This study examined the effectiveness of nonprofessional tutors in a phonologically based reading treatment similar to those in which successful reading outcomes have been demonstrated. Participants were 23 first graders at risk for learning disability who received intensive one-to-one tutoring from noncertified tutors for 30 minutes, 4 days a week, for one school year. Tutoring included instruction in phonological skills, letter-sound correspondence, explicit decoding, rime analysis, writing, spelling, and reading phonetically controlled text. At year end, tutored students significantly outperformed untutored control students on measures of reading, spelling, and decoding. Effect sizes ranged from .42 to 1.24. Treatment effects diminished at follow-up at the end of second grade, although tutored students continued to significantly outperform untutored students in decoding and spelling. Findings suggest that phonologically based reading instruction for first graders at risk for learning disability can be delivered by nonteacher tutors. Our discussion addresses the character of reading outcomes associated with tutoring, individual differences in response to treatment, and the infrastructure required for nonprofessional tutoring programs.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Adams, M.J. (1990). Beginning to read: Thinking and learning about print. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press .
2.
Berninger, V.W. (1990). Multiple orthographic codes: Key to alternative instructional methodologies for developing the orthographic-phonological connections underlying word recognition. School Psychology Review, 19, 518-533.
3.
Berninger, V.W., Thalberg, S., DeBruyn, I., & Smith, R. (1987). Preventing reading disabilities by assessing and remediating phonemic skills. School Psychology Review, 16, 554-565.
4.
Berninger, V.W., Vaughan, K., Abbott, R.D., Brooks, A., Abbott, S.P., Rogan, L., Reed, E., & Graham, S. (1998). Early intervention for spelling problems: Teaching spelling units of varying size with a multiple connections framework. Journal of Educational Psychology, 90, 1-19.
5.
Blachman, B.A. (1994). What we have learned from longitudinal studies of phonological processing and reading, and some unanswered questions: A response to Torgesen, Wagner, and Rashotte. Journal of Learning Disabilities , 27, 287-291.
6.
Bowey, J.A. (1995). Socioeconomic status differences in preschool phonological sensitivity and first-grade reading achievement. Journal of Educational Psychology, 87, 476-487.
7.
Bradley, L., & Bryant, P.E. (1985). Rhyme and reason in reading and spelling. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press .
8.
Bryant, N.D. (1975). Diagnostic test of basic decoding skills. New York: Columbia University, Teachers College.
9.
Catts, H.W. (1993). The relationship between speech-language impairments and reading disabilities. Journal of Speech and Hearing Research , 36, 948-958.
10.
Clay, M. (1985). The early detection of reading difficulties (3rd ed.). Tadworth, Surrey: Heinemann.
11.
Deno, S.L. (1985). Curriculum-based measurement: The emerging alternative . Exceptional Children, 52, 219-232.
12.
Dolch, E.W. (1939). A manual for remedial reading. Champaign, IL: Garrard Press.
13.
Dunn, L.M., & Dunn, L. (1981). Peabody picture vocabulary test-Revised. Circle Pines, MN: American Guidance Service .
14.
Ehri, L.C. (1980). The development of orthographic images. In U. Frith (Ed.), Cognitive processes in spelling (pp. 311-338). London, England: Academic Press.
15.
Ehri, L.C., & Robbins, C. (1992). Beginners need some decoding skill to read words by analogy. Reading Research Quarterly, 27, 13-26.
16.
Ehri, L.C., & Wilce, L.S. (1985). Movement into reading: Is the first stage of printed word learning visual or phonetic?Reading Research Quarterly , 20, 163-179.
17.
Ellson, D.G., Harris, P., & Barber, L. (1968). A fieldtest of programmed and directed tutoring . Reading Research Quarterly, 3, 307-367.
18.
Fielding-Barnsley, R. (1997). Explicit instruction in decoding benefits children high in phonemic awareness and alphabet knowledge. Scientific Studies of Reading, 1, 85-98.
19.
Foorman, B.R., Francis, D.J., Beeler, T., Winikates, D., & Fletcher, J.M. (1997). Early interventions for children with reading problems: Study designs and preliminary findings. Learning Disabilities, 8, 63-71.
20.
Goswami, U., & Bryant, P. (1990). Phonological skills and learning to read. Hove, England: Erlbaum.
21.
Hatcher, P.J., Hulme, C., & Ellis, A.W. (1994). Ameliorating early reading failure by integrating the teaching of reading and phonological skills: The phonological linkage hypothesis. Child Development, 65, 41-57.
22.
Invernizzi, M., Juel, C., & Rosemary, C.A. (1997). A community volunteer tutorial that works. The Reading Teacher, 50, 304-311.
23.
Invernizzi, M., Rosemary, C., Juel, C., & Richards, H.C. (1997). At-risk readers and community volunteers: A 3-year perspective. Scientific Studies of Reading , 1, 277-300.
24.
Iversen, S., & Tunmer, W.E. (1993). Phonological processing skills and reading recovery program. Journal of Educational Psychology, 85, 112-126.
25.
Jastak, S., & Wilkinson, G.S. (1984). The wide range achievement test-Revised. Wilmington, DE: Jastak Associates.
26.
Jenkins, J.R., Vadasy, P.F., Firebaugh, M., & Profilet, K. (in press). Tutoring first-grade struggling readers in phonological reading skills. Learning Disabilities Research and Practice .
27.
Juel, C. (1988). Learning to read and write: A longitudinal study of 54 children from first through fourth grades. Journal of Educational Psychology, 80, 437-447.
28.
Juel, C. (1996). What makes literacy tutoring effective?Reading Research Quarterly, 30, 268-289.
29.
Juel, C., & Roper/Schneider, D. (1985). The influence of basal readers on first-grade reading. Reading Research Quarterly , 20, 134-152.
30.
Larsen, S.C., & Hammill, D.D. (1994). Test of written spelling (3rd ed.). Austin, TX: PRO-ED.
31.
Liberman, I.Y., Shankweiler, D., Blachman, B.A., Camp, L., & Werfelman, M. (1980). Steps towards literacy. In P. Levinson & C. Sloan (Eds.), Auditory processing and language: Clinical and research perspectives (pp. 189-215). New York: Grune & Stratton.
32.
Lovett, M.W., Borden, S.L., Deluca, T., Lacerenza, L., Benson, N.J., & Brackstone, D. (1994). Treating the core deficits of developmental dyslexia: Evidence of transfer of learning after phonologically and strategy-based reading training programs. Developmental Psychology, 30, 805-822.
33.
Madden, N.A., Slavin, R.E., Karweit, N.L., Dolan, L.J., & Wasik, B.A. (1993). Success for all: Longitudinal effects of a restructuring program for inner-city elementary schools. American Educational Research Journal, 30, 123-148.
34.
O'Connor, R.E. (1997, February). Layers of intervention. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Pacific Coast Research Conference, La Jolla, CA.
35.
O'Connor, R.E., Jenkins, J.R., & Slocum, T.A. (1995). Transfer among phonological tasks in kindergarten: Essential instructional content. Journal of Educational Psychology , 87, 202-217.
36.
Olson, R.K., Wise, B., Ring, J., & Johnson, M. (1997). Computer-based remedial training in phoneme awareness and phonological decoding: Effects on the post-training development of word recognition. Scientific Studies of Reading, 1, 235-254.
37.
Pinnell, G.S., Lyons, C.A., DeFord, D.E., Byrk, A.S., & Seltzer, M. (1994). Comparing instructional models for the literacy education of high-risk first graders. Reading Research Quarterly , 29, 9-39.
38.
Rosner, J. (1979). Helping children overcome learning disabilities (2nd ed.). New York: Walker.
39.
Samuels, S.J., & Flor, R.F. (1997). The importance of automaticity for developing expertise in reading. Reading and Writing Quarterly, 13, 107-122.
40.
Shanahan, T., & Barr, R. (1995). Reading Recovery: An independent evaluation of the effects of an early instructional intervention for at-risk children. Reading Research Quarterly, 30, 958-996.
41.
Share, D.L. (1995). Phonological recoding and self-teaching: Sine qua non of reading acquisition. Cognition, 55, 151-218.
42.
Share, D.L., & Stanovich, K.E. (1995). Cognitive processes in early reading development: Accommodating individual differences into a model of acquisition. Issues in Education, 1, 1-58.
43.
Silver, A.A., Hagin, R.A., & Beecher, R. (1981). A program for secondary prevention of learning disabilities: Research in academic achievement and in emotional adjustment. Journal of PreventivePsychiatry, 1, 77-87.
44.
Slavin, R.E., Madden, N.A., Karweit, N.L., Livermon, B.J., & Dolan, L. (1990). Success for All: First-year outcomes of a comprehensive plan for reforming urban education. American Educational Research Journal, 27, 255-278.
45.
Spear-Swerling, L., & Sternberg, R.J. (1996). Off track: When poor readers become 'learning disabled'. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
46.
Stanovich, K.E. (1986). Matthew effects in reading: Some consequences of individual differences in the acquisition of literacy. Reading Research Quarterly, 21, 360-406.
47.
Torgesen, J.K., Wagner, R.K., & Rashotte, C.A. (1994). Longitudinal studies of phonological processing and reading. Journal of Learning Disabilities , 27, 276-286.
48.
Torgesen, J.K., Wagner, R.K., & Rashotte, C.A. (1997). Prevention and remediation of severe reading disabilities: Keeping the end in mind. Scientific Studies in Reading, 1, 217-234.
49.
Torgesen, J.K., Wagner, R.K., Rashotte, C.A., Alexander, A.W., & Conway, T. (1997). Preventive and remedial interventions for children with severe reading disabilities. Learning Disabilities, 8, 51-61.
50.
Vadasy, P.F., Jenkins, J.R., Antil, L., Wayne, S., & O'Connor, R.E. (1997a). Community-based early reading intervention for at-risk first graders. Learning Disabilities Research and Practice, 12, 29-39.
51.
Vadasy, P.F., Jenkins, J.R., Antil, L., Wayne, S., & O'Connor, R.F. (1997b). The effectiveness of one-to-one tutoring by community tutors for at-risk beginning readers. Learning Disability Quarterly, 20, 126-139.
52.
Vadasy, P.F., Wayne, S.R., O'Connor, R.E., Jenkins, J.R., & Pool, K. (1998). Sound Partners: One-to-one tutoring in early reading skills. Manuscript submitted for publication.
53.
Vandervelden, M.C., & Siegel, L.S. (1997). Teaching phonological processing skills in early literacy: A developmental approach. Learning Disability Quarterly , 20, 63-82.
54.
Vellutino, F.R., Scanlon, D.M., Sipay, E.R., Small, S.G., Pratt, A., Chen, R., & Denckla, M.B. (1996). Cognitive profiles of difficult-to-remediate and readily re-mediated poor readers: Early intervention as a vehicle for distinguishing between cognitive and experiential deficits as basic causes of specific reading disability. Journal of Educational Psychology, 88, 601-638.
55.
Vellutino, F.R., Scanlon, D.M., & Tanzman, M.S. (1994). In G. R. Lyon (Ed.), Frames of reference for the assessment of learning disabilities: New views on measurement issues (pp. 279-332). Baltimore: Brookes.
56.
Venezky, R. (1970). The structure of English orthography. The Hague: Mouton.
57.
Wallach, M.A., & Wallach, L. (1976). Teaching all children to read. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
58.
Wasik, B.A. (1998). Volunteer tutoring programs in reading: A review . Reading Research Quarterly, 33, 266-292.
59.
Wasik, B.A., & Slavin, R.E. (1993). Preventing early reading failure with one-to-one tutoring: A review of five programs. Reading Research Quarterly , 28, 179-200.
60.
Williams, J.P. (1985). The case for explicit decoding instruction. In J. Osborn, P. Wilson, & R. Anderson (Eds.), Reading education: Foundations for a literate America (pp. 205-213). Lexington, MA: D.C. Health.
