The authors draw on emerging research in organization theory to suggest how different firm-level identity orientations (individualistic, relational, or collectivistic) impact governance choice. They develop a conceptual framework that focuses on the relationship between a focal firm’s own identity orientation and that of a value chain partner. The framework identifies a series of match and mismatch scenarios, where the latter represent unique governance problems that are not accounted for by existing theory. Some of the mismatch scenarios involve pseudo-matches that resemble convergent orientations between parties but actually represent governance problems. Theoretically, this framework advances the governance literature by providing a comprehensive and nuanced account of (1) the orientations that parties bring to bear on a relationship, and (2) how their effects vary depending on the interdependence structure between the parties. The authors also advance the general literature on identity orientation by connecting it to concrete governance practices, by showing how multiple internal identity orientations create unique internal governance challenges, and by delineating two possible solutions to these challenges. They rely on the framework to develop managerial guidelines for governance choice.
AhearneMichaelBhattacharyaChitrabhan B.GruenThomas (2005), “Antecedents and Consequences of Customer-Company Identification: Expanding the Role of Relationship Marketing,” Journal of Applied Psychology, 90 (3), 574–85.
2.
AlbertStuart (1998), “Metadefinition of Identity,” in Identity in Organizations: Building Theory Through Conversations, WhettenD.A.GodfreyP.C., eds. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications, 1–13.
3.
AlbertStuartWhettenDavid A. (1985), “Organizational Identity,” Research in Organizational Behavior, 7, 263–95.
4.
AlvessonMatsAshcraftKaren L.ThomasRobyn (2008), “Identity Matters: Reflections on the Construction of Identity Scholarship in Organization Studies,” Organization, 15 (1), 5–28.
5.
ArgyresNicholasMayerKyle J. (2007), “Contract Design as a Firm Capability: An Integration of Learning and Transaction Cost Perspectives,” Academy of Management Review, 32 (4), 1060–77.
6.
AshforthBlake E.MaelFred A. (1996), “Organizational Identity and Strategy as a Context for the Individual,” Advances in Strategic Management, 13, 19–64.
7.
BacharachMichael (2006), Beyond Individual Choice: Teams and Frames in Game Theory. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
BellSimon J.TraceyPaulHeideJan B. (2009), “The Organization of Regional Clusters,” Academy of Management Review, 34 (4), 623–42.
10.
BeyerJanice M.TriceHarrison M. (1987), “How an Organization’s Rites Reveal Its Culture,” Organizational Dynamics, 15 (4), 5–24.
11.
BhattacharyaChitrabhan B.RaoHayagreevaGlynnMary Ann (1995), “Understanding the Bond of Identification: An Investigation of Its Correlates Among Art Museum Members,” Journal of Marketing, 59 (4), 46–57.
12.
BhattacharyaChitrabhan B.SenSankar (2003), “Consumer-Company Identification: A Framework for Understanding Consumers’ Relationships with Companies,” Journal of Marketing, 67 (2), 76–88.
13.
BonomaThomas V. (1976), “Conflict, Cooperation and Trust in Three Power Systems,” Behavioral Science, 21 (6), 499–514.
14.
BrewerMarilynn B.GardnerWendi (1996), “Who Is This ‘We’? Levels of Collective Identity and Self Representations,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 71 (1), 83–93.
15.
BricksonShelley L. (2000), “The Impact of Identity Orientation on Individual and Organizational Outcomes in Demographically Diverse Settings,” Academy of Management Review, 25 (1), 82–101.
16.
BricksonShelley L. (2005), “Organizational Identity Orientation: Forging a Link Between Organizational Identity and Organizations’ Relations with Stakeholders,” Administrative Science Quarterly, 50 (4), 576–609.
17.
BricksonShelley L. (2007), “Organizational Identity Orientation: The Genesis of the Role of the Firm and Distinct Forms of Social Value,” Academy of Management Review, 32 (3), 864–88.
18.
BricksonShelley L. (2008), “Re-Assessing the Standard: The Expansive Positive Potential of a Relational Identity in Diverse Organizations,” Journal of Positive Psychology, 3 (1), 40–54.
19.
BruscoSebastiano (1999), “The Rules of the Game in Industrial Districts,” in Interfirm Networks: Organization and Industrial Competitiveness, GrandoriA., ed. New York: Taylor & Francis, 17–40.
20.
CarsonStephen J.GhoshMrinal (2019), “An Integrated Power and Efficiency Model of Contractual Channel Governance: Theory and Empirical Evidence,” Journal of Marketing, 83 (4), 101–20.
21.
ChatmanJennifer A. (1991), “Matching People and Organizations: Selection and Socialization in Public Accounting Firms,” Administrative Science Quarterly, 36 (3), 459–84.
22.
Chmielewski-RaimondoDanielle A.ShamsollahiAliBellSimon J.HeideJan B. (2022), “When the Honeymoon Is Over: A Theory of Relationship Liabilities and Evolutionary Processes,” Journal of Marketing (published online February 15), https://doi.org/10.1177/00222429211062247.
23.
CorritoreMatthewGoldbergAmirSrivastavaSameer B. (2020), “The New Analytics of Culture,” Harvard Business Review, 98 (1), 76–83.
24.
DeshpandéRohitFarleyJohn U.WebsterFrederick E.Jr. (1993), “Corporate Culture, Customer Orientation, and Innovativeness in Japanese Firms: A Quadrad Analysis,” Journal of Marketing, 57 (1), 23–37.
DyerJeffrey H.SinghHarbir (1998), “The Relational View: Cooperative Strategy and Sources of Interorganizational Competitive Advantage,” Academy of Management Review, 23 (4), 660–79.
27.
DyerJeffrey H.SinghHarbirHesterlyWilliam S. (2018), “The Relational View Revisited: A Dynamic Perspective on Value Creation and Value Capture,” Strategic Management Journal, 39 (12), 3140–62.
28.
EllicksonRobert C. (1989), “A Hypothesis of Wealth-Maximizing Norms: Evidence from the Whaling Industry,” Journal of Law, Economics & Organization, 5 (1), 83–97.
29.
EllicksonRobert C. (1991), Order Without Law. Boston: Harvard University Press.
30.
EmersonRichard M. (1962), “Power-Dependence Relations,” American Sociological Review, 27 (1), 31–41.
31.
EstradaIsabelFaemsDriesCruzNatalia MartinSantanaPilar Perez (2016), “The Role of Interpartner Dissimilarities in Industry-University Alliances: Insights from a Comparative Case Study,” Research Policy, 45 (10), 2008–22.
32.
FauchartEmmanuelleGruberMarc (2011), “Darwinians, Communitarians, and Missionaries: The Role of Founder Identity in Entrepreneurship,” Academy of Management Journal, 54 (5), 935–57.
33.
FisherGregKothaSureshLahiriAmrita (2016), “Changing With the Times: An Integrated View of Identity, Legitimacy, and New Venture Life Cycles,” Academy of Management Review, 41 (3), 383–409.
34.
FishmanCharles (2006), “The Wal-Mart Effect and a Decent Society: Who Knew Shopping Was So Important?” Academy of Management Perspectives, 20 (3), 6–25.
35.
FlynnFrancis J.WiltermuthScott S. (2010), “Who’s With Me? False Consensus, Brokerage, and Ethical Decision Making in Organizations,” Academy of Management Journal, 53 (5), 1074–89.
36.
FreemanR. Edward (1984), Strategic Management: A Stakeholder Perspective. Boston: Pitman.
37.
GalUriJensenTina B.LyytinenKalle (2014), “Identity Orientation, Social Exchange, and Information Technology Use in Interorganizational Collaborations,” Organization Science, 25 (5), 1372–90.
GeyskensIngeSteenkampJan-Benedict E.M.KumarNirmalya (2006), “Make, Buy, or Ally: A Transaction Cost Theory Meta-Analysis,” Academy of Management Journal, 49 (3), 519–43.
40.
GhoshMrinalJohnGeorge (1999), “Governance Value Analysis and Marketing Strategy,” Journal of Marketing, 63 (4), 131–45.
41.
GibbonsRobertRobertsJohn (2013), “Economic Theories of Incentives in Organizations,” in The Handbook of Organizational Economics, GibbonsR.RobertsJ., eds. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 56–99.
42.
GioiaDennis A.PriceKristin N.HamiltonAimee L.ThomasJames B. (2010), “Forging an Identity: An Insider-Outsider Study of Processes Onvolved in the Formation of Organizational Identity,” Administrative Science Quarterly, 55 (1), 1–46.
43.
GiulianiElisa (2013), “Network Dynamics in Regional Clusters: Evidence from Chile,” Research Policy, 42 (8), 1406–19.
44.
Golden-BiddleKarenRaoHayagreeva (1997), “Breaches in the Boardroom: Organizational Identity and Conflicts of Commitment in a Nonprofit Organization,” Organization Science, 8 (6), 593–611.
45.
GranovetterMark (2005), “Business Groups and Social Organization,” in The Handbook of Economic Sociology, SmelserN.J.SwedbergR., eds. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 429–50.
46.
GrewalRajdeepChakravartyAninditaSainiAmit (2010), “Governance Mechanisms in Business-To-Business Electronic Markets,” Journal of Marketing, 74 (4), 45–62.
47.
HeideJan B. (1994), “Interorganizational Governance in Marketing Channels,” Journal of Marketing, 58 (1), 71–85.
48.
HeideJan B.JohnGeorge (1990), “Alliances in Industrial Purchasing: The Determinants of Joint Action in Buyer-Supplier Relationships,” Journal of Marketing Research, 27 (1), 24–36.
49.
HeideJan B.JohnGeorge (1992), “Do Norms Matter in Marketing Relationships?” Journal of Marketing, 56 (2), 32–44.
50.
HelperSusanLevineDavid I. (1992), “Long-Term Supplier Relations and Product-Market Structure,” Journal of Law, Economics, & Organization, 8 (3), 561–81.
51.
HeniszWitold J.WilliamsonOliver E. (1999), “Comparative Economic Organization—Within and Between Countries,” Business and Politics, 1 (3), 261–77.
52.
HernandezMorela (2012), “Toward an Understanding of the Psychology of Stewardship,” Academy of Management Review, 37 (2), 172–93.
53.
HustedBryan W.FolgerRobert (2004), “Fairness and Transaction Costs: The Contribution of Organizational Justice Theory to an Integrative Model of Economic Organization,” Organization Science, 15 (6), 719–29.
54.
JapSandy D. (1999), “Pie-Expansion Efforts: Collaboration Processes in Buyer–Supplier Relationships,” Journal of Marketing Research, 36 (4), 461–75.
55.
JapSandy D. (2015), Partnering With the Frenemy: A Framework for Managing Business Relationships, Minimizing Conflict, and Achieving Partnership Success. London: FT Press.
56.
JapSandy D.GanesanShankar (2000), “Control Mechanisms and the Relationship Life Cycle: Implications for Safeguarding Specific Investments and Developing Commitment,” Journal of Marketing Research, 37 (2), 227–45.
57.
JaworskiBernard J.KohliAjay K. (1993), “Market Orientation: Antecedents and Consequences,” Journal of Marketing, 57 (3), 53–70.
58.
KaplanRobert S.NortonDavid P. (1996), “Linking the Balanced Scorecard to Strategy,” California Management Review, 39 (1), 53–79.
59.
KashimaEmiko S.HardieElizabeth A. (2000), “The Development and Validation of the Relational, Individual, and Collective Self–Aspects (RIC) Scale,” Asian Journal of Social Psychology, 3 (1), 19–48.
60.
KohliAjay K.JaworskiBernard J. (1990), “Market Orientation: The Construct, Research Propositions, and Managerial Implications,” Journal of Marketing, 54 (2), 1–18.
61.
KreinerGlen E.HollensbeElaineSheepMathew L.SmithBrett R.KatariaNiyati (2015), “Elasticity and the Dialectic Tensions of Organizational Identity: How Can We Hold Together While We Are Pulling Apart?” Academy of Management Journal, 58 (4), 981–1011.
62.
KumarNirmalyaScheerLisa K.SteenkampJan-Benedict E.M. (1995), “The Effects of Perceived Interdependence on Dealer Attitudes,” Journal of Marketing Research, 32 (3), 348–56.
63.
LorenzenMarkFossNicolai J. (2002), “Cognitive Coordination, Institutions and Clusters: An Exploratory Discussion,” in Cooperation, Networks and Institutions in Regional Innovation Systems, BrennerT.FornahlD., eds. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar, 82–104.
64.
MarkusenAnn (1996), “Sticky Places in Slippery Space: A Typology of Industrial Districts,” Economic Geography, 73 (3), 293–313.
65.
MayerKyle J.ArgyresNicholas S. (2004), “Learning to Contract: Evidence From the Personal Computer Industry,” Organization Science, 15 (4), 394–410.
66.
McCallGeorge J.SimmonsJerry L. (1966), Identities and Interactions: An Examination of Human Associations in Everyday Life. New York: The Free Press.
67.
McMillanCharles (2018), “Organizational Identity, Corporate Strategy, and Habits of Attention: A Case Study of Toyota,” in Strategic Management: A Dynamic View, EmeagwaliO.L., ed. London: IntechOpen, 1–20.
68.
MooiErik A.GhoshMrinal (2010), “Contract Specificity and Its Performance Implications,” Journal of Marketing, 74 (2), 105–20.
69.
MoormanChristineDeshpandéRohitZaltmanGerald (1993), “Factors Affecting Trust in Market Research Relationships,” Journal of Marketing, 57 (1), 81–101.
70.
NagRajivCorleyKevin G.GioiaDennis A. (2007), “The Intersection of Organizational Identity, Knowledge, and Practice: Attempting Strategic Change Via Knowledge Grafting,” Academy of Management Journal, 50 (4), 821–47.
71.
NarverJohn C.SlaterStanley F. (1990), “The Effect of a Market Orientation on Business Profitability,” Journal of Marketing, 54 (4), 20–35.
NoordewierThomas G.JohnGeorgeNevinJohn R. (1990), “Performance Outcomes of Purchasing Arrangements in Industrial Buyer-Vendor Relationships,” Journal of Marketing, 54 (4), 80–93.
74.
Pallares-BarberaMontserratTullaAntoni F.VeraAna (2004), “Spatial Loyalty and Territorial Embeddedness in the Multi-Sector Clustering of the Berguedà Region in Catalonia (Spain),” Geoforum; Journal of Physical, Human, and Regional Geosciences, 35 (5), 635–49.
75.
PorterMichael E.KramerMark R. (2011), “Creating Shared Value,” Harvard Business Review, 89 (1/2), 62–77.
76.
PrattMichael G.CorleyKevin G. (2007), “Managing Multiple Organizational Identities: On Identity Ambiguity, Identity Conflict, and Members’ Reactions,” in Identity and the Modern Organization, BartelC.A.BladerS.WrzesniewskiA., eds. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 99–118.
77.
PrattMichael G.ForemanPeter O. (2000), “Classifying Managerial Responses to Multiple Organizational Identities,” Academy of Management Review, 25 (1), 18–42.
78.
ProvanKeith G.KenisPatrick (2008), “Modes of Network Governance: Structure, Management, and Effectiveness,” Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 18 (2), 229–52.
79.
RavasiDavidePhillipsNelson (2011), “Strategies of Alignment: Organizational Identity Management and Strategic Change at Bang & Olufsen,” Strategic Organization, 9 (2), 103–35.
80.
RavasiDavideSchultzMajken (2006), “Responding to Organizational Identity Threats: Exploring the Role of Organizational Culture,” Academy of Management Journal, 49 (3), 433–58.
81.
RindfleischAricAntiaKersiBercovitzJanetBrownJames R.CannonJosephCarsonStephen J., et al. (2010), “Transaction Costs, Opportunism, and Governance: Contextual Considerations and Future Research Opportunities,” Marketing Letters, 21 (3), 211–22.
82.
RindfleischAricHeideJan B. (1997), “Transaction Cost Analysis: Past, Present, and Future Applications,” Journal of Marketing, 61 (4), 30–54.
83.
RomanelliElaineKhessinaOlga M. (2005), “Regional Industrial Identity: Cluster Configurations and Economic Development,” Organization Science, 16 (4), 344–58.
84.
SantosFilipe M.EisenhardtKathleen M. (2005), “Organizational Boundaries and Theories of Organization,” Organization Science, 16 (5), 491–508.
85.
SaxenianAnnaLee (1994), Regional Advantage: Culture and Competition in Silicon Valley and Route 128. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
86.
ScheerLisa K.KumarNirmalyaSteenkampJan-Benedict E.M. (2003), “Reactions to Perceived Inequity in US and Dutch Interorganizational Relationships,” Academy of Management Journal, 46 (3), 303–16.
87.
SethiPrakash (2014), “The Wal-Mart Affair—Where Implausible Deniability is the Coin of the Realm,” Corporate Governance, 14 (3), 424–51.
StrykerSheldonSerpeRichard T. (1982), “Commitment, Identity Salience, and Role Behavior: Theory and Research Example,” in Personality, Roles, and Social Behavior, IckesW.KnowlesE.S., eds. New York: Springer, 199–218.
90.
TallmanStephenJenkinsMarkHenryNickPinchSteven (2004), “Knowledge, Clusters, and Competitive Advantage,” Academy of Management Review, 29 (2), 258–71.
91.
ThoitsPeggy A. (1983), “Multiple Identities and Psychological Well-Being: A Reformulation and Test of the Social Isolation Hypothesis,” American Sociological Review, 48 (2), 174–87.
92.
TraceyPaulHeideJan B.BellSimon J. (2014), “Bringing ‘Place’ Back In: Regional Clusters, Project Governance, and New Product Outcomes,” Journal of Marketing, 78 (6), 1–16.
93.
TriceHarrison M.BeyerJanice M. (1984), “Studying Organizational Cultures Through Rites and Ceremonials,” Academy of Management Review, 9 (4), 653–69.
94.
VisserEvert-JanBoschmaRon (2004), “Learning in Districts: Novelty and Lock-In in a Regional Context,” European Planning Studies, 12 (6), 793–808.
95.
WathneKenneth H.HeideJan B.MooiErik A.KumarAlok (2018), “Relationship Governance Dynamics: The Roles of Partner Selection Efforts and Mutual Investments,” Journal of Marketing Research, 55 (5), 704–21.
96.
WeberMax (1947), The Theory of Social and Economic Organization. New York: Oxford University Press.
97.
WeberLibbyMayerKyle (2014), “Transaction Cost Economics and the Cognitive Perspective: Investigating the Sources and Governance of Interpretive Uncertainty,” Academy of Management Review, 39 (3), 344–63.
98.
WeissAllen M.AndersonErin (1992), “Converting From Independent to Employee Salesforces: The Role of Perceived Switching Costs,” Journal of Marketing Research, 29 (1), 101–15.
99.
WhettenDavid A. (2006), “Albert and Whetten Revisited: Strengthening the Concept of Organizational Identity,” Journal of Management Inquiry, 15 (3), 219–34.
100.
WhettenDavid A.MackeyAlison (2002), “A Social Actor Conception of Organizational Identity and its Implications for the Study of Organizational Reputation,” Business & Society, 41 (4), 393–414.
101.
WilliamsonOliver E. (1975), Markets and Hierarchies: Analysis and Antitrust Implications. New York: The Free Press.
102.
WilliamsonOliver E. (2010), “Transaction Cost Economics: The Natural Progression,” American Economic Review, 100 (3), 673–90.
103.
WimmerEngelbertMuniArun (2011), Motoring the Future: VW and Toyota Vying for Pole Position. Basingstoke, UK: Palgrave Macmillan.
104.
WuytsStefanGeyskensInge (2005), “The Formation of Buyer-Supplier Relationships: Detailed Contract Drafting and Close Partner Selection,” Journal of Marketing, 69 (4), 103–17.
105.
ZajacEdward J.OlsenCyrus P. (1993), “From Transaction Cost to Transactional Value Analysis: Implications for the Study of Interorganizational Strategies,” Journal of Management Studies, 30 (1), 131–45.
