Corrections-based education, vocation, and work programs are a major rehabilitative component of our correctional system. Recent reviews of the research literature raise doubt about the effectiveness of these programs in reducing recidivism. This study meta-analyzed the recidivism outcomes of 33 independent experimental and quasi-experimental evaluations of education, vocation, and work programs and found that program participants recidivate at a lower rate than nonparticipants. The generally weak methodological character of these studies, however, prevents attributing this observed effect on criminal behavior to the activities of the programs. Future evaluative research in this area could be strengthened through the incorporation of theoretical links between the program activities and future criminal involvement and through designs that control for self-selection bias beyond basic demographic differences.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Adams, K.
, K. J. Bennett, T. J. Flanagan, J. W. Marquart, S. J. Cuvelier, E. Fritsch, J. Gerber, D. R. Longmire, and V. S. Burton, Jr.1994. “A Large-Scale Multidimensional Test of the Effect of Prison Education Programs on Offenders' Behavior.”The Prison Journal74:433-449.
2.
Anderson, D.1981. “The Relationship between Correctional Education and Parole Success.”Journal of Offender Counseling, Services, and Rehabilitation5:13-25.
3.
Anderson, S. V.
1995. Evaluation of the Impact of Correctional Education Programs on Recidivism. Columbus, OH: Office of Management Information Systems Bureau of Planning and Evaluation, Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Correction.
4.
Andrews, D. A.
and J. Bonta. 1994. The Psychology of Criminal Conduct. Cincinnati, OH: Anderson.
5.
Andrews, D. A.
, J. Bonta, and R. D. Hoge. 1990. “Classification for Effective Rehabilitation: Rediscovering Psychology.”Criminal Justice and Behavior17:19-52.
6.
Andrews, D. A.
, I. Zinger, R. D. Hoge, J. Bonta, P. Gendreau, and F. T. Cullen. 1990. “Does Correctional Treatment Work? A Clinically-Relevant and Psychologically Informed Meta-Analysis.”Criminology28:369-404.
7.
Applegate, B. K.
, F. T. Cullen, and B. S. Fisher. 1997. “Public Support for Correctional Treatment: The Continuing Appeal of the Rehabilitative Ideal.”The Prison Journal77:237-258.
8.
Batiuk, M. E.
, P. Moke, and P. W. Rountree. 1997. “Crime and Rehabilitation: Correctional Education as an Agent of Change.”Justice Quarterly14:167-180.
9.
Blackburn, F. S.
1981. “The Relationship between Recidivism and Participation in a Community College Associate of Arts Degree Program for Incarcerated Offenders.” Presented at the meeting of the Thirty-Sixth Annual Conference of the Correctional Education Association, July, Costa Mesa, CA.
10.
Bushway, S. D.1998. “The Impact of an Arrest on the Job Stability of Young White American Men.”Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency35:454-479.
11.
Bushway, S.
and P. Reuter. 1997. “Labor Markets and Crime Risk Factors.” Pp. 6-1-6-59 in Preventing Crime: What Works, What Doesn't, What's Promising, edited by L. W. Sherman, D. Gottfredson, D. MacKenzie, J. Eck, P. Rueter, and S. Bushway. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs.
12.
Chen, H-T.
1990. Theory-Driven Evaluations. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
13.
Chen, H-T., ed. 1989. “The Theory-Driven Perspective.”Evaluation and Program Planning12:297-398.
14.
Chen, H-T.
and P. H. Rossi. 1983. “Evaluating with Sense: The Theory-Driven Approach.”Evaluation Review7:283-302.
15.
Clark, D. D.
1991. Analysis of Return Rates of the Inmate College Program Participants. Albany, NY: New York State, Department of Correctional Services.
16.
Coffey, B. B. 1983. “The Effectiveness of Vocational Education in Kentucky's Correctional Institutions as Measured by Employment Status and Recidivism” (Ph.D. dissertation, University of Kentucky). Dissertation Abstracts International 44-09A:2745-2877.
17.
Cook, T. D.
and D. T. Campbell. 1979. Quasi-Experimentation: Design and Analysis Issues for Field Settings. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin.
18.
Cullen, F. T.
, S. E. Skovron, and J. E. Scott. 1990. “Public Support for Correctional Treatment: The Tenacity of Rehabilitative Ideology. Survey of Cincinnati and Columbus Residents.”Criminal Justice and Behavior17:6-18.
19.
Davis, S.
and B. Chown. 1986. Recidivism among Offenders Incarcerated by the Oklahoma Department of Corrections Who Received Vocational-Technical Training: A Survival Data Analysis of Offenders Released January 1982 through July 1986. Oklahoma City, OK: Oklahoma State Department of Corrections.
20.
Downes, E. A.
, K. R. Monaco, and S. O. Schreiber. 1989. “Evaluating the Effects of Vocational Education on Inmates: A Research Model and Preliminary Results.” Pp. 249-262 in The Yearbook of Correctional Education, edited by S. Duguid. Burnaby, British Columbia, Canada: Simon Fraser University.
21.
Fleiss, J. L.
1994. “Measures of Effect Size for Categorical Data.” Pp. 245-260 in The Handbook of Research Synthesis, edited by H. Cooper and L. V. Hedges. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
22.
Gaither, C.
1976. An Evaluation of the Texas Department of Corrections' Junior College Program. Huntsville, TX: Department of Correction Treatment Directorate, Research and Development Division.
23.
Gerber, J.
and E. J. Fritsch. 1995. “Adult Academic and Vocational Correctional Education Programs: A Review of Recent Research.”Journal of Offender Rehabilitation22:119-142.
24.
Gleser, L. J.
and I. Olkin. 1994. “Stochastically Dependent Effect Sizes.” Pp. 339-356 in The Handbook of Research Synthesis, edited by H. Cooper and L. V. Hedges. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
25.
Gottfredson, M. R.
and T. Hirschi. 1990. A General Theory of Crime. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
26.
Harer, M. D.1995. “Recidivism among Federal Prisoners Released in 1987.”Journal of Correctional Education46 (3): 98-127.
27.
Hedges, L. V.
and I. Olkin. 1985. Statistical Methods for Meta-Analysis. Orlando, FL: Academic Press.
28.
Holloway, J.
and P. Moke. 1986. Post-Secondary Correctional Education: An Evaluation of Parolee Performance. Wilmington, OH: Wilmington College. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. Microfiche ED 269 578)
29.
Hull, K. A.
1995. Analysis of Recidivism Rates for Participants of the Academic/Vocational/Transition Education Programs Offered by the Virginia Department of Correctional Education. Richmond, VA: Commonwealth of Virginia Department of Correctional Education.
30.
Kalaian, H. A.
and S. W. Raudenbush. 1996. “A Multivariate Mixed Linear Model for Meta-Analysis.”Psychological Methods1:227-235.
31.
Kraemer, H. C.
, C. Garnder, J. O. Brooks, III, and J. A. Yesavage. 1998. “Advantages of Excluding Underpowered Studies in Meta-Analysis: Inclusionist versus Exclusionist Viewpoints.”Psychological Methods3:23-31.
32.
Langenbach, M.
, M. Y. North, L. Aagaard, and W. Chown. 1990. “Televised Instruction in Oklahoma Prisons: A Study of Recidivism and Disciplinary Actions.”Journal of Correctional Education41:87-94.
33.
Lattimore, P. K.
, A. D. Witte, and J. R. Baker. 1990. “Experimental Assessment of the Effect of Vocational Training on Youthful Property Offenders.”Evaluation Review14:115-133.
34.
Lee, K. M. 1983. “The Wichita Work Release Center: An Evaluative Study (Kansas)” (Ph.D. dissertation, Kansas State University). Dissertation Abstracts International 44-02A: 0583-0785.
35.
Linden, R.
, L. Perry, D. Ayers, and T.A.A. Parlett. 1984. “An Evaluation of a Prison Education Program.”Canadian Journal of Criminology26:65-73.
36.
Lipsey, M. W.
1990. “Theory as Method: Small Theories of Treatment.” Pp. 33-51 in Health Services Research Methodology: Strengthening Causal Inference from Nonexperimental Research, edited by L. Sechrest, J. Bunker, and E. Perrin. Washington, DC: National Center for Health Services Research and Health Care Technology Research.
37.
Lipsey, M. W.
1992. “Juvenile Delinquency Treatment: A Meta-Analytic Inquiry into the Variability of Effects.” Pp. 83-127 in Meta-Analysis for Explanation: A Casebook, edited by T. D. Cook, H. Cooper, D. S. Cordray, H. Hartmann, L. V. Hedges, R. J. Light, T. A. Louis, and F. Mosteller. New York: Russell Sage.
38.
Lipsey, M. W.
and D. B. Wilson. 2000. Practical Meta-Analysis. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
39.
Lockwood, D.
1991. “Prison Higher Education and Recidivism: A Program Evaluation.” Pp. 187-201 in Yearbook of Correctional Education. Burnaby, British Columbia, Canada: Simon Fraser University, Institute for the Humanities.
40.
Luftig, J. T.1978. “Vocational Education in Prison: An Alternative to Recidivism.”Journal of Studies in Technical Careers1:31-42.
41.
Maciekowich, Z. D. 1976. “Academic Education/Vocational Training and Recidivism of Adult Prisoners” (Ph.D. dissertation, Arizona State University). Dissertation Abstracts International, 37-08A, 5080-5195.
42.
MacKenzie, D. L.
and L. J. Hickman. 1998. What Works in Corrections? An Examination of the Effectiveness of the Type of Rehabilitation Programs Offered by Washington State Department of Corrections: Report to the State of Washington Legislature Joint Audit and Review Committee. College Park, MD: University of Maryland.
43.
Maguire, K. E.
, T. J. Flanagan, and T. P. Thornberry. 1988. “Prison Labor and Recidivism.”Journal of Quantitative Criminology4:3-18.
44.
McGee, C. J.
1997. The Positive Impact of Corrections Education on Recidivism and Employment. Springfield, IL: Illinois Department of Corrections and Illinois Council on Vocational Education.
45.
Menon, R.
, C. Blakely, D. Carmichael, and L. Silver 1992. An Evaluation of Project RIO Outcomes: An Evaluative Report. College Station, TX: Texas A&M University, Public Policy Resources Laboratory.
46.
New York State Department of Correctional Services
. 1992. Overview of Department Follow-Up Research on Return Rates of Participants in Major Programs. Albany, NY: Department of Correctional Services.
47.
O'Neil, M.1990. “Correctional Higher Education: Reduced Recidivism?”Journal of Correctional Education41:28-31.
48.
Pawson, R.
and N. Tilley. 1997. Realistic Evaluation. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
49.
Piehl, A. M.
1995. “Learning while Doing Time.”John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA. Unpublished manuscript.
50.
Piehl, A. M.
1998. “Economic Conditions, Work, and Crime.” Pp. 302-319 in The Handbook of Crime and Punishment, edited by M. Tonry. New York: Oxford University Press.
51.
Porporino, F. J.
and D. Robinson. 1992. “Can Educating Adult Offenders Counteract Recidivism?” Presented at the meeting of the American Correctional Association (ACA) Winter Conference, December, Portland, OR.
52.
Ramsey, C.
1988. The Value of Receiving a General Education Development Certificate while Incarcerated in the South Carolina Department of Corrections on the Rate of Recidivism. Columbia, SC: South Carolina Department of Corrections.
53.
Raudenbush, S. W.
1994. “Random Effects Models.” Pp. 301-321 in The Handbook of Research Synthesis, edited by H. Cooper and L. V. Hedges. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
54.
Reuter, P.
, R. MacCoun, and P. Murphy. 1990. Money From Crime: A Study of the Economics of Drug Dealing in Washington, D.C. (NCJRS No. 126021). Santa Monica, CA: RAND.
55.
Rosenthal, R.
and D. B. Rubin. 1983. “A Simple, General Purpose Display of Magnitude of Experimental Effect.”Journal of Educational Psychology74:166-169.
56.
Sampson, R. J.
and J. H. Laub. 1993. Crime in the Making: Pathways and Turning Points through Life. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
57.
Saylor, W. G.
and G. G. Gaes. 1996. PREP: Training Inmates through Industrial Work Participation and Vocational and Apprenticeship Instruction. Washington, DC: U.S. Federal Bureau of Prisons.
58.
Schumacker, R. E.
, D. B. Anderson, and S. L. Anderson. 1990. “Vocational and Academic Indicators of Parole Success.”Journal of Correctional Education41:8-12.
59.
Shadish, W. R.
and C. K. Haddock. 1994. “Combining Estimates of Effect Size.” Pp. 261-281 in The Handbook of Research Synthesis, edited by H. Cooper and L. V. Hedges. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
60.
Sharpe, D.1997. “Of Apples and Oranges, File Drawers and Garbage: Why Validity Issues in Meta-Analysis Will Not Go Away.”Clinical Psychology Review17:881-901.
61.
Sherman, L. W.
, D. Gottfredson, D. L. MacKenzie, J. Eck, P. Reuter, and S. Bushway. 1997. Preventing Crime: What Works, What Doesn't, What's Promising. Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice.
62.
Siegel, G. R.
and J. Basta. 1997. The Effect of Literacy and General Education Development Programs on Adult Probationers. Tuscon, AZ: Adult Probation Department of the Superior Court in Pima County.
63.
Stephan, J. J.
1997. Census of State and Federal Correctional Facilities, 1995. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics.
64.
Thornberry, T. P.
and R. L. Christenson. 1984. “Unemployment and Criminal Involvement: An Investigation of Reciprocal Causal Structures.”American Sociological Review49:398-411.
65.
Tracy, C.
and C. Johnson. 1994. Review of Various Outcome Studies Relating Prison Education to Reduced Recidivism. Austin, TX: Windham School System.
66.
Van Stelle, K. R.
, J. R. Lidbury, and D. P. Moberg. 1995. Final Evaluation Report: Specialized Training and Employment Project (STEP). Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin-Madison Medical School, Department of Preventive Medicine, Center for Health Policy and Program Evaluation.
67.
Walsh, A.1985. “An Evaluation of the Effects of Adult Basic Education on Rearrest Rates among Probationers.”Journal of Offender Counseling, Services, and Rehabilitation9:69-76.
68.
Wilson, D. B.
, C. A. Gallagher, M. B. Coggeshal, and D. L. MacKenzie. 1999. “A Quantitative Review and Description of Corrections Based Education, Vocation and Work Programs.”Corrections Management Quarterly3 (4): 8-18.
69.
Winterton, J. L.
1995. “Transformations: Technology Boot Camp. Summative evaluation.” Unpublished manuscript.
70.
Zamble, E.
and F. J. Porporino. 1988. Coping, Behavior, and Adaptation in Prison Inmates. New York: Springer-Verlag.
