Test scores of two groups of learning disabled children with a mean age of 10 years (N=63 and N=96) were submitted to cluster analysis in an attempt to replicate previously described subtypes. Part of these subjects and a matched control group (N = 170) followed up into adulthood and tested at a mean age of 24 years were cluster analyzed to investigate the persistence of subtypes into adulthood. The clusters found in both childhood and adult samples did resemble subtypes reported in the literature, although at adult age the ‘linguistic’ subtype was no longer present. The results of several validation procedures indicated that the derived subtypes were somewhat less stable than desired. Tests for age differences across clusters shawed significant effects only with unstandardized variables in the adult sample but not in children. Tests for differences between derived clusters in neurological impairment as assessed in childhood proved significant only between control and LD clusters; a similar analysis with adult neurological categories showed signifcant trends related to severity. Tracing individual subjects from childhood to adult clusters showed only a moderate degree of persistence.
A subsidiary analysis with two of the samples investigated the presence and outcome of the ACID subtype. One clear example of this type was found at both ages, but tracing subjects showed only little persistence of this type into adult years. A second example of the ACID type was also found at adult age which consisted mainly of subjects who were average learners in school. The paper stresses the need for reexamination of the notion of “specific” disabilities and further study of the replicability and long-term outcome of LD subtypes
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Ackerman, P.T., Dykman, R.A., & Peters. J.E. (1977). Learning Disabled Boys as Adolescents: Cognitive Factors and Achievement. Journal of the American Academy of Child Psychiatry, 16, 296–313.
2.
Andrews, H., Snee, R., & Sarner, M. (1980). Graphical Display of Means. The American Statistician, 34, 195–199.
3.
Applebee, A. (1971). Research in Reading Retardation: Two Critical Problems. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 12, 91–113.
4.
Bakker, D.J. (1979). Hemispheric Differences and Reading Strategies: Two Dyslexias?Bulletin of the Orton Society, 29, 84–100.
5.
Bakker, D.J. (1984). The brain as a dependent variable. Journal of Clinical Neuropsychology, 6, 1–16.
6.
Bakker, D.J, & Staz, P (eds.) (1970). Specific Reading Disability: Advances in Theory and Method.Rotterdam: Rotterdam University Press.
7.
Benton, A.L. (1959). Right-Left Discrimination and Finger Localization.New York: Hoeber-Horper.
8.
Benton, A.L., & Pearl, D. (1978). Dyslexia: An Appraisal of Current Knowledge. Oxford University Press.
9.
Blashfield, R.K. (1980). Propositions Regarding the use of Cluster Analysis in Clinical Research. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 48,(4), 456–459.
10.
Boder, E. (1970). Developmental Dyslexia: A New Diagnostic Approach Based on the Identification of Three Subtypes. Journal of School Health, 40, 289–290.
11.
Culver, CM. (1969). Test of Right-Left Discrimination. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 29, 863–867.
12.
Decker, S.N. (1982). Reading disability: is there a hereditary pattern? In: R.N. Malatesha & L.C. Hartlage (Eds.), Neuropsychology and Cognition, Vol. 2. The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff.
13.
Decker, S.N., & DeFries, J.C. (1982). Cognitive ability profiles in families of reading-disabled children., Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology.
14.
Denckla, M.B. (1977). Minimal Brain Dysfunction and Dyslexia: Beyond Diagnosis by Exclusion. In M.E. Blaw, I. Rapin, & M. Kinsbournc (Eds.), Topics in Child Neurology.New York: Spectrum Publications.
15.
Doehring, D.G., & Hoshko, I.M. (1977). Classification of Reading Problems by the Q Technique of Factor Analysis. Cortex, 13, 281–294.
16.
Doehring, D.G., Trites, R.L., Patel, P.G., & Fidorowicz, A.M. (1981). Reading Disabilities: The Interaction of Reading, Language, and Neuropsychological Deficits.New York: Academic Press.
17.
Dunn, L.M., & Markwardt, F.C., Jr. (1970). Manual: Peabody Individual Achievement Test.Circle Pines, Minn.: American Guidance Service.
18.
Dykman, R.A., Peters, J.E., & Ackerman, P.T. (1973). Experimental Approaches to the Study of Minimal Brain Dysfunction: A Follow-Up Study. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 205, 93–107.
19.
Fisk, J.L., & Rourke, B.P. (1979). Identification of Subtypes of Learning Disabled Children at Three Age Levels: A Neuropsychological, Multivariate Approach. Journal of Clinical Neuropsychology, I, 289–310.
20.
Gaddes, W.H., & Crockett, D. (1975). The Spreen Benton Aphasia Tests: Normative Data as a Measure of Normal Language Development. Brain and Language, 5,(3), 257–280.
21.
Gottesman, R.L., Belmont, I., & Kaminer, R. (1975). Admission and Follow-Up Status of Reading Disabled Children Referred to a Medical Clinic. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 8, 642–650.
22.
Halstead, W.C. (1947). Brain and Intelligence.Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
23.
Hern, A. (1984). Neurological Signs in Learning Disabled Children: Persistence over Time, and Incidence in Adulthood Compared to Normal Learners. Unpublished Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Victoria.
24.
Jastak, J., & Jastak, R. (1978). Manual: The Wide Range Achievement Test.Wilmington, Delaware: Jastak Associates.
25.
Kleinpeter, U., & Goellnitz, G. (1976). Achievement and Adaptation Disorders in Brain-Damaged Children. International Journal of Mental Health, 4,(4), 19–35.
26.
LaBreche, T.M. (1982). The Victoria Revision of the Halstead Category Test. Unpublished Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Victoria.
27.
Lai, C. (1982). Hierarchical Grouping Analysis with Optional Contiguity Constraint. Program Manual, Computing Services, University of British Columbia.
28.
Lorr, M. (1983). Cluster Analysis for Social Scientists.Jossey-Bass, San Francisco.
29.
Lovett, M.W. (1984). A Developmental Perspective on Reading Dysfunction: Accuracy and Rate Criteria in the Subryping of Dyslexic Children. Brain and Language, 22, 67–91.
30.
Lovett, M.W., Ransby, M.J., Hardwick. N., & Johns, M. (1984). Treatment-Specific and Generalized Treatment Effects in Dyslexic Children's Response to Remediation. INS Bulletin. November, 1983, p. 23.
31.
Lyon, R. and Watson, B. (1981). Empirically Derived Subgroups of Learning Disabled Readers: Diagnostic Characteristics. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 14, 256–261.
32.
Marshall, J.C., & Newcombe, F. (1973). Patterns of Paralexia: A Psycholinguistic Approach. Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology, 2, 175–199.
33.
Mattis, S., French, J., & Rapin, I. (1975). Dyslexia in Children and Young Adults: Three Independent Neuropsychological Syndromes. Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology., 17, 150–163.
34.
Maxwell, A.E. (1971). Multivariate Statistical Methods and Classification Problems. British Journal of Psychiatry, 119, 121–127.
35.
Mojena, R., & Wishart, D. (1980). Stopping Rules for Word's Clustering Method. COMPSTAT: 1980, Proceedings in Computational Statistics. Fourth Symposium. Wien: Physica-Verlag.
36.
Morris, R., Blashfield, R., & Staz, P. (1981). Neuropsychology and Cluster Analysis: Potentials and Problems. Journal of Clinical Neuropsychology, 3, 79–99.
37.
Orton, S.T. (1937). Reading, Writing and Speech Problems in Children.New York: Norton.
38.
Purdue Research Foundation (1948). Examiner's Manual for the Purdue Pegboard.Chicago: Science Research Associates.
39.
Rourke, B.P., & Orr, R.R. (1977). Prediction of the Reading and Spelling Performances of Normal and Retarded Readers: A 4 Year Follow Up. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 5, 9–20.
40.
Rourke, B.P., Strang, J.D. (1983). Subtypes of Reading and Arithmetical Disabilities: A Neuropsychological Analysis. In M. Rutter (Ed.), Developmental Neuropsychiatry, Guilford Press, New York, 473–488.
41.
Rutter, N. (1978). Prevalence and Types of Dyslexia. In A.L. Benton & D. Pearl (Eds.), Dyslexia; An Appraisal of Current Knowledge., Oxford University Press, 4–28.
42.
Sarle, W.S. (1982). Documentation for SAS Clustering Routine. In SAS User's Guide; Statistics, SAS Institute, Cary, North Carolinass.
43.
Satz, P., & Morris, R. (1981). Learning Disability Subtypes: A Review. In F.J. Pirozzolo & M.C. Wittrock (Eds.), Neuropsychological and Cognitive Processes in Reading, 109—141.
44.
Staz, P., Taylor, G., Friel, J., & Fletcher, J. (1978). Some Developmental and Predictive Precursors of Reading Disabilities: A Six Year Follow-Up. In A.L. Benton & D. Pearl (Eds.), Dyslexia: An Appraisal of Current Knowledge, Oxford University Press, 315–347.
45.
Shankweiler, D. (1964). Developmental Dyslexia: A Critique and Review of Recent Evidence. Cortex, 1, 53–62.
46.
Spreen, O. (1983). Learning Disabled Children Growing Up: A Follow-up into Adulthood.University of Victoria Monograph.
47.
Spreen, O. (1984). A Prognostic View from Middle Childhood. In M. Levine & P. Staz (Eds.), Middle Childhood: Developmental Variations and Dysfunctions.New York: Academic Press.
48.
Spreen, O., & Benton, A.L. (1967, 1977) The Neurosensory Center Comprehensive Examination for Aphasia.University of Victoria.
49.
Spreen, O., & Gaddes, W.H. (1969). Developmental Norms for 15 Neuropsychological Tests Age 6 to 15. Cortex, 5, 171–191.
50.
Spreen, O., & McAllister, M. (1981). Normative Data for School Age Children with Selected Achievement and Other Tests in a B.C. School Population. Unpublished Manuscript, University of Victoria.
51.
Tuokko, H.A. (1982). Cognitive Correlates of Arithmetic Performance in Clinic Referred Children. Unpublished Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Victoria.
52.
Ward, J. (1963). Hierarchical Grouping to Optimize an Objective Function. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 58, 236–244.
53.
Watson, B.U., Goldgar, D.E., & Ryschon, K.I. (1983). Subtypes of Reading Disability. Journal of Clinical Neuropsychology, 5, 377–399.
54.
Wechsler, D. (1974). Manual for the WISC-R.The Psychological Corporation, New York.
55.
Wechsler, D. (1981). Manual for the WAIS-R.The Psychological Corporation, New York.
56.
Wechsler, D., & Stone, C.P. (1945). Manual: The Wechsler Memory Scale.The Psychological Corporation, New York.
