Not since 1945 has the UN enjoyed such support across the East-West divide as today. Cold War standards to evaluate UN performance are now of little value, but there is little general and theoretical discussion of alternative criteria. In an effort to clarify the issues at stake in what is sure to be a lively debate, the authors derive four distinct performance criteria extant in the literature on UN performance. These criteria include (1) declarations found in organic documents (charter-based), (2) medium and short-term objectives established by agency officials (operational), (3) past performance (trend-based), and (4) a scenario following elimination of the agency (absence-based). The strengths and weaknesses of each criteria are discussed theoretically and concretely through use of the four criteria to assess UN peace-keeping operations. The authors conclude that a blending of the operational and trend-based approach offers the most promising avenue for UN evaluation.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Ascher, William , 1984. `New Development Approaches and the Adaptability of International Agencies: The Case of the World Bank', International Organization, vol. 37, no. 3, Summer, pp. 415-439.
2.
Carter, Hodding , 1990. `A Dim Silver Lining Within Washington's Poisonous Clouds', Wall Street Journal, 25 October, p. A23-A23.
3.
Diehl, Paul F. , 1989. `The Conditions for Success in Peacekeeping Operations', pp. 173-188 in Paul F. Diehl, ed., The Politics of International Organizations: Patterns and Insights. Chicago, IL: Dorsey.
4.
Ewing, A. F. , 1986. `Reform of the United Nations', Journal of World Trade Law, vol. 20, no. 1, pp. 131-141.
5.
Farer, Tom , 1987. `The United Nations and Human Rights: More than a Whimper, Less than a Roar', Human Rights Quarterly, vol. 9, no. 4, November, pp. 550-586.
6.
Finkelstein, Lawrence , ed., 1988. Politics in the United Nations System. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
7.
Forsythe, David, 1988. `The Politics of Efficacy: The United Nations and Human Rights', pp. 246-273 in Finkelstein, 1988.
8.
Franck, Thomas , 1985. Nation Against Nation: What Happened to the U.N. Dream and What the U.S. Can Do About It. New York: Oxford University Press.
9.
Groom, A. J. R. , 1989. `Reflections on a Changing System', pp. 285-296 in Paul Taylor & A. J. R. Groom, eds, Global Issues in the United Nations' Framework. New York: St Martins.
10.
Haas, Ernst , 1983. `Regime Decay: Conflict Management and International Organizations. 1945-1981', International Organization, vol. 32, no. 2, Spring, pp. 189-235.
11.
Howard, Michael, 1988. `The United Nations and International Security', pp. 31-46 in Roberts & Kingsbury, 1988.
12.
James, Alan, 1988. `Unit Veto Dominance in United Nations Peace-Keeping', pp. 75-105 in Finkelstein, 1988.
13.
Jensen, Erik , 1985. `The Secretary-General's Use of Good Offices and the Question of Bahrain', Millenium, vol. 17, no. 3, Spring, pp. 335-348.
14.
Kaufman, Johan & Nico Schrijver, 1990. `Changing Global Needs: Expanding Roles for the United Nations System', ACUNS Reports and Papers, 1990-95. New York: Academic Council on the UN System.
15.
Kim, Samuel , 1985. `The United Nations, Lawmaking, and World Order', Alternatives, vol. 10, no. 4, April, pp. 643-675.
16.
Lafever, Ernest W. , 1967. Uncertain Mandate: Politics of the UN Congo Operation. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
17.
Luard, Evan , 1979. The United Nations: How It Works and What It Does. New York: St Martin's.
18.
Luck, Edward , 1984-85. `The UN at 40: A Supporter's Lament', Foreign Affairs, vol. 57, no. 1, Winter, pp. 143-159.
19.
Mouat, Lucian , 1990. `Reaction to Gulf Crisis Displays UN's Enhanced Security Role', Christian Science Monitor, 5 December, pp. 1-2.
20.
Murphy, John F. , 1982. The United Nations and the Control of International Violence: A Legal and Political Analysis. Totowa, NJ: Allanheld & Osmun.
21.
Parsons, Anthony, 1988. `The United Nations and the National Interests of States', pp. 46-61 in Roberts & Kingsbury, 1988.
22.
Peres de Cuellar, Javier, 1982. Report of the Secretary-General on the Work of the Organization. Official Records of the General Assembly, Thirty-Seventh Session, Supplement no. 1, A/37/1, September.
23.
Pines, Burton Yale , ed., 1984. A World Without a UN: What Would Happen if the UN Shut Down. Washington, DC: Heritage Foundation.
24.
Plano, Jack C. & Robert E. Riggs, 1988. The United Nations: International Organization and World Politics. Chicago, IL: Dorsey.
25.
Rikhye, Indar Jit , 1984. The Theory and Practice of Peacekeeping. London: Hurst.
26.
Roberts, Adam & Benedict Kingsbury, eds, 1988. United Nations, Divided World. Oxford: Clarendon.
27.
Rogers, William , 1991. `The Principle of Force, the Force of Principles', pp. 95-107 in David Scheffer, ed., Right v. Might: International Law and the Use of Force. 2nd ed.New York: Council on Foreign Relations.
28.
Rotberg, Robert I. , ed., 1983. Namibia: Political and Economic Prospects. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
29.
Ruggie, John Gerard , 1985. `The United States and the United Nations: Toward a New Realism', International Organization, vol. 39, no. 2, Spring, pp. 343-356.
30.
Schechter, Michael, 1988. `The Political Roles of Recent World Bank Presidents', pp. 350-382 in Finkelstein, 1988.
31.
Slomanson, William R. , 1990. Fundamental Perspectives on International Law. New York: West Publishing.
32.
Stanley, Richard , 1985. `Opening Remarks', Stanley Foundation Symposium. New Paltz, NY: Stanley Foundation.
33.
Stiles, Kendall , 1991. Negotiating Debt: The Process of IMF Lending. Boulder, CO: Westview.
34.
Tessitore, John & Susan Woolfson, eds, 1990. Issues Before the 44th General Assembly of the United Nations. New York: Lexington Books.
35.
Thakur, Ramesh , 1987. International Peacekeeping in Lebanon: United Nations Authority and Multilateral Force. Boulder, CO: Westview.
36.
United Nations , 1987. `General Assembly Approves Reforms', UN Chronicle, vol. 24, no. 2, February, p. 21-21.
37.
Urquhart, Brian , 1986. `The Role of the UN in Maintaining and Improving International Security', Survival, vol. 28, no. 5, September-October, pp. 225-231.
38.
Van den Haag, Ernest , 1989. `Is The United Nations Useful?', Social Education, vol. 53, September, pp. 289-290.
39.
Van den Haag, Ernest & John Conrad, 1987. The UN: In or Out?New York: Plenum.
40.
Waldheim, Kurt , 1984. `The United Nations: The Tarnished Image', Foreign Affairs, vol. 63, no. 1, Fall, pp. 93-107.
41.
Wilkenfeld, Jonathan & Michael Brecher, 1984. `International Crises, 1945-1975: The UN Dimension', International Studies Quarterly, vol. 28, no. 1, March, pp. 45-67.
