Auditory Discrimination Ability in Negro Dialect-Speaking Children

Abstract

Three groups of 40 first grade boys – Negro dialect-speaking, Negro standard English-speaking, and white standard English-speaking – were given an auditory discrimination test. The test was composed of two kinds of word pairs: (1) those pairs pronounced as homonyms in Negro dialect but as contrasting words in standard English, and (2) those pairs pronounced as contrasting words by all subjects. The word pairs were presented on tape by both Negro dialect and standard English speakers. The purpose of the study was to examine whether differences existed in auditory discrimination ability between the Negro dialect-speaking and the standard English-speaking boys. Results indicate that there were no significant group differences in auditory discrimination performance on those word pairs which could be commonly differentiated in the speech of all subjects. However, both groups of standard English-speaking children scored significantly higher than the group of Negro dialect-speaking children on those word pairs pronounced as homonyms in Negro dialect when they were presented contrastingly by standard English speakers.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Clark, Ann D. , and Richards, Charlotte J. : Auditory discrimination among economically disadvantaged and non-disadvantaged preschool children. Exceptional Child., 1966, 33, 259–262.

Cohen, Julian, H. , and Diehl, Charles F. : Relation to speech-sound discrimination ability to articulation-type speech defects. J. Speech and Hearing Disorders, 1963, 28, 187–190.

Deutsch, Cynthia P. : Auditory discrimination and learning: social factors. Merrill-Palmer Quart., 1964, 10, 277–296.

Deutsch, Martin , and Brown, Bert : Social influences in Negro-white intelligence differences. J. Social Issues, 1964, 20, 24–35.

Gottesman, Ruth L. : Auditory discrimination ability in standard English-speaking and Negro dialect-speaking children. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Teachers College, Columbia Univ., 1968.

Jones, Daniel : The phoneme: its nature and use (2nd ed. rev.). Cambridge, England: W. Heffer and Sons, 1962.

Labov, William , Cohen, Paul , and Robins, Clarence : A Preliminary Study of the Structure of English Used by Negro and Puerto Rican Speakers in New York City. New York: Columbia Univ., 1965.

Labov, William : Some sources of reading problems for Negro speakers of non-standard English. In A. Frazier (Ed.), New Directions in Elementary English. Chicago, Ill. National Council of Teachers of English, 1967, 140–147.

Liberman, A., et al. : An effect of learning on speech perception: the discrimination of durations of silence with and without phonemic significance. Language and Speech, 1961, 4, 175–196.

10.

Lotz, J., et al. : The perception of English stops by speakers of English, Spanish, Hungarian and Thai: a tape-cutting experiment. Language and Speech, 1960, 3, 71–77.

11.

MacNeilage, Peter F. : Electromyographic and acoustic study of the production of certain final clusters. J. Acoustical Society of Amer., 1963, 35, 461–463.

12.

Pederson, Lee A. : Some structural differences in the speech of Chicago Negros. In: Roger W. Shuy (Ed.), Social Dialects and Language Learning. Champaign, Ill. National Council of Teachers of English, Proceedings of the Bloomington, Indiana Conference, 1964, 28–61.

13.

Prim, David : Relations among specific articulatory deviations and responses to a clinical measure of sound discrimination ability. J. Speech and Hearing Disorders, 1963, 28, 382–388.

14.

Singh, Sadanand , and Black, John W. : Study of twenty-six intervocalic consonants as spoken and recognized by four language groups. J. Acoustical Society of Amer., 1966, 39, 372–387.

15.

Stern, Carolyn : Language competencies of four- and five-year-old children under current experimental programs in language instruction. Paper presented at a symposium on Early First Language Instruction for the Culturally Different Child, Amer. Educ. Research Assn., Chicago, Ill., 1966.

16.

Stewart, William A. : Foreign language teaching methods in quasi-foreign language situations. In: William A. Stewart (Ed.), Non-standard Speech and the Teaching of English. Washington, D.C.: Center for Applied Linguistics, 1964.

17.

Weiner, P. S. : Auditory discrimination and articulation. J. Speech and Hearing Disorders, 1967, 32, 19–28.

18.

Wepman, Joseph : Auditory Discrimination Test, Chicago, Ill.: Univ. of Chicago, 1958.

19.

Winer, B. J. : Statistical Principles in Experimental Design. New York: McGraw Hill, 1962.