The aim of this study was to test the validity of Bakker's (1983, 1990) theory and treatment paradigm of dyslexia. Twenty-one children (mean age = 9.9 years) categorized as P-type dyslexics (showing accurate but slow and fragmented reading) and 19 children (mean age = 9.7 years) categorized as L-type dyslexics (fast but inaccurate readers) were presented with hemisphere-specific stimulation (HSS) and hemisphere-alluding stimulation (HAS). HSS was produced by presenting words to either the left or the right visual half-field, or to the left or right hand of the participant. HAS training was achieved through the presentation of either semantically /phonetically demanding or perceptually demanding text. Participants were given either a treatment program that was specifically designed for their particular dyslexia subtype, or a program that had been deliberately chosen to be inconsistent with their subtype. Contrary to predictions, participants made gains on all of the reading measures, regardless of the type of treatment given. On the basis of these findings it is suggested that treatment gains made are due to nonspecific training effects and not to the specific nature of Bakker's remedial strategies.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Bakker, D.J. (1983). Hemispheric specialization and specific reading retardation. In M. Rutter (Ed.), Developmental neuropsychiatry (pp. 498-506). New York: Guilford Press.
2.
Bakker, D.J. (1990). Neuropsychological treatment of dyslexia. New York: Oxford University Press.
3.
Bakker, D.J. (1992). Neuropsychological classification and treatment of dyslexia. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 25, 102-109.
4.
Bakker, D.J., Bouma, A., & Gardien, C.J. (1990). Hemisphere-specific treatment of dyslexia subtypes: A field experiment. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 23, 433-438.
5.
Bakker, D.J., & Licht, R. (1986). Learning to read: Changing horses in midstream . In G. T. Pavlidis & D. F. Fisher (Eds.), Dyslexia: Neuropsychology and treatment (pp. 87-95). London: Wiley.
6.
Bakker, D.J., Licht, R., & Van Strien, J. (1991). Biophysiological validation of L- and P-type dyslexia. In B. P. Rourke (Ed.), Neuropsychological validation of learning disability subtypes (pp. 124-139). New York: Guilford Press.
7.
Bakker, D.J., & Moerland, R. (1991). HEMSTIM user manual. Rijswijk , The Netherlands: Centrum Informatica voor Gehandicapten .
8.
Bakker, D.J., Moerland, R., & Goekoop-Hoefkens, M. (1981). Effects of hemisphere-specific stimulation on the reading performance of dyslexic boys: A pilot study. Journal of Clinical Neuropsychology, 3(2), 155-159.
9.
Bakker, D.J., & Vinke, J. (1985). Effects of hemisphere-specific stimulation on brain activity and reading in dyslexics. Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology, 7, 505-525.
10.
Boder, E., & Jarrico, S. (1982). The Boder test of reading-spelling patterns. Orlando, FL: Grune & Stratton
11.
Bouma, A., Bakker, D.J., & Gardien, C.J. (1988). Hemisphere-specific stimulation through tactile modality in dyslexics. Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology, 10, 323.
12.
Bradley, L., & Bryant, P. (1978). Difficulties in auditory organization as a possible cause of reading backwardness. Nature ( London), 2711, 746-747.
13.
Bradley, L., & Bryant, P. (1983). Categorizing sounds and learning to read: A causal connection. Nature (London), 301, 419-421.
14.
Bryden, M.P. (1988). Does laterality make any difference? Thoughts on the relation between cerebral asymmetry and reading. In D. L. Molfese & S. J. Segalowitz (Eds.), Brain lateralization in children: Developmental implications (pp. 509-525). New York: Guilford Press.
15.
Burt, C. (1921). Mental and scholastic tests. London: P. S. King & Sons
16.
Cronbach, L.J., & Snow, R.E. (1977). Aptitudes and instructional methods: A handbook for research on interactions. New York: Irvington.
17.
Ellis, A.W. (1985). The cognitive neuropsychology of developmental (and acquired) dyslexia: A critical survey. Cognitive Neuropsychology , 2, 169-205.
18.
Ellis, H.D., & Shepherd, J.W. (1974). Recognition of abstract and concrete words presented in left and right visual field. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 103, 1035-1036.
19.
Ferguson, G.A., & Takane, Y. (1989). Statistical analysis in psychology and education (6th ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill.
20.
Francis, W.N., & Kucera, H. (1982). Frequency analysis of English usage: Lexicon and grammar. Boston: Houghton Mifflin .
21.
Friendly, M., Franklin, P.E., Hoffman, D., & Rubin, D.C. (1982). The Toronto word pool: Norms for imagery, concreteness, orthographic variables, and grammatical usage for 1,080 words. Behavior Research Methods and Instrumentation, 14, 375-399.
22.
Gilhooly, K.J., & Logie, R.H. (1980). Age-of-acquisition, imagery, concreteness, familiarity, and ambiguity measures for 1,944 words. Behavior Research Methods and Instrumentation, 12, 395-427.
23.
Grace, G.M. (1990). Effects of hemisphere-specific stimulation on academic performance and event-related potentials in dyslexic children. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Victoria University, Victoria, Canada.
Hynd, G.W. (1992). Neurological aspects of dyslexia: Comment on the balance model. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 25, 110-112.
26.
Lambert, A.J. (1982a). Right hemisphere language ability: 1. Clinical evidence. Current Psychological Reviews, 2, 77-93.
27.
Lambert, A.J. (1982b). Right hemisphere language ability: 2. Evidence from normal subjects. Current Psychological Reviews, 2, 139-152.
28.
Lambert, A.J., & Beaumont, J.G. (1983). Imageability does not interact with visual field in lateral word recognition with oral report. Brain andLanguage, 20, 115-142.
29.
Larsen, J.P., Hoien, T., Lundberg, I., & Odegaard, H. (1990). MRI evaluation of the size and symmetry of the planum temporale in adolescents with developmental dyslexia. Brain and Language, 39, 289-301.
30.
Licht, R., Bakker, D.J., Kok, A., & Bouma, A. (1988). The development of lateral event-related potentials (ERPs) related to word naming: A four year longitudinal study. Neuropsychologia, 26, 327-340.
31.
Lindamood, C., & Lindamood, P. (1969). Auditory discrimination in depth. Boston: Teaching Resources.
32.
Lindamood, C., & Lindamood, P. (1979). Lindamood auditory conceptualization test (rev. ed.)Allen, TX: DLM.
33.
Masutto, C., Bravar, L., & Fabbro, F. (1994). Neurolinguistic differentiation of children with subtypes of dyslexia. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 27, 520-526.
34.
Mitchell, J.V., Jr. (1985). The ninth mental measurements yearbook . Lincoln, NE: The Buros Institute of Mental Measurements.
35.
Newby, R.F., & Reid Lyon, G. (1991). Neuropsychological subtypes of learning disabilities . In J. E. Obrzut & G. W. Hynd (Eds.), Neuropsychological foundations of learning disabilities: A handbook of issues, methods, and practice (pp. 355-385). San Diego: Academic Press.
36.
New Zealand Council for Educational Research ( 1981). The Burt word reading test: New Zealand revision. Wellington: Author.
37.
Paivio, A., Yuille, J.C., & Madigan, S.A. (1968). Concreteness, imagery, and meaningfulness values for 925 nouns. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 76, 1-25.
38.
Reid Lyon, G., & Risucci, D. (1989). Classification of learning disabilities. In K. A. Kavale (Ed.), Learning disabilities: State of the art and practice (pp. 44-70). Boston : College-Hill.
39.
Stanovich, K.E. (1988). Explaining the differences between the dyslexic and the garden-variety poor reader: The phonological-core variable-difference model. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 21, 590-604.
40.
Thomson, M.E. (1990). Developmental dyslexia: Studies in disorders of communication (3rd ed.). London : Whurr.
41.
Van Strien, J.W., Bakker, D.J., Bouma, A., & Koops, W. (1988). Familial antecedents of P- and L-type dyslexia . Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology, 10, 323.
42.
Van Strien, J.W., Bakker, D.J., Bouma, A., & Koops, W. (1989). Familial resemblance for cognitive abilities in families with P-type or L-type dyslexic children. Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology, 11, 359.
43.
Van Strien, J.W., Bakker, D.J., Bouma, A., & Koops, W. (1990). Familial resemblance for cognitive abilities in families with P-type dyslexic, L-type dyslexic, or normal reading boys. Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology, 12, 843-856.
44.
Van Strien, J.W., Stolk, B.D., & Zuiker, S. (1995). Hemisphere-specific treatment of dyslexia subtypes: Better reading with anxiety-laden words?Journal of Learning Disabilities, 28, 30-34.
45.
Wechsler, D. (1974). The Wechsler intelligence scale for children-Revised . San Antonio, TX: Psychological Corp.
Wise, B.W., & Olson, R.K. (1991). Remediating reading disabilities. In J. E. Obrzut & G. W. Hynd (Eds.), Neuropsychological foundations of learning disabilities: A handbook of issues, methods, and practice (pp. 631-658). San Diego: Academic Press.
