It is argued that the long debate concerning the scientific credentials of marketing has been couched in terms of an idealized notion of science as the ultimate source of objectively certified knowledge. A review of contemporary literature in the philosophy, sociology, and history of science reveals that this canonical conception of science cannot be supported. The implications of this literature for the marketing–as–science debate are developed, and practical measures for the enhancement of scientific practice in marketing are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbbagnanoNicola (1967), “Positivism,”Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 6, EdwardsPaul, ed., New York: Macmillan.
2.
AldersonWroe, and CoxReavis (1948), “Towards a Theory of Marketing,”Journal of Marketing, 13 (October), 137–152.
3.
AndersonPaul F. (1982), “Marketing, Strategic Planning and the Theory of the Firm,”Journal of Marketing, 46 (Spring), 15–26.
4.
AngelmarReinhard, and PinsonChristian (1975), “The Meaning of Marketing,”Philosophy of Science, 42 (June), 208–13.
5.
BagozziRichard P. (1975), “Marketing as Exchange,”Journal of Marketing, 39 (October), 32–39.
6.
BarnesBarry (1977), Interests and the Growth of Knowledge, London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
7.
BarnesBarry (1979), “Vicissitudes of Belief,”Social Studies of Science, 9, 247–63.
8.
BarnesBarry, and MacKenzieDonald (1979), “On the Role of Interests in Scientific Change,” in On The Margins of Science: The Social Construction of Rejected Knowledge, WallisR., ed., Keele, U.K.: University of Keele, 49–66.
9.
BarnesBarry, and ShapinSteven (1979), Natural Order, Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
10.
BartelsRobert (1951), “Can Marketing Be a Science?,”Journal of Marketing, 15 (January), 319–28.
11.
BaumolW. J. (1957), “On the Role of Marketing Theory,”Journal of Marketing, 21 (April), 413–18.
12.
BeckerGary (1971), Economic Theory, New York: Knopf.
13.
Ben-DavidJ. (1971), The Scientist's Role in Society, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
14.
BhaskarRoy (1979), The Possibility of Naturalism, Brighton, U.K.: The Harvester Press.
15.
BlackMax (1967), “Induction,”Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 4, EdwardsPaul, ed., New York: Macmillan.
16.
BloorDavid (1976), Knowledge and Social Imagery, London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
17.
BourdieuPierre (1975), “The Specificity of the Scientific Field and the Social Conditions of the Progress of Reason,”Social Science Information, 14, 19–47.
18.
BranchBen (1978), “The Impact of Operating Decisions on ROI Dynamics,”Financial Management, 7 (Winter), 54–60.
19.
BronfenbrennerMartin (1971), “The ‘Structure of Revolutions’ in Economic Thought,”History of Political Economy, 3 (Spring), 136–151.
20.
BrownHarold I. (1977), Perception, Theory and Commitment, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
21.
BuzzellRobert D. (1963), “Is Marketing a Science?,”Harvard Business Review, 41 (January-February), 32–170.
22.
BuzzellRobert D., GaleBradley T., and SultanRalph G. M. (1975), “Market Share: A Key to Profitability,”Harvard Business Review, 53 (January-February), 97–106.
23.
CalderBobby J., PhillipsLynn W., and TyboutAlice M. (1981), “Designing Research for Applications,”Journal of Consumer Research, 8 (September), 197–207.
24.
CarnapRudoph (1936), “Testability and Meaning,”Philosophy of Science, 3, 419–71.
25.
CarnapRudoph (1937), “Testability and Meaning,”Philosophy of Science, 4, 1–40.
26.
CarnapRudoph (1953), “Testability and Meaning,” in Readings in the Philosophy of Science, FeigelHerbert, and BrodbeckMay, eds., New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts, 47–92.
27.
ChalmersA. F. (1976), What Is This Thing Called Science?, St. Lucia, Australia: University of Queensland Press.
28.
ClarkPeter (1976), “Atomism versus Thermodynamics,” in Method and Appraisal in the Physical Sciences, HowsonColin, ed., Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge University Press, 41–105.
29.
CollinsH. M. (1975), “The Seven Sexes: A Study in the Sociology of a Phenomenon, or the Replication of Experiments in Physics,”Sociology, 9, 205–24.
30.
CollinsH. M. (1981a), “Stages in the Empirical Program of Relativism,”Social Studies of Science, 11, 3–10.
31.
CollinsH. M. (1981b), “Son of Seven Sexes: The Social Destruction of a Physical Phenomenon,”Social Studies of Science, 11, 33–62.
32.
ConversePaul D. (1945), “The Development of a Science of Marketing,”Journal of Marketing, 10 (July), 14–23.
33.
CoxReavis, AldersonWroe, and ShapiroStanley J. (1964), Theory in Marketing, Homewood, IL: Irwin.
34.
CyertRichard M., and MarchJames G. (1963), A Behavioral Theory of the Firm, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
35.
DuhemPierre (1953), “Physical Theory and Experiment,” in Readings in the Philosophy of Science, FeiglHerbert, and BrodbeckMay, eds., New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts, 235–52.
36.
FeyerabendPaul (1970), “Consolations for the Specialist,” in Criticism and the Growth of Knowledge, LakatosImre, and MusgraveAlan, eds., Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge University Press, 197–230.
37.
FeyerabendPaul (1975), Against Method, Thetford, England: Lowe and Brydone.
38.
FeyerabendPaul (1978), “From Incompetent Professionalism to Professionalized Incompetence—The Rise of a New Breed of Intellectuals,”Philosophy of the Social Sciences, 8 (March), 37–53.
39.
FeyerabendPaul (1981), “More Clothes from the Emperor's Bargain Basement,”British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 32, 57–94.
40.
FineSeymour H. (1981), The Marketing of Ideas and Social Issues, New York: Praeger.
41.
FoxKaren F. A., and KotlerPhilip (1980), “The Marketing of Social Causes: The First 10 Years,”Journal of Marketing, 44 (Fall), 24–33.
42.
FrankelHenry (1979), “The Career of Continental Drift Theory,”Studies in History and Philosophy of Science, 10, 21–66.
43.
FranklinAllan (1979), “The Discovery and Nondiscovery of Parity Nonconservation,”Studies in History and Philosophy of Science, 10, 201–57.
44.
GornGerald J. (1982), “The Effects of Music in Advertising on Choice Behavior: A Classical Conditioning Approach,”Journal of Marketing, 46 (Winter), 94–101.
45.
GouldStephen (1977), Ever Since Darwin, New York: Norton.
46.
GouldStephen (1980), The Panda's Thumb, New York: Norton.
47.
GouldnerAlvin W. (1974), “Objectivity: The Realm of the ‘Sacred’ in Social Science,” in Values, Objectivity and the Social Sciences, RileyGresham, ed., Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley, 53–64.
48.
HalbertMichael (1965), The Meaning and Sources of Marketing Theory, New York: McGraw-Hill.
49.
HansonNorwood R. (1958), Patterns of Discovery, Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge University Press.
50.
HempelCarl G. (1965), Aspects of Scientific Explanation, New York: The Free Press.
51.
HowardJohn A., and ShethJagdish N. (1969), The Theory of Buyer Behavior, New York: Wiley.
52.
HumeDavid (1911), A Treatise of Human Nature, New York: Dutton.
53.
HuntShelby D. (1976a), “The Nature and Scope of Marketing,”Journal of Marketing, 40 (July), 17–28.
54.
HuntShelby D. (1976b), Marketing Theory, Columbus, OH: Grid.
55.
HuntShelby D. (1983), Marketing Theory, Homewood, IL: Irwin.
56.
HutchinsonKenneth D. (1952), “Marketing as a Science: An Appraisal,”Journal of Marketing, 16 (January), 286–93.
57.
JacobyJacob (1978), “Consumer Research: A State of the Art Review,”Journal of Marketing, 42 (April), 87–96.
58.
JonesW. T., SontagFrederick, BecknerMorton O., and FogelinRobert J. (1977), Approaches to Ethics, 3rd ed., New York: McGraw-Hill.
59.
KassarjianHarold H. (1978), “Anthropomorphism and Parsimony,” in Advances in Consumer Research, 5, HuntH. K., ed., Chicago: Association for Consumer Research, xiii–xiv.
60.
KeatRussell, and UrryJohn (1975), Social Theory as Science, London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
61.
KelleyEugene J. (1971), “Marketing's Changing Social/Environmental Role,”Journal of Marketing, 35 (July), 1–2.
62.
Knorr-CetinaKarin D. (1981), The Manufacture of Knowledge, Oxford, U.K.: Pergamon.
63.
Knorr-CetinaKarin D. (1983), “The Ethnographic Study of Scientific Work: Toward a Constructivist Interpretation of Science,” in Science Observed, Knorr-CetinaK. D., and MulkayM., eds., London: Sage, 115–40.
64.
KotlerPhilip (1972), “A Generic Concept of Marketing,”Journal of Marketing, 36 (April), 46–54.
65.
KotlerPhilip (1975), Marketing for Nonprofit Organizations, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
66.
KotlerPhilip (1979), “Strategies for Introducing Marketing into Nonprofit Organizations,”Journal of Marketing, 43 (January), 37–44.
67.
KotlerPhilip, and LevySidney J. (1969), “Broadening the Concept of Marketing,”Journal of Marketing, 33 (January), 10–15.
68.
KotlerPhilip, and ZaltmanGerald (1971), “Social Marketing: An Approach to Planned Social Change,”Journal of Marketing, 35 (July), 3–12.
69.
KuhnThomas S. (1957), The Copernican Revolution: Planetary Astronomy in the Development of Western Thought, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
70.
KuhnThomas S. (1962), The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
71.
KuhnThomas S. (1970), The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, 2nd ed., Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
72.
KuhnThomas S. (1977), The Essential Tension, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
73.
KuninLeonard, and Stirton WeaverF. (1971), “On the Structure of Scientific Revolutions in Economics,”History of Political Economy, 3 (Fall), 391–97.
74.
LakatosImre (1974), “Falsification and the Methodology of Scientific Research Programs,” in Criticism and The Growth of Knowledge, LakatosImre, and MusgraveAlan, eds., Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge University Press, 91–195.
75.
LatourBruno, and WoolgarSteve (1979), Laboratory Life, Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
76.
LaudanLarry (1977), Progress and Its Problems, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
77.
LaudanLarry (1980), “Views of Progress: Separating the Pilgrims from the Rakes,”Philosophy of the Social Sciences, 10, 273–86.
78.
LaudanLarry (1981), “The Pseudo-Science of Science?,”Philosophy of the Social Sciences, 11, 173–198.
79.
LaudanLarry (1982a), “The Demise of the Demarcation Problem,” paper presented at the Workshop on the Demarcation between Science and Pseudo-Science, Virginia Polytechnic, April 30–May 2.
80.
LaudanLarry (1982b), “More on Bloor,”Philosophy of the Social Sciences, 12, 71–74.
81.
LaudanLarry (1982c), “Science and Values,”, Center for the Study of Science in Society, Blacksburg, VA: Virginia Polytechnic, unpublished paper.
82.
LawJohn, and WilliamsR. J. (1982), “Putting Facts Together: A Study of Scientific Persuasion,”Social Studies of Science, 12, 535–58.
83.
LeahyThomas H. (1980), A History of Psychology, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
84.
LevySidney, and ZaltmanGerald (1975), Marketing, Society and Conflict, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
85.
LutzRichard J., and BettmanJames R. (1977), “Multiattribute Models in Marketing: A Bicentennial Review,” in Consumer and Industrial Buying Behavior, WoodsideArch G., ShethJagdish N., and BennettPeter D., eds., New York: North-Holland, 137–49.
86.
MachlupFritz (1967), “Theories of the Firm: Marginalist, Behavioral, Managerial,”American Economic Review, 57 (March), 1–33.
87.
MacKenzieDonald A., and BarnesBarry (1979), “Scientific Judgment: The Biometry-Mendelism Controversy,” in Natural Order, BarnesBarry, and ShapinSteven, eds., Beverly Hills, CA: Sage, 191–210.
88.
MadsenK. B. (1974), Modern Theories of Motivation, New York: Wiley.
89.
ManierEdward (1980), “Levels of Reflexivity: Unnoted Differences within the ‘Strong Programme’ in the Sociology of Knowledge,” in Proceedings of the 1980 Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association, AsquithP. D., and GiereR. N., eds., East Lansing, MI: Philosophy of Science Association, 197–207.
90.
MarkinRom J. (1969), The Psychology of Consumer Behavior, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
91.
MarkinRom J. (1974), Consumer Behavior, New York: Macmillan.
92.
MedawarP. B. (1979), Advice to a Young Scientist, New York: Harper.
93.
MertonRobert K. (1973), The Sociology of Science, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
94.
MillJohn Stuart (1959), A System of Logic, London: Longman, Green.
95.
MulkayMichael, and Nigel GilbertG. (1982), “What is the Ultimate Question? Some Remarks in Defense of the Analysis of Scientific Discourse,”Social Studies of Science, 12, 309–19.
96.
MusgraveAlan (1976), “Why Did Oxygen Supplant Phlogiston?,” in Method and Appraisal in the Physical Sciences, HowsonColin, ed., Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge University Press, 181–209.
97.
NordWalter R., and Paul PeterJ. (1980), “A Behavior Modification Perspective on Marketing,”Journal of Marketing, 44 (Spring), 36–47.
98.
OlsonJerry C. (1981), “Towards a Science of Consumer Behavior,” in Advances in Consumer Research, 9, MitchellAndrew, ed., Association for Consumer Research, v–x.
99.
O'ShaughnessyJohn, and RyanMichael J. (1979), “Marketing, Science, and Technology,” in Conceptual and Theoretical Developments in Marketing, FerrellO. C., BrownStephen W., and LambCharles W.Jr., eds., Chicago: American Marketing, 577–589.
100.
PapineauDavid (1978), For Science in the Social Sciences, London: Macmillan.
101.
PassmoreJohn (1967), “Logical Positivism,”Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 5, EdwardsPaul, ed., New York: Macmillan.
102.
PeterJ. Paul (1982), “Current Issues in the Philosophy of Science: Implications for Marketing Theory—A Panel Discussion,” in Marketing Theory: Philosophy of Science Perspectives, BushRonald F., and HuntShelby D., eds., Chicago: American Marketing, 11–16.
103.
PeterJ. Paul (1983), “Some Philosophical and Methodological Issues in Consumer Research,” in Marketing Theory, HuntS., Homewood, IL: Irwin, 382–94.
104.
PeterJ. Paul, and NordWalter R. (1982), “A Clarification and Extension of Operant Conditioning Principles in Marketing,”Journal of Marketing, 46 (Summer), 102–7.
105.
PeterJ. Paul, and OlsonJerry C. (1983), “Is Science Marketing?,”Journal of Marketing, 47 (Fall), 111–25.
106.
PickeringAndrew (1981), “The Hunting of the Quark,”Isis, 72 (June), 216–36.
107.
PlattJohn R. (1964), “Strong Inference,”Science, 46 (October), 347–53.
108.
PolanyiMichael (1958), Personal Knowledge, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
109.
PopperKarl (1962), Conjectures and Refutations, New York: Harper.
RavetzJerome R. (1971), Scientific Knowledge and its Social Problems, New York: Oxford University Press.
112.
ReaganCharles E. (1969), Ethics for Scientific Researchers, Springield, IL: Charles C. Thomas.
113.
RosenbergAlexander (1980), Sociobiology and the Preemption of Social Science, Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press.
114.
RothschildMichael L. (1981), An Incomplete Bibliography of Works Related to Marketing for Public Sector and Nonprofit Organizations, 3rd ed., Madison, WI: Graduate School of Business, University of Wisconsin.
115.
RothschildMichael, WilliamLand, GaidisC. (1981), “Behavioral Learning Theory: Its Relevance to Marketing and Promotions,”Journal of Marketing, 45 (Spring), 70–78.
116.
SavittRonald (1980), “Historical Research in Marketing,”Journal of Marketing, 44 (Fall), 52–58.
117.
SchoefflerSidney (1979), “SPI Seeks Science, Not Single ‘Oversimplistic’ Strategy Variable: Another Look at Market Share,”Marketing News, 13 (February) 4.
118.
ShapereDudley (1964), “The Structure of Scientific Revolutions,”Philosophical Review, 73, 383–94.
119.
ShapinSteven (1981), “The History of Science and Its Sociological Reconstructions,” working paper, Science Studies Unit, Edinburgh University.
120.
ShapiroBenson (1973), “Marketing for Nonprofit Organizations,”Harvard Business Review, 51 (September-October), 123–32.
121.
ShethJagdish N. (1967), “A Review of Buyer Behavior,”Management Science, 13 (August), B719–B756.
122.
ShethJagdish N. (1972), “The Future of Buyer Behavior,” in Proceedings of the Third Annual Conference, VenkatensanM., ed., Association for Consumer Research, 562–75.
123.
ShethJagdish N. (1979), “The Surpluses and Shortages in Consumer Behavior Theory and Research,”Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 7 (Fall), 414–27.
124.
TheoryBehavior, and WrightPeter L., eds. (1974), Marketing Analysis for Societal Problems, Urbana, IL: University of Illinois, Bureau of Economic and Business Research.
125.
SteinerRobert L. (1976), “The Prejudice Against Marketing,”Journal of Marketing, 40 (July), 2–9.
126.
SuppeFrederick (1974), The Structure of Scientific Theories, Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press.
127.
TaylorWeldon J. (1965), “Is Marketing a Science? Revisited,”Journal of Marketing, 29 (July), 49–53.
128.
ThomasDavid (1979), Naturalism and Social Science, Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge University Press.
129.
TruzziMarcello (1980), “A Skeptical Look at Paul Krutz's Analysis of the Scientific Status of Parapsychology,”Journal of Parapsychology, 44 (March), 35–55.
130.
TuckerW. T. (1974), “Future Directions in Marketing Theory,”Journal of Marketing, 38 (April), 30–35.
131.
VaileRoland S. (1949), “Towards a Theory of Marketing—Comment,”Journal of Marketing, 13 (April), 520–22.
132.
WilkieWilliam L., and PessemierEdgar A. (1973), “Issues in Marketing's Use of Multi-Attribute Attitude Models,”Journal of Marketing Research, 10 (November), 428–41.
133.
WinchPeter (1958), The Idea of a Social Science, London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
134.
WindYoram, and ThomasRober J. (1980), “Conceptual and Methodological Issues in Organizational Buying Behavior,”European Journal of Marketing, 14, 239–63.
135.
WoolgarSteve (1981), “Interests and Explanation in the Social Study of Science,”Social Studies of Science, 11, 365–94.
136.
WynneBrian (1976), “C. G. Barkla and the J Phenomenon: A Case Study in the Treatment of Deviance in Physics,”Social Studies of Science, 6, 307–47.
137.
ZaltmanGerald, PinsonChristian R. A., and AngelmarReinhard (1973), Metatheory and Consumer Research, New York: Holt.
138.
ZaltmanGerald, LeMastersKaren, and HeffringMichael (1982), Theory Construction in Marketing: Some Thoughts on Thinking, New York: Wiley.
