The authors test the proposition that the effectiveness of a particular strategic orientation—reactor, defender, analyzer, and prospector—is contingent upon the dynamics of the market. In mildly volatile markets, analyzer organizations are found to outperform other organization strategy types. However, in more volatile markets, the strategy-performance alignment is less clearly determined by the market environment.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbernathyWilliam J., and WayneKenneth (1974), “Limits of the Learning Curve,”Harvard Business Review, 52 (September-October), 109–19.
2.
American Bank Directory (1983). Norcross, GA: McFadden Business Publication.
3.
American Bank Directory (1986). Norcross, GA: McFadden Business Publication.
4.
AndersonCarl R., and ZeithamlCarl P. (1984), “Stage of the Product Life Cycle, Business Strategy, and Business Performance,”Academy of Management Journal, 27 (1), 5–24.
5.
BagozziRichard P. (1974), “Marketing as an Organized Behavioral System of Exchange,”Journal of Marketing, 38 (October), 77–81.
6.
BenstonGeorge J. (1985), “The Validity of Profits-Structure Studies with Particular Reference to the FTC's Line of Business Data,”American Economic Review, 75 (March), 37–67.
7.
BoalKimberly B., and BrysonJohn M. (1987), “Presentation, Testing and Policy Implications of Planning Processes,”Strategic Management Journal, 8 (May-June), 211–31.
8.
BourgeoisLionel J.III (1980), “Strategy and Environment: A Conceptual Integration,”Academy of Management Review, 5 (January), 25–39.
9.
BourgeoisLionel J.III (1984), “Strategic Management and Determinism,”Academy of Management Review, 9 (October), 586–96.
10.
BourgeoisLionel J.III (1985), “Strategic Goals, Perceived Uncertainty, and Economic Performance in Volatile Environments,”Academy of Management Journal, 10 (October), 586–96.
11.
BurrellGibson, and MorganGareth (1979), Sociological Paradigms and Organizational Analysis.London: Heinemann.
12.
BuzzellRobert D., and GaleBradley T. (1987), The PIMS Principles: Linking Strategy to Performance.New York: The Free Press.
13.
BuzzellRobert D., and WiersemaFrederik D. (1981), “Modeling Changes in Market Share: A Cross-Sectional Analysis,”Strategic Management Journal, 2 (January-March), 27–42.
14.
CameronKim S., and WhettenDavid A. (1983), Organizational Performance: A Comparison of Multiple Models.New York: Academic Press, Inc.
ChildJohn (1972), “Organizational Structure, Environment and Performance: The Role of Strategic Choice,”Sociology, 6, 1–22.
17.
CosseThomas J., and SwanJohn E. (1983), “Strategic Marketing Planning by Product Managers—Room for Improvement?”Journal of Marketing, 47 (Summer), 92–102.
18.
DayGeorge (1981), “The Product Life Cycle: Analysis and Applications Issues,”Journal of Marketing, 45 (Fall), 60–7.
19.
DayGeorge, and WensleyRobin (1983), “Marketing Theory with a Strategic Orientation,”Journal of Marketing, 41 (Fall), 79–89.
20.
DealTerrence E., and KennedyAllen A. (1982), Corporate Cultures: The Rites and Rituals of Corporate Life.Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley Publishing Company.
21.
GeusDe, ArieP. (1988), “Planning as Learning,”Harvard Business Review, 66 (March-April), 70–4.
22.
DessGregory G., and BeardDonald W. (1984), “Dimensions of Organizational Environments,”Administrative Science Quarterly, 29 (March), 52–73.
23.
FiegenbaumAvi, and ThomasHoward (1988), “Attitudes Toward Risk and the Risk-Return Paradox: Prospect Theory Explanations,”Academy of Management Journal, 31 (March), 85–106.
24.
FisherFranklin M., and McGowanJohn J. (1983), “On the Misuse of Accounting Rates of Return to Infer Monopoly Profits,”American Economic Review, 73 (March), 82–97.
25.
FordWilliam F., and OlsenDennis A. (1978), “How 1,000 High-Performance Banks Weathered the Recent Recession,”Banking (April), 36.
26.
FryLouis W., and SmithDeborah A. (1987), “Congruence, Contingency, and Theory Building,”Academy of Management Review, 12 (January), 117–32.
27.
GalbraithJay R. (1977), Organization Design.Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley Publishing Company.
28.
GarciaF. L. (1985), How to Analyze a Bank Statement, 7th ed. Boston: Bankers Publishing Co.
29.
GronroosChristian (1983), “Strategic Management and Marketing in the Service Sector,” Report No. 83–104, Marketing Science Institute.
30.
HambrickDonald C. (1982), “Environmental Scanning and Organizational Strategy,”Strategic Management Journal, 3 (April-June), 159–75.
31.
HambrickDonald C. (1983a), “High Profit Strategies in Mature Capital Goods Industries: A Contingency Approach,”Academy of Management Journal, 26 (December), 687–707.
32.
HambrickDonald C. (1983b), “Some Tests of the Effectiveness and Functional Attributes of Miles and Snows' Strategic Types,”Academy of Management Journal, 26 (March), 5–26.
33.
HambrickDonald C., MacMillanI. C., and DayD. L. (1982), “Strategic Attributes and Performance in the BOG Matrix—A PIMS-Based Analysis of Industrial Products Businesses,”Academy of Management Journal, 25 (September), 510–31.
34.
HarriganKathryn R. (1983), “Research Methodologies for Contingency Approaches to Business Strategy,”Academy of Management Review, 8 (July), 398–405.
35.
HayR. D., and GinterP. M. (1979), “Strategies for Maintaining a Share of the Market,” paper presented at Annual Meeting of Southern Academy of Management.
36.
HendersonBruce D. (1984), “The Application and Misapplication of the Experience Curve,”Journal of Business Strategy, 4 (Winter), 3–9.
37.
HrebiniakLawrence G., and JoyceWilliam F. (1985), “Organizational Adaptation: Strategic Choice and Environmental Determinism,”Administrative Science Quarterly, 30 (September), 336–49.
38.
JacobsenRobert (1987), “The Validity of ROI as a Measure of Business Performance,”American Economic Review, 11 (June), 470–8.
39.
JacobsenRobert (1988), “The Persistence of Abnormal Returns,”Strategic Management Journal, 9 (September-October), 415–30.
40.
KotlerPhilip (1986), “Megamarketing,”Harvard Business Review, 64 (March-April), 117–24.
41.
KotlerPhilip (1988), Marketing Management: Analysis, Planning, Implementation and Control, 6th ed. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, Inc.
LevittTheodore (1965), “Exploit the Product Life Cycle,”Harvard Business Review, 43 (November-December), 81–94.
44.
LilienGary L., and KotlerPhilip (1983), Marketing Decision Making: A Model-Building Approach.New York: Harper & Row.
45.
LongWilliam F., and RavenscraftDavid J. (1984), “The Misuse of Accounting Rates of Return: Comment,”American Economic Review, 74 (June), 494–500.
46.
MacMillanI., HambrickD., and DayD. (1982), “The Product Portfolio and Profitability—A PIMS-Based Analysis of Industrial-Product Businesses,”Academy of Management Journal, 25 (December), 733–55.
47.
McDanielStephen W., and KolariJames W. (1987), “Marketing Strategy Implications of the Miles and Snow Typology,”Journal of Marketing, 51 (October), 19–30.
48.
MeyerAlan D. (1982), “Adapting to Environmental Jolts,”Administrative Science Quarterly, 28 (December), 515–37.
49.
MilesRaymond E., and SnowCharles C. (1978), Organizational Strategy, Structure, and Process.New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company.
50.
MilesRobert H. (1982), Coffin Nails and Corporate Strategy.Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, Inc.
51.
MoriartyMark (1975), “Cross-Sectional, Time-Series Issues in the Analysis of Marketing Decision Variables,”Journal of Marketing Research, 12 (May), 142–50.
52.
NunnallyJum C. (1978), Psychometric Theory, 2nd ed. New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company.
53.
ParasuramanA., BerryLeonard L., and ZeithamlValarie A. (1983), “Service Firms Need Marketing Skills,”Business Horizons, 26 (November-December), 28–31.
54.
PfefferJeff, and SalancikGerald (1978), The External Control of Organizations.New York: Harper and Row.
55.
PriceJames L., and MuellerCharles W. (1986), Handbook of Organizational Measurement.Marshfield, MA: Pitman Publishing Inc.
56.
ReedEdward W., CotterRichard V., GillEdward K., and SmithRichard K. (1976), Commerical Banking.Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, Inc.
57.
RosenbergMorris (1968), The Logic of Survey Analysis.New York: Basic Books.
58.
RoussakisEmmanuel N. (1984), Commercial Banking in an Era of Deregulation.New York: Praeger Publishers.
59.
RuekertRobert W., and WalkerOrville C.Jr. (1987), “Interactions Between Marketing and R&D Departments in Implementing Different Business Strategies,”Strategic Management Journal, 8 (May-June), 233–48.
60.
RuekertRobert W., WalkerOrville C.Jr., and RoeringKenneth J. (1985), “The Organization of Marketing Activities: A Contingency Theory of Structure and Performance,”Journal of Marketing, 49 (Winter), 13–25.
61.
SalamonGerald L. (1985), “Accounting Rates of Return,”American Economic Review, 75 (June), 495–504.
62.
SharmaSubhash, DurandRichard M., and Gur-ArieOded (1981), “Identification and Analysis of Moderator Variables,”Journal of Marketing Research, 18 (August), 291–300.
63.
Sheshunoff Rating Services Inc. (1986), Sheshunoff Bank Quarterly: March 1986 Results.Austin, TX.
64.
ShraderCharles B., TaylorLew, and DaltonDan R. (1984), “Strategic Planning and Organizational Performance: A Critical Appraisal,”Journal of Management, 10 (Summer), 149–71.
65.
SmartCarolyne, and VertinskyIlan (1984), “Strategy and the Environment: A Study of Corporate Responses to Crisis,”Strategic Management Journal, 5 (July-September), 199–213.
66.
SnowCharles C., and HambrickDonald C. (1980), “Measuring Organizational Strategies: Some Theoretical and Methodological Problems,”Academy of Management Review, 5 (October), 527–38.
67.
SnowCharles C., and HrebiniakLawrence G. (1980), “Strategy, Distinctive Competence, and Organizational Performance,”Administrative Science Quarterly, 25 (June), 317–36.
68.
SnyderNeil H., and GlueckWilliam F. (1982), “Can Environmental Volatility Be Measured Objectively?”Academy of Management Journal, 25 (March), 185–92.
69.
StaschStanley F., and LanktreePatricia (1980), “Can Your Marketing Planning Procedures Be Improved?”Journal of Marketing, 44 (Summer), 79–90.
70.
TosiH., AldagR., and StoreyR. (1973), “On the Measurement of the Environment: An Assessment of the Lawrence and Lorsch Environmental Uncertainty Subscale,”Administrative Science Quarterly, 18 (March), 27–36.
71.
VenkatramanN., and RamanujanVasudevan (1986), “Measurements of Business Performance in Strategy Research: A Comparison of Approaches,”Academy of Management Review, 11 (October), 801–14.
72.
WalkerOrville CJr., and RuekertRobert W. (1987), “Marketing's Role in the Implementation of Business Strategies: A Critical Review and Conceptual Framework,”Journal of Marketing, 51 (July), 15–33.
73.
WassonChester R. (1974), Dynamic Competitive Strategy and Product Life Cycles.St. Charles, IL: Challenge Books.
74.
WeickKarl E. (1977), “Re-Puncturing the Problem,” in New Perspectives on Organizational Effectiveness, GoodmanPaul S., PenningsJohannes M. and Associates, eds. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass Inc., Publishers.
75.
WeickKarl E. (1979), The Social Psychology of Organizing, 2nd ed. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley Publishing Company.
76.
WeissDoyle L. (1968), “Determinants of Market Share,”Journal of Marketing Research, 5 (August), 290–5.
77.
WindJ. (1981), “Product Life Cycle,” unpublished manuscript, The Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania.
78.
ZammutoRaymond F. (1982), Assessing Organizational Effectiveness: Systems Change, Adaptation, and Strategy.Albany: State University of New York Press.
79.
ZeithamlCarl P., and FryLouis W. (1984), “Contextual and Strategic Differences Among Mature Businesses in Four Dynamic Performance Situations,”Academy of Management Journal, 27 (4), 841–60.
80.
ZeithamlCarl P., and ZeithamlValarie A. (1984), “Environmental Management: Revising the Marketing Perspective,”Journal of Marketing, 48 (Spring), 46–53.
81.
ZeithamlValarie A., VaradarajanP., and ZeithamlCarl P. (1988), “The Contingency Approach: Its Foundations and Relevance to Theory Building and Research in Marketing,”European Journal of Marketing, 22 (7), 37–63.
