Diagnostic Implications of Bannatyne's Recategorized WISC-R Scores for Identifying Learning Disabled Children

Abstract

This study examines the use of Bannatyne's WISC-R subtest score recategorization hierarchy in identifying students with learning disabilities. Five groups of 40 students each were selected from previously diagnosed children from each of the following categories: full-time learning disabilities placement, resource room learning disabilities placement, emotionally disturbed (ED), gifted, and educable mentally handicapped, (EMH). WISC-R subtest scores were recategorized in order to obtain Spatial, Conceptual, Sequential and Acquired Knowledge scores, as suggested by Bannatyne. The five groups were examined to determine the frequency with which the Spatial<Conceptual<Sequential ordering was observed. In addition, four of the five groups were collapsed to form two groups, one consisting of LD students and the other consisting of the EMH and ED students. The two groups did not significantly differ in the proportion of students conforming to Bannatyne's pattern. The results indicated that Bannatyne's pattern was of little value in differentiating between LD students and non-LD students and, if used, might even contribute to misdiagnosis.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bannatyne, A. Diagnosing learning disabilities and writing remedial prescriptions. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 1968, 1, 242–249.

Bannatyne, A. Diagnosis: A note on recategorization of the WISC scaled scores. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 1974, 7, 272–273.

Gutkin, T.B. Bannatyne patterns of Caucasian and Mexican-American learning disabled children. Psychology in the Schools, 1979, 16, 178–183.

Page, E.B. Ordered hypotheses for multiple treatments: A significance test for linear ranks. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 1963, 58, 216–229.

Rugel, R.P. WISC subtest scores of disabled readers: A review with respect to Bannatyne's recategorization. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 1974, 7, 57–64.

Sattler, J. Assessment of Children's Intelligence. Philadelphia: W. B. Saunders Co., 1974.

Smith, M.D. , Coleman, M. , Dokecki, P.R. & Davis, E.E. Recategorized WISC-R scores of learning disabled children. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 1977, 10, 437–443.

Vance, H.B. , & Singer, M.G. Recategorization of the WISC-R subtest scaled scores for learning disabled children. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 1979, 12, 487–491.

Wechsler, D. Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children. New York: The Psychological Corp., 1949.

10.

Wechsler, D. Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Revised. New York: The Psychological Corp., 1974.

11.

While, W.G. Evaluating scaled score differences for the Bannatyne recategorization of the Wechsler subtests. Psychology in the Schools, 1979, 16, 174–177.