Recent research has raised the question of whether age- and IQ-discrepancy forms of reading disability (RD) are distinguishable in terms of either their underlying linguistic deficit or their response to treatment, thus threatening the external validity of the traditional distinction between specific reading retardation and reading backwardness. The present study pursued the external validity of this distinction in three domains: (a) genetic etiology, (b) sex ratio and clinical correlates, and (c) neuropsychological profiles. Each of these domains was explored in the RD (n=640) and control (n=436) twins participating in the Colorado Reading Project (514 males, 562 females, with an overall mean age of 12.42 years). Little evidence for external validity was found in terms of the clinical correlates of attention deficit-hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), immune disorders, or handedness. Most importantly, there was no evidence of differential genetic etiology of the two phenotypes in this sample, in that deficits in both phenotypes were similarly heritable (h2g=.40 and .46 for age and IQ phenotypes, respectively) and the genetic correlation between them was high (rG=.88 to .96). However, the genetic and neuropsychological profile analyses did suggest that age- and IQ-discrepancy definitions of RD may relate differentially to component reading processes, such as phonological awareness and orthographic coding.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
American Psychiatric Association. (1987). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (3rd ed., rev.). Washington DC: Author.
2.
Baker, H.J., & Leland, B. (1959). Detroit tests of learning aptitude. Indianapolis: Bobbs-Merrill.
3.
Conners, F., & Olson, R.K. (1991). Reading comprehension in dyslexic and normal readers: A component-skills analysis. In D.A. Balota, G.B. Flores d'Arcais, & K. Raynor (Eds.), Comprehension processes in reading (pp. 557–579). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
4.
DeFries, J.C., & Fulker, D. (1985). Multiple regression analysis of twin data. Behavior Genetics, 15, 467–473.
5.
DeFries, J.C., & Fulker, D. (1988). Multiple regression analysis of twin data: Etiology of deviant scores versus individual differences. Acta Medicae et Gemellologiae: Twin Research, 37, 205–216.
6.
DeFries, J.C., & Gillis, J.J. (1990). Etiology of reading deficits in learning disabilities: Quantitative genetic analysis. In J.E. Obrzut & G.W. Hynd (Eds.), Advances in the neuropsychology of learning disabilities: Issues, methods, and practices. Orlando, FL: Academic Press.
7.
DeFries, J.C., Olson, R.K., Pennington, B.F., & Smith, S.D. (1991). Colorado reading project: An update. In D. Duane & D.B. Gray (Eds.), The reading brain: The biological basis of dyslexia (pp. 53–87). Parkton, MD: York Press.
8.
DeFries, J.C., Plomin, R., Vandenberg, S., & Kuse, A.R. (1981). Parent-offspring resemblance for cognitive abilities in the Colorado Adoption Project: Biological, adoptive, and control parents and one-year old children. Intelligence, 5, 245–277.
9.
Dunn, L.M., & Markwardt, F.C., Jr. (1970). Manual for the Peabody Individual Achievement Test. Circle Pines, MN: American Guidance Service.
10.
Francis, D.J., Espy, K.A., Rourke, B.P., & Fletcher, J.M. (1991). Validity of intelligence test scores in the definition of learning disability: A critical analysis. In B.P. Rourke (Eds.), Neuropsychological validation of learning disability subtypes (pp. 15–44). New York: Guilford Press.
11.
French, J.W., Ekstrom, R.G., & Price, L.A. (1963). Manual for a kit of reference tests for cognitive factors. Princeton, NJ: Educational Testing Service.
12.
Fulker, D.W., Cardon, L.R., DeFries, L.R., Kimberling, W.J., Pennington, B.F., & Smith, S.D. (1991). Multiple regresion analysis of sib-pair data on reading to detect quantitative trait loci. Reading and Writing, 3, 299–313.
13.
Gilger, J.W., Pennington, B.F., Borecki, I., & DeFries, J.C. (1992, July). Commingling and segregation analysis of complex psychological traits: Are extremes of normal variance etiologically distinct?Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Behavior Genetics Association, Boulder, CO.
14.
Gilger, J.W., Pennington, B.F., & DeFries, J.C. (1992a, February). Is dyslexia a distinct deviation from normal variance in reading skills?Paper presented at the 20th annual meeting of the International Neuropsychological Society, San Diego, CA.
15.
Gilger, J.W., Pennington, B.F., & DeFries, J.C. (1992b). A twin study of the etiology of comorbidity: Attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder and dyslexia. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 31(2), 343–348.
16.
Gilger, J.W., Pennington, B.F., Green, P.A., Smith, S.M., & Smith, S.D. (1992). Reading disability, immune disorders and non-right-handedness: Twin and family studies of their relations. Neuro-psychologia, 30(3), 209–227.
17.
Hallgren, B. (1950). Specific dyslexia (congenital word-blindness): A clinical and genetic study. Acta Psychiatrica et Neurologica Supplement, 65, 1–287.
18.
Herjanic, B., Campbell, J., & Reich, W. (1982). Development of a structured psychiatric interview for children: Agreement between child and parent on individual symptoms. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 10, 307–324.
19.
Nettleship, E. (1901). Cases of congenital word-blindness (inability to learn to read). Ophthalmic Review, 20, 61–67.
20.
Nichols, R.C., & Bilbro, W.C. (1966). The diagnosis of twin zygosity. Acta Geneticae Medicae et Gemellologiae, 16, 265–275.
21.
Olson, R., Gillis, J., Rack, J.P., DeFries, J.C., & Fulker, D.W. (1991). Confirmatory factor analysis of word recognition and process measures in the Colorado Reading Project. Reading and Writing, 3, 235–248.
22.
Olson, R., Wise, B., Conners, F., Rack, J., Fulker, D.W. (1989). Specific deficits in component reading and language skills: Genetic and environmental influences. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 22, 339–348.
23.
Pennington, B.F., Gilger, J., Pauls, D., Smith, S.A., Smith, S.D., & DeFries, J.C. (1991). Evidence for major gene transmission of developmental dyslexia. Journal of the American Medical Association, 266(11), 1527–1534.
24.
Rodgers, B. (1983). The identification and prevalence of specific reading retardation. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 53, 369–373.
25.
Rutter, M., & Yule, W. (1975). The concept of specific reading retardation. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 16, 181–197.
26.
Science Research Associates. (1965). The primary mental abilities: Technical report. Chicago: Author.
27.
Share, D.L., McGhee, R., McKenzie, D., Williams, S., & Silva, P.D. (1987). Further evidence related to the distinction between specific reading retardation and general reading backwardness. British Journal of Developmental Psychology, 5, 35–44.
28.
Shaywitz, S.E., Escobar, M.D., Shaywitz, B.A., Fletcher, J.M., & Maknuch, R. (1992). Evidence that dyslexia may represent the lower tail of a normal distribution of reading ability. New England Journal of Medicine, 326(3), 145–150.
29.
Silva, P.A., McGhee, R., & Williams, S. (1985). Some characteristics of nine year old boys with general reading backwardness or specific reading retardation. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 20, 407–421.
30.
Smith, S.D., Kimberling, W.J., & Pennington, B.F. (1991). Screening for multiple genes influencing dyslexia. Reading and Writing, 3, 285–298.
31.
Stanovich, K.E. (1986). Matthew effects in reading: Some consequences of individual differences in the acquisition of literacy. Reading Research Quarterly, 21, 360–407.
32.
Stanovich, K.E. (1988). Explaining the variance in reading ability in terms of psychological processes: What have we learned?Annals of Dyslexia, 35, 67–96.
33.
Stevenson, J. (1988). Which aspects of reading ability show a “hump” in their distribution?Applied Cognitive Psychology, 2, 77–85.
34.
Stevenson, J. (1991). Identifying sex differences in reading disability: Lessons from a twin study. Manuscript submitted for publication.
35.
Wechsler, D. (1974). Examiner's manual: Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Revised. San Antonio, TX: Psychological Corp.
36.
Wechsler, D. (1981). Examiner's manual: Wechsler Intelligence Adult Scale-Revised. San Antonio, TX: Psychological Corp.
