This study compared the effectiveness of two reading interventions in a public school setting. Forty-five second-grade children with reading disabilities were randomly assigned to a 6-week phonological awareness, word analogy, or math-training program. The two reading interventions differed from each other in (a) the unit of word analysis (phoneme versus onset-rime), (b) the approach to intervention (contextualized versus decontextualized), and (c) the primary domain of reading instruction (oral versus written language). Results indicate that children in both reading programs achieved significant gains in beginning reading skills, learning the specific skills taught in their respective programs, and applying what they had learned to uninstructed material on several transfer-of-learning measures, in comparison to children in the control group. For children in both reading intervention groups, the most significant mediator of growth in oral reading fluency was a child's initial level of word identification skill. Implications of these findings are that systematic, high quality reading intervention can occur in a small group, public school setting and that there are several different paths to the remediation of children with reading disabilities.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Adams, M.J. (1990). Beginning to read: Thinking and learning about print. Cambridge, Massachusetts: The MIT Press.
2.
Alexander, A., Anderson, H., Heilman, P.C., Voeller, K.S., & Torgesen, J.K. (1991). Phonological awareness training and remediation of analytic decoding deficits in a group of severe dyslexics. Annals of Dyslexia, 41, 193-206.
3.
Ball, E.W., & Blachman, B.A. (1991). Does phoneme awareness training in kindergarten make a difference in early word recognition and developmental spelling?Reading Research Quarterly, 26, 49-66.
4.
Benson, N.J., Lovett, M.W., & Kroebler, C.L. (1997). Training and transfer-of-learning effects in disabled and normal readers: Evidence of specific deficits. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 64, 343-366.
5.
Bradley, L., & Bryant, P.E. (1983). Categorizing sounds and learning to read—A causal connection. Nature, 301, 419-421.
6.
Brown, A.L., Palincsar, A.S., & Purcell, L. (1986). Poor readers: Teach, don't label. In U. Neisser (Ed.), The school achievement of minority children (pp. 105-143). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
7.
Bryk, A.S., & Raudenbush, S.W. (1987). Application of hierarchical linear models to assessing change. Psychological Bulletin,101, 147-158.
8.
Carnine, D.W. (1977). Phonics versus look-say: Transfer to new words. ReadingTeacher, 30, 636-640.
9.
Chall, J.S. (1983). Stages of reading development. New York: McGraw-Hill.
10.
Cohen, J. (1988). Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences (2nd ed.). New York : Academic Press.
Daneman, M., & Carpenter, P.A. (1980). Individual differences in working memory and reading. Journal of Verbal Learning & Verbal Behavior, 19, 450-466.
13.
Deno, S.L. (1985). Curriculum-based assessment: The emerging alternative . Exceptional Children, 52, 219-232.
14.
Deno, S.L., & Mirkin, P.K. (1977). Data-based program modification: A manual. Res-ton, VA: Council for Exceptional Children.
15.
Ehri, L.C., & Robbins, C. (1992). Beginners need some decoding skill to read words by analogy. Reading Research Quarterly, 27, 12-26.
16.
Ehri, L.C., & Wilce, L.S. (1987). Does learning to spell help beginners learn to read words?Reading Research Quarterly, 22, 47-65.
17.
Fletcher, J.M., Shaywitz, S.E., Shankweiler, D.P., Katz, L., Liberman, I.Y., Stuebing, K.K., Francis, D.J., Fowler, A.E., & Shaywitz, B.A. (1994). Cognitive profiles of reading disability: Comparisons of discrepancy and low achievement definitions. Journal of Educational Psychology, 86, 6-23.
18.
Foorman, B.R., Francis, D.J., Novy, D.M., & Liberman, D. (1991). How letter-sound instruction mediates progress in first grade reading and spelling. Journal of Educational Psychology, 83, 456-469.
19.
Foorman, B.R., Francis, D.J., Winikates, D., Mehta, P., Schatschneider, C., & Fletcher, J.M. (1997). Early interventions for children with reading disabilities. Scientific Studies of Reading, 3, 255-276.
20.
Freebody, P., & Byrne, B. (1988). Word-reading strategies in elementary school children: Relations to comprehension, reading time, and phonemic awareness. Reading Research Quarterly, 23, 441-453.
21.
Gaskins, I.W., Downer, M.A., & Gaskins, R.W. (1986). The Benchmark School Word Identification/Vocabulary Development Program. Media, PA: Benchmark School.
22.
Glass, G.V., & Hopkins, K.D. (1984). Statistical methods in education and psychology (2nd ed.). Needham Heights, MA: Allyn & Bacon.
23.
Goswami, U., & Bryant, P. (1990). Phonological skills and learning to read. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
24.
Gresham, F.M., & Elliott, S.N. (1990). Social Skills Rating System. Circle Pines, MN: American Guidance Service.
25.
Hatcher, P.J., Hulme, C., & Ellis, A.W. (1994). Ameliorating early reading failure by integrating the teaching of reading and phonological skills: The phonological linkage hypothesis. Child Development, 65, 41-57.
26.
Hedges, L.V. (1987). How hard is hard science, how soft is soft science? The empirical cumulativeness of research. American Psychologist , 42, 443-455.
27.
Hintze, J.M., Shapiro, E.S., & Lutz, J.G. (1994). The effects of curriculum on the sensitivity of curriculum-based measurement in reading. The Journal of Special Education, 28, 188-202.
28.
Juel, C. (1988). Learning to read and write: A longitudinal study of fifty-four children from first through fourth grade. Journal of Educational Psychology, 80, 437-447.
29.
Juel, C., Griffith, P.L., & Gough, P.B. (1986). Acquisition of literacy: A longitudinal study of children in first and second grade. Journal of Educational Psychology, 78, 243-255.
30.
Juel, C., & Roper-Schneider, D. (1985). The influence of basal readers on first grade reading. Reading Research Quarterly , 20, 134-152.
31.
Lalli, P.E. & Shapiro, E.S. (1990). The effects of self-monitoring and contingent reward on sight word acquisition. Education and Treatment of Children, 13, 129-141.
32.
Liberman, I.Y., Shankweiler, D.P., & Liberman, A.M. (1989). The alphabetic principle and learning to read. In D. P. Shankweiler , & I. Y. Liberman (Eds.), Phonology and reading disability: Solving the puzzle (IARLD Monograph Series) . Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
33.
Lovett, M.W. (1991). Reading, writing, and remediation: Perspectives on the dyslexic learning disability from remedial outcome data. Learning and Individual Differences, 3, 295-305.
34.
Lovett, M.W., Borden, S.L., DeLuca, T., Lacerenza, L., Benson, N.J., & Brackstone, D. (1994). Treating the core deficits of developmental dyslexia: Evidence of transfer of learning after phonologically- and strategy-based reading training programs. Developmental Psychology, 30, 805-822.
35.
Lovett, M.W., Ransby, M.J., & Barron, R.W. (1988). Treatment, subtype, and word type effects in dyslexic children's response to remediation. Brain andLanguage, 34, 328-349.
36.
Lovett, M.W., Warren-Chaplin, P.M., Ransby, M.J., & Borden, S.L. (1990). Training the word recognition skills of reading disabled children: Treatment and transfer effects. Journal of Educational Psychology, 82, 769-780.
37.
Lyon, G.R., Vaasen, M., & Toomey, F. (1989). Teachers' perceptions of their undergraduate and graduate preparation. Teacher Education and Special Education , 12, 164-169.
38.
Manis, F.R., Custodio, R., & Szeszulski, P.A. (1993). Development of phonological and orthographic skill: A 2-year longitudinal study of dyslexic children. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 56, 64-86.
39.
Markwardt, F.C. (1989). Peabody Individual Achievement Test-Revised. Circle Pines, MN: American Guidance Service .
40.
Moats, L.C. (1994). The missing foundation in teacher education: Knowledge of the structure of spoken and written language. Annals of Dyslexia, 44, 81-102.
41.
Morrison, F.J., Smith, L., & Dow-Ehrensberger, M. (1995). A natural experiment . Developmental Psychology, 31, 789-799.
42.
Nagy, W.E., Anderson, R.C., & Herman, P.A. (1987). Learning word meanings from context during normal reading. American Educational Research Journal, 24, 237-270.
43.
Olson, R., Wise, B., Conners, F., Rack, J., & Fulker, D.W. (1989). Specific deficits in component reading and language skills: Genetic and environmental influences. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 22, 339-348.
44.
O'Shaughnessy, T.E. (1997). A comparison of two reading interventions for children with or at-risk for reading disabilities (Doctoral dissertation, University of California, Riverside, 1997). Dissertation Abstracts International.
45.
O'Shaughnessy, T.E., & Gresham, F.G. (1999). Effects of phonological awareness training or word analogy training on acquisition of beginning reading skills in children at-risk for reading failure. Manuscript submitted for publication.
46.
O'Shea, L.J., Munson, S.M., & O'Shea, D.J. (1984). Error correction in oral reading: Evaluating the effectiveness of three procedures. Education and Treatment of Children, 7, 203-214.
47.
Pressley, M. (1998). Reading instruction that works: The case for balanced teaching. New York: Guilford.
48.
Rack, J.P., Snowling, M.J., & Olson, R.K. (1992). The nonword reading deficit in developmental dyslexia: A review. Reading Research Quarterly, 27, 28-53.
49.
SAS Institute, Inc. (1995). JMP statistics and graphics software. Cary, NC: Author.
50.
Sattler, J.M. (1992). Assessment of children-Revised and updatedthird edition. San Diego: Jerome M. Sattler.
51.
Shinn, M.R. (1989). Identifying and defining academic problems: CBM screening and eligibility procedures. In M. R. Shinn (Ed.), Curriculum-based measurement: Assessing special children. New York: Guilford .
52.
Siegel, L.S. (1993). Phonological processing deficits as the basis of a reading disability [Special Issue: Phonological processes and learning disability]. Developmental Review, 13, 246-257.
53.
Snowling, M.J. (1996). Contemporary approaches to the teaching of reading . Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 37, 139-148.
54.
Stanovich, K.E. (1986). Matthew effects in reading: Some consequences of individual differences in the acquisition of literacy. Reading Research Quarterly, 21, 360-407.
55.
Stanovich, K.E. (1988). Explaining the differences between the dyslexic and the garden-variety poor reader: The phonological core variable difference model. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 21, 590-604.
56.
Stanovich, K.E., Cunningham, A.E., & Cramer, B. (1984). Assessing phonological awareness differences in early reading acquisition: Issues of task comparability. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 38, 175-190.
57.
Stanovich, K.E., & Siegel, L.S. (1994). Phenotypic performance profile of children with reading disabilities: A regression-based test of the phonological-core-variable-difference model. Journal of Educational Psychology, 86, 24-53.
Swanson, H.L. (1992). The generality and modifiability of working memory in skilled and less skilled readers. Journal of Educational Psychology, 84, 473-488.
60.
Swanson, H.L. (1996). Individual and age-related differences in children's working memory. Memory & Cognition, 24, 70-82.
61.
Swanson, H.L., O'Shaughnessy, T.E., Mc-Mahon, C., Hoskyn, M., & Sachse-Lee, C.M. (1998). Interventions for children and adults with learning disabilities: A selective synthesis of the intervention literature from 1966-1996. In T. C. Scruggs & M. A. Mastropieri (Eds.), Advances in learning and behavioral disabilities (Vol XI). Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
62.
Torgesen, J.K. (1977). The role of nonspecific factors in the task performance of learning disabled children: A theoretical assessment. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 10, 27-34.
Torgesen, J.K., & Bryant, B.R. (1994b). Test of Phonological Awareness. Austin, TX: PRO-ED.
65.
Torgesen, J.K., & Davis, C. (1996). Individual difference variables that predict response to training in phonological awareness. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 63, 1-21.
66.
Torgesen, J.K., Morgan, S., & Davis, C. (1992). The effects of two types of phonological awareness training on word learning in kindergarten children. Journal of Educational Psychology, 84, 364-370.
67.
Torgesen, J.K., Wagner, R.K., & Rashotte, C.A. (1994). Longitudinal studies of phonological processing and reading. Journal of Learning Disabilities , 5, 276-286.
68.
Torgesen, J.K., Wagner, R.K., Rashotte, C.A., Alexander, A.W., & Conway, T. (1997). Preventive and remedial interventions for children with severe reading disabilities. Learning Disabilities, 8, 51-61.
69.
Tunmer, W.E., & Hoover, W.A. (1993). Phonological recoding skill and beginning reading . Reading and Writing, 5, 161-179.
70.
Uhry, J.K., & Shepherd, M.J. (1997). Teaching phonological recoding to young children with phonological processing deficits: The effect on sight-vocabulary acquisition. Learning Disability Quarterly, 20, 104-125.
71.
Vellutino, F.R. (1979). Dyslexia: Theory and research. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
72.
Vellutino, F.R. (1987). Dyslexia. Scientific American , 256, 34-41.
73.
Vellutino, F.R., & Scanlon, D.M. (1987). Phonological coding, phonological awareness, and reading ability: Evidence from a longitudinal and experimental study. Merrill-Palmer Quarterly, 33, 321-363.
74.
Vellutino, F.R., Scanlon, D.M., Sipay, E.R., Small, S.G., Pratt, A., Chen, R., and Denckla, M.B. (1996). Cognitive profiles of difficult-to-remediate and readily remediated poor readers: Early intervention as a vehicle for distinguishing between cognitive and experiential deficits as basic causes of specific reading disability. Journal of Educational Psychology, 88, 601-638.
75.
Wagner, R.K., & Torgesen, J.K. (1987). The nature of phonological processing and its causal role in the acquisition of reading skills. Psychological Bulletin,101, 192-212.
76.
Wagner, R.K., Torgesen, J.K., & Rashotte, C.A. (1994). The development of reading-related phonological processing abilities: New evidence of bi-directional causality from a latent variable longitudinal study. Developmental Psychology , 30, 73-87.
77.
Wechsler, D. (1991). Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III. San Antonio, TX: Psychological Corp.
78.
Wechsler, D. (1992). Wechsler Individual Achievement Test. San Antonio, TX: Psychological Corp.
79.
Woodcock, R. (1987). Woodcock Reading Mastery Tests-Revised. Circle Pines, MN: American Guidance Service .
