This paper is an attempt to profile the personal and societal incentives for selective refusal among Israeli reserve soldiers during the Intifada. The article draws in part upon Kohlberg's model of moral development and addresses the following questions: (1) What is the motivation for selective refusal in times of morally-controversial conflicts such as the Intifada? (2) What socio-psychological incentives could ease the way to refusal? (3) What differentiates the individual objecting soldier from the objecting soldier who does not refuse to serve? The data for this theoretical discussion are taken from studies of 48 Israeli reserve soldiers out of 165 who decided to refuse military service within the first four years of the Intifada (Linn, 1995a, 1995b, 1995c) and of 36 out of 86 soldiers who refused during the war in Lebanon (Linn, 1989a). The findings suggest that unlike other objecting yet non-refusing soldiers, the selective refusers were motivated to change the unjust situation by assuming a position of disobedience to which they were personally predisposed and were capable of doing in their close milieu. Intifada and Lebanon refusers differed in their political affiliation and their different social support for their action.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Ben-Ari, E. , 1990. `Masked Soldiers: The IDF and the Intifada, pp. 2-36 in Reuven Gal, ed., The Seventh War: The Effects of the Intifada on the Israeli Society. Tel-Aviv: Hakibutz Hameuchad (in Hebrew).
2.
Benvenisti, Miron , 1992. Fatal Embrace. Tel Aviv: Maxwell-Macmillan-Keter.
3.
Blatt, Moshe ; Uri Davis & P. Kleinbaum, 1975. Dissent and Ideology in Israel-Resistance to the Draft (1948-1973). London: Ithaca.
4.
Candee, Dan , 1976. `Structure and Choice in Moral Reasoning'. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, vol. 34, no. 6, pp. 1293-1301.
5.
Cohen, Carl , 1971. Civil Disobedience - Conscience, Tactics and The Law. New York: Columbia University Press.
6.
Colby, Anne & Lawrence Kohlberg, 1987. The Measurement of Moral Judgment: Volume 1. New York: Cambridge University Press.
7.
Emler, Nicolas , 1983. `Morality and Politics: the Ideological Dimension in the Theory of Moral Development', pp. 47-70 in Helen Weinrich Haste & Don Locke, eds, Morality in the Making - Thoughts Action and Social Context. Chichester: Wiley.
8.
Fromm, Erich , 1981. On Disobedience - and Other Essays. New York: Harper & Row.
9.
Gabriel, Richard , 1984. Operation Peace for the Galilee: The Israeli-PLO War in Lebanon. New York: Hill & Wang.
10.
Gal, Reuven . 1986. A Portrait of the Israeli Soldier. Westport, CT: Greenwood.
11.
Gal, Reuven , 1990. The Seventh War - The Effect of the Intifada on the Israeli Society. Tel Aviv: Kibbutz Meuchad.
12.
Gilbar, Gadi & Ahron Susser, eds, 1992. The Core of the Conflict - The Intifada. Tel Aviv: Kibbutz Meuchad.
13.
Hardan, Dan , ed., 1985. The Moral and Existential Dilemmas of the Israeli Soldier. Jerusalem: World Zionist Organization.
14.
Inbar, Ephraim , 1991. `Israel's Small War: The Military Response to the Intifada'. Armed Forces and Society, vol. 18, no. 1, Fall, pp. 29-50.
15.
Kimmerling, Baruch , 1985. The Interrupted System. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Books.
16.
Kohlberg, Lawrence , 1984. Essays on Moral Development: The Psychology of Moral Development: The Nature and Validity of Moral Stages, Volume 2. San Francisco, CA: Harper & Row.
17.
Lieblich, Amla , 1989. Transition to Adulthood during Military Service: The Israeli Case. Albany: State University of New York Press. [First published in 1987 as The Spring of Their Years in Hebrew.]
18.
Linn, Ruth , 1986. `Conscientious Objection in Israel During the War in Lebanon'. Armed Forces and Society, vol. 12, no. 4, Summer, pp. 489-511.
19.
Linn, Ruth , 1988. `Moral Judgement in Extreme Social Contexts - Soldiers Who Refuse to Fight and Physicians Who Strike?', Journal of Applied Social Psychology, vol. 18, no. 13, pp. 1149-1170.
20.
Linn, Ruth , 1989. Not Shooting and Not Crying - Psychological Inquiry into Moral Disobedience. Westport, CT: Greenwood.
21.
Linn, Ruth , 1991. `Holocaust Metaphors and Symbols in the Moral Dilemmas of Contemporary Israeli Soldiers', Metaphor and Symbolic Activity, vol. 6, no. 2, pp. 61-86.
22.
Linn, Ruth , 1995a. `Resistance and Motivation - Moral, Political or Personal?'Social Behavior and Personality, vol. 23, no. 1, pp. 35-44.
23.
Linn, Ruth , 1995b. `The Claim for Moral Maturity, Consistency and Integrity of Israeli Soldiers During Morally Controversial War', Journal of Applied Social Psychology, vol. 25, no. 5, pp. 399-415.
24.
Linn, Ruth , 1995c. `To Go or Not to Go? Objecting Israeli Reservists in Face of the Obligation to Suppress', Peace Psychology Review, vol. 1, no. 2, Autumn/Winter, pp. 130-140.
25.
Linn, Ruth , 1996. Conscience at War - The Israeli Soldier as a Moral Critic. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.
26.
Linn, Ruth & Carol Gilligan, 1990. `One Action - Two Moral Orientations: The Tension Between Justice and Care. Voices in Israeli Selective Conscientious Objectors'. New Ideas in Psychology, vol. 8, no. 2, pp. 189-203.
27.
Locke, Don , 1983. `Moral Reasons and Moral Action', pp. 111-124 in Helen Weinrich-Haste & Don Locke, eds, Morality in the Making: Thought Action and Social Context. Chichester: Wiley.
28.
Mischal, Shaul & Reuven Aharoni, 1989. Speaking Stones: The Words Behind the Palestinian Intifada. Tel Aviv: Kibbutz Meuchad.
29.
Moskos, Charles & J. W. Chambers, eds, 1993. The New Conscientious Objection - From Sacred to Secular Resistance. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
30.
Peled, Yair , 1993. Soldier. Jerusalem: Ma'ariv.
31.
Peri, Yoram , 1993. `Israel: Conscientious Objection in a Democracy Under Siege', pp. 146-157 in Charles Moskos & J. W. Chambers, eds, The New Conscientious Objection. From Sacred to Secular Resistance. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
32.
Rawls, John , 1971. `A Theory of Civil Disobedience', in P. Harris, ed., Civil Disobedience. University Press of America.
33.
Schiff, Rebecca , 1992. `Israel as an “Uncivil” State: A Reconsideration of Civil-Military Relations'. Security Studies, vol. 1, no. 4, pp. 636-658.
34.
Schiff, Zeeve & Ehud Yaari, 1984. Israel's Lebanon War. Trans. and ed. Ina Friedman. New York: Simon & Schuster.
35.
Schiff, Zeeve & Ehud Yaari, 1990. Intifada. Tel Aviv: Schoken.
36.
Shalev, Avner , 1990. The Intifada: Causes and Effects. Tel Aviv: Papirus.
37.
Sprinzak, Ehud , 1977. `Extreme Politics in Israel', The Jerusalem Quarterly, vol. 5, Fall, pp. 33-47.
38.
Sprinzak, Ehud , 1986. Every Man Whatever in his Own Eyes. Tel Aviv: Sifriat Poalim.
39.
Student, M. , 1991. In the Shadow of War: Memories of a Soldier and Therapist. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
40.
Walzer, Michael , 1968. `Civil Disobedience and “Resistance” ', Dissent, January-Februay, pp. 13-15.
41.
Walzer, Michael , 1970. Obligations: Essays on Disobedience, War and Citizenship. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
42.
Walzer, Michael , 1977. Just and Unjust Wars. New York: Basic Books.
43.
Walzer, Michael , 1988. The Company of Critics: Social Criticism and Political Commitment in the Twentieth Century. New York: Basic Books.
44.
Yaniv, Anver , 1993. National Security and Democracy in Israel. London: Lynne Rienner.
