In 1896 Beatrice Webb reported that those individuals opposed to special labour laws designed to protect women employees had formed a powerful alliance. The alignment of forces making up this alliance was composed of employers, free market economists and the middle-class wing of the movement for women's emancipation. In this paper it is argued that a similar alliance is active presently in Australia. Like its 1890s counterpart, this modern Australian alliance is campaigning for the abolition of certain special laws that exist to defend women employees from excessive demands on the part of employers. The paper discusses the nature of this alliance and examines one of its more recent successes. It is concluded that industrial relations analysts have paid insufficient attention to the protective character of these laws and that this is an omission that must be remedied.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Actu (1986), Executive Decision, ACTU Executive Meeting, 20 August (mimeo).
ACTU-VTHC Occupational Health and Safety Unit ( 1984), 'ACTU Health and Safety Preferred Standard: Manual Handling ', Health and Safety Bulletin, No. 40, July.
4.
ACTU-VTHC Occupational Health and Safety Unit ( 1984), 'Women and Occupational Health', Discussion paper, Health and Safety Bulletin, No. 41, September.
5.
Bacchi, C.L. (1990), Same Difference: Feminism and Sexual Difference , Allen & Unwin, Sydney.
6.
Bishop, P., Cureton, K. and Collins, M. (1987), 'Sex Difference in Muscular Strength in Equally-Trained Men and Women', Ergonomics30, pp. 675-87.
7.
Braithwaite, John and Grabosky, Peter (1985), Occupational Health and Safety Enforcement in Australia, Australian Institute of Criminology, Canberra.
8.
Buckland, D. (1985), 'A National Employer Perspective' in B. Creighton and N. Gunningham (eds), The Industrial Relations of Occupational Health and Safety, Croom Helm, Sydney, pp. 171-8.-
9.
Burvill, Chris (1985), 'Women and Protective Legislation', Refractory Girl28, May, pp. 27-9.
10.
Business Regulation Review Unit (1987), Review of Business Regulations. Information Paper No. 8, Safe Manual Handling , Commonwealth of Australia, AGPS , Canberra.
11.
Business Regulation Review Unit (1987), Safe Manual Handling, Information Paper Number 8, August, Department of Industry, Technology and Commerce, Canberra .
12.
Celentano, E.J. and Noy, L. (1981), Development of Occupational Physical Selection Standards for Canadian Forces Trades: Performance Considerations, Department of National Defence, Canada.
13.
Celentano, E.J., Nottrodt, J.W. and Saunders, P.L. (1984), 'The Relationship between Size, Strength and Task Demands', Ergonomics27, 5, May, pp. 481-8.
14.
Chaffin, D.B. (1974), 'Human Strength Capability and Low-Back Pain', Journal of Occupational Medicine16, pp. 248-54.
15.
Chaffin, D.B., Gary, D., Herrin and Monroe Keyserling, W. (1978 ), 'Pre-employment Strength Testing. An Updated Position', Journal of Occupational Medicine20, pp. 403-8.
16.
Confederation of Australian Industry (n.d.), Manual Handling, Position paper, Melbourne.
17.
Coote, A. (1975), Women Factory Workers. The Case Against Repealing the Protective Laws, National Council for Civil Liberties , London.
18.
Coussins, Jean (1979), The Shift Work Swindle, National Council for Civil Liberties, London.
19.
Coyle, Angela (1980), 'The Protection Racket', Feminist Review4, pp. 1-12.
20.
Creighton, B. and Gunningham, N. (eds) (1985), The Industrial Relations of Occupational Health and Safety, Croom Helm, Sydney.
21.
Creighton, W.B. (1979), Working Women and the Law, Mansell Publishing, London.
22.
Crompton, K.C. (1985), 'An Employers' Peak Council View', in B. Creighton and N. Gunningham (eds), The Industrial Relations of Occupational Health and Safety, Croom Helm, Sydney, pp. 179-89.
23.
Curthoys, A. (1988), For and Against Feminism—A Personal Journey into Feminist Theory and History, Allen & Unwin, Sydney.
24.
Denning, J. (1985), 'Women at Work', Occupational Safety andHealth, May, pp. 14-20.
25.
Draper, H. and Lipow, A. (1976), Marxist Women Versus Bourgeois Feminists', in R. Miliband and J. Saville (eds), The Socialist Register 1976, Merlin Press, London, pp. 179-226.
26.
Eldred, C.A. (1975), A Report of a Study of Women Training or Working in Outside Plant Craft Jobs in the Bell System, Westat, Inc., Rockville, Marylands.
27.
Employers Federation of New South Wales (1987 a), 'Employers' Federation Submission re: Manual Handling', in Employers' Review59 (5), March.
28.
Employers Federation of New South Wales (1987 b), 'Manual Handling', Employers' Review59 (21), November.
29.
Employers Federation of New South Wales (1987 c), 'National Occupational Health and Safety Commission Manual Handling', Employers' Review59 (4), supplement.
30.
Employers Federation of New South Wales (1987 d), 'Occupational Health and Safety Update', Employers' Review59 (1), January.
31.
Employers Federation of New South Wales (1987 e), 'Occupational Health and Safety Update', Employers' Review59 (14), July.
32.
Employers' Federation of New South Wales ( 1987f), 'Occupational Health and Safety Update', Employers' Review59 (15), August.
33.
Employers Federation of New South Wales (1987 g), 'Occupational Health and Safety Update', Employers' Review59 (16), August.
34.
Employers Federation of New South Wales (1987 h), Submission to the National Occupational Health and Safety Commission on Safe Manual Handling, March.
35.
Federated Miscellaneous Workers Union (1987 ), Manual Handling Policy (mimeo).
36.
Gunningham, N. (1985), 'Workplace Safety and the Law', in B. Creighton and N. Gunningham (eds), The Industrial Relations of Occupational Health and Safety, Croom Helm, Sydney, pp. 18-53.
37.
Hall, Philippa (1989), 'Equal Employment Opportunity and Occupational Health—Interface or Barrier?', Paper prepared and delivered at Worksafe seminar, November.
38.
Hopkins, A. and Parnell, N. (1984), 'Why Coal Mine Safety Regulations are Not Enforced ', in Roman Tomasic (ed), Business Regulation in Australia, CCH, Sydney.
39.
Howie, A. (1988), Manual Handling, Public Information Pamphlet, Number 15, Committee for Economic Development of Australia , March.
40.
Hutchins, B.L. and Harrison, A. (1966), A History of Factory Legislation, Frank Cass & Co., London.
41.
Larsson, Tore J. (1988), 'What Does Experience Tell Us?', Paper presented at the International Occupational Health and Safety Convention, October, Victoria.
42.
Lewis, J. and Davies, C. (1991), 'Protective Legislation in Britain, 1870-1990: Equality, Difference and their Implications for Women', Policy and Politics19 (1), pp. 13-25.
43.
Magora, A. (1970), 'Investigation of the Relation Between Low-Back Pain and Occupation: 1. Age, Sex, Community, Education and Other Factors', Industrial MedicalSurgery39 (6), pp. 376-82.
44.
Malker, B. and Zamore, K. (1987), 'Yrkesrelaterade belastningssjukdomar 1980-1983—en oversikt', in Lakartidningen84 (6), 376-82.
45.
Miller, A., Treiman, R., Donald, J., Cain, P.S. and Roos, P.A. (1980), Work, Jobs and Occupations: A Criticial Review of the 'Dictionary of Occupational Titles', National Academy Press, Washington DC.
46.
Mullen, E. (1990), 'Influences on Health and Safety Practices in New Zealand Enterprises', in Griffin Gerard (ed.), Current Research in Industrial Relations, AIRAANZ, Melbourne.
47.
National Council for Civil Liberties, Women's Rights Unit (1986), NCCL Briefing: Sex Discrimination Bill, NCCL, London.
48.
National Council for Civil Liberties, Rights for Women Unit (1987), Legislating for Change: NCCL's Response to the Equal Opportunities Commission's Consultative Document on Sex Discrimination Laws, 1976, NCCL.
49.
National Council for Civil Liberties, Rights for Women Unit (1988), Restriction or Protection? NCCL's Response to the Department of Employment's Consultative Document on the Restrictions on the Employment of Young People and the Removal of Sex Discrimination in Legislation, NCCL, London.
50.
Neary, J. (1991), 'Women's Occupational Health and Safety—Development and Repercussions', Paper presented to Women, Management and Industrial Relations Conference, July.
51.
New South Wales Anti-Discrimination Board ( 1984), Protective Legislation at Work: A Case Study of the 'Weight Limit' on Manual Handling, Government Printer, NSW.
52.
O'Donnell, C. (1984), The Basis of the Bargain: Gender, Schooling and Jobs, George Allen & Unwin, Sydney.
53.
O'Donnell, C. and Hall, P. (1988), Getting Equal—Labour Market Regulation and Women's Work, Allen & Unwin, Sydney.
54.
Shop Distributive and Allied Employees Association (1987), Submission to Victorian Occupational Health and Safety Commission on Draft Regulations and Code of Practice for Manual Handling , October.
55.
Ward, J.S. (1978), 'Sex Discrimination is Essential in Industry', Journal of Occupational Medicine20 (9), September, pp. 594-6.
56.
Wardle, M.G. and Gloss, D.S. (1980), 'Women's Capacities to Perform Strenuous Work ', Women and Health5 (2), Summer, pp. 5-15.
57.
Webb, B. (1896), Women and the Factory Acts, The Fabian Society, London.
58.
Wentworth, E. (1979), 'Protective Labour Legislation for Women and the (Victorian) Equal Opportunity Act, 1977', Research Project 730-413, November.
59.
Wills, D. (1987), 'Safe Manual Handling—A New Regulatory Playground ?', Business Council Bulletin34, May 1987, pp. 8-19.
60.
Worksafe (1990), National Approach to Occupational Health and Safety for Women Workers, National Occupational Health and Safety Commission, AGPS, Canberra.
61.
Worksafe (1986), Safe Manual Handling: Discussion Paper and Draft, Code of Practice, National Occupational Health and Safety Commission, AGPS, Canberra.
62.
Worksafe (1990), National Standard for Afanual Handling and National Code of Practice for Manual Handling, National Occupational Health and Safety Commission, AGPS, Canberra.
