Historically, marketing control research has involved either the development of output-oriented financial controls or the analysis of how financial controls affect performance. This work on marketing control is limited in that it (1) has focused primarily on the control of marketing plans/activities, not on the control of marketing personnel, (2) fails to capture all controls operating within the marketing unit, (3) does not consider environmental conditions that both influence the use and moderate the effects of controls, and (4) ignores the behavioral and psychological impact of controls on individuals. To overcome these limitations, a theory integrating environmental context, controls, and the consequences of controls is proposed. Previous research is categorized within the framework, relevant propositions are advanced, and directions for future research are proposed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AldrichHoward E. (1979), Organizations and Environments., Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, Inc.
2.
AndersonErin (1985), “The Salesperson as Outside Agent or Employee: A Transaction Cost Analysis,”Marketing Science, 4 (Summer), 234–54.
3.
AndersonPaul (1982), “Marketing, Strategic Planning and the Theory of the Firm,”Journal of Marketing, 46 (Spring), 15–26.
4.
AndersonPaul, and ChambersTerry (1985), “A Reward/Measurement Model of Organizational Buying Behavior,”Journal of Marketing, 49 (Spring), 7–23.
5.
AnsariShahid L. (1977), “An Integrated Approach to Control System Design,”Accounting, Organizations and Society, 2, 101–2.
6.
AnthonyRobert (1952), Management Controls in Industrial Research Organizations., Cambridge, MA: Division of Research, Graduate School of Business, Harvard University Press.
7.
ArgyrisChris (1951), The Impact of Budgets on People., New York: Controllership Foundation.
8.
ArgyrisChris (1953), “Human Problems with Budgets,”Harvard Business Review, 31 (January-February), 97–110.
9.
ArgyrisChris (1957), Personality and Organization., New York: Harper.
10.
ArgyrisChris (1971), “Management Information Systems: The Challenge to Rationality and Emotionality,”Management Science, 17 (February), 275–92.
11.
ArrowKenneth (1964), “Control in Large Organizations,”Management Science, 10 (April), 397–408.
12.
BarnardChester (1938), The Functions of the Executive., Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
13.
BassettWilliam R. (1922), “Sales and Administrative Costs,”NACA Yearbook, National Association of Cost Accountants, 103–15.
14.
BaumlerJohn V. (1971), “Defined Criteria of Performance in Organizational Control,”Administrative Science Quarterly, 16 (September), 340–9.
15.
BeckerSelwyn, and GordonGerald (1966), “An Entrepreneurial Theory of Formal Organizations Part I,”Administrative Science Quarterly, 11 (December), 315–44.
16.
BeikLeland L., and BusbyStephen L. (1973), “Profitability Analysis by Market Segments,”Journal of Marketing, 37 (July), 48–53.
17.
BentzWilliam F., and LuschRobert F. (1980), “Now You Can Control Your Product's Market Performance,”Management Accounting, 49 (January), 17–25.
18.
BirnbergJ. G., TuropolecL., and YoungS. M. (1983), “The Organizational Context of Accounting,”Accounting, Organizations and Society, 8, 111–29.
19.
BlauPeter, and ScottW. R. (1972), Formal Organizations., San Francisco: Chandler Publishing.
20.
BowerJoseph L. (1983), “Managing for Efficiency, Managing for Equity,”Harvard Business Review, 61 (July-August), 83–90.
21.
BrownellPeter (1985), “Budgetary Systems and the Control of Functionally Differentiated Organizational Activities,”Journal of Accounting Research, 23 (Autumn), 502–12.
22.
BrunsWilliamJr., and WaterhouseJohn H. (1975), “Budgetary Control and Organizational Structure,”Journal of Accounting Research, 13 (Autumn), 177–202.
23.
BurnsThomas, and StalkerG. M. (1966), The Management of Innovation., London: Tavistock.
24.
CherianJoseph, and DeshpandeRohit (1985), “The Impact of Organizational Culture on the Adoption of Industrial Innovations,” in AMA Educators’ Proceedings, Series 51, LuschRobert F., eds. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 30–4.
25.
ChildJohn (1972), “Organizational Structure and Strategies of Control: A Replication of the Aston Study,”Administrative Science Quarterly, 17 (June), 163–77.
26.
ChurchillGilbert A.Jr., FordNeil M., and WalkerOrville C.Jr. (1985), Sales Force Management, 2nd ed.Homewood, IL: Richard D. Irwin, Inc.
27.
CooperDavid J., HayesDavid, and WolfFrank (1981), “Accounting in Organized Anarchies: Understanding and Designing Accounting Systems in Ambiguous Situations,”Accounting, Organizations and Society, 6, 175–91.
28.
CronbachLee J. (1987), “Statistical Tests for Moderator Variables: Flaws in Analyses Recently Proposed,”Psychological Bulletin, 102 (November), 414–17.
29.
CyertRichard, and MarchJames (1963), A Behavioral Theory of the Firm., Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, Inc.
30.
DaltonGene W. (1971), “Motivation and Control in Organizations,” in Motivation and Control in Organizations, DaltonGene W., and LawrencePaul R., eds. Homewood, IL: Richard D. Irwin, Inc., 1–35.
31.
DayGeorge (1977), “Diagnosing the Product Portfolio,”Journal of Marketing, 41 (April), 29–38.
32.
DeshpandeRohit, and ParasuramanA. (1984), “Organizational Culture and Marketing Effectiveness,” in Scientific Method in Marketing, AndersonPaul F., and RyanMichael J., eds. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 137–40.
33.
DeshpandeRohit, and ZaltmanGerald (1982), “Factors Affecting the Use of Market Research Information: A Path Analysis,”Journal of Marketing Research, 19 (February), 14–31.
34.
DonaldsonGordon (1985), “Financial Goals and Strategic Consequences,”Harvard Business Review, 63 (May-June), 57–66.
35.
DunbarRoger L. M. (1981), “Designs for Organizational Control,” in Handbook of Organizational Design, NystromPaul C., and StarbuckWilliam H., eds. London: Oxford University Press.
36.
EtgarMichael (1976), “Effects of Administrative Control on Efficiency of Vertical Marketing Systems,”Journal of Marketing Research, 13 (February), 12–24.
37.
FlamholtzEric G. (1983), “Accounting, Budgeting, and Control Systems in Their Organizational Context: Theoretical and Empirical Perspectives,”Accounting, Organizations and Society, 8, 153–69.
38.
FlamholtzEric G., DasT. K., and TsuiAnne (1985), “Toward an Integrative Framework of Organizational Control,”Accounting, Organizations and Society, 10, 35–50.
39.
FutrellCharles M., SwanJohn E., and ToddJohn T. (1976), “Job Performance Related to Management Control Systems for Pharmaceutical Salesmen,”Journal of Marketing Research, 13 (February), 25–37.
GatignonHubert (1984), “Competition as a Moderator of the Effect of Advertising on Sales,”Journal of Marketing Research, 21 (November), 387–98.
42.
GordonLawrence, and NarayananV. K. (1984), “Management Accounting Systems, Perceived Environmental Uncertainty and Organizational Structure: An Empirical Investigation,”Accounting, Organizations and Society, 9, 33–47.
43.
GovindarajanV. (1984), “Appropriateness of Accounting Data in Performance Evaluation: An Empirical Examination of Environmental Uncertainty as an Intervening Variable,”Accounting, Organizations and Society, 9, 125–35.
44.
GrantJohn, and KingWilliam R. (1982), The Logic of Strategic Planning., Boston: Little, Brown & Co., Inc.
45.
HayesRobert, and AbernathyW. J. (1980), “Managing Our Way to Economic Decline,”Harvard Business Review, 58 (July-August), 67–77.
46.
HerseyM. L. (1937), “The Elements of a System of Marketing Control,”Journal of Marketing, 2 (October), 201–8.
47.
HirstM. K. (1981), “Accounting Information and the Evaluation of Subordinate Performance: A Situational Approach,”Accounting Review, 56 (October), 771–84.
48.
HirstM. K. (1983), “Reliance on Accounting Performance Measures, Task Uncertainty, and Dysfunctional Behavior: Some Extensions,”Journal of Accounting Research, 21 (Autumn), 596–605.
49.
HofstedeG. H. (1967), The Game of Budget Control., Assen, The Netherlands: Van Gorcum.
50.
HofstedeG. H. (1978), “The Poverty of Management Control,”Academy of Management Review, 3, 450–61.
51.
HofstedeG. H. (1981), “Management Control of Public and Not-For-Profit Activities,”Accounting, Organizations and Society, 6, 143–211.
52.
HopwoodAnthony (1972), “An Empirical Study of the Role of Accounting Data in Performance Evaluation,”Empirical Research in Accounting: Selected Studies, 1972, supplement to Journal of Accounting Research, 10 (Summer), 156–82.
53.
HopwoodAnthony (1974), Accounting and Human Behavior., London: Haymarket Publishing Limited.
54.
HulbertJames, and ToyNorman E. (1977), “A Strategic Framework for Marketing Control,”Journal of Marketing, 41 (April), 12–21.
55.
ImoisilliOlumhense (1985), “Task Complexity, Budget Style of Evaluating Performance and Managerial Stress: An Empirical Investigation,” unpublished dissertation, Graduate School of Business, University of Pittsburgh.
56.
JaworskiBernard J. (1986), “The Impact of Control Systems-in-Use and Task-Related Knowledge on Select Psychological and Behavioral Response of Marketing Managers,” unpublished dissertation, Graduate School of Business, University of Pittsburgh.
57.
JöreskogKarl (1971), “Simultaneous Factor Analysis in Several Populations,”Psychometrika, 36 (December), 409–26.
58.
KerrSteven, and SlocumJohn W. (1981), “Controlling the Performance of People in Organizations,” in Handbook of Organizational Design, NystromPaul C., and StarbuckWilliam H., eds. London: Oxford University Press, 116–34.
59.
KhandwallaPradip N. (1972), “The Effect of Different Types of Competition on the Use of Management Controls,”Journal of Accounting Research, 10 (Autumn), 275–85.
60.
KhandwallaPradip N. (1973), “Effect of Competition on the Structure of Top Management Control,”Academy of Management Journal, 10 (June), 285–95.
61.
KilmannRalph (1984), Beyond the Quick Fix., San Francisco: Jossey-Bass Publishers.
62.
KimJay S. (1984), “Effect of Behavior Plus Outcome Goal Setting and Feedback on Employee Satisfaction and Performance,”Academy of Management Journal, 27 (March), 139–49.
63.
LandauMartin, and StoudtRussellJr. (1979), “To Manage is Not to Control: Or the Folly of Type II Errors,”Public Administration Review, 39 (March/April), 148–56.
64.
LawlerEdward E. (1976), “Control Systems in Organizations,” in Handbook of Industrial and Organizational Psychology, DunnetteM. D., ed. Chicago: Rand McNally, Inc.
65.
LawlerEdward E., and RhodeJohn G. (1976), Information and Control in Organizations., Pacific Palisades, CA: Goodyear Publishing Company.
66.
LevittTheodore (1977), “Marketing When Things Change,”Harvard Business Review, 55 (November-December), 107–13.
67.
LikertRensis (1967), The Human Organization., New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company.
68.
ManzCharles C., and SimsHenry P. (1980), “Self Management as a Substitute for Leadership: A Social Learning Perspective,”Academy of Management Review, 5, 361–7.
69.
MarchJames, and SimonHerbert (1958), Organizations., New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
70.
MarkusLynne, and PfefferJeffrey (1983), “Power and the Design and Implementation of Accounting and Control Systems,”Accounting, Organizations and Society, 8, 205–18.
71.
MerchantKenneth (1981), “The Design of the Corporate Budgeting System: Influences of Managerial Behavior and Performance,”Accounting Review, 56 (October), 813–29.
72.
MerchantKenneth (1984), “Influences on Departmental Budgeting: An Empirical Examination of a Contingency Model,”Accounting, Organizations and Society, 9, 291–307.
73.
MerchantKenneth (1985a), Control in Business Organizations., Boston: Pitman Publishing.
74.
MerchantKenneth (1985b), “On the Incidence and Causes of Dysfunctional Side Effects of Control Systems,” paper presented at American Accounting Association Annual Meeting, Reno, NV.
75.
MerchantKenneth, and SimonsRobert (1985), “Research on Complex Organizations,” paper presented at American Accounting Association Annual Meeting, Reno, NV.
76.
MeyerJohn W., and RowanBrian (1977), “Institutionalized Organizations: Formal Structure as Myth and Ceremony,”American Journal of Sociology, 83 (September), 340–63.
77.
MillsPeter (1985), “The Control Mechanism of Employees at the Encounter of Service Organizations,” in The Service Encounter, CzepielJohn A., eds. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
78.
MinerJohn B. (1975), “The Uncertain Future of the Leadership Concept: An Overview,” in Leadership Frontiers, HuntJames G., and LarsonLars L., eds. Kent, OH: Kent State University Press, 197–208.
79.
OtleyDavid (1978), “Budget Use and Managerial Performance,”Journal of Accounting Research, 16 (Spring), 112–49.
80.
OtleyDavid (1980), “The Contingency Theory of Management Accounting: Achievement and Prognosis,”Accounting, Organizations and Society, 5, 413–28.
81.
OuchiWilliam G. (1978), “The Transmission of Control Through Organizational Hierarchy,”Academy of Management Journal, 21 (June), 173–92.
82.
OuchiWilliam G. (1979), “A Conceptual Framework for the Design of Organizational Control Mechanisms,”Management Science, 25 (September), 833–47.
83.
OuchiWilliam G. (1980), “Markets, Bureaucracies and Clans,”Administrative Science Quarterly, 25 (March), 129–41.
84.
OuchiWilliam G., and MaguireM. A. (1975), “Organizational Control: Two Functions,”Administrative Science Quarterly, 20 (December), 559–69.
85.
ParasuramanA., and DeshpandeRohit (1984), “The Cultural Context of Marketing Management,” in AMA Educators’ Proceedings, Series 50, BelkRussell W., eds. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 176–9.
86.
ParkC. Whan, and ZaltmanGerald (1987), The Management of Markets., New York: Dryden Press.
87.
PerrowCharles (1965), “Hospital Technology, Structure and Goals,” in Handbook of Organizations, MarchJames, ed. Chicago: Rand McNally, Inc.
88.
PhillipsLynn (1982), “Explaining Control Losses in Corporate Marketing Channels: An Organizational Analysis, Journal of Marketing Research, 19 (November), 525–49.
89.
PorterL. W., LawlerE. E., and HackmanJ. R. (1975), Behavior in Organizations., New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company.
90.
PorterMichael (1980), Competitive Strategy., New York: The Free Press.
91.
ReevesT. K., and WoodwardJoan (1970), “The Study of Managerial Control,” in Industrial Organizations: Behavior and Control, WoodwardJoan, ed. London: Oxford University Press.
92.
ReukertRobert W., WalkerOrville C.Jr., and RoeringKenneth J. (1985), “The Organization of Marketing Activities: A Contingency Theory of Structure and Performance,”Journal of Marketing, 49 (Winter), 13–25.
93.
RidgewayV. F. (1956), “Dysfunctional Consequences of Performance Measurement,”Administrative Science Quarterly, 1 (September), 240–47.
94.
RoethlisbergerF. J., and DicksonW. J. (1939), Management and the Worker., Cambridge, MA: Harvard University.
95.
SchoonhovenClaudia Bird (1981), “Problems with Contingency Theory: Testing Assumptions Hidden Within the Language of Contingency ‘Theory’,”Administrative Science Quarterly, 26 (September), 349–77.
96.
SharmaSubhash, and AchabalDale D. (1982), “STEMCOM: An Analytical Model for Marketing Control,”Journal of Marketing, 46 (Spring), 104–13.
97.
ShostackG. Lynn (1987), “Service Positioning Through Structural Change,”Journal of Marketing, 51 (January), 34–43.
98.
SimonHerbert (1964), “On the Concept of Organizational Goal,”Administrative Science Quarterly, 9 (June), 1–22.
99.
SmithGeorge David, and SteadmanLawrence E. (1981), “Present Value of Corporate History,”Harvard Business Review, 59 (November-December), 164–73.
100.
StantonWilliam J., and BuskirkRichard H. (1987), Management of the Sales Force, 7th ed.Homewood, IL: Richard D. Irwin, Inc.
101.
SwieringaR. J., and MoncurR. H. (1972), “The Relationship Between Managers’ Budget Oriented Behavior and Selected Attitude, Position, Size and Performance Measures,” Empirical Research in Accounting: Selected Studies, supplement toJournal of Accounting Research, 10, 194–209.
102.
TannebaumArnold (1968), Control in Organizations., New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company.
103.
TerborgJ. K., and MillerH. E. (1978), “Motivation, Behavior and Peformance: A Closer Examination of Goal Setting and Monetary Incentives,”Journal of Applied Psychology, 63 (February), 29–39.
104.
ThompsonJames D. (1967), Organizations in Action., New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company.
105.
VroomV. H. (1969), Work and Motivation., New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
106.
WaterhouseJ. H., and TiessenP. (1978), “A Contingency Framework for Management Accounting Systems Research,”Accounting, Organizations and Society, 3, 65–76.
107.
WeberMax (1946), From Max Weber: Essays on Sociology, GerthH. H., and Wright MillsC., eds. New York: Oxford University Press.
108.
WeitzBarton A. (1981), “Effectiveness in Sales Interactions: A Contingency Framework,”Journal of Marketing, 45 (Winter), 85–103.
109.
WeitzBarton A. (1985), “Introduction to Special Issue on Competition in Marketing,”Journal of Marketing Research, 22 (August), 229–36.
110.
WhyteWilliam F. (1955), Money and Motivation., New York: Harper.
111.
WildavskyA. (1964), The Politics of the Budgetary Process., Boston: Little, Brown & Co., Inc.
112.
WilkinsAlan L., and OuchiWilliam G. (1983), “Efficient Cultures: Exploring the Relationship Between Culture and Organizational Performance,”Administrative Science Quarterly, 28 (September), 468–81.
113.
WilliamsonOliver (1970), Corporate Control and Business Behavior., Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, Inc.
114.
WilsonR. M. S. (1980), Management Controls and Marketing Planning., New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
115.
WoodStephen (1979), “A Reappraisal of the Contingency Approach to Organization,”Journal of Management Studies, 16 (October), 334–54.
116.
WoodwardJoan (1965), Industrial Organization: Theory and Practice., London: Oxford University Press.
117.
WoodwardJoan, ed. (1970), Industrial Organization: Behavior and Control., London: Oxford University Press.
118.
YoungS. Mark (1985), “Participative Budgeting: The Effects of Risk Aversion and Asymmetric Information on Budgetary Slack,”Journal of Accounting Research, 23 (Autumn), 829–42.
119.
ZeithamlCarl P., and ZeithamlValarie A. (1984), “Environmental Management: Revising the Marketing Perspective,”Journal of Marketing, 48 (Spring), 46–53.
120.
ZeithamlValarie, BerryLeonard L., and ParasuramanA. (1987), “Communication and Control Processes in the Delivery of Service Quality,” Marketing Science Institute Working Paper Series.
121.
ZeithamlValarie, ParasuramanA., and BerryLeonard L. (1985), “Problems and Strategies in Services Marketing,”Journal of Marketing, 49 (Spring), 33–46.
