This study empirically investigates whether and to what extent suppliers’ decisions to start selling directly to end consumers provoke reactions in the ordering strategy of downstream channel partners, such as independent multibrand retailers. Using a multimethod approach that combines transactional data, survey data, and a scenario-based experiment, the authors demonstrate that retailers tend to exit these relationships after a direct channel introduction, as exhibited by their strategic decisions to order fewer distinct stockkeeping units (SKUs), accompanied by higher wholesale prices per unit. On average, retailers decrease the number of distinct SKUs ordered by 15 (or 18.75%) and pay a higher average wholesale price by €.79 (or 20.84%). Yet the responses also differ across retailers, reflecting moderating impacts of retailer power, expertise, and relationship quality. Retailer power emerges as a robust moderating factor, with more powerful retailers indicating a lower propensity to exit the relationship. Expertise and relationship quality have more nuanced influences on retailers’ ordering strategies. The multimethod approach serves to reveal the underlying mechanisms of these moderating effects, such that both rational (coercive power and switching costs) and emotional (conflict and confidence) considerations are in play.
AilawadiKusum L. (2021), “Commentary: Omnichannel from a Manufacturer’s Perspective,” Journal of Marketing, 85 (1), 121–25.
2.
AilawadiKusum L.FarrisPaul W. (2020), Getting Multi-Channel Distribution Right. John Wiley & Sons.
3.
AilawadiKusum L.ZhangJieKrishnaAradhnaKrugerMichael W. (2010), “When Wal-Mart Enters: How Incumbent Retailers React and how This Affects Their Sales Outcomes,” Journal of Marketing Research, 47 (4), 577–93.
4.
AndersonErinWeitzBarton (1992), “The Use of Pledges to Build and Sustain Commitment in Distribution Channels,” Journal of Marketing Research, 29 (1), 18–34.
5.
AndersonJames C.NarusJames A. (1990), “A Model of Distributor Firm and Manufacturer Firm Working Partnerships,” Journal of Marketing, 54 (1), 42–58.
6.
AryaAnilMittendorfBrianSappingtonDavid E.M. (2007), “The Bright Side of Supplier Encroachment,” Marketing Science, 26 (5), 651–59.
7.
BarneyJay (1991), “Firm Resources and Sustained Competitive Advantage,” Journal of Management, 17 (1), 99–121.
8.
BrownJames R.LuschRobert F.NicholsonCarolyn Y. (1995), “Power and Relationship Commitment: Their Impact on Marketing Channel Member Performance,” Journal of Retailing, 71 (4), 363–92.
9.
CaiGangshu George (2010), “Channel Selection and Coordination in Dual-Channel Supply Chains,” Journal of Retailing, 86 (1), 22–36.
10.
CaiGangshu GeorgeZhangZhe GeorgeZhangMichael (2009), “Game Theoretical Perspectives on Dual-Channel Supply Chain Competition with Price Discounts and Pricing Schemes,” International Journal of Production Economics, 117 (1), 80–96.
11.
CattaniKyleGillandWendellHeeseHans SebastianSwaminathanJayashankar (2006), “Boiling Frogs: Pricing Strategies for a Manufacturer Adding a Direct Channel That Competes with the Traditional Channel,” Production and Operations Management, 15 (1), 40–56.
12.
ChangKuo-HsiungGotcherDonald F. (2010), “Conflict-Coordination Learning in Marketing Channel Relationships: The Distributor View,” Industrial Marketing Management, 39 (2), 287–97.
13.
ChiangWei-yu KevinChhajedDilipHessJames D. (2003), “Direct Marketing, Indirect Profits: A Strategic Analysis of Dual-Channel Supply-Chain Design,” Management Science, 49 (1), 1–20.
14.
ChurchillGilbert A.,Jr. (1979), “A Paradigm for Developing Better Measures of Marketing Constructs,” Journal of Marketing Research, 16 (1), 64–73.
15.
CleerenKathleenVan HeerdeHarald J.DekimpeMarnik G. (2013), “Rising from the Ashes: How Brands and Categories Can Overcome Product-Harm Crises,” Journal of Marketing, 77 (2), 1–54.
16.
CookKaren S.EmersonRichard M. (1978), “Power, Equity and Commitment in Exchange Networks,” American Sociological Review, 43 (5), 721–39.
17.
CroninJoseph J.MorrisMichael H. (1989), “Satisfying Customer Expectations: The Effect on Conflict and Repurchase Intentions in Industrial Marketing Channels,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 17 (1), 41–49.
18.
CrosbyLawrence A.EvansKenneth R.CowlesDeborah (1990), “Relationship Quality in Services Selling: An Interpersonal Influence Perspective,” Journal of Marketing, 54 (3), 68–81.
19.
DeleersnyderBarbaraGeyskensIngeGielensKatrijnDekimpeMarnik G. (2002), “How Cannibalistic is the Internet Channel? A Study of the Newspaper Industry in the United Kingdom and the Netherlands,” International Journal of Research in Marketing, 19 (4), 337–48.
20.
De WulfKristofOdekerken-SchröderGaby J. (2001), “A Critical Review of Theories Underlying Relationship Marketing in the Context of Explaining Consumer Relationships,” Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour, 31 (1), 73–101.
21.
DharSanjay K.HochStephen J. (1997), “Why Store Brand Penetration Varies by Retailer,” Marketing Science, 16 (3), 208–27.
22.
DraganskaMichaelaKlapperDaniel (2007), “Retail Environment and Manufacturer Competitive Intensity,” Journal of Retailing, 83 (2), 183–98.
23.
DukesAnthony J.GeylaniTansevSrinivasanKannan (2009), “Strategic Assortment Reduction by a Dominant Retailer,” Marketing Science, 28 (2), 309–19.
24.
DumrongsiriAussadavutFanMingJainApurvaMoinzadehKamran (2008), “A Supply Chain Model with Direct and Retail Channels,” European Journal of Operational Research, 187 (3), 691–718.
EshghiKamranRaySourav (2021), “Conflict and Performance in Channels: A Meta-Analysis,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 49 (2), 327–49.
27.
EslamiHadiKackerManishHibbardJonathan D. (2019), “Antecedents of Locus of Causality Attributions for Destructive Acts in Distribution Channels,” Journal of Business Research, 107 (c), 302–14.
28.
FrazierGary L. (1999), “Organizing and Managing Channels of Distribution,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 27 (2), 226–40.
29.
FrazierGary L.LassarWalfried M. (1996), “Determinants of Distribution Intensity,” Journal of Marketing, 60 (4), 39–51.
30.
GanesanShankar (1994), “Determinants of Long-Term Orientation in Buyer-Seller Relationships,” Journal of Marketing, 58 (2), 1–19.
31.
GeyskensIngeSteenkampJan-Benedict E.M. (2000), “Economic and Social Satisfaction: Measurement and Relevance to Marketing Channel Relationships,” Journal of Retailing, 76 (1), 11–32.
32.
GeyskensIngeSteenkampJan-Benedict E.M.ScheerLisa K.KumarNirmalya (1996), “The Effects of Trust and Interdependence on Relationship Commitment: A Trans-Atlantic Study,” International Journal of Research in Marketing, 13 (4), 303–17.
33.
GielensKatrijnSteenkampJan-Benedict E.M. (2019), “Branding in the Era of Digital (Dis)Intermediation,” International Journal of Research in Marketing, 36 (3), 367–84.
34.
GielensKatrijnVan de GuchtLinda M.SteenkampJan-Benedict E.M.DekimpeMarnik G. (2008), “Dancing with a Giant: The Effect of Wal-Mart’s Entry into the U.K. on the Performance of European Retailers,” Journal of Marketing Research, 45 (5), 519–34.
35.
GrégoireYanyFisherRobert J. (2006), “The Effects of Relationship Quality on Customer Retaliation,” Marketing Letters, 17 (1), 31–46.
36.
HairJoseph F.CelsiMary WolfinbargerOrtinauDavid J.BushRobert P. (2017), Essentials of Marketing Research. McGraw-Hill.
37.
HibbardJonathan D.KumarNirmalyaSternLouis W. (2001), “Examining the Impact of Destructive Acts in Marketing Channel Relationships,” Journal of Marketing Research, 38 (1), 45–61.
38.
HirschmanAlbert O. (1970), Exit, Voice, and Loyalty: Responses to Decline in Firms, Organizations, and States. Harvard University Press.
39.
HoDaniel E.ImaiKosukeKingGaryStuartElizabeth A. (2007), “Matching as Nonparametric Preprocessing for Reducing Model Dependence in Parametric Causal Inference,” Political Analysis, 15 (3), 199–236.
40.
HotkarParshuramGilbertStephen M. (2021), “Supplier Encroachment in a Nonexclusive Reselling Channel,” Management Science, 67 (9), 5821–37.
41.
HuaGuoweiWangShouyangEdwin ChengT.C. (2010), “Price and Lead Time Decisions in Dual-Channel Supply Chains,” European Journal of Operational Research, 205 (1), 113–26.
42.
KumarNandaRuanRanran (2006), “On Manufacturers Complementing the Traditional Retail Channel with a Direct Online Channel,” Quantitative Marketing and Economics, 4 (3), 289–323.
43.
KumarNirmalyaScheerLisa K.SteenkampJan-Benedict E.M. (1995), “The Effects of Perceived Interdependence on Dealer Attitudes,” Journal of Marketing Research, 32 (3), 348–56.
44.
LeonidouLeonidas C.BarnesBradley R.TaliasMichael A. (2006), “Exporter-Importer Relationship Quality: The Inhibiting Role of Uncertainty, Distance, and Conflict,” Industrial Marketing Management, 35 (5), 576–88.
LimLeon GimTuliKapil R.DekimpeMarnik G. (2018), “Investors’ Evaluations of Price-Increase Preannouncements,” International Journal of Research in Marketing, 35 (3), 359–77.
47.
LodishLeonard M.AbrahamMagid M.LivelsbergerJeanneLubetkinBethRichardsonBruceStevensMary Ellen (1995), “A Summary of Fifty-Five In-Market Experimental Estimates of the Long-Term Effect of TV Advertising,” Marketing Science, 14 (3), G133–40.
48.
McShaneBlakeley B.BradlowEric T.LynchJohn G.Jr.MeyerRobert J. (2024), “‘Statistical Significance’ and Statistical Reporting: Moving Beyond Binary,” Journal of Marketing, 88 (3), 1–19.
49.
MorganRobert M.HuntShelby D. (1994), “The Commitment-Trust Theory of Relationship Marketing,” Journal of Marketing, 58 (3), 20–38.
50.
PalmatierRobert W.DantRajiv P.GrewalDhruvEvansKenneth R. (2006), “Factors Influencing the Effectiveness of Relationship Marketing: A Meta-Analysis,” Journal of Marketing, 70 (4), 136–53.
51.
PalmatierRobert W.SivadasEugeneSternLouis W.El-AnsaryAdel I. (2020), Marketing Channel Strategy: An Omni-Channel Approach. Routledge.
52.
PingRobert A.,Jr. (1993), “The Effects of Satisfaction and Structural Constraints on Retailer Exiting, Voice, Loyalty, Opportunism, and Neglect,” Journal of Retailing, 69 (3), 320–52.
53.
RodríguezBetzabéAydınGöker (2015), “Pricing and Assortment Decisions for a Manufacturer Selling Through Dual Channels,” European Journal of Operational Research, 242 (3), 901–09.
54.
SamahaStephen A.PalmatierRobert W.DantRajiv P. (2011), “Poisoning Relationships: Perceived Unfairness in Channels of Distribution,” Journal of Marketing, 75 (3), 99–117.
55.
Sa VinhasAlbertoAndersonErin (2005), “How Potential Conflict Drives Channel Structure: Concurrent (Direct and Indirect) Channels,” Journal of Marketing Research, 42 (4), 507–15.
56.
Sa VinhasAlbertoHeideJan B. (2015), “Forms of Competition and Outcomes in Dual Distribution Channels: The Distributor’s Perspective,” Marketing Science, 34 (1), 160–75.
57.
ShiHuanhuanSridharShrihariGrewalRajdeepLilienGary (2017), “Sales Representative Departures and Customer Reassignment Strategies in Business-to-Business Markets,” Journal of Marketing, 81 (2), 25–44.
58.
SkinnerSteven J.GassenheimerJule B.KelleyScott W. (1992), “Cooperation in Supplier-Dealer Relations,” Journal of Retailing, 68 (2), 174–93.
59.
SternLouis W.El-AnsaryAdel I. (1992), Marketing Channels. Prentice-Hall.
60.
TahirovNailGlockChristoph H. (2022), “Manufacturer Encroachment and Channel Conflicts: A Systematic Review of the Literature,” European Journal of Operational Research, 302 (2), 403–26.
61.
TsayAndy A.AgrawalNarendra (2004), “Channel Conflict and Coordination in the E-Commerce Age,” Production and Operations Management, 13 (1), 93–110.
62.
Van CrombruggeMichielBreugelmansElsBreinerFlorianScheinerChristian W. (2024), “Assessing the Multichannel Impact of Brand Store Entry by a Digital-Native Grocery Brand,” Journal of Marketing, 88 (3), 88–109.
63.
Van der MaelenSaraBreugelmansElsCleerenKathleen (2017), “The Clash of the Titans: On Retailer and Manufacturer Vulnerability in Conflict Delistings,” Journal of Marketing, 81 (1), 118–35.
64.
VidalDavid (2012), “Does Loyalty Make Customers Blind? The Impact of Relationship Quality on Channel Members’ Attributions and Behaviors Following Negative Critical Incidents,” Journal of Business-to-Business Marketing, 19 (2), 97–128.
65.
VidalDavid (2014), “Eye for an Eye,” European Journal of Marketing, 48 (1/2), 47–67.
66.
WeissAllen M.AndersonErin (1992), “Converting from Independent to Employee Salesforces: The Role of Perceived Switching Costs,” Journal of Marketing Research, 29 (1), 101–15.
67.
WuLei-YuChenPo-YuanChenKuan-Yang (2015), “Why Does Loyalty-Cooperation Behavior Vary Over Buyer-Seller Relationship?” Journal of Business Research, 68 (11), 2322–29.
68.
XiongYuYanWeiFernandesKiranXiongZhong-KaiGuoNian (2012), “‘Bricks vs. Clicks’: The Impact of Manufacturer Encroachment with a Dealer Leasing and Selling of Durable Goods,” European Journal of Operational Research, 217 (1), 75–83.
69.
XuHeLiuZhen ZhenZhangSheng Hao (2012), “A Strategic Analysis of Dual-Channel Supply Chain Design with Price and Delivery Lead Time Considerations,” International Journal of Production Economics, 139 (2), 654–63.
70.
YooWeon SangLeeEunkyu (2011), “Internet Channel Entry: A Strategic Analysis of Mixed Channel Structures,” Marketing Science, 30 (1), 29–41.
71.
ZhangJianxiongLiSaZhangShichenDaiRui (2019), “Manufacturer Encroachment with Quality Decision Under Asymmetric Demand Information,” European Journal of Operational Research, 273 (1), 217–36.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
