Dynamite under the Intercommunal Bridge: How Can Aid Agencies Help Defuse It?

Abstract

Drawing on evidence from two case-study projects, this article identifies two types of conflict transformation approaches used by aid agencies in developing countries: promotive and pre-emptive. Recognizing activities designed to promote linkage between groups often are ineffective in preventing conflict, the article explores how the second `pre-emptive' approach seems to address short-comings in the `promotive' approach. Together, the two are seen to be analogous to early investment in production capacity undertaken in the business sphere even before demand for a product justifies such investment. The article explores the impact of `flash-points' that shift the usual non-war:war asymmetry in the direction of violence that overwhelms peace. Flash-points are events that heighten and unleash emotions of fear, insecurity, frustration, and anger so that they overwhelm more normal emotions and actions conducive to and supportive of peace. The article concludes that this problem may be overcome by strategies to support the effective exercise of leadership that invokes inclusiveness, and measures to foster disciplined information processing to prevent self-reinforcing intergroup stereotyping. Finally, policy questions are suggested to guide aid agencies in making effective early `investments' in peace.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anderson, Mary B. , 1994. `International Assistance and Conflict: An Exploration of Negative Impacts', Local Capacities for Peace Project, Issue Series, no. 1 (July). Cambridge, MA: Collaborative for Development Action.

Anderson, Mary B. , 1996a. Do No Harm: Supporting Local Capacities for Peace through Aid. Cambridge, MA: Collaborative for Development Action.

Anderson, Mary B. , 1996b. `Understanding Difference and Building Solidarity: A Challenge to Development Initiatives' in Deborah Eade , ed., Development and Social Diversity. Oxford: Oxfam UK and Ireland (7-15).

Bock, Joseph G. , 1995. `The Harmony Project of the St Xavier's Social Service Society, Ahmedabad, Gujarat, India', Local Capacities for Peace Project, Case Study Series, no. 1 (January). Cambridge, MA: Collaborative for Development Action.

Gurr, Ted Robert , 1993. Minorities at Risk: A Global View of Ethnopolitical Conflicts. Washington, DC: United States Institute of Peace Press.

Hansen, Greg , 1995. `SAWA/Education for Peace: Uniting Lebanon's Children and Youth During War', Local Capacities for Peace Project, Case Studies Series, no. 8 (June). Cambridge, MA: Collaborative for Development Action.

Leatherman, Janie ; William DeMars , Patrick Gaffney & Raimo Väyrynen , 1998. Preventive and Inventive Action in Intrastate Crises. West Hartford, CT: Kumarian Press.

Lederach, John Paul , 1995. Preparing for Peace: Conflict Transformation Across Cultures. Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press.

Lyke, Susan A. & Joseph G. Bock , 1996. `Orangi Pilot Project - Research and Training Institute of Karachi, Pakistan', Local Capacities for Peace Project, Case Studies Series, no. 9 (January). Cambridge, MA: Collaborative for Development Action.

10.

Maynes, Charles William , 1993. `Humanitarian Intervention: Its Possibilities and Limits', in Gerard F. Powers , Drew Christiansen & Robert T. Hennemeyer , eds, Peacemaking: Moral and Policy Challenges for a New World. Washington, DC: United States Catholic Conference (229-238).

11.

Merton, Thomas , 1960. The Wisdom of the Desert. Boston, MA: Shambhala.

12.

Minear, Larry , 1995. `Reconciliation Across Borders: An Experiment in Croatia', Local Capacities for Peace Project, Case Studies Series, no. 2 (January). Cambridge, MA: Collaborative for Development Action.

13.

Prakash, Cedric , 1995. Annual Report of the St Xavier's Social Services Society, Ahmedabad, India.

14.

Sallin, Lena , 1995. `ICRC in Burundi: A Case Study', Local Capacities for Peace Project, Case Studies Series, no. 7 (June). Cambridge, MA: Collaborative for Development Action.

15.

Senge, Peter M. , 1994. The Fifth Discipline: The Art and Practice of the Learning Organization. New York: Currency Doubleday.

16.

Simoska, E. , 1993. `Macedonia and the Myths of the “Muslim Conspiracy” and “Endangered Orthodoxy” ', in The Social, Political and Cultural Role of the Muslim Communities in Post Bipolar Europe. Skopje, Macedonia: Centre for Ethnic Relations, University of Exeter (95-101).

17.

Sterman, John , 1988a. `Strategy Dynamics: The Rise and Fall of People Express', Cambridge, MA: MIT System Dynamics Group Working Paper D-3959/3967.

18.

Sterman, John , 1988b. People Express Management Flight Simulator, Cambridge, MA: Sloan School of Management, MIT.

19.

Weeks, Willet , 1995. `Save the Children Federation (USA) in Lower Shabelle (Somalia) 1992-95', Local Capacities for Peace Project, Case Studies Series, (January). Cambridge, MA: Collaborative for Development Action.