Why do some civil wars feature the mass killing of civilians while others do not? Recent research answers this question by adopting a ‘varieties of civil war’ approach that distinguishes between guerrilla and conventional civil wars. One particularly influential claim is that guerrilla wars feature more civilian victimization because mass killing is an attractive strategy for states attempting to eliminate the civilian support base of an insurgency. In this article, I suggest that there are two reasons to question this ‘draining the sea’ argument. First, the logic of ‘hearts and minds’ during guerrilla wars implies that protecting civilians – not killing them – is the key to success during counterinsurgency. Second, unpacking the nature of fighting in conventional wars gives compelling reasons to think that they could be particularly deadly for civilians caught in the war’s path. After deriving competing predictions on the relationship between civil war type and mass killing, I offer an empirical test by pairing a recently released dataset on the ‘technology of rebellion’ featured in civil wars with a more nuanced dataset of mass killing than those used in several previous studies. Contrary to the conventional wisdom, I find that mass killing onset is more likely to occur during conventional wars than during guerrilla wars.
AchenChristopher H (2002) Toward a new political methodology: Microfoundations and ART. Annual Review of Political Science5(1): 423–450.
2.
AndreasPeterGreenhillKelly M, (eds) (2010) Sex, Drugs, and Body Counts: The Politics of Numbers in Global Crime and Conflict. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
3.
ArjonaAna (2014) Wartime institutions: A research agenda. Journal of Conflict Resolution58(8): 1360–1389.
4.
Arreguin-ToftIvan M (2001) How the weak win wars: A theory of asymmetric conflict. International Security26(1): 93–128.
5.
BalcellsLaia (2010) Rivalry and revenge: Violence against civilians in conventional civil wars. International Studies Quarterly54(2): 291–313.
6.
BalcellsLaia (2017) Rivalry and Revenge: The Politics of Violence during Civil War. New York: Cambridge University Press.
7.
BalcellsLaiaKalyvasStathis N (2014) Does warfare matter? Severity, duration, and outcomes of civil wars. Journal of Conflict Resolution58(8): 1–29.
8.
BBC News (2016) Aleppo battle: UN says civilians shot on the spot. BBC News13 December.
9.
CarterDavid BSignorinoCurtis S (2010) Back to the future: Modeling time dependence in binary data. Political Analysis18(3): 271–292.
10.
CondraLuke NShapiroJacob N (2012) Who takes the blame? The strategic effects of collateral damage. American Journal of Political Science56(1): 167–187.
11.
Department of the Army (2006) FM 3-24: Counterinsurgency. Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office.
12.
DownesAlexander B (2007) Draining the sea by filling the graves: Investigating the effectiveness of indiscriminate violence as a counterinsurgency strategy. Civil Wars9(4): 420–444.
13.
DownesAlexander B (2008) Targeting Civilians in War. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
14.
EckKristineHultmanLisa (2007) One-sided violence against civilians in war: Insights from new fatality data. Journal of Peace Research44(2): 233–246.
15.
FearonJames DLaitinDavid D (2003) Ethnicity, insurgency, and civil war. American Political Science Review97(1): 75–90.
16.
FindleyMichael GYoungJoseph K (2007) Fighting fire with fire? How (not) to neutralize an insurgency. Civil Wars9(4): 378–401.
17.
GalulaDavid (1964) Counterinsurgency Warfare: Theory and Practice. New York: Praeger.
18.
GeddesBarbaraWrightJosephFrantzErica (2014) Autocratic breakdown and regime transitions: A new data set. Perspectives on Politics12(2): 313–331.
19.
GleditschNils PetterWallensteenPeterErikssonMikaelSollenbergMargaretaStrandHåvard (2002) Armed conflict 1946–2001: A new dataset. Journal of Peace Research39(5): 615–637.
20.
HarffBarbara (2003) No lessons learned from the Holocaust? Assessing risks of genocide and political mass murder since 1955. American Political Science Review97(1): 57–73.
21.
HestonAlanSummersRobertAtenBettina (2012) Penn World Table Version 7.1. Philadelphia, PA: Center for International Comparisons of Production, Income and Prices at the University of Pennsylvania (http://cid.econ.ucdavis.edu/pwt.html).
22.
KaldorMary (1999) New and Old Wars: Organized Violence in a Global Era. Palo Alto, CA: Stanford University Press.
23.
KalyvasStathis N (2006) The Logic of Violence in Civil War. New York: Cambridge University Press.
24.
KalyvasStathis NBalcellsLaia (2010) International system and technologies of rebellion: How the end of the Cold War shaped internal conflict. American Political Science Review104(3): 415–429.
25.
KaplanRobert D (1993) Balkan Ghosts: A Journey Through History. New York: St Martin’s.
26.
KilcullenDavid (2009) The Accidental Guerrilla: Fighting Small Wars in the Midst of a Big One. New York: Oxford University Press.
27.
KingGaryTomzMichaelWittenbergJason (2000) Making the most of statistical analyses: Improving interpretation and presentation. American Journal of Political Science44(2): 347–361.
28.
KocherMatthew AdamPepinskyThomas BKalyvasStathis N (2011) Aerial bombing and counterinsurgency in the Vietnam War. American Journal of Political Science55(2): 201–218.
29.
KrainMatthew (1997) State-sponsored mass murder: The onset and severity of genocides and politicides. Journal of Conflict Resolution41(3): 331–360.
30.
LacinaBethanyGleditschNils Petter (2005) Monitoring trends in global combat: A new dataset of battle deaths. European Journal of Population21(2–3): 145–166.
31.
LeitesNathanWolfCharles (1970) Rebellion and Authority. Chicago, IL: Markham.
32.
LyallJason (2009) Does indiscriminate violence incite insurgent attacks? Evidence from Chechnya. Journal of Conflict Resolution53(3): 331–362.
33.
MasonDavid TKraneDale (1989) The political economy of death squads: Toward a theory of the impact of state-sanctioned terror. International Studies Quarterly33(2): 175–198.
34.
MaoZedong (1961) On Guerrilla Warfare. New York: Praeger.
35.
McKernanBethan (2016) Aleppo could witness one of the worst massacres since World War Two, France warns. Independent29 November.
36.
MelanderErikPetterssonTheréseThemnérLotta (2016) Organized violence, 1989–2015. Journal of Peace Research53(5): 727–742.
37.
MeromGil (2003) How Democracies Lose Small Wars: State, Society, and the Failures of France in Algeria, Israel in Lebanon, and the United States in Vietnam. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
38.
MontalvoJose GReynal-QuerolMarta (2008) Discrete polarisation with an application to the determinants of genocides. Economic Journal118(533): 1835–1865.
39.
NaglJohn A (2002) Counterinsurgency Lessons from Malaya and Vietnam: Learning to Eat Soup with a Knife. Westport, CT: Praeger.
40.
NaglJohn ABurtonBrian M (2009) Dirty windows and burning houses: Setting the record straight on irregular warfare. Washington Quarterly32(2): 91–101.
41.
PapeRobert A (1996) Bombing to Win: Air Power and Coercion in War. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
42.
PetersenRoger (2001) Resistance and Rebellion: Lessons from Eastern Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
43.
RummelRudolph J (1995) Democracy, power, genocide, and mass murder. Journal of Conflict Resolution39(1): 3–26.
44.
SalehyanIdean (2007) Transnational rebels: Neighboring states as sanctuary for rebel groups. World Politics59(2): 217–242.
45.
SalehyanIdeanSirokyDavidWoodReed M (2014) External rebel sponsorship and civilian abuse: A principal-agent analysis of wartime atrocities. International Organization68(3): 633–661.
46.
TaubBen (2016) The Assad files. New Yorker18 September: 36–49.
47.
ThompsonRobert (1966) Defeating Communist Insurgency: The Lessons of Malaya and Vietnam. New York: Praeger.
ValentinoBenjamin A (2004) Final Solutions: Mass Killing and Genocide in the Twentieth Century. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
51.
ValentinoBenjamin A (2014) Why we kill: The political science of political violence against civilians. Annual Review of Political Science17(1): 89–103.
52.
ValentinoBenjamin AHuthPaulBalch-LindsayDylan (2004) Draining the sea: Mass killing and guerrilla warfare. International Organization58(2): 375–407.
53.
WalshDeclan (2011) Pakistan’s secret dirty war. Guardian29 March.
54.
WoodElisabeth Jean (2003) Insurgent Collective Action and Civil War in El Salvador. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
55.
WoodReed M (2010) Rebel capability and strategic violence against civilians. Journal of Peace Research47(5): 601–614.
WrightJoseph (2008) Do authoritarian institutions constrain? How legislatures affect economic growth and investment. American Journal of Political Science52(2): 322–343.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
