Networks of Collaborating Criminals: Assessing the Structural Vulnerability of Drug Markets

Abstract

Uncovering the resiliency of ties between individuals involved in criminal enterprise will contribute to our understanding of how illicit markets function. To examine activities along the entire drug market commodity chain, this study extracted information about individuals involved or associated with trafficking (1,998 people) from police intelligence reports generated from 2004 to 2006. Significant differences were found for centrality and cohesion across market niches. Results show that the highest fragmentation potential lies with individuals who are involved with smuggling, supply, and financing, particularly when these individuals are also involved in other niches. Variability in small-world and scale-free properties suggest that interdiction strategies must be tailored to niche characteristics.

Keywords

social network analysis criminal enterprise illicit drug market commodity chain

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Barabasi, Albert L. , Hawoong Jeong, Zoltan N. Neda , Erzsebet Ravasz, Albert Schubert , and Tamas Vicsek. 2002. ‘‘Evolution of the Social Network of Scientific Collaborations.’’ Physica A 311:590-611.

Borgatti, Stephen P. 2003. ‘‘The Key Player Problem.’’ Pp. 241-52 in Dynamic Social Network Modeling and Analysis: Workshop Summary and Papers, edited by R. Breiger, K. Carley, and P. Pattison. Washington, DC: National Academy of Sciences Press.

Borgatti, Stephen P. and Martin G. Everett. 2006. ‘‘A Graph-Theoretic Perspective on Centrality.’’ Social Networks 28:466-84.

Borgatti, Stephen P. , Martin G. Everett , and Linton C. Freeman . 2002. UCINET for Windows: Software for Social Network Analysis. Harvard, MA: Analytic Technologies.

Brown, Rick and Ronald V. Clarke. 2004. ‘‘Police Intelligence and Theft of Vehicles for Export: Recent U.K. Experience.’’ Pp. 173-92 in Understanding and Preventing Car Theft. Crime Prevention Studies, Vol. 17, edited by M. G. Maxfield and R. G. Clarke. Monsey, NY: Criminal Justice Press.

Bruinsma, Gerben and Wim Bernasco. 2004. ‘‘Criminal Groups and Transnational Illegal Markets.’’ Crime, Law and Social Change 41:79-94.

Chase-Dunn, Christopher , Yukio Kawano , and Benjamin D. Brewer . 2000. ‘‘Trade Globalization Since 1795: Waves of Integration in the World-System.’’ American Sociological Review 65:77-95.

Chin, Ko-lin , and Sheldon Zhang. 2003. Characteristics of Chinese Human Smugglers: A Cross-National Study, Final Report. Washington, DC. Office of Justice Programs, National Institute of Justice, U.S. Department of Justice.

Caulkins, Jonathan P. 1993. ‘‘Local Drug Markets’ Response to Focused Police Enforcement.’’ Operations Research 41:848-63.

10.

Caulkins, Jonathan P. 1997. ‘‘Modeling the Domestic Distribution Network for Illicit Drugs.’’ Management Science 43:1364-71.

11.

Dorn, Nicholas , Michael Levi , and Leslie King. 2005. Literature Review on Upper Level Drug Trafficking. London, UK: Home Office Research, Online Report.

12.

Dorn, Nicholas , Lutz Oette , and Simone White. 1998. ‘‘Drugs Importation and the Bifurcation of Risk: Capitalization, Cut Outs and Organized Crime. ’’ British Journal of Criminology 38:537-60.

13.

Eck, John E. and Jeffrey G. Gersh. 2000. ‘‘Drug Trafficking as a Cottage Industry. ’’ Pp. 241-72 in Illegal Drug Markets: From Research to Policy . Crime Prevention Studies, Vol.11, edited by M. Natarajan and M. Hough. Monsey, NY: Criminal Justice Press.

14.

Fijnaut, Cyrille and Gary T. Marx. 1995. Undercover: Police Surveillance in Comparative Perspective . Leiden, Belgium: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers.

15.

Freeman, Linton F. 1979. ‘‘Centrality in Social Networks: Conceptual Clarification.’’ Social Networks 1:215-39.

16.

Johnson, Bruce D. , Eloise Dunlap , and Sylvie C. Tourigny . 2000. ‘‘Crack Distribution and Abuse in New York.’’ Pp. 19-57 in Illegal Drug Markets: From Research to Policy. Crime Prevention Studies, Vol. 11, edited by M. Natarajan and M. Hough. Monsey, NY: Criminal Justice Press.

17.

Kersel, Morag. 2007. ‘‘Transcending Borders: Objects on the Move .’’ Archaeologies: Journal of the World Archaeological Congress 3:81-98.

18.

Malm, Aili E. and George E. Tita. 2006. ‘‘A Spatial Analysis of Green Teams: A Tactical Response to Marijuana Production in British Columbia.’’ Policy Sciences 39:361-77.

19.

McGloin, Jean-Marie. 2005. ‘‘Policy and Intervention Considerations of a Network Analysis of Street Gangs.’’ Criminology and Public Policy 4:607-36.

20.

McGrath, Cathleen and David Krackhardt. 2003. ‘‘Network Conditions for Organizational Change .’’ The Journal of Applied Behavioral Sciences 39:324-36.

21.

Medina, Richard and George Hepner. 2008. ‘‘Geospatial Analysis of Dynamic Terrorist Networks.’’ Pp.151-67 in Values and Violence: Intangible Aspects of Terrorism, edited by I. Karawan , W. McCormack and S. E. Reynolds. Berlin, Germany : Springer.

22.

Morselli, Carlos and Katia Petit. 2007. ‘‘Law Enforcement Disruption of a Drug Importation Network.’’ Global Crime 8:109-130.

23.

Morselli, Carlos and Julie Roy. 2008. ‘‘Brokerage Qualifications in Ringing Operations .’’ Criminology 46:71-98.

24.

Natarajan, Mangai. 2000. ‘‘Understanding the Structure of a Drug Trafficking Organization: A Conversational Analysis.’’ Pp. 273-98 in Illegal Drug Markets: From Research to Policy. Crime Prevention Studies , Vol. 11, edited by M. Natarajan and M. Hough. Monsey, NY: Criminal Justice Press.

25.

Natarajan, Mangai. 2006. ‘‘Understanding the Structure of a Large Heroin Distribution Network: A Quantitative Analysis of Qualitative Data. ’’ Journal of Quantitative Criminology 22:171-92.

26.

Natarajan, Mangai and Mathieu Belanger. 1998. ‘‘Varieties of Upper-level Drug Dealing Organisations: A Typology of Cases Prosecuted in New York City.’’ Journal of Drug Issues 28:1005-1026.

27.

Öztuna, Derya. 2006. ‘‘Investigation of Four Different Normality Tests in Terms of Type 1 Error Rate and Power under Different Distributions .’’ Turkish Journal of Medical Science 36:171-6.

28.

Pearson, Geoffrey and Dick Hobbs. 2001. Middle Market Drug Distribution. Home Office Research Study 227. London, UK: Home Office Research, Development and Statistics Directorate.

29.

Poitras, Geoffrey. 2006. ‘‘More on the Correct Use of Omnibus Tests for Normality.’’ Economics Letters 90:304-309.

30.

Raab, Jorg and H. Brinton Milward. 2003. ‘‘Dark Networks as Problems .’’ Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 13:413-39.

31.

Reuter, Peter and John Hagga. 1989. The Organization of High-Level Drug Markets: An Exploratory Study. Santa Monica, CA: RAND.

32.

Rodrigue, Jean-Paul. 2008. ‘‘Commodity Chain Analysis.’’ Department of Economics & Geography, Hofstra University. Retrieved February 29, 2008 (http://people.hofstra.edu/geotrans/eng/ch5en/ch5menu.html).

33.

Royal Canadian Mounted Police. 2000. SLEIPNIR: The Long Matrix for Organized Crime, An Analytical Technique for Determining Relative Levels of Threat Posed by Organized Crime Groups. Criminal Analysis Branch, Criminal Intelligence Directorate , Royal Canadian Mounted Police. Ottawa, ON.

34.

Ruggiero, Vincent. 2000. ‘‘Criminal Franchising: Albanians and Illicit Drugs.’’ Pp. 203-218 in Illegal Drug Markets: From Research to Policy. Crime Prevention Studies, Vol. 11, edited by M. Natarajan and M. Hough. Monsey, NY: Criminal Justice Press.

35.

Sarnecki, Jerzy. 2001. Delinquent Networks: Youth Co-offending in Stockholm. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

36.

Sarnecki, Jerzy and Tove Pettersson. 2001. ‘‘Criminal Networks in Stockholm.’’ Pp. 200-220 in The Eurogang Paradox: Street Gangs and Youth Groups in the U.S. and Europe , edited by M. W. Klein , H. J. Kerner , C. Maxson , and E. G. M. Weitekamp. Amsterdam, Netherlands : Kluwer Publishing .

37.

Sheptycki, James W. E. 1998. ‘‘The Global Cops Cometh: Reflections on Transnationalization, Knowledge Work and Policing Subculture’’ British Journal of Criminology 49:57-74.

38.

Sparrow, Malcolm K. 1991. ‘‘The Application of Network Analysis to Criminal Intelligence: An Assessment of the Prospects.’’ Social Networks 13:251-74.

39.

Tremblay, Pierre , Bernard Talon , and Doug Hurley. 2001. ‘‘Body Switching and Related Adaptations in the Resale of Stolen Vehicles: Script Elaborations and Aggregate Crime Learning Curves.’’ British Journal of Criminology 41:561-79.

40.

Van de Bunt, Henk G. , Edward R. Kleemans , and Christianne J. de Poot. 2007. Organized Crime in the Netherlands: Third Report of the Organized Crime Monitor. Amsterdam, Netherlands: Ministry of Justice.

41.

Watts, Duncan and Steven Stogatz. 1998. ‘‘Collective Dynamics of Small-World Networks .’’ Nature 393:440-42.

42.

Wasserman, Stanley and Kathryn Faust. 1994. Social Network Analysis: Methods and Applications. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

43.

Xu, Jennifer and Hsinchun Chen. 2003. ‘‘Fighting Organized Crimes: Using Shortest-Path Algorithms to Identify Associations in Criminal Networks. ’’ Decision Support Systems 38:473-87.

44.

Xu, Jennifer and Hsinchun Chen. 2008. ‘‘The Topology of Dark Networks. ’’ Communications of the ACM 51:58-65.

45.

Xu, Jennifer , Byron Marshall , Siddharth Kaza , and Hsinshun Chen. 2004. ‘‘Analyzing and Visualizing Criminal Network Dynamics: A Case Study.’’ LNCS 3073:359-77.