Australian trade union use of financial information in second-tier bargaining may lead to information-disclosure disputes with employers. United Kingdom experience with the Employment Protection Act, 1975 is reviewed to identify the type of financial information likely to be the focus of such disputes. Prospects for resolution and policy options for mitigating the effects of similar financial information disclosure disputes in Australia are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ACAC (Australian Conciliation and Arbitration Commission) (1987), National Wage Case March 1987, Dec. 110/87, Print G6800.
2.
Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service ( 1977), 'Disclosure of Information to Trade Unions for Collective Bargaining Purposes', Code of Practice 2, HMSO.
3.
Amemic, J.H. (1985), 'The roles of accounting in collective bargaining ', Accounting, Organizations and Society10 (2), 227-53.
4.
ASRB (Accounting Standards Review Board) ( 1986), 'Accounting Standards Review Board— Procedures for the Approval of Accounting Standards', ASRB Release200.
5.
Australian Society of Accountants (1974), Disclosure of Forecasts, Bulletin no. 16, Melbourne, September.
6.
Australian Society of Accountants and the Institute of Chartered Accountants in Australia (1984), AAS 16 Statement of Accounting Standards 'Financial Reporting by Segments; Australian Society of Accountants Members Handbook, 1143-54.
7.
Bellace, J.R. & Gospel, H.F. (1983), 'Disclosure of information to trade unions: a comparative perspective', International Labour Review122 (1), 57-74.
8.
Confederation of British Industry (1975), 'The provision of information to employees', cited by R. Hussey and A. Marsh, Disclosure of Information and Employee Reporting, Gower , Aldershot, 1983.
9.
Craft, J.A. (1981), 'Information disclosure and the role of the accountant in collective bargaining', Accounting, Organizations and Society , 97-107.
10.
Craig, R.J. (1977a), 'Trade union use of company annual reports', The Chartered Accountant in Australia, May, 8-12.
11.
— (1977b), 'A profile of trade union use of company annual reports', The Chartered Accountant in Australia, August, 22-27.
12.
DEIR (Department of Employment and Industrial Relations) (1986), Industrial Democracy and Employee Participation , Working Environment Branch, AGPS, Canberra.
13.
Department of Trade (1987), Australia Reconstructed, Report by ACTU/TDC Members of the Mission to Western Europe, AGPS, Canberra.
14.
Foley, B.J. & Maunders, K.T. (1977), Accounting Information and Collective Bargaining, Macmillan, London.
15.
Goodwin, J. & Goodwin, D. (1987), 'AAS16: is it achieving its objective?', The Chartered Accountant in Australia, July, 40-5.
16.
Gospel, H. & Willman, P. (1981), 'Disclosure of information: the C.A.C. approach ', Industrial Law Journal10, 10-22.
17.
Hussey, R. & Marsh, A. (1983), Disclosure of Information and Employee Reporting , Gower, Aldershot, UK.
18.
Jackson-Cox, J., Thirkell, J. E. M & McQueeney,l. (1984), 'The disclosure of company information to trade unions: the relevance of the ACAS Code of Practice on Disclosure', Accounting, Organizations and Society9 (3/4), 253-73.
19.
Jager, M.O., Taylor, R.B. & Craig, R.J. (1987), Company Financial Statements: Form and Content , Butterworths, Sydney.
20.
Jones, K. (1981), 'A trade union view of disclosure' in A. Marsh & R. Hussey (eds), Employees, Trade Unions and Company Information: Research and Practice, BUIRA Conference Papers , Touche Ross & Co., London .
21.
Marsh, A. & Hussey, R. (1979), Disclosure to Unions-How the Law is Working, Touche Ross & Co. and St Edmund Hall Industrial Relations Annexe, London.
22.
Mitchell, R. (1978), 'The Employment Protection Act 1975 and the Extension of Industrial Democracy in Britain—Lessons for Australia', Australian Business Law Review, June, 105-29.
23.
Moore, R. (1980), 'Information to unions: use or abuse?', Personnel Management, May, 34-8.
24.
National Labour Consultative Council (1984 ), Guidelines on Information Sharing, AGPS , Canberra.
25.
Ogden, S. & Bougen, P. (1985), 'A radical perspective on the disclosure of accounting information to trade unions', Accounting, Organizations and Society10 (2), 211-24.
26.
Ormonde, P. (1985), "Opening the books: meeting the needs of shop stewards', Work andPeople11 (3), 3-5.
27.
Owen, D.L. & Lloyd, A.J. (1985), 'The use of financial information by trade union negotiators in plant level collective bargaining', Accounting, Organizations and Society10 (3), 329-50.
28.
Pillsbury, W.F. (1958), 'Organized labor's views of corporate financial information', Journal of Accountancy105, June, 46-56.
29.
Smith, R. & Manley, P.S. (1973), 'Company information and the development of collective bargaining', The Three Banks Review, no. 99, September, 27-48.
30.
Standish, P.M. (1975), 'Proposals for reform of Australian company financial disclosure requirements' in Australian Society of Accountants, Australian Company Financial Reporting, Bulletin no. 18, Melbourne, May, 1-82.
31.
Thomas, T. (1982), 'Now the shop floor demands information', Business Review Weekly, May 15-21, 49-51.
32.
Tuta (1983), Statement of Accord by the Australian Labor Party and The Australian Council of Trade Unions Regarding Economic Policy, TUTA Training Resources, February.
