What exactly is it about democracy that enables it to protect human rights? As part of the research program addressing that important question, this article examines the relationship between democratic national legislative and presidential elections and government respect for human rights in over 100 countries from 1981 to 2000. Both presidential (direct and semi-presidential) and lower-house national legislative elections are found to be reliably associated with greater government respect for human rights, but only in the years following an election and not in election years themselves. Interestingly, national legislative elections were found to be associated with greater government respect for human rights, while presidential elections were associated with less respect for human rights. Consequently, the authors caution that the historically popular concept of electoralism (the use of elections alone as a proxy for full democracy) is unlikely to play a positive part in any policy intending to protect human rights.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abouharb, M. Rodwan & David Cingranelli , 2006a. ` The Human Rights Effects of World Bank Structural Adjustment Lending, 1981—2000 ', International Studies Quarterly50(2): 233—262 .
2.
Abouharb, M. Rodwan & David Cingranelli , 2006b. Harsh Medicine: Structural Adjustment & Human Rights . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
3.
Achen, Christopher , 2000. ` Why Lagged Dependent Variables Can Suppress the Explanatory Power of Other Independent Variables ', paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Political Methodology Section of the American Political Science Association, University of California , Los Angeles, CA, 20—22 July.
4.
African Studies Center , 2002. ` Liberia: Elections and Human Rights', University of Pennsylvania (http://www.africa.upenn.edu/Urgent_Action/apic-020502.html ).
5.
Arendt, Hannah , 1973. The Origins of Totalitarianism. Orlando, FL: Harcourt .
6.
Austin, Dennis , 1994. Democracy and Violence in India and Sri Lanka. New York: Council on Foreign Relations Press .
7.
Barkan, Joel D. , 2000. ` Protracted Transitions Among Africa's New Democracies' , Democratization7(3): 227—243 .
8.
Beer, Caroline & Neil J. Mitchell , 2004. ` Democracy and Human Rights in the Mexican States: Elections or Social Capital ?', International Studies Quarterly48(2): 293—312 .
9.
Bejarano, Ana Maria & Eduardo Leongomez , 2002. `From “Restricted” to “Besieged”: The Changing Nature of the Limits to Democracy in Colombia', Kellogg Institute Working Paper No. 296 (http://kellogg.nd.edu/publications/workingpapers/WPS/296.pdf ).
10.
Bollen, Kenneth , 1980. ` Issues in the Comparative Measurement of Political Democracy ', American Sociological Review45(3): 370—390 .
11.
Brown, Robert D. , 1995. ` Party Cleavages and Welfare Efforts in the American States ', American Political Science Review87(4): 945—948 .
12.
Budge, Ian , 1994. ` A New Spatial Theory of Party Competition: Uncertainty, Ideology and Policy Equilibria Viewed Comparatively and Temporally ', British Journal of Political Science24(4): 443—467 .
13.
Chaturvedi, Ashish , 2005. ` Rigging Elections with Violence ', Public Choice125(1): 189—202 .
14.
Cingranelli, David L. & David L. Richards , 1999a. ` Measuring the Pattern, Level, and Sequence of Government Respect for Human Rights ', International Studies Quarterly43(2): 407—417 .
15.
Cingranelli, David L. & David L. Richards , 1999b. ` Respect for Human Rights After the End of the Cold War ', Journal of Peace Research36(5): 511—534 .
16.
Cingranelli, David L. & David L. Richards , 2005. The CIRI Human Rights Dataset, Version 2005.10.12 (http://www.humanrightsdata.org ).
17.
Coulon, Christian , 1990. `Senegal: The Development and Fragility of Semidemocracy ', in Larry Diamond , Juan J. Linz & Seymour Martin Lipset , eds, Politics in Developing Countries. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner (141—178).
18.
Dahl, Robert , 1989. Democracy and Its Critics. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press .
19.
Davenport, Christian , 1997. ` From Ballots to Bullets: An Empirical Assessment of How National Elections Influence State Uses of Political Repression ', Electoral Studies16(4): 517—540 .
20.
Davenport, Christian , 1998. ` Liberalizing Event or Lethal Episode?: An Empirical Assessment of How National Elections Affect the Suppression of Political and Civil Liberties ', Social Science Quarterly79(2): 321—341 .
21.
Davenport, Christian & David A. Armstrong , 2004. `Democracy and the Violations of Human Rights: A Statistical Analysis from 1976 to 1996 ', American Journal of Political Science48(3): 538—554 .
22.
Diamond, Larry , 1999. Developing Democracy: Toward Consolidation. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press .
23.
Fischer, Jeff , 2002. `Electoral Conflict and Violence: A Strategy for Study and Prevention', International Foundation for Election Systems , White Paper (http://www.ifes.org/publicationsdetail.html?id=265).
24.
Gibney, Mark & Matthew Dalton , 1996. `The Political Terror Scale ', in David L. Cingranelli , ed., Human Rights and Developing Countries. Greenwich, CT: JAI (73—84).
25.
Gleditsch, Nils Petter ; Peter Wallensteen, Mikael Eriksson , Margareta Sollenberg & Håvard Strand , 2002. ` Armed Conflict 1946—2001: A New Dataset ', Journal of Peace Research39(5): 615—637 .
26.
Golder, Matthew , 2004. Codebook: Democratic Electoral Systems Around the World, 1946—2000 (http://homepages.nyu.edu/%7Emrg217/codebook_es1.pdf ).
27.
Golder, Matthew , 2005. ` Democratic Electoral Systems Around the World, 1946—2000 ', Electoral Studies24(1): 103—121 .
28.
Hafner-Burton, Emilie M. & Kiyoteru Tsutsui , 2005. ` Human Rights in a Globalizing World: The Paradox of Empty Promises ', American Journal of Sociology110(5): 1373—1411 .
29.
Hague, Rod & Martin Harrop , 2004. Political Science. New York: Palgrave Macmillan .
30.
Hamilton , Alexander ; James Madison & John Jay , 1961. The Federalist Papers. Clinton Rossiter , ed. New York: Penguin .
31.
Henderson , Conway , 1991. ` Conditions Affecting the Use of Political Repression' , Journal of Conflict Resolution35(1): 120—142 .
32.
Henderson, Conway , 1993. ` Population Pressures and Political Repression' , Social Science Quarterly74(2): 322—333 .
33.
Jackman, Robert W. , 1986. ` Elections and the Democratic Class Struggle ', World Politics39(1): 123—146 .
34.
Kupchan, Charles A. , 1998. ` Illiberal Illusions: Restoring Democracy's Good Name ', Foreign Affairs77(3): 122—126 .
35.
Liao, Tim F. , 1994. Interpreting Probability Models. London : Sage .
36.
Lijphart, Arend , 1984. Democracies: Patterns of Majoritarian and Consensus Government in Twenty-One Countries. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press .
37.
Lijphart, Arend , 2000. ` The Future of Democracy: Reasons for Pessimism but also Some Optimism ', Scandinavian Political Studies23(3): 265—272 .
38.
Linz, Juan , 1994. `Presidential or Parliamentary Democracy: Does It Make a Difference?', in Juan J. Linz & Arturo Valenzuela , eds, The Failure of Presidential Democracy. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press (3—87).
39.
Linz, Juan , 2003. `The Perils of Presidentialism', in Robert Dahl, Ian Shapiro & Jose Antonio Ceibub, eds, The Democracy Source Book . Cambridge, MA: MIT Press (258—265).
40.
Long, J. Scott & Jeremy Freese , 2006. Regression Models for Categorical Dependent Variables Using Stata, 2nd edn. College Station, TX: Stata Press .
41.
Lyons, Terrence , 2002. `Postconflict Elections: War Termination, Democratization, and Demilitarizing Politics', in Institute for Conflict Analysis and Resolution Working Paper No. 20. Washington, DC: George Mason University (http://icar.gmu.edu/wp_20_lyons.pdf).
42.
McCann, James A. & Mark Gibney , 1996. `An Overview of Political Terror in the Developing World, 1980—1991', in David L. Cingranelli , ed., Human Rights and Developing Countries. Greenwich, CT: JAI (15—27).
43.
McKelvey, R.D. & W. Zavoina , 1975. ` A Statistical Model for the Analysis of Ordinal Level Dependent Variables', Journal of MathematicalSociology4(1): 103—120 .
44.
Maharramov, Sarvat , 2005. ` Azerbaijan's 2005 Elections: Can CSO Seize the Moment ?', Democracy at Large1(4): 14—15 .
45.
Mainwaring, Scott & Matthew S. Shugart , 1997. ` Juan Linz, Presidentialism, and Democracy: A Critical Appraisal ', Comparative Politics29(4): 449—471 .
46.
Makumbe, John , 2002. ` Zimbabwe's Hijacked Election ', Journal of Democracy13(4): 87—101 .
47.
Marshall, Monty G. & Keith Jaggers , 2003. Polity IV Project: Dataset Users' Manual. College Park, MD: Center for International Development and Conflict Management .
48.
Mitchell, Neil J. & James M. McCormick , 1988. ` Is U.S. Aid Really Linked to Human Rights in Latin America ?', American Journal of Political Science32(2): 476—498 .
49.
Ottaway , Marina, 2003. Democracy Challenged. Washington, DC: Carnegie Endowment for International Peace .
50.
Pacific Magazine, 2002. ` Tonga's Pro-Democracy Movement Calls for Reforms ', April (http://www.pacificislands.cc/pm42002/pmdefault.php?urlarticleid=0033).
51.
Poe, Steven C. & C. Neal Tate , 1994. ` Repression of Human Rights to Personal Integrity in the 1980s: A Global Analysis' , American Political Science Review88(4): 853—872 .
52.
Poe, Steven C. ; C. Neal Tate & Linda Camp Keith , 1999. `Repression of Human Rights to Personal Integrity Revisited' , International Studies Quarterly43(2): 291—314 .
53.
Poe, Steven C. ; Sabine C. Carey & Tanya C. Vazquez , 2001. ` How Are These Pictures Different? A Quantitative Comparison of the US State Department and Amnesty International Human Rights Reports, 1976—1995 ', Human Rights Quarterly23(3): 650—677 .
54.
Przeworski, Adam , 1999. `Minimalist Conception of Democracy: A Defense', in Ian Shapiro & Casiano Hacker-Cordon, eds, Democracy's Value . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press (23—55).
55.
Reilly, Benjamin , 2002. ` Electoral Systems for Divided Societies ', Journal of Democracy13(2): 156—170 .
56.
Richards, David L. , 1999. ` Perilous Proxy: Human Rights and the Presence of National Elections ', Social Science Quarterly80(4): 648—665 .
57.
Richards, David L. ; Ronald Gelleny & David Sacko , 2001. ` Money with a Mean Streak? Foreign Economic Penetration and Government Respect for Human Rights in Developing Countries ', International Studies Quarterly45(2): 219—239 .
58.
Rogowski, Ronald , 1987. ` Trade and the Variety of Democratic Institutions' , International Organization41(2): 203—223 .
59.
Russell, Meg , 2001. ` What Are Second Chambers For? ', Parliamentary Affairs54(3): 442—458 .
60.
Shively, W. Phillips , 2005 . Power and Choice. New York: McGraw-Hill .
61.
Snyder, Jack , 2000. From Voting to Violence. New York: Norton .
62.
Steiner, Henry , 1988. `Political Participation as a Human Right', in Harvard Human RightsYearbook. New York : United Nations .
63.
Strand, Håvard ; Joachim Carlsen , Nils Petter Gleditsch , Håvard Hegre , Christin Ormhaug & Lars Wilhelmsen , 2005. Armed Conflict Dataset Codebook Version 3-2005 (http://www.prio.no/cscw/armedconflict ).
64.
Tufte, Richard R. , 1974. Data Analysis for Politics and Policy. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall .
65.
van Schuur, Wijbrandt H. , 2003. ` Mokken Scale Analysis: Between the Guttman Scale and Parametric Item Response Theory', PoliticalAnalysis11(2): 139—163 .
66.
Wolff, Stefan , 2003. `The Ethnopolitical Dynamics of Elections', European Center for Minority Issues , Working Paper No. 17 (http://www.ecmi.de/download/working_paper_17.pdf).
67.
World Bank , 2005. World Development Indicators on CD-ROM. Washington, DC: International Bank for Reconstruction and Development/World Bank .
68.
Zakaria, Fareed , 1997. ` The Rise of Illiberal Democracy ', Foreign Affairs76(6): 22—43 .
69.
Zanger, Sabine C. , 2000. ` A Global Analysis of the Effect of Political Regime Changes on Life Integrity Violations, 1977—93 ', Journal of Peace Research37(2): 213—233 .
70.
Zimbabwe Human Rights NGO Forum , 2002. `Human Rights and Zimbabwe's Presidential Election: March 2002', Special Report 4 (http://www.hrforumzim.com/special_hrru/Special_Report_4_2002%2520Election/SR4_0.htm).
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
