This study investigates whether gender responsive programming is effective at reducing recidivism relative to traditional, reinforcement-based programming for both girls and boys in secure detention.
Methods:
Event-history analysis is used to examine recidivism outcomes for two propensity score matched samples of girls (n = 148) and boys (n = 140) released from gender responsive versus traditional detention facilities in Connecticut. The contingent effects of trauma, depression/anxiety, alcohol/drug abuse, anger/irritability, and somatic complaints are also examined.
Results:
Compared to traditional programming, gender responsive programming for youth in secure detention is associated with a lower risk of recidivism for girls with gender-sensitive risk factors but a higher risk of recidivism among girls who do not display these risk factors. Gender responsive programs are no more or less effective at reducing recidivism for boys, regardless of whether they display risk factors commonly associated with girls’ delinquency and confinement.
Conclusions:
The results suggest that girls in secure detention require different approaches depending on their histories of trauma and associated mental and physical health issues. While girls who follow gendered pathways into detention benefit from the relational approach employed in gender responsive programs, girls without such issues benefit more from traditional reinforcement programming.
AgnewRobertWhiteHelene Raskin. 1992. “An Empirical-test of General Strain Theory.”Criminology30:475–99.
2.
AndrewsD. A.ZingerIvanHogeRobert D.BontaJamesGendreauPaulCullenFrancis T.1990. “Does Correctional Treatment Work? A Clinically Relevant and Psychologically Informed Meta-analysis.”Criminology28:369–404.
3.
ArcherRobert P.Simonds-BisbeeElise C.SpiegelDavid R.HandelRichard W.ElkinsDavid E.2010. “Validity of the Massachusetts Youth Screening Instrument-2 (MAYSI-2) Scales in Juvenile Justice Settings.”Journal of Personality Assessment92:337–48.
4.
ArcherRobert P.StrednyRebecca VauterMasonJohn A.ArnauRandolph C.2004. “An Examination and Replication of the Psychometric Properties of the Massachusetts Youth Screening Instrument—Second Edition (MAYSI-2) Among Adolescents in Detention Settings.”Assessment11:290–302.
5.
BelknapJoanne. 2001. The Invisible Woman: Gender, Crime, and Justice. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.
6.
BelknapJoanneHolsingerKristi. 2006. “The Gendered Nature of Risk Factors for Delinquency.”Feminist Criminology1:48–71.
7.
BenedictAlyssaSokoloffKimberly. 2007. Capacity Building: Creating a Gender Responsive Juvenile Detention System for Girls in Connecticut. Wethersfield, CT: State of Connecticut Judicial Branch, Court Support Services Division.
8.
BloomBarbaraOwenBarbaraCovingtonStephanie. 2003. Gender-responsive Strategies: Research, Practice, and Guiding Principles for Women Offenders. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, National Institute of Corrections.
9.
BloomBarbaraOwenBarbaraDeschenesElizabeth PiperRosenbaumJill. 2002a. “Improving Juvenile Justice for Females: A Statewide Assessment in California.”Crime & Delinquency48:325–53.
10.
BloomBarbaraOwenBarbaraDeschenesElizabeth PiperRosenbaumJill. 2002b. “Moving Toward Justice for Female Juvenile Offenders in the New Millennium: Modeling Gender-Specific Policies and Programs.”Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice18:37–56.
11.
BrodyLeslie R.HallJudith A.2008. “Gender and Emotions in Context.” Pp. 395–408 in Handbook of Emotions, edited by LewisM.Haviland-JonesJ. M.BarrettL. F.New York: Guilford Press.
12.
BroidyLisa M.2001. “A Test of General Strain Theory.”Criminology39:9–36.
13.
BroidyLisaAgnewRobert. 1997. “Gender and Crime: A General Strain Theory Perspective.”Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency34:275–306.
14.
CauffmanElizabeth. 2004. “A Statewide Screening of Mental Health Symptoms among Juvenile Offenders in Detention.”Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry43:430–439.
15.
CauffmanE.FeldmanS. S.WatermanJ.SteinerH.1998. “Posttraumatic Stress Disorder among Female Juvenile Offenders.”Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry37:1209–16.
16.
Chesney-LindMeda. 1989. “Girls' Crime and Woman’s Place: Toward a Feminist Model of Female Delinquency.”Crime and Delinquency35:5–29.
17.
Chesney-LindMedaPaskoLisa. 2013. The Female Offender: Girls, Women, and Crime. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
18.
CoxDavid R.1972. “Regression Models and Life-tables.”Journal of the Royal Statistical Society. Series B34:187–220.
19.
CrosnoeRobertEricksonKristan GlasgowDornbuschSanford M.2002. “Protective Functions of Family Relationships and School Factors on the Deviant Behavior of Adolescent Boys and Girls: Reducing the Impact of Risky Friendships.”Youth & Society33:515–44.
20.
DalyKathleen. 1992. “Women’s Pathways to Felony Court: Feminist Theories of Lawbreaking and Problems of Representation. Southern California Review of Law and Women’s Studies2:11–52.
21.
De CosterStacy. 2005. “Depression and Law Violation: Gendered Responses to Gendered Stresses.”Sociological Perspectives48:155–87.
22.
De CosterStacyZitoRena Cornell. 2010. “Gender and General Strain Theory: The Gendering of Emotional Experiences and Expressions.”Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice26:224–45.
23.
Evans-ChaseMichelleZhouHuiquan. 2012. “A Systematic Review of the Juvenile Justice Intervention Literature: What It Can (and Cannot) Tell Us about What Works with Delinquent Youth.”Crime and Delinquency, 60:451–470.
24.
FoleyAllison. 2008. “The Current State of Gender-specific Delinquency Programming.”Journal of Criminal Justice36:262–69.
25.
FordJulian D.ChapmanJohn F.PearsonGeraldineBorumRandyWolpawJennifer Meltzer. 2008. “Psychometric Status and Clinical Utility of the MAYSI-2 with Girls and Boys in Juvenile Detention.”Journal of Psychopathology and Behavioral Assessment30:87–99.
26.
GavazziStephen M.YarcheckCourtney M.Chesney-LindMeda. 2006. “Global Risk Indicators and the Role of Gender in a Juvenile Detention Sample.”Criminal Justice and Behavior33:597–612.
27.
GilliganCarol. 1982. In a Different Voice: Psychological Theory and Women’s Development. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
28.
GreenwoodPeter W.2008. “Prevention and Intervention Programs for Juvenile Offenders.”The Future of Children18:185–210.
29.
GrissoThomasBarnunRichard. 2006. Massachusetts Youth Screening Instrument—version 2: User’s Manual and Technical Report. Worcester, MA: University of Massachusetts Medical School.
30.
GrissoThomasBarnumRichardFletcherKenneth E.CauffmanElizabethPeuscholdDawn. 2001. “Massachusetts Youth Screening Instrument for Mental Health Needs of Juvenile Justice Youths.”Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry40:541–48.
31.
GrissoThomasFuscoSamanthaPaiva-SalisburyMelissaPerraultRachaelWilliamsValerieBarnunRichard. 2012. The Massachusetts Youth Screening Instrument-version 2 (MAYSI-2): Comprehensive Research Review. Worcester: University of Massachusetts Medical School.
32.
GrissoThomasQuinlanJudith C.2005. “Massachusetts Youth Screening Instrument—Version 2.” Pp. 99–111 in Mental Health Screening and Assessment in Juvenile Justice, edited by GrissoT.VincentG.SeagraveD.New York: Guilford Press.
HaganJohnGillisA. R.SimpsonJohn. 1985. “The Class Structure of Gender and Delinquency: Toward a Power-control Theory of Common Delinquent Behavior.”American Journal of Sociology90:1151–78.
HeimerKarenDe CosterStacy. 1999. “The Gendering of Violent Delinquency.”Criminology37:277–318.
37.
HennesseyMarianneFordJulian D.MahoneyKarenKoSusan J.SiegfriedChrsitine B.2004. Trauma among Girls in the Juvenile Justice System. Los Angeles, CA: National Child Traumatic Stress Network.
38.
HipwellAlison E.LoeberRolf. 2006. “Do We Know Which Interventions are Effective for Disruptive and Delinquent Girls?”Clinical Child and Family Psychology Review9:221–55.
39.
HubbardDana JonesMatthewsBetsy. 2008. “Reconciling the Differences between the ‘Gender-responsive’ and the ‘What Works’ Literatures to Improve Services for Girls.”Crime and Delinquency54:225–58.
40.
HubbardDana JonesPrattTravis C.2002. “A Meta-analysis of the Predictors of Delinquency among Girls.”Journal of Offender Rehabilitation34:1–13.
41.
JasperAnneSmithCarlyBaileySusan. 1998. “One Hundred Girls in Care Referred to an Adolescent Forensic Mental Health Service.”Journal of Adolescence21:555–68.
42.
KruttschnittCandace. 2013. “Gender and Crime.”Annual Review of Sociology39:291–308.
43.
LipseyMark W.2009. “The Primary Factors that Characterize Effective Interventions with Juvenile Offenders: A Meta-analytic Overview.”Victims and Offenders4:124–47.
44.
LiuRuth X.2004. “Parent–youth Conflict and School Delinquency/Cigarette Use: The Moderating Effects of Gender and Associations with Achievement-oriented Peers.”Sociological Inquiry74:271–97.
45.
ManiglioRoberto. 2014. “Significance, Nature, and Direction of the Association between Child Sexual Abuse and Conduct Disorder: A Systematic Review.”Trauma, Violence, & Abuse, published online before print March 12, 2014. doi:10.1177/1524838014526068
46.
MatthewsBetsyHubbardDana Jones. 2008. “Moving ahead: Five Essential Elements for Working Effectively with Girls.”Journal of Criminal Justice36:494–502.
47.
McCabeKristenLansingAmy E.GarlandAnnHoughRichard. 2002. “Gender Differences in Psychopathology, Functional Impairment, and Familial Risk Factors Among Adjudicated Delinquents.”Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry41:860–867.
48.
MesserschmidtJames W.1993. Masculinities and Crime: Critique and Reconceptualization of Theory. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
49.
MesserschmidtJames W.2000. Nine Lives: Adolescent Masculinities, the Body, and Violence. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
50.
MillerJodiMullinsChristopher W.2009. “Feminist Theories of Girls’ Delinquency.” Pp. 30–49 in The Delinquent Girl, edited by ZahnMargaret A.Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
51.
PayneAllison A.GottfredsonDenise C.KruttschnittCandance. 2009. “Girls, Schooling, and Delinquency.” Pp. 146–63 in The Delinquent Girl, edited by ZahnMargaret A.Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
52.
ReisigMichael D.HoltfreterKristyMorashMerry. 2006. “Assessing Recidivism Risk across Female Pathways to Crime.”Justice Quarterly23:384–405.
53.
RosenbaumPaul R.RubinDonald B.1983. “The Central Role of the Propensity Score in Observational Studies for Causal Effects.”Biometrika70:41–55.
54.
RosenbaumPaul R.RubinDonald B.1985. “Constructing a Control Group Using Multivariate Matched Sampling Methods That Incorporate the Propensity Score.”The American Statistician39:33–38.
55.
RubinDonald B.2001. “Using Propensity Scores to Help Design Observational Studies: Application to Tobacco Litigation.”Health Services and Outcomes Research Methodology2:169–88.
56.
SalisburyEmily J.Van VoorhisPatricia. 2009. “Gendered Pathways: A Quantitative Investigation of Women Probationers' Paths to Incarceration.”Criminal Justice and Behavior36:541–66.
57.
SedlakAndrea J.McPhersonKarla S.2010. Youth’s Needs and Services: Findings from the Survey of Youth in Residential Placement. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention.
58.
ShaddishWilliam R.2013. “Propensity Score Analysis: Promise, Reality, and Irrational Exuberance.”Journal of Experimental Criminology9:129–44.
59.
ShaddishWilliam R.ClarkM. H.SteinerPeter M.2008. “Can Nonrandomized Experiments Yield Accurate Answers? A Randomized Experiment Comparing Random and Nonrandom Assignments.”Journal of the American Statistical Association103:1334–44.
60.
ShaddishWilliam R.SteinerPeter M.2010. “A Primer on Propensity Score Matching.”Newborn and Infant Nursing Reviews10:19–26.
61.
SimonRobin W.NathLeda E.2004. “Gender and Emotion in the United States: Do Men and Women Differ in Self-reports of Feelings and Expressive Behavior?”American Journal of Sociology109:1137–76.
62.
SmithCarolynThornberryTerrence P.1995. “The Relationship between Childhood Maltreatment and Adolescent Involvement in Delinquency.”Criminology33:451–81.
63.
SnyderHoward N.2000. Sexual Assault of Young Children as Reported to Law Enforcement: Victim, Incident, and Offender Characteristics. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, Bureau of Justice Statistics.
64.
SnyderHoward N.SickmundMelissa. 2006. Juvenile Offenders and Victims: 2006 National Report. Washington, DC: Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention.
65.
SteffensmeierDarrellSchwartzJenniferZhongHuaAckermanJeff. 2005. “An Assessment of Recent Trends in Girls' Violence Using Diverse Longitudinal Sources: Is the Gender Gap Closing?”Criminology43:355–406.
66.
SteinerPeter M.CookDavid. 2013. “Matching and Propensity Scores.” Pp. 237–259 in The Oxford Handbook of Quantitative Methods in Psychology, Vol. 1, edited by LittleT. D.New York: Oxford University Press.
67.
SteinerPeter M.CookDavidShaddishWilliam R.ClarkM. H.2010. “The Importance of Covariate Selection in Controlling for Selection Bias in Observational Studies.”Psychological Methods15:250–67.
68.
StuartElizabeth A.2010. “Matching Methods for Causal Inference: A Review and a Look Forward.”Statistical Science25:1–21.
69.
TeplinLinda A.AbramKaren M.McClellandGary M.DulcanMina K.MericleAmy A.2002. “Psychiatric Disorders in Youth in Juvenile Detention.”Archives of General Psychology59:1133–43.
70.
TopitzesJamesMerskyJoshua P.ReynoldsArthur J.2011. “Child Maltreatment and Offending Behavior: Gender-specific Effects and Pathways.”Criminal Justice and Behavior38:492–510.
71.
TracyPaul E.Kempf-LeonardKimberlyAbramoske-JamesStephanie. 2009. “Gender Differences in Delinquency and Juvenile Justice Processing: Evidence from National Data.”Crime and Delinquency55:171–215.
72.
Van VoorhisPatriciaWrightEmily M.SalisburyEmilyBaumanAshley. 2010. “Women’s Risk Factors and Their Contributions to Existing Risk/Needs Assessment: The Current Status of a Gender-responsive Supplement.”Criminal Justice and Behavior37:261–88.
73.
WelshBrandon C.FarringtonDavid P.2006. “Evidence-based Crime Prevention.” Pp. 1–20 in Preventing Crime: What Works for Children, Offenders, Victims, and Places, edited by WelshB. C.FarringtonD. P.Dordrecht, the Netherlands: Springer.
74.
WidomCathy Spatz. 2000. “Childhood Victimization: Early Adversity, Later Psychopathology.”National Institute of Justice Journal242:3–9.
75.
ZahnMargaret A.2009. The Delinquent Girl. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
76.
ZahnMargaret A.AgnewRobertFishbeinDianaMillerShariWinnDonna-MarieDakoffGayleKruttschnittCandanceGiordanoPeggyGottfredsonDenise C.PayneAllison A.FeldBarry C.Chesney-LindMeda. 2010. Causes and Correlates of Girls' Delinquency. Washington, DC: Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention.
77.
ZahnMargaret A.DayJacob C.MihalicSharon F.TichavskyLisa. 2009. “Determining What Works for Girls in the Juvenile Justice System: A Summary of Evaluation Evidence.”Crime & Delinquency55:266–93.
