This research challenges the entrenched belief that financial vulnerability affects only low-income consumers. Instead, most consumers across the socioeconomic spectrum experience varying degrees of financial vulnerability at different points during their lives, whether sporadically or chronically; vulnerability is dynamic and heterogeneous. The authors propose a novel, theory-driven definition of consumer financial vulnerability (CFV) as the risk of incurring future harm, given the consumer's current access to various financial resources. A new conceptual framework decouples “vulnerability” from “harm” to distinguish the state of CFV, its determinants (access to various interdependent financial resources), and the constructs it foreshadows (multiple interconnected forms of realized harm). Five research propositions follow: (1) financial resource volatility plays a vital role in CFV, (2) recovering from harm requires more financial resources than preventing harm, (3) a multiperiod lens is needed to assess CFV accurately, (4) greater financial resource access can increase CFV, and (5) generalized financial literacy is not a panacea for mitigating CFV. The propositions and their implications for marketing strategy, public policy, and consumer well-being offer a rich research agenda. The authors propose a measure of CFV—the probability that financial resources are insufficient to meet or exceed a harm threshold—for future empirical investigations.
AbdallahChadi S.LastrapesWilliam D. (2012), “Home Equity Lending and Retail Spending: Evidence from a Natural Experiment in Texas,” American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics, 4 (4), 94–125.
2.
AdelinoManuelSchoarAntoinetteSeverinoFelipe (2016), “Loan Originations and Defaults in the Mortgage Crisis: The Role of the Middle Class,” Review of Financial Studies, 29 (7), 1635–70.
AmarMotyArielyDanAyalShaharCryderCynthia E.RickScott I. (2011), “Winning the Battle but Losing the War: The Psychology of Debt Management,” Journal of Marketing Research, 48 (Special Issue), S38–50.
5.
AndreasenAlan R. (1975), The Disadvantaged Consumer. The Free Press.
6.
AndreasenAlan R. (1993), “Revisiting the Disadvantaged: Old Lessons and New Problems,” Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 12 (2), 270–75.
7.
AngeletosGeorge-MariosLaibsonDavidRepettoAndreaTobacmanJeremyWeinbergStephen (2001), “The Hyperbolic Consumption Model: Calibration, Simulation, and Empirical Evaluation,” Journal of Economic Perspectives, 15 (3), 47–68.
8.
AnsariAsimMelaCarl F.NeslinScott A. (2008), “Customer Channel Migration,” Journal of Marketing Research, 45 (1), 60–76.
BakerStacey Menzel (2009), “Vulnerability and Resilience in Natural Disasters: A Marketing and Public Policy Perspective,” Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 28 (1), 114–23.
11.
BakerStacey M.HuntDavid M.RittenburgTerry L. (2007), “Consumer Vulnerability as a Shared Experience: Tornado Recovery Process in Wright, Wyoming,” Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 26 (1), 6–19.
12.
BaumgartnerH.BlanchardSimon J.SprottDavid (2022), “The Critical Role of Methodological Pluralism for Policy-Relevant Empirical Marketing Research,” Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 41 (3), 203–05.
13.
BenartziShlomoThalerRichard H. (2013), “Behavioral Economics and the Retirement Savings Crisis,” Science, 339 (6124), 1152–53.
14.
BernheimB. DouglasForniLorenzoGokhaleJagadeeshKotlikoffLaurence J. (2003), “The Mismatch Between Life Insurance Holdings and Financial Vulnerabilities: Evidence from the Health and Retirement Study,” American Economic Review, 93 (1), 354–65.
15.
BlanchardSimon J.TrudelRemi (2022), “Now Is Not the Time! (In)Effective Use of Present-Oriented Gain Frames to Interest Young Adults in Life Insurance,” working paper, Georgetown University.
16.
BolenJ. BrandonElliehausenGregoryMiller Jr.Thomas W. (2020), “Do Consumers Need More Protection from Small-Dollar Lenders? Historical Evidence and a Roadmap for Future Research,” Economic Inquiry, 58 (4), 1577–613.
17.
BoneSterling A.ChristensenGlen L.WilliamsJerome D. (2014), “Rejected, Shackled, and Alone: The Impact of Systemic Restricted Choice on Minority Consumers’ Construction of Self,” Journal of Consumer Research, 41 (2), 451–74.
BrownAlexander L.CamererColin F.ChuaZhikang Eric (2006), “Learning and Visceral Temptation in Dynamic Savings Experiments,” Working Paper No. 321307000000000048, Department of Economics, University of California, Los Angeles.
21.
BrownAlexander L.ChuaZhikang EricCamererColin F. (2009), “Learning and Visceral Temptation in Dynamic Saving Experiments,” Quarterly Journal of Economics, 124 (1), 197–231.
22.
BrownAlexander L.GrodzickiDanielMedinaPaolina C. (2022), “When Nudges Spill Over: Student Loan Use Under the CARD Act,” working paper, SSRN, https://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4129413.
23.
BrowningMartinCrossleyThomas F. (2001), “The Life-Cycle Model of Consumption and Saving,” Journal of Economic Perspectives, 15 (3), 3–22.
CaldieraroFabioZhangJonathan Z.CunhaMarcusJr.ShulmanJeffrey D. (2018), “Strategic Information Transmission in Peer-to-Peer Lending,” Journal of Marketing, 82 (2), 42–63.
26.
CalvoCesar (2018), “Vulnerability to Poverty: Theoretical Approaches,” in Handbook of Research on Economic and Social Well-Being, Conchita D’Ambrosio, ed. Edward Elgar, 272–83.
27.
CarlsonKurt A.WolfeJaredBlanchardSimon J.HuberJoel C.ArielyDan (2015), “The Budget Contraction Effect: How Contracting Budgets Lead to Less Varied Choice,” Journal of Marketing Research, 52 (3), 337–48.
28.
CarrollChristopher D. (1992), “The Buffer-Stock Theory of Saving: Some Macroeconomic Evidence,” Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 1992 (2), 61–156.
29.
CarrollChristopher D. (1997), “Buffer-Stock Saving and the Life Cycle/Permanent Income Hypothesis,” Quarterly Journal of Economics, 112 (1), 1–55.
30.
CarrollChristopher D.OverlandJodyWeilDavid N. (2000), “Saving and Growth with Habit Formation,” American Economic Review, 90 (3), 341–55.
ChanKimmy WaYimChi Kin (Bennett)LamSimon S.K. (2010), “Is Customer Participation in Value Creation a Double-Edged Sword? Evidence from Professional Financial Services Across Cultures,” Journal of Marketing, 74 (3), 48–64.
33.
Charron-ChenierRaphael (2020), “Predatory Inclusion in Consumer Credit: Explaining Black and White Disparities in Payday Loan Use,” Sociological Forum, 35 (2), 370–92.
34.
De BartolomeCharles A. (1995), “Which Tax Rate Do People Use: Average or Marginal?” Journal of Public Economics, 56 (1), 79–96.
35.
DeightonKatie (2022), “White House Presents Plan to Fix Federal Customer Experience,” The Wall Street Journal (April 19), https://www.wsj.com/articles/white-house-presents-plan-to-fix-federal-customer-experience-11650362400.
36.
DellaertBenedict G.C.JohnsonEric J.DuncanShannonBakerTom (2022), “Choice Architecture for Healthier Insurance Decisions: Ordering and Partitioning Together Can Improve Consumer Choice,” Journal of Marketing(published online July 27), https://doi.org/10.1177/00222429221119086.
37.
DingLeiHwangJackelyn (2016), “The Consequences of Gentrification: A Focus on Residents’ Financial Health in Philadelphia,” Cityscape, 18 (3), 27–56.
38.
DuRex Y.KamakuraWagner A. (2008), “Where Did All That Money Go? Understanding How Consumers Allocate Their Consumption Budget,” Journal of Marketing, 72 (4), 109–31.
39.
EchevinDamien (2013), “Measuring Vulnerability to Asset-Poverty in Sub-Saharan Africa,” World Development, 46, 211–22.
40.
FarrellDianaGreigFiona (2016), “Paychecks, Paydays, and the Online Platform Economy,” Proceedings. Annual Conference on Taxation and Minutes of the Annual Meeting of the National Tax Association, 109, 1–40.
41.
Federal Reserve Board (2018), Report on the Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households in 2017. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System.
42.
FernandesDanielLynchJohn G.Jr.NetemeyerRichard G. (2014), “Financial Literacy, Financial Education, and Downstream Financial Behaviors,” Management Science, 60 (8), 1861–83.
43.
FlanneryMarkSamolykKatherine (2005), “Payday Lending: Do the Costs Justify the Price?” Working Paper No. 2005-09, FDIC Center for Financial Research.
44.
FramEugene H.McCarthyMichael S. (1999), “The True Price of Penalties,” Marketing Management, 8 (3), 48–56.
45.
FulfordScott L. (2015), “How Important Is Variability in Consumer Credit Limits?” Journal of Monetary Economics, 72, 42–63.
46.
GarbinskyEmily N.MeadNicole L.GreggDaniel (2021), “Popping the Positive Illusion of Financial Responsibility Can Increase Personal Savings: Applications in Emerging and Western Markets,” Journal of Marketing, 85 (3), 97–112.
47.
GardnerDavid M. (1975), “Deception in Advertising: A Conceptual Approach,” Journal of Marketing, 39 (1), 40–46.
Gutiérrez-NietoBegoñaSerrano-CincaCarlosCamón-CalaJuan (2016), “A Credit Score System for Socially Responsible Lending,” Journal of Business Ethics, 133, 691–701.
50.
HamiltonRebecca M.ThompsonDeboraBoneSterlingChaplinLan NguyenGriskeviciusVladasGoldsmithKellyHillRonaldRoedder JohnDeborahMittalChiraagO’GuinnThomasPiffPaulRouxCarolineShahAnujZhuMeng (2019), “The Effects of Scarcity on Consumer Decision Journeys,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 47 (3), 532–50.
51.
HawsKelly L.BeardenWilliam O.NenkovGergana Y. (2012), “Consumer Spending Self-Control Effectiveness and Outcome Elaboration Prompts,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 40 (5), 695–710.
HillRonald PaulStameyMark (1990), “The Homeless in America: An Examination of Possessions and Consumption Behaviors,” Journal of Consumer Research, 17 (3), 303–21.
54.
HimmelsteinDavid U.LawlessRobert M.ThorneDeborahFooheyPamelaWoolhandlerSteffie (2019), “Medical Bankruptcy: Still Common Despite the Affordable Care Act,” American Journal of Public Health, 109, 431–33.
55.
KettleKeri L.TrudelRemiBlanchardSimon J.HäublGerald (2016), “Repayment Concentration and Consumer Motivation to Get Out of Debt,” Journal of Consumer Research, 43 (3), 460–77.
LakeRebecca (2021), “Will Gifts from Grandparents Hurt Financial Aid?” The Balance (November 11), https://www.thebalance.com/will-gifts-from-grandparents-hurt-financial-aid-4783269.
58.
LeeflangPeter S.H.van RaaijW.F. (1993), “The Changing Consumer in the Netherlands: Recent Changes in Environmental Variables and Their Consequences for Future Consumption and Marketing,” International Journal of Research in Marketing, 10 (4), 345–63.
59.
LiuXiaoMontgomeryAlanSrinivasanKannan (2018), “Analyzing Bank Overdraft Fees With Big Data,” Marketing Science, 37 (6), 855–82.
60.
LusardiAnnamariaHaslerAndreaYakoboskiPaul J. (2021), “Building Up Financial Literacy and Financial Resilience,” Mind & Society, 20 (2), 181–87.
61.
LusardiAnnamariaSchneiderDaniel J.TufanoPeter (2011), “Financially Fragile Households: Evidence and Implications,” Working Paper No. 17072, National Bureau of Economic Research, https://www.nber.org/papers/w17072.
62.
MalmendierUlrike (2021), “Exposure, Experience, and Expertise: Why Personal Histories Matter in Economics,” Working Paper 29336, National Bureau of Economic Research, https://www.nber.org/papers/w29336.
63.
MartinKelly D.HillRonald Paul (2012), “Life Satisfaction, Self-Determination, and Consumption Adequacy at the Bottom of the Pyramid,” Journal of Consumer Research, 38 (6), 1155–68.
64.
MendeMartinSalisburyLinda CourtNenkovGergana Y.ScottMaura L. (2020), “Improving Financial Inclusion Through Communal Financial Orientation: How Financial Service Providers Can Better Engage Consumers in Banking Deserts,” Journal of Consumer Psychology, 30 (2), 379–91.
MillerSarah (2012), “The Impact of the Massachusetts Health Care Reform on Health Care Use Among Children,” American Economic Review, 102 (3), 502–07.
67.
MillsGregoryVerickerTracyLippoldKyeWheatonLauraElkinSam (2014), Understanding the Rates, Causes, and Costs of Churning in the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP). Urban Institute.
68.
MoschisGeorge P. (1994), “Consumer Behavior in Later Life: Multidisciplinary Contributions and Implications for Research,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 22 (3), 195–204.
69.
MrkvaKellenPosnerNathaniel A.ReeckCrystalJohnsonEric J. (2021), “Do Nudges Reduce Disparities? Choice Architecture Compensates for Low Consumer Knowledge,” Journal of Marketing, 85 (4), 67–84.
OrhunA. YeşimPalazzoloMike (2019), “Frugality Is Hard to Afford,” Journal of Marketing Research, 56 (1), 1–17.
72.
RappJustine F.HillRonald Paul (2018), “Poverty Research and Measurement: Making the Case for Consumption Adequacy,” Journal of Consumer Affairs, 52 (3), 770–91.
73.
RindfleischAricBurroughsJames E.DentonFrank (1997), “Family Structure, Materialism, and Compulsive Consumption,” Journal of Consumer Research, 23 (4), 312–25.
74.
RohdeNicholasTangKam Ki (2018), “Economic Insecurity: Theoretical Approaches,” in Handbook of Research on Economic and Social Well-Being, Conchita D’Ambrosio, ed. Edward Elgar, 300–315.
75.
RupertTimothy J.WrightArnold M. (1998), “The Use of Marginal Tax Rates in Decision Making: The Impact of Tax Rate Visibility,” Journal of the American Taxation Association, 20 (2), 83–99.
76.
RustRoland T.LemonKatherine N.ZeithamlValarie A. (2004), “Return on Marketing: Using Customer Equity to Focus Marketing Strategy,” Journal of Marketing, 68 (1), 109–27.
77.
SaatçioğluBigeOzanneJulie L. (2013), “Moral Habitus and Status Negotiation in a Marginalized Working-Class Neighborhood,” Journal of Consumer Research, 40 (4), 692–710.
78.
SawyerNoahTemkinKenneth (2004), Analysis of Alternative Financial Service Providers. Fannie Mae Foundation and the Urban Institute.
79.
SextonDonald (1971), “Comparing the Cost of Food to Blacks and Whites: A Survey,” Journal of Marketing, 35 (3), 40–6.
SomanDilipCheemaAmar (2002), “The Effect of Credit on Spending Decisions: The Role of the Credit Limit and Credibility,” Marketing Science, 21 (1), 32–53.
82.
SpillerStephen A. (2011), “Opportunity Cost Consideration,” Journal of Consumer Research, 38 (4), 595–610.
83.
StegmanMichael A.FarisRobert (2003), “Payday Lending: A Business Model That Encourages Chronic Borrowing,” Economic Development Quarterly, 17 (1), 8–32.
84.
SussmanAbigail B.O’BrienRourke L. (2016), “Knowing When to Spend: Unintended Financial Consequences of Earmarking to Encourage Savings,” Journal of Marketing Research, 53 (5), 790–803.
85.
TarasiCrina O.BoltonRuth N.HuttMichael D.WalkerBeth A. (2011), “Balancing Risk and Return in a Customer Portfolio,” Journal of Marketing, 75 (3), 1–17.
86.
ThalerRichard H.SunsteinCass R. (2008), Nudge: Improving Decisions About Health, Wealth, and Happiness. Yale University Press.
Van RooijMaartenLusardiAnnamariaAlessieRob (2011), “Financial Literacy and Stock Market Participation,” Journal of Financial Economics, 101 (2), 449–72.
89.
ViswanathanMadhuRosaJosé AntonioRuthJulie A. (2010), “Exchanges in Marketing Systems: The Case of Subsistence Consumer-Merchants in Chennai, India,” Journal of Marketing, 74 (3), 1–17.
90.
WardAdrian F.LynchJohn G.Jr. (2019), “On a Need-to-Know Basis: How the Distribution of Responsibility Between Couples Shapes Financial Literacy and Financial Outcomes,” Journal of Consumer Research, 45 (5), 1013–36.
91.
WestColinWhillansAshley V.DeVoeSanford (2020), “Income Volatility Increases Financial Impatience,” Working Paper 21-053, Harvard Business School.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
