The effect of the Feingold diet on 'normal' school children P

Abstract

Approximately 300 children in seven primary (elementary) schools used the Feingold diet for two weeks. Ratings were made by teachers before and after use of the diet on questionnaires developed from Conners' long teacher questionnaire. The questionnaire incorporated Conners' hyperactivity factor items, but related to the normal or average child, by referring to most children. Of the total sample, 8.5% improved by five points or more. The mean before diet scores of children who improved were below the cut off value for hyperactivity, indicating hyperactivity itself is not a necessary condition for improvement. Item by item analysis of the response showed that the behavior problems mostly likely to show improvement were distractability, attention span, fiddling, and demands for attention. Parents provided information on the additive foods being ingested by their children. Those children who were reported to be taking a great deal of additive were found to rate significantly higher in behavioral problems compared with children receiving little additive.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Breakey, J. , Dietary management of hyperkinesis and behavioural problems. Aust Fam Physician, 1978;7:720-724.

Brenner, A. , A study of the efficacy of the Feingold diet on hyperkinetic children . Clinical Pediatrics, 1977;16:652-656.

Conners, C.K. , Goyette, C.H. , Southwick, D.A. , Lees, J.M. , Andrulonis, P.A. , Food additives and hyperkinesis: a controlled double-blind experiment . Pediatrics, 1976;58:155-166

Cook, P.S. , Woodhill, J.M. , The Feingold dietary treatment of hyperkinetic syndrome. Medical Journal of Australia, 1976;2:85-90.

Davids, A. , An objective instrument for assessing hyperkinesis in children. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 1971;4:518-523.

Dickie, L.D. , Clinical Ecology, Springfield, Ill, 1976.

Douglas, V.I. , Stop, look and listen: The problem of sustained attention and impulse control in hyperactive and normal children. Can J Behav Sci. , 1972;4:(4), 259-282.

Feingold, B.F. , Why vour child is hyperactive, New York, Random House, 1975.

Fitzsimon, M. , Holborow, P. , Berry, P. , and Latham, S. , Salicylate sensitivity and hyperactive children. Medical Journal of Australia, 1978; (2), 570-572.

10.

Gittleman-Klein, R. , Klein, D.F. , Katz, S. , Saraf, K. , Pollack, E. , Comparative effects of methylphenidate and thioridacine in hyperkinetic children . Archives of General Psychiatry, 1976;33: 1217-1231.

11.

Harley, J.P. , Ray, R. , Tomasi, L. , Eichman, P.U. , Matthews, S. , Chun, R. , Cleeland, C. , Traisman, E. , Hyperkinesis and food additives: Testing the Feingold hypothesis. Pediatrics, 1978;61:818-828.

12.

Hindle, R.C. , Priest, J. , The management of hyperkinetic children; a trial of dietary therapy . The New Zealand Medical Journal, 1978 ;88: (616), 43-45.

13.

Holborow, P. , Berry, P. , and Elkins, J. , (In preparation). The prevalence of hyperactivity in Brisbane schools .

14.

Huessy, H.R. , Minimal brain disfunction in children. (Hyperkinetic Syndrome): Recognition and treatment. Drug therapy, Sept 1973:52-63.

15.

Kolbye, A.C. , Preliminary findings and recommendations of the Interagency Collaborative Group of Hyperkinesis. Submission to the US Deputy Assistance for Health, Department of Health, Education and Welfare , 1975.

16.

Levy, F. , Dumbrell, S. , Hobbes, G. , Ryan, M. , Witton, N. , Woodhill, J.M. , Hyperkinesis and diet. A double-blind crossover trial with a tartazine challenge . Medical Journal of Australia, 1978;1:61-64.

17.

Lipton, M. , and Wender, E. , Statement summarizing research findings on the issue of the relationship between food additive free diets and hyperkinesis in children. Report to the Nutrition Foundation, June, 1977.

18.

Miller, R.G. , Palkes, H.S. , and Stewart, M.A. , Hyperactive children in suburban elementary schools. Child Psychiatry and Human Development, 1973;4:121-127.

19.

Palmer, S. , Rapoport, H.D. , and Quinn, P.O. , Food additives and hyperactivity. Clinical Pediatrics , 1976;14:956-959.

20.

Rapp, D.J. , Does diet affect hyperactivity, Journal of Learning Disabiilties , 1978;11:383-389.

21.

Rose, T. , The functional relationship between artificial food colours and hyperactivity . Journal of Applied Behaviour Analysis. 1978 :11:(4), 439-446.

22.

Salzman, L.K. , Allergy testing, psychological assessment and dietary treatment of the hyperactive child syndrome. Medical Journal of Australia , 1976;2:248-251.

23.

Shannon, W.R. , Neuropathic manifestations in infants and children as a result of anaphylactic reaction to foods contained in their dietary. American Journal of Diseases of Children, 1922;24:80-94.

24.

Spring, C. , Sandoval, J. , Food additives and hyperkinesis. A critical evaluation of the evidence . Journal of Learning Disabilities, 1976 ; 9:560-569.

25.

Sprague, R.L. , Gadow, K. , The role of the teacher in drug treatment. School Review, 1976;85:(1), 109-140.

26.

Swanson, J.M. , Bell, L. , Kinsbourne, M. , An evaluation and a test of Feingold's dietary treatment for hyperactivity . Paper presented at NATO Conference, Ottawa, 1978.

27.

Werry, J.S. , Food additives and hyperactivity. Medical Journal of Australia , 1976;2:281-2.

28.

Werry, J.S. , Studies on the hyperactive child: IV. An empirical analysis of the minimal brain dysfunction syndrome. Archives of General Psychiatry , 1968;19:9-16.