In this study, we examine the nature and quality of students' comprehension of history. Specifically, we explore whether cognitive— psychological theories developed to capture the comprehension of narrative text can be used to capture the comprehension of history. Participants were 36 students with learning disabilities who had taken part in an earlier study designed to investigate the effects of an interactive instructional intervention in history. The results of the original study supported the effectiveness of the intervention in terms of amount recalled. The results of the present study reveal that historical understanding can be characterized as the construction of meaning through the creation of a causal network of events. The study of history within a causal network framework has implications for understanding the nature and quality of students' learning of history, and for potentially identifying sources of failure in learning.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Bauer, P.J., & Wewerka, S.S. (1997). Saying is revealing: Verbal expression of event memory in the transition from infancy to early childhood. In P. van den Broek, P. Bauer, & T. Bourg (Eds.), Developmental spans in event comprehension: Bridging fictional and actual events (pp. 139—168). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum .
2.
Beck, I.L., McKeown, M.G., & Gromoll, E.W. (1989). Learning from social studies text. Cognition and Instruction, 6, 99—158.
3.
Beck, I.L., McKeown, M.G., Sinatra, G.M., & Loxterman, J.A. (1991). Revising social studies text from a text-processing perspective: Evidence of improved comprehensibility . Reading Research Quarterly, 26, 251—276.
4.
Bourg, T., Bauer, P.J., & van den Broek, P. (1997). Building the bridges: The development of event comprehension and representation. In P. van den Broek, P. Bauer, & T. Bourg (Eds.), Developmental spans in event comprehension: Bridging fictional and actual events (pp. 385—408). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum .
5.
Britt, M.A., & Aglinskas, C. (2002). Improving students' ability to identify and use source information. Cognition and Instruction, 20, 485—522.
6.
Campione, J., & Brown, A. (1987). Linking dynamic assessment with school achievement . In C. S. Lidz (Ed.), Dynamic assessment (pp. 82—116). New York: Guildford. Carnine, D., Steely , D., & Silbert, J. (1996). Understanding U.S. history—Reconstruction to world leadership. Eugene: University of Oregon.
7.
DeVinney, J.A. (Writer/Producer). (1991). Eyes on the prize—America's civil rights years, 1954—1965 [Documentary]. United States: Blackside .
8.
Fletcher, C.R., & Bloom, C.P. (1988). Causal reasoning and comprehension of simple narrative texts. Journal of Memory andLanguage, 27, 235—244.
9.
Gersten, R., Baker, S.K., Smith-Johnson, J., Dimino, J., & Peterson, A. (2006). Eyes on the prize: Teaching complex historical content to middle school students with learning disabilities. Exceptional Children, 72, 264—280.
10.
Goldman, S.R., & Varnhagen, C.K. (1986). Memory for embedded and sequential story structures. Journal of Memory andLanguage , 25, 401—418.
11.
Harniss, M.K., Hollenbeck, K.L., Craw-ford, D.B., & Carnine, D. (1994). Content organization and the instructional design issues in the development of history texts. Learning Disability Quarterly, 17, 235—248.
12.
Jennings, P., & Brewster, T. (1998). The century. New York: Doubleday.
13.
Kinder, D., & Bursuck, W. (1993). History strategy instruction: Problem—solution— effect analysis, timeline, and vocabulary instruction. Exceptional Children, 59, 324— 335.
14.
Kinder, D., Bursuck, W., & Epstein, M. (1992). An evaluation of history textbooks. The Journal of Special Education, 25, 472—491.
15.
Lorch, E.P., & Sanchez, R.P. (1997). Children's memory for televised events. In P. van den Broek, P. Bauer, & T. Bourg (Eds.), Developmental spans in event comprehension: Bridging fictional and actual events (pp. 271—294). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum .
16.
Mackie, J.L. (1980). The cement of the universe: A study of causation . Oxford: Clarendon Press.
17.
Mandler, J.M., & Johnson, N.S. (1977). Remembrance of things parsed: Story structure and recall. Cognitive Psychology, 9, 111—151.
18.
McKeown, M.G., & Beck, I.L. (1990). The assessment and characterization of young learners' knowledge of a topic in history. American Educational Research Journal, 27, 688—726.
19.
McKeown, M.G., Beck, I.L., Sinatra, G.M., & Loxterman, J.A. (1992). The contribution of prior knowledge and coherent text to comprehension. Reading Research Quarterly, 27, 78—93.
20.
O'Brien, E.J., & Myers, J.L. (1987). The role of causal connections in the retrieval of text. Memory & Cognition, 15, 419—427.
21.
Perfetti, C.A., Rouet, J.-F., & Britt, M.A. (1999). Toward a theory of documents representation. In H. van Oostendorp & S. R. Goldman (Eds.), The construction of mental representations during reading (pp. 99—122). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
22.
Rouet, J.-F., Britt, A.M., Mason, R.A., & Perfetti, C. (1996). Using multiple sources of evidence to reason about history. Journal of Educational Psychology, 88, 478—493.
23.
Rouet, J.-F., Favart, M., Britt, M.A., & Perfetti, C.A. (1997). Studying and using multiple documents in history: Effects of discipline expertise. Cognition and Instruction, 15, 85—106.
24.
Rumelhart, D.E. (1975). Notes on a schema for stories. In D. Bobrow & A. Collins (Eds.), Representation and understanding: Studies in cognitive science (pp. 211—235). New York: Academic Press.
25.
Shapiro, B.P., van den Broek, P., & Fletcher, C.R. (1995). Using story-based causal diagrams to analyze disagreements about complex events. Discourse Processes, 19, 51—77.
26.
Stahl, S.A., Hynd, C.R., Britton, B., McNish, M.M., & Bosquet, D. (1996). What happens when students read multiple source documents in history?Reading Research Quarterly, 31, 430—456.
27.
Stein, N.L., & Glenn, C.G. (1979). An analysis of story comprehension in elementary school children. In R. O. Freedle (Ed.), New directions in discourse processing: Vol. 2. Advances in discourse processes (pp. 53—120). Norwood, NJ: Ablex.
28.
Trabasso, T., & Sperry, L.L. (1985). Causal relatedness and importance of story events. Journal of Memory andLanguage, 24, 595—611.
29.
Trabasso, T., & van den Broek, P. (1985). Causal thinking and the representation of narrative events. Journal of Memory andLanguage, 12, 1—25.
30.
van den Broek, P.W. (1988). The effects of causal relations and hierarchical position on the importance of story statements. Journal of Memory andLanguage, 27, 1—22.
31.
van den Broek, P.W. (1989a). Causal reasoning and inference making in judging the importance of story statements. Child Development, 60, 286—297.
32.
van den Broek, P.W. (1989b). The effects of causal structure on the comprehension of narratives: Implications for education. Reading Psychology: AnInternational Quarterly, 10, 19—44.
33.
van den Broek, P. (1994). Comprehension and memory of narrative texts. In M. A. Gernsbacher (Ed.), Handbook of psycholinguistics (pp. 539—588). London: Academic Press.
34.
van den Broek, P. (1997). Discovering the cements of the universe: The development of event comprehension from childhood to adulthood. In P. van den Broek, P. Bauer, & T. Bourg (Eds.), Developmental spans in event comprehension: Bridging fictional and actual events (pp. 321—342). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum .
35.
van den Broek, P., Bauer, P., & Bourg, T. (Eds.). (1997). Developmental spans in event comprehension: Bridging fictional and actual events. Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.
36.
van den Broek, P., Kendeou, P., Kremer, K., Lynch, J., Butler, J., White, M.J., et al. (2005). Assessment of comprehension abilities in young children. In S. G. Paris & S. A. Stahl (Eds.), Children's reading comprehension and assessment (pp. 107—130). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
37.
van den Broek, P.W., Lorch, E.P., & Thurlow, R. (1996). Children's and adults' memory for television stories: The role of causal factors, story-grammar categories and hierarchical level . Child Development, 67, 3010—3029.
38.
van den Broek, P., Lorch, R.F., Jr., Linderholm, T., & Gustafson, M. (2001). The effects of readers' goals on inference generation and memory for texts. Memory & Cognition, 29, 1081—1087.
39.
Wineburg, S.S. (1991). Historical problem solving: A study of the cognitive processes used in the evaluation of documentary and pictorial evidence. Journal of Educational Psychology, 83, 73—87.
40.
Wineburg, S. (1998). Reading Abraham Lincoln: An expert/expert study in the interpretation of historical texts. Cognitive Science , 22, 319—346.
41.
Wolman, C. (1991). Sensitivity to causal cohesion in stories by children with mild mental retardation, children with learning disabilities, and children without disabilities. The Journal of Special Education, 25, 135—154.
42.
Wolman, C., van den Broek, P., & Lorch, R.F. (1997). Effects of causal structure on immediate and delayed story recall by children with mild mental retardation, children with learning disabilities, and children without disabilities. The Journal of Special Education, 30, 439—455.
