Archival content analysis studies of British and German newspapers and diplomatic documents in 1914 showed an increasingly asymmetrical pattern of perceived intentions. Levels of power motive imagery in reports or paraphrases of statements by the `other' side were accentuated, while levels in reports or paraphrases of statements by one's own (favored) side were diminished. As a result, the overall sense of threat was increased. In contrast, an archival study of US and Soviet newspapers during the peacefully resolved 1962 Cuban Missile Crisis showed no such pattern of asymmetrical accentuation-diminution. These results confirm a pattern of perceived intentions previously found in other escalating conflict situations, and are consistent with many related social psychological phenomena and experimental results. These findings suggest that comparing mutual perceptions of power imagery is a precise, operational way to measure `threatening' intentions and thus an important mechanism of conflict escalation.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Albertini, Luigi, 1957. The Origins of the War of 1914, Vol. 3. London: Oxford University Press .
2.
Asch, Solomon E.; H. Block & M. Hertzman, 1938. `Studies in the Principles of Judgment and Attitude: I. Two Basic Principles of Judgment' , Journal of Psychology5(2): 219-251 .
3.
Blake, Robert R. & Janet S. Mouton, 1962. `Comprehension of Own and Outgroup Positions Under Intergroup Competition' , Journal of Conflict Resolution5(4): 304-310 .
4.
Blight, James G., 1990. The Shattered Crystal Ball: Fear and Learning in the Cuban Missile Crisis. Savage, MD: Rowman & Littlefield .
5.
Blight, James G. & David A. Welch, 1989. On the Brink: Americans and Soviets Reexamine the Cuban Missile Crisis. New York: Hill & Wang .
6.
Bruner, Jerome S., 1957. `Going Beyond the Information Given', in Colorado University Psychology Department, ed., Contemporary Approaches to Cognition. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press (41-69).
7.
Bryant, DeAunderia N. & David G. Winter, 2002. Patterns of Misperception and Crisis Escalation: Munich 1938 and Poland 1939 Compared. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the International Society of Political Psychology, Berlin, July.
8.
Bülow, Prince Bernhard von, 1932. Memoirs of Prince von Bülow. Vol. 3. The World War and Germany's Collapse, 1909-1919. Boston, MA: Little, Brown .
9.
Butterfield, Herbert, 1965. `Sir Edward Grey in July 1914', in J. L. McCracken, ed., Historical Studies V: Papers Read Before the Sixth Conference of Irish Historians. London: Bowes & Bowes (1-25).
10.
Chang, Laurence & Peter Kornbluh, eds, 1992. The Cuban Missile Crisis, 1962: A National Security Archive Documents Reader. New York: New Press .
11.
Crick, Nicki R. & Kenneth A. Dodge, 1994. `A Review and Reformulation of Social Information-Processing Mechanisms in Children's Social Adjustment' , Psychological Bulletin115(1): 74-101 .
12.
Dugdale, Edgar T. S., ed., 1928-31. German Diplomatic Documents 1871-1914. 4 vols. London: Methuen .
13.
Eckstein, Harry, 1992. `Case Study and Theory in Political Science', in Regarding Politics: Essays on Political Theory, Stability, and Change. Berkeley & Los Angeles, CA: University of California Press (117-176). [Original work published 1975.]
14.
Ekstein, M., 1971. `Sir Edward Grey and Imperial Germany in 1914' , Journal of Contemporary History6(3): 121-131 .
15.
Erdmann, Karl D., ed., 1972. Kurt Riezler: Tagebücher, Aufsätze, Dokumente [Kurt Riezler: Diaries, Essays, Documents]. Göttingen: Vandenkoeck & Ruprecht .
16.
Etzioni, Amatai, 1967. `The Kennedy Experiment: Unilateral Initiatives' , Western Political Quarterly20(2, part 1): 361-380 .
17.
Fay, Sidney B., 1928. The Origins of the World War. New York: Macmillan .
18.
Ferguson, Niall, 1999. The Pity of War. London: Allen Lane, Penguin .
19.
Frisch, Max, 1962. Three Plays. London: Methuen .
20.
Fursenko, Aleksandr V. & Timothy Naftali, 1997. `One Hell of a Gamble': Khrushchev, Castro, and Kennedy, 1958-1964. New York: Norton .
21.
Garthoff, Raymond L., 1989. Reflections on the Cuban Missile Crisis, rev. edn. Washington, DC: Brookings .
22.
George, Alexander L., 1979. `Case Studies and Theory Development: The Method of Structured, Focused Comparison', in Paul G. Lauren, ed., Diplomacy: New Approaches in History, Theory, and Policy. New York: Free Press (43-68).
23.
Gooch, George P., 1938. Before the War: Studies in Diplomacy. Vol. 2, The Coming of the War. London: Oxford University Press .
24.
Gooch, George P. & Harold Temperley, eds, 1926-38. British Documents on the Origins of the War 1898-1914. 11 vols. London: His Majesty's Stationery Office .
25.
Greenwald, Anthony G. & Mahzarin R. Banaji, 1995. `Implicit Social Cognition: Attitudes, Self-Esteem, and Stereotypes' , Psychological Review102(1): 4-27 .
26.
Grey, Sir Edward, 1925. Twenty-Five Years: 1892-1916. 2 vols. New York: Stokes .
27.
Gribkov, Anatoli I. & William Y. Smith, 1994. Operation ANADYR: U.S. and Soviet Generals Recount the Cuban Missile Crisis. Chicago, IL: Edition q .
28.
Hale, Oron J., 1940. Publicity and Diplomacy: With Special Reference to England and Germany 1890-1914. New York: Appleton-Century .
29.
Holsti, Ole R., 1972. Crisis, Escalation, War. Montreal: McGill-Queen's University Press .
30.
Holsti, Ole R., 1989. `Crisis Decision Making', in Philip E. Tetlock, ed., Behavior, Society, and Nuclear War. New York: Oxford University Press (Vol. 1: 8-84).
31.
Holsti, Ole R.; Robert C. North & Richard Brody, 1968. `Perception and Action in the 1914 Crisis', in J. David Singer, ed., Quantitative International Politics: Insights and Evidence. New York: Free Press (123-158).
32.
Hovland, Carl I. & Muzafer Sherif, 1952. `Judgmental Phenomena and Scales of Attitude Measurement: Item Displacement in Thurstone Scales' , Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology47(4): 922-832 .
33.
Huang, Li-Ning & Katherine C. McAdams, 2000. `Ideological Manipulation via Newspaper Accounts of Political Conflict: A Cross-National News Analysis of the 1991 Moscow Coup', in Abbas Malek & Anandam P. Kavoori, eds, The Global Dynamics of News: Studies in International News Coverage and News Agenda. Stamford, CT: Ablex (57-73).
34.
Jagow, Gunther G. K. E. von, 1919. Ursachen und Ausbruch des Weltkrieges [Origins and Outbreak of the World War]. Berlin: Hobbing .
35.
Janis, Irving L., 1983. Groupthink: Psychological Studies of Policy Decisions and Fiascos. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin .
36.
Jarausch, Konrad H., 1973. The Enigmatic Chancellor: Bethmann Hollweg and the Hubris of Imperial Germany. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press .
37.
Jervis, Robert, 1968. `Hypotheses on Misperception' , World Politics20(3): 454-479 .
38.
Jervis, Robert, 1976. Perception and Misperception in International Relations. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press .
Joll, James, 1992. The Origins of the First World War, 2nd edn. London: Longman .
41.
Kahneman, Daniel; Paul Slovic & Amos Tversky, eds, 1982. Judgment Under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases. New York: Cambridge University Press .
42.
Keltner, Dacher & Robert J. Robinson, 1996. `Extremism, Power, and the Imagined Basis of Social Conflict' , Current Directions in Psychological Science5(4): 101-105 .
43.
Kemmelmeier, Markus & David G. Winter, 2000. `Putting Threat into Perspective: Experimental Studies on Perceptual Distortion in International Conflict' , Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin26(7): 795-809 .
44.
Kennedy, Paul M., 1980. The Rise of the Anglo-German Antagonism 1860-1914. Winchester, MA: Allen & Unwin .
45.
Klein, M. W. & Nathan Maccoby, 1954. `Newspaper Objectivity in the 1952 Campaign' , Journalism Quarterly31(3): 285-296 .
46.
Knorr, Klaus, 1976. `Threat Perception', in Klaus Knorr, ed., Historical Dimensions of National Security Problems. Lawrence, KS: University Press of Kansas (78-119).
47.
Kraus, Karl, 1976. `In These Great Times', in Harry Zohn, ed., In These Great Times: A Karl Kraus Reader. Montréal: Engendra (70-83). [Original work published 1914.]
48.
Lichnowsky, Karl M. von, 1928. Heading for the Abyss: Reminiscences. New York: Payson & Clarke .
49.
Liddell Hart, Basil H., 1970. History of the First World War. London: Cassell .
50.
Lord, Charles G.; Lee Ross & Mark R. Lepper, 1979. `Biased Assimilation and Attitude Polarization: The Effects of Prior Theories on Subsequently Considered Evidence' , Journal of Personality and Social Psychology37(11): 2098-2109 .
51.
McClelland, David C.; Richard Koestner & Joel Weinberger, 1989. `How do Self-Attributed and Implicit Motives Differ?' , Psychological Review96(4): 690-702 .
52.
May, Ernest R. & Philip D. Zelikow, 1997. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis. New York: Norton .
53.
Montgelas, Maximilian M. K. D. & Walter Schücking, eds, 1924. Outbreak of the World War: German Documents Collected by Karl Kautsky. New York: Oxford University Press .
54.
Nelson, Keith L. & Spencer C. Olin, 1979. Why War? Ideology, Theory, and History. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press .
55.
New York Times, 1994. `Tapes Show Kennedy as Calm in a Crisis', 28 July (A15).
56.
Pape, Robert A., 1996. `A Surgical Strike That Could Backfire', New York Times, 27 April (23).
57.
Peterson, Bill E.; David G. Winter & Richard M. Doty, 1994. `Laboratory Tests of a Motivational-Perceptual Model of Conflict Escalation' , Journal of Conflict Resolution38(4): 719-748 .
58.
Pool, Ithiel de S., 1952. The `Prestige Papers'. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press .
59.
Robbins, Keith, 1971. Sir Edward Grey: A Biography of Lord Grey of Fallodon. London: Cassell .
60.
Rosenthal, Robert, 1978. `Combining the Results of Independent Studies' , Psychological Bulletin85(1): 185-193 .
61.
Rubin, Jeffrey Z., 1981. Dynamics of Third Party Intervention: Kissinger in the Middle East. New York: Praeger .
62.
Silverstein, Brett & Catherine Flamenbaum, 1989. `Biases in the Perception and Cognition of the Actions of Enemies' , Journal of Social Issues45(2): 51-72 .
63.
Smith, Charles P., ed., 1992. Motivation and Personality: Handbook of Thematic Content Analysis. New York: Cambridge University Press .
Steed, Henry W., 1925. Through Thirty Years 1892-1922: A Personal Narrative. Garden City, NY: Doubleday, Page .
66.
Steiner, Zara S., 1977. Britain and the Origins of the First World War. London: Macmillan .
67.
Stuart, Douglas & Harvey Starr, 1981-82. `The “Inherent Bad Faith Model” Reconsidered: Dulles, Kennedy, and Kissinger' , Political Psychology3(3/4): 1-33 .
68.
Suedfeld, Peter & Philip E. Tetlock, 1977. `Integrative Complexity in International Crises' , Journal of Conflict Resolution21(1): 169-184 .
69.
Tajfel, Henri, 1981. Human Groups and Social Categories. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
70.
Taylor, Alan J. P., 1954. The Struggle for Mastery in Europe. London: Oxford University Press .
71.
Taylor, Alan J. P., 1967. `The Outbreak of the First World War', in Europe: Grandeur and Decline. Harmondsworth: Penguin (183-189).
72.
Tuchman, Barbara W., 1962. The Guns of August. New York: Macmillan .
73.
Turner, John, 1982. `Towards a Cognitive Redefinition of the Social Group', in Henri Tajfel, ed., Social Identity and Intergroup Relations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press (15-40).
74.
US Central Intelligence Agency, 1994. The Secret Cuban Missile Crisis Documents. Washington, DC: Brassey's .
75.
US Department of State, 1996. Foreign Relations of the United States 1961-1963, Vol. XI: Cuban Missile Crisis and Aftermath. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office .
76.
Watt, Donald C., 1971. `The British Reactions to the Assassination at Sarajevo' , European Studies Review1(3): 233-247 .
77.
White, Ralph K., 1970. Nobody Wanted War: Misperception in Vietnam and Other Wars. Garden City, NY: Doubleday .
78.
Wilson, Keith, 1995. `Britain', in Keith Wilson, ed., Decisions for War 1914. London: UCL Press (175-208).
79.
Winter, David G., 1973. The Power Motive. New York: Free Press .
80.
Winter, David G., 1987. `Enhancement of an Enemy's Power Motivation as a Dynamic of Conflict Escalation' , Journal of Personality and Social Psychology52(1): 41-46 .
81.
Winter, David G., 1991. `Measuring Personality at a Distance: Development of an Integrated System for Scoring Motives in Running Text', in Abigail J. Stewart, Joseph M. Healy, Jr. & Daniel J. Ozer, eds, Perspectives in Personality: Approaches to Understanding Lives. London: Jessica Kingsley (59-89).
82.
Winter, David G., 1993. `Power, Affiliation, and War: Three Tests of a Motivational Model' , Journal of Personality and Social Psychology65(3): 532-545 .
83.
Zinnes, Dina A., 1968. `The Expression and Perception of Hostility in Prewar Crisis: 1914', in J. David Singer, ed., Quantitative International Politics: Insights and Evidence. New York: Free Press (85-119).
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
