplinary Standards for Systemic Qualitative Research, edited byLamontM.WhiteP.. Arlington, VA: National Science Foundation.
53.
MitaniYokoAndrewsRussel D.SatoKatsufumiKatoAkikoNaitoYasuhikoCostaDaniel P.. 2010. “Three-dimensional Resting Behaviour of Northern Elephant Seals: Drifting Like a Falling Leaf.” Biology Letters6:163–66.
54.
MoellerKim. 2016. “Temporal Transaction Patterns in an Open-air Cannabis Market.” Police Practice and Research17:37–50.
55.
NassauerAnne. 2015. “Effective Crowd Policing: Empirical Insights on Avoiding Protest Violence.” Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management38:3–23.
56.
NassauerAnne. 2016. “From Peaceful Marches to Violent Clashes: A Micro-situational Analysis.” Social Movement Studies15:1–16.
57.
NassauerAnneNicolasLegewie. 2016. “Visual Data Analysis: Towards a Methodological Framework for a Novel Trend in Studying Behavior.” Paper, presented at the American Sociological Association Annual Meeting, Seattle, USA.
58.
O’ConnellAllan F.NicholsJames D.Ullas KaranthK.. 2011. Camera Traps in Animal Ecology; Methods and Analyses. New York: Springer.
59.
PizaEric L.SytsmaVictoria A.. 2016. “Exploring the Defensive Actions of Drug Sellers in Open-air Markets: A Systematic Social Observation.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency53:36–65.
60.
PsathasGeorge. 1995. Conversation Analysis: The Study of Talk-in-interaction. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
61.
RaentoMikaOulasvirtaAnttiEagleNathan. 2009. “Smartphones: An Emerging Tool for Social Scientists.” Sociological Methods & Research37:426–54.
62.
ReynaldDanielle M.2009. “Guardianship in Action: Developing a New Tool for Measurement.” Crime Prevention and Community Safety11:1–20.
63.
SacksHarvey. 1984. “Notes on Methodology.” Pp. 21–27 in Structures of Social Action: Studies in Conversation Analysis, edited byAtkinsonJ. M.HeritageJ.. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
64.
SacksHarveyEmanuelSchegloffGailJefferson. 1973. “A Simplest Systematics for the Organization of Turn-Taking for Conversation. Language50: 696–735.
65.
SampsonRobert J.RaudenbushStephen W.. 1999. “Systematic Social Observation of Public Places: A New Look at Disorder in Urban Neighborhoods.” American Journal of Sociology105:613–51.
66.
SlaterMelRoviraAitorSouthernRichardSwappDavidZhangJian J.CampbellClaireLevineMark. 2013. “Bystander Responses to a Violent Incident in an Immersive Virtual Environment.” PLoS ONE8:e52766.
67.
SongChaomingQuZehuiBlummNicholasBarabasiAlbert-Laszlo. 2010. “Limits of Predictability in Human Mobility.” Science327:1018–21.
68.
St.JeanPeter K. B.2007. Pockets of Crime. Broken Windows, Collective Efficacy, and the Criminal Point of View. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
69.
SullivanChristopher J.McGloinJean Marie. 2014. “Looking Back to Move Forward; Some Thoughts on Measuring Crime and Delinquency over the Past 50 Years.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency51:445–66.
70.
TabbLoni PhilipBallesterLanceGrubesicTony H.. 2016. “The Spatio-temporal Relationship between Alcohol Outlets and Violence before and after Privatization: A Natural Experiment, Seattle, WA 2010–2013.” Spatial and Spatio-temporal Epidemiology19:115–24.
71.
VardalisJamesCoxTerry C.. 1998. “A Descriptive Analysis of Bank Robberies in Dade County, Florida, During 1994.” Journal of Security Administration21:1–18.
72.
VenkateshSudhir. 2008. Gang Leader for a Day: A Rogue Sociologist Takes to the Streets. London, UK: Penguin.
VinciarelliAlessandroPanticMajaBourlardHervé. 2009. “Social Signal Processing: Survey of an Emerging Domain.” Image and Vision Computing27:1743–59.
75.
VrijAldertHopeLorraineFisherRonald P.. 2014. “Eliciting Reliable Information in Investigative Interviews.” Policy Insights from the Behavioral and Brain Sciences1:129–36.
76.
WatanabeYuuki Y.TakahashiAkinori. 2013. “Linking Animal-borne Video to Accelerometers Reveals Prey Capture Variability.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences110:2199–204.
77.
WeeninkDon. 2014. “Frenzied Attacks. A Micro-sociological Analysis of the Emotional Dynamics of Extreme Youth Violence.” The British Journal of Sociology65:411–33.
78.
WilmersChristopher C.NickelBarryBryceCaleb M.SmithJustine A.WheatRachel E.YovovichVeronica. 2015. “The Golden Age of Bio-logging: How Animal-borne Sensors Are Advancing the Frontiers of Ecology.” Ecology96:1741–53.
79.
WrightRichard T.DeckerScott H.. 1994. Burglars on the Job: Streetlife and Residential Break-ins. Boston, MA: Northeastern University Press.
80.
WrightRichard T.DeckerScott H.. 1997. Armed Robbers in Action. Boston, MA: Northeastern University Press.
