The purpose of this study was to determine whether children with dyslexia, that is, children whose reading levels were significantly lower than would be predicted by their IQ scores, constituted a distinctive group when compared with poor readers, that is, children whose reading scores were consistent with their IQ scores. The performance of children with dyslexia, poor readers, and normally achieving readers was compared on a variety of reading, spelling, phonological processing, language, and memory tasks. Although the children with dyslexia had significantly higher IQ scores than the poor readers, these two groups did not differ in their performance on reading, spelling, phonological processing, or most of the language and memory tasks. In all cases, the performance of both reading disabled groups was significantly below that of nondisabled readers. The findings were similar whether absolute difference or regression scores were used. Reading disabled children, whether or not their reading is significantly below the level predicted by their IQ scores, experience significant problems in phonological processing, short-term and working memory, and syntactic awareness. On the basis of these data, there does not seem to be a need to differentiate between individuals with dyslexia and poor readers. Both of these groups are reading disabled and have deficits in phonological processing, verbal memory, and syntactic awareness.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Baron, J. (1979). Orthographic and word-specific mechanisms in children's reading of words. Child Development, 50, 60–72.
Bloom, A., Wagner, M., Reskin, L., & Bergman, A. (1980). A comparison of intellectually delayed and primary reading disabled children on measures of intelligence and achievement. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 36, 788–790.
4.
Case, R., Kurland, D.M., & Goldberg, J. (1982). Operational efficiency of short-term memory span. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 33, 386–404.
5.
Daneman, M., & Carpenter, P.A. (1980). Individual differences in working memory and reading. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 19, 450–466.
6.
Das, J.P., Mensink, D., & Mishra, R.K. (1990). Cognitive processes separating good and poor readers when IQ is covaried. Learning and Individual Differences, 2, 423–436.
7.
Dunn, L. (1965). Peabody picture vocabulary test. Circle Pines, MN: American Guidance Service.
8.
Dunn, L.M., & Dunn, L.M. (1981). Peabody picture vocabulary test-Revised. Circle Pines, MN: American Guidance Service.
9.
Dunn, L.M., & Markwardt, F.C. (1979). Peabody individual achievement test. Circle Pines, MN: American Guidance Service.
10.
Ellis, N., & Large, B. (1987). The development of reading: As you seek so shall you find. British Journal of Psychology, 78, 1–28.
11.
Finucci, J.M., Isaacs, S.D., Whitehouse, C.C., & Childs, B. (1982). Empirical validation of reading and spelling quotients. Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology, 24, 733–744.
12.
Fischer, F.W., Liberman, I.Y., & Shankweiler, D. (1978). Reading reversals and developmental dyslexia: A further study. Cortex, 14, 496–510.
13.
Fletcher, J.M., Espy, K.A., Francis, P.J., Davidson, K.C., Rourke, B.P., & Shaywitz, S.E. (1989). Comparisons of cutoff and regression-based definitions of reading disabilities. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 22, 334–338.
14.
Francis, D.J., Espy, K.A., Rourke, B.A., & Fletcher, J.M. (1990). Validity of intelligence scores in the definition of learning disability: A critical analysis. In B.P. Rourke (Ed.), Neuropsychological validation of learning disability subtypes (pp. 15–44). New York: Guilford.
15.
Friedman, G., & Stevenson, J. (1988). Reading processes in specific reading retarded and reading backward 13 year olds. British Journal of Developmental Psychology, 6, 97–108.
Goldman, R., Fristoe, M., & Woodcock, R.W. (1974). GFW Sound-Symbol Tests. Circle Pines, MN: American Guidance Service.
20.
Golick, M. (1977). Language disorders in children: A linguistic investigation. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, McGill University, Montreal, Canada.
21.
Gough, P.B., & Tunmer, W.E. (1986). Decoding, reading, and reading disability. Remedial and Special Education, 7, 6–10.
22.
Graham, S.A., & Kline, R.B. (1991). IQ differences among poor readers: Do they matter? Unpublished manuscript, Concordia University, Montreal, Quebec.
23.
Jastak, J.R., & Jastak, S.R. (1978). Wide range achievement test. Wilmington, DE: Jastak Associates.
24.
Jastak, S., & Wilkinson, G.S. (1984). Wide range achievement test-Revised. Wilmington, DE: Jastak Associates.
25.
Johnson, R.S., & Rugg, M.D. (in press). Rhyme judgment in good and poor readers. Language and Education.
26.
Johnston, R.S., Rugg, M.D., & Scott, T. (1987a). The influence of phonology on good and poor readers when reading for meaning. Journal of Memory and Language, 26, 57–68.
27.
Johnston, R.S., Rugg, M.D., & Scott, T. (1987b). Phonological similarity effects, memory span and developmental reading disorders: The nature of the relationship. British Journal of Psychology, 78, 205–211.
28.
Johnston, R.S., Rugg, M.D., & Scott, T. (1988). Pseudohomophone effects in 8 and 11 year old good and poor readers. Journal of Research in Reading, 11, 110–132.
29.
Jorm, A.F., Share, D.L., Maclean, R., & Matthews, R. (1986). Cognitive factors at school entry predictive of specific reading retardation and general reading backwardness: A research note. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 27, 45–54.
30.
Jorm, A.F., Share, D.L., Matthews, R.J., & Maclean, R. (1986). Behaviour problems in specific reading retarded and general reading backward children: A longitudinal study. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 27, 33–43.
31.
Kirk, S.A., McCarthy, J.J., & Kirk, W.D. (1968). Illinois test of psycholinguistic ability. Urbana, IL: University of Chicago Press.
32.
Liberman, I.Y., Shankweiler, D., Orlando, C., Harris, K.S., & Berti, F.B. (1971). Letter confusions and reversals of sequence in the beginning reader: Implications for Orton's theory of developmental dyslexia. Cortex, 7, 127–142.
33.
Merrell, K.W. (1990). Differentiating low achieving students and students with learning disabilities: An examination of performances on the Woodcock-Johnson Psycho-Educational Battery. The Journal of Special Education, 24, 296–305.
34.
Olson, R., Kliegl, R., Davidson, B.J., & Foltz, G. (1985). Individual and developmental differences in reading disability. In T.G. Waller (Ed.), Reading research: Advances in theory and practice (Vol. 4, pp. 1–64). New York: Academic Press.
35.
Rack, J.P. (1989, April). Reading-IQ discrepancies and the phonological deficit in reading disability. Paper presented at the biennial meeting of the Society for Research in Child Development, Kansas City, MO.
36.
Rispens, J., & van Yperen, T.A. (1990). The identification of specific reading disorders: Measuring a severe discrepancy. In G.T. Pavlidis (Ed.), Perspectives on dyslexia (Vol. 2, pp. 17–42). New York: Wiley.
37.
Rodgers, B. (1983). The identification and prevalence of specific reading retardation. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 53, 369–373.
38.
Rutter, M. (1978). Prevalence and types of dyslexia. In A.L. Benton & D. Pearl (Eds.), Dyslexia: An appraisal of current knowledge (pp. 3–28). New York: Oxford University Press.
39.
Rutter, M., & Yule, W. (1975). The concepts of specific reading retardation. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 16, 181–197.
40.
Sattler, J.M. (1982). Assessment of children's intelligence and special abilities (2nd ed.). Boston: Allyn & Bacon.
41.
Scarborough, H.S. (1989a). A comparison of methods for identifying reading disabilities in adults. Unpublished manuscript.
42.
Scarborough, H.S. (1989b). Prediction of reading disability from familial and individual differences. Journal of Educational Psychology, 81, 101–108.
43.
Seidenberg, M.S., Bruck, M., Fornarolo, G., & Backman, J. (1985). Word recognition processes of poor and disabled readers: Do they necessarily differ?Applied Psycholinguistics, 6, 161–180.
44.
Shankweiler, D., Liberman, I.Y., Mark, L.S., Fowler, C.A., & Fischer, F.W. (1979). The speech code and learning to read. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory, 5, 531–545.
45.
Share, D.L., Jorm, A.F., McGee, R., Silva, P.A., Maclean, R., Matthews, R., & Williams, S. (1987). Dyslexia and other myths. Unpublished manuscript.
46.
Share, D.L., McGee, R., McKenzie, D., Williams, S., & Silva, P.A. (1987). Further evidence relating to the distinction between specific reading retardation and general reading backwardness. British Journal of Developmental Psychology, 5, 35–44.
47.
Siegel, L.S. (1986). Phonological deficits in children with a reading disability. Canadian Journal of Special Education, 2, 45–54.
48.
Siegel, L.S. (1988a). Evidence that IQ scores are irrelevant to the definition and analysis of reading disability. Canadian Journal of Psychology, 42, 202–215.
49.
Siegel, L.S. (1988b). Definitional and theoretical issues and research on learning disabilities. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 21, 264–266.
50.
Siegel, L.S. (1989a). IQ is irrelevant to the definition of learning disabilities. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 22, 469–478, 486.
51.
Siegel, L.S. (1989b). Why we do not need IQ test scores in the definition and analyses of learning disability. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 22, 514–518.
52.
Siegel, L.S. (1990a). IQ and learning disabilities: R.I.P. In H.L. Swanson & B. Keogh (Eds.), Learning disabilities: Theoretical and research issues (pp. 111–128). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
53.
Siegel, L.S. (1990b). Siegel's reply. [Letter to the editor]. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 23, 268–269, 319.
54.
Siegel, L.S. (1991, July). Phonological processing, working memory, and syntactic awareness as determinants of reading skill. Paper presented at the International Conference on Memory, Lancaster, UK.
55.
Siegel, L.S. (in press). Phonological processing deficits as the basis for a reading disability. Developmental Review.
56.
Siegel, L.S., & Faux, D. (1989). Acquisition of certain grapheme-phoneme correspondences in normally achieving and disabled readers. Reading and Writing: An Interdisciplinary Journal, 1, 37–52.
57.
Siegel, L.S., & Heaven, R.K. (1986). Categorization of learning disabilities. In S.J. Ceci (Ed.), Handbook of cognitive, social and neuropsychological aspects of learning disabilities (Vol. 1, pp. 95–121). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
58.
Siegel, L.S., & Linder, B.A. (1984). Short-term memory processes in children with reading and arithmetic learning disabilities. Developmental Psychology, 20, 200–207.
59.
Siegel, L.S., & Ryan, E.B. (1988). Development of grammatical sensitivity, phonological, and short-term memory skills in normally achieving and learning disabled children. Developmental Psychology, 24, 28–37.
60.
Siegel, L.S., & Ryan, E.B. (1989a). The development of working memory in normally achieving and subtypes of learning disabled children. Child Development, 60, 973–980.
61.
Siegel, L.S., & Ryan, E.B. (1989b). Subtypes of developmental dyslexia: The influence of definitional variables. Reading and Writing: An Interdisciplinary Journal, 1, 257–287.
62.
Silva, P.A., McGee, R., & Williams, S. (1985). Some characteristics of 9-year old boys with general reading backwardness or specific reading retardation. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 26, 407–421.
63.
Stanovich, K.E. (1986). Matthew effects in reading: Some consequences of individual differences in the acquisition of literacy. Reading Research Quarterly, 21, 360–407.
64.
Stanovich, K.E. (1988a). Explaining the differences between the dyslexic and garden-variety poor reader: The phonological-core variance-difference model. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 21, 590–604, 612.
65.
Stanovich, K.E. (1988b). The right and wrong places to look for the cognitive locus of reading disability. Annals of Dyslexia, 38, 154–177.
66.
Stanovich, K.E. (1991). Discrepancy definitions of reading disability: Has intelligence led us astray?Reading Research Quarterly, 26, 1–29.
67.
Taylor, H.G., Satz, P., & Friel, J. (1979). Developmental dyslexia in relation to other childhood reading disorders: Significance and clinical utility. Reading Research Quarterly, 15, 84–101.
68.
van der Wissel, A., & Zegers, F.E. (1985). Reading retardation revisited. British Journal of Developmental Psychology, 3, 3–9.
69.
Vellutino, F.R. (1979). Dyslexia: Theory and research. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
70.
Wechsler, D. (1974). Manual for the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Revised. San Antonio, TX: Psychological Corp.
71.
Woodcock, R.W. (1973). Woodcock reading mastery tests. Circle Pines, MN: American Guidance Service.
72.
Yule, W. (1973). Differential prognosis of reading backwardness and specific reading retardation. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 43, 244–248.
