In the course of the debate over the existence and possible explanations for democratic peace (the tendency of democracies not to fight wars with one another), some scholars have looked to the world of Classical Greece to bolster their claims about the phenomenon. This article critiques the best of these efforts, looking at the way the ancient evidence has been handled and the conclusions drawn therefrom. It is argued that while the ancient world is an entirely appropriate era to investigate with regard to the issue, the analyses offered thus far have not made a strong case for the existence of a Greek democratic peace. Indeed, contrary to what investigators had hoped to show, the evidence from the period in and around the Peloponnesian war indicates that not only did ancient democracies go to war with each other, they did so with relatively high frequency. Both quantitative and more traditional literary analyses support this conclusion. These results do not so much attack the general notion of democratic peace as offer a more fruitful way of using ancient history to help explain it: by focusing on the differences between ancient and modern democracies and their historical settings, future studies may be able to identify the factors which encourage or discourage democratic peace.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Asheri, David , 1990. `Agrigento libera: rivolgimenti interni e problemi constituzionali, ca 471-446 a.C.' [Free Agrigentum: Internal Upheavals and Constitutional Problems, c. 471-446 B.C.]. Athenaeum78: 483-501.
2.
Asheri, David , 1992. `Sicily, 478-431 B.C.', in David Lewis, John Boardman & John Kenyon Davies, eds, The Cambridge Ancient History, vol. 5, 2nd edn.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press (147-170).
3.
Bachteler, Tobias , 1997. `Explaining the Democratic Peace: The Evidence from Ancient Greece Reviewed', Journal of Peace Research34(3): 315-323.
4.
Bradeen, Donald , 1960. `The Popularity of the Athenian Empire', Historia9: 257-269.
5.
Brunt, Peter , 1957. Review of Wentker, Sizilien und Athen [Sicily and Athens], in Classical Review7(ns): 243-245.
6.
Cawkwell, George , 1997. Thucydides and the Peloponnesian War. London: Routledge.
7.
Chan, Steve , 1997. `In Search of Democratic Peace: Problems and Promise', Mershon International Studies Review41: 59-91.
8.
Clauss, Manfred , 1983. Sparta. Munich: Beck.
9.
Consolo Langher, Sebastiana Nerina , 1997. Un imperialismo tra democrazia e tirannide. Siracusa nei secoli V e IV a.C. [An Imperialism between Democracy and Tyranny. Syracuse in the 5th and 4th Centuries B.C.]. Rome: Bretschneider.
10.
Cordano, Federica , 1992. Le tessere pubbliche del tempio di Atena a Camarina [The Public Tokens from the Temple of Athena at Camarina]. Rome: Istituto italiano per la storia antica.
11.
Farber, Henry & Joanne Gowa, 1996. `Politics and Peace', International Security20(2): 123-146.
Fornara, Charles , 1977. `IG I2, 39.52-57 and the “Popularity” of the Athenian Empire', California Studies in Classical Antiquity10: 39-55.
14.
Fritz, Kurt von & Ernst Kapp, 1950. Aristotle's Constitution of Athens. New York: Hafner.
15.
Gartzke, Erik , 1998. `Kant We All Just Get Along? Opportunity, Willingness, and the Origins of the Democratic Peace', American Journal of Political Science42(1): 1-27.
16.
Gehrke, Hans-Joachim , 1985. Stasis: Untersuchungen zu den inneren Kriegen in den griechischen Staaten des 5. und 4. Jahrhunderts v. Chr. [Sedition: Studies on the Internal Wars within the Greek States of the 5th and 4th Centuries B.C.]. Munich: Beck.
17.
Gigon, Olof , 1987. Aristotelis Opera, Vol. 3: Librorum Deperditorum Fragmenta [Aristotle's Works, Volume 3: Remnants of Lost Books]. Berlin: de Gruyter.
18.
Gomme, Arnold Wycombe , 1933. The Population of Athens in the Fifth and Fourth Centuries B.C.Oxford: Blackwell.
19.
Gomme, Arnold Wycombe ; Antony Andrewes & Kenneth Dover, 1945-81. A Historical Commentary on Thucydides. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
20.
Gorman, Vanessa , forthcoming. Miletos, the Ornament of Ionia. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.
21.
Graham, John , 1983. Colony and Mother City in Ancient Greece, 2md edn.Chicago, IL: Ares.
22.
Hamilton, Charles , 1991. Agesilaus and the Failure of Spartan Hegemony. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
23.
Hansen, Mogens Herman , 1982. `Demographic Reflections on the Number of Athenian Citizens 451-309 BC', American Journal of Ancient History7: 172-189.
24.
Hansen, Mogens Herman , 1989. Was Athens a Democracy? Popular Rule, Liberty and Equality in Ancient and Modern Political Thought. Copenhagen: Royal Danish Academy of Sciences and Letters.
25.
Hansen, Mogens Herman , 1994. `The Number of Athenian Citizens secundum Sekunda', Echos du monde classique13: 299-310.
26.
Hansen, Mogens Herman , 1996. `The Ancient Athenian and Modern Liberal View of Liberty as a Democratic Ideal', in Josiah Ober & Charles Hedrick, eds, Demokratia: A Conversation on Democracies, Ancient and Modern. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press (91-104).
27.
Hegre, Håvard , 2000. `Development and the Liberal Peace: What Does it Take to be a Trading State?', Journal of Peace Research37(1): 5-30.
28.
Hornblower, Simon , 1991-96. A Commentary on Thucydides, vols. 1-2. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
29.
Hornblower, Simon , 1994. Thucydides, 2nd edn.London: Duckworth.
30.
Kagan, Donald , 1981. The Peace of Nicias and the Sicilian Expedition. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
31.
Lapini, Walter , 1997. Commento all' Athenaion Politeia dello Pseudo-Senofonte [Commentary on the Constitution of the Athenians by Pseudo-Xenophon]. Florence: Universita degli studi di Firenze.
32.
Layne, Christopher , 1994. `Kant or Cant: The Myth of the Democratic Peace', International Security19(2): 5-49.
33.
Levy, Jack , 1988. `Domestic Politics and War', Journal of Interdisciplinary History18: 653-673.
34.
Manganaro, Giacomo , 1995. `Sikelika I' [Sicilian Items I], Quaderni urbinati di cultura classica49: 93-109.
35.
Maoz, Zeev , 1998. `Realist and Cultural Critiques of the Democratic Peace: A Theoretical and Empirical Re-Assessment', International Interactions24(1): 3-89.
36.
Meiggs, Russell , 1972. The Athenian Empire. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
37.
Meiggs, Russell & David Lewis, 1988. A Selection of Greek Historical Inscriptions. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
38.
Meister, Klaus , 1967. Die Sizilische Geschichte bei Diodor von den Anfängen bis zum Tod des Agathokles: Quellenuntersuchungen zu Buch IV-XXI [The Sicilian History in Diodorus from the Beginnings to the Death of Agathocles: Source Studies in Books IV-XXI]. Munich: Inaugural Dissertation.
39.
Miro, Ernesto de , 1967. `L'Ecclesiasterion in Contrada S. Nicola di Agrigento' [The Assembly Grounds at Contrada S. Nicola in Agrigentum], Palladio16: 164-168.
40.
Murray, Oswyn , 1995. `Liberty and the Ancient Greeks', in John Koumoulides, ed., The Good Idea: Democracy and Ancient Greece. New Rochelle, NY: Caratzas (33-55).
41.
Ober, Josiah , 1998. Political Dissent in Democratic Athens. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
42.
Ostwald, Martin , 1996. `Shares and Rights: “Citizenship” Greek Style and American Style', in Josiah Ober & Charles Hedrick, eds, Demokratia: A Conversation on Democracies, Ancient and Modern. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press (63-90).
43.
Parke, Herbert William , 1930. `The Development of the Second Spartan Empire', Journal of Hellenic Studies50: 37-79.
44.
Pleket, Henri Willy , 1963. `Thasos and the Popularity of the Athenian Empire', Historia12: 70-77.
45.
Pope, Maurice , 1988. `Thucydides and Democracy', Historia37: 276-296.
46.
Quinn, Trevor , 1964. `Thucydides and the Unpopularity of the Athenian Empire', Historia13: 257-266.
47.
Rabe, Hugo , ed., 1931. Prolegomenon Sylloge [A Collection of Prolegomena]. Leipzig: Teubner.
48.
Raymond, Gregory , 1996. `Demosthenes and Democracies: Regime-Types and Arbitration Outcomes', International Interactions22(1): 1-20.
49.
Rhodes, Peter John , 1993, A Commentary on the Aristotelian Athenaion Politeia. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
50.
Robinson, Eric , 1997. The First Democracies: Early Popular Government Outside Athens. Historia Einzelschriften #107. Stuttgart: Franz Steiner Verlag.
51.
Robinson, Eric , 2001. `Democracy in Syracuse, 466-412 BC', forthcoming in Harvard Studies in Classical Philology100.
52.
Rood, Tim , 1998. Thucydides: Narrative and Explanation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
53.
Ruschenbusch, Eberhard , 1985. `Die Zahl der griechischen Staaten und Arealgrösse und Bürgerzahl der “Normalpolis” ' [The Number of Greek States and the Territorial Size and Population of the `Normal City-State'], Zeitschrift für Papyrologie und Epigraphik59: 253-263.
54.
Russett, Bruce & William Antholis, 1992. `Do Democracies Fight Each Other? Evidence from the Peloponnesian War', Journal of Peace Research29(4): 415-434.
55.
Russett, Bruce & William Antholis, 1993. `Chapter 3. The Imperfect Democratic Peace of Ancient Greece', in Grasping the Democratic Peace. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press (43-71).
56.
Russett, Bruce & John Oneal, 2001. Triangulating Peace: Democracy, Interdependence, and International Organizations. New York: Norton.
57.
Sacks, Kenneth , 1990. Diodorus Siculus and the First Century. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
58.
Sandys, John Edwin , 1912. Aristotle's Constitution of Athens. London: Macmillan.
59.
Sekunda, Nicholas , 1992. `Athenian Demography and Military Strength 338-322 BC', Annual of the British School at Athens87: 311-355.
60.
Spiro, David , 1994. `The Insignificance of the Liberal Peace', International Security19(2): 50-86.
61.
Ste Croix, Geoffrey de , 1954. `The Character of the Athenian Empire', Historia3: 1-41.
62.
Tomlinson, Richard Allen , 1972. Argos and the Argolid. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
63.
Weart, Spencer , 1994. `Peace among Democratic and Oligarchic Republics', Journal of Peace Research31(3): 299-316.
64.
Weart, Spencer , 1998. Never At War: Why Democracies Will Not Fight One Another. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
65.
Weil, Raymond , 1960. Aristote et l'histoire [Aristotle and History]. Paris: Klincksieck.
66.
Wentker, Hermann , 1956. Sizilien und Athen. Die Begegnung der attischen Macht mit den Westgriechen [Sicily and Athens. The Meeting of Attic Power and the Western Greeks]. Heidelberg: Quelle & Meyer.
67.
Westlake, Henry Dickinson , 1976. `The Commons at Mytilene', Historia25: 429-440.
68.
Zucker, Friedrich , 1954. Isokrates' Panathenaikos. Berlin: Akademie-Verlag.
