Influences on Public Opinion of Unions and Industrial Relations

Abstract

The article attempts to explore the complex question of media influence on public opinion of unions and industrial relations by using social survey techniques. The findings indicate a general acceptance of unionism and the worker's right to withhold labour coupled to the view that this right is exercised too frequernly. Opinions on unions originated in the mass media, first- or second-hand experience and personal contacts, in that order. Attitudes to unions are closely related to political views and respondents with differing political views used different informa tion sources. Anti-union bias by the media seems to emerge only with respect to Labor Party voters. Liberal Party voters influenced by the media and first- or second-hand experience are less anti-union than those influenced by personal net works. Data on politically polarised statements also support the view of the media as a moderating influence compared to personal neuvorks.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ashbolt, A. (1975), 'Mass Media: Structure, Functioning and Control' , in E. L. Wheelwright & K. Buckley , eds, Essays in the Political Economy of Australian Capitalism, vol. 1, Australian and New Zealand Book Co., Sydney.

Beharrell, P. & Philo, G. , eds (1979), Trade Unions and the Media , Macmillan, London.

Blumler, J.G. & Ewbank, A.J. (1970), 'Trade Unionists, The Mass Media and Unofficial Strikes', British Journal of Industrial Relations 8, 32-54.

Boetcher, W. (1980), address to the Annual Convention, Industrial Relations Society of Western Australia, Bunbury.

Cater, D. (1959), The Fourth Branch of Governmenl, Houghton-Miflin, Boston.

Connell, R.W. (1977), Ruling Class, Ruling Culture, Cambridge University Press, Melbourne.

Davies, A.F. (1970), 'Mass Communications', in A. F. Davies & S. Encel , eds, Australian Society, Cheshire, Melbourne .

— (1972), 'Political Sociology', in F. J. Hunt , ed., Socialisation in Australia, Angus and Robertson, Sydney.

Davis, E. (1979), 'Community Attitudes Towards Trade Unions', Journal of Industrial Relations 21, 381-97.

10.

Dufty, N.F. (1979), Industrial Relations in the Public Sector—The Firemen, University of Queensland Press, Brisbane.

11.

— (1980), 'Unions, Politics, Worker Participation and the Industrial Relations Climate', Human Resource Management Australia 18, 32-5.

12.

Glasgow University Media Group (1976), Bad News, vol. 1, Routledge & Kegan Paul, London.

13.

Gordon, M.E. , Philpot, J.W. , Burt, R.E. , Thompson, C.A. & Spiller, W.E. (1980), 'Commitment to the Union: Development of a Measure and an Examination of its Correlates', Journal of Applied Psychology Monograph 65, 479-99.

14.

Key, V.O. (1964), Public Opinion and American Democracy, Knopf, Chicago.

15.

MacDonald, R. (1979), 'Press Coverage of Industrial Relations in Australia ', Journal of Industrial Relations 21, 497-502.

16.

Mayer, H. (1964), The Press in Australia, Lansdowne , Melbourne.

17.

McColl, M. (1980), 'Mass Media and Industrial Relations News: A Case Study', Journal of Industrial Relations 22, 420-41.

18.

McKenzie, R. & Silver, A. (1968), Angels in Afarble, Heinemann , London.

19.

McQuail, D. (1969), Towards a Sociology of Mass Communications, Collier Macmillan, London.

20.

McQueen, H. (1977), Australia's Media Monopolies, Widescope, Melbourne.

21.

Ostell, A. , Macfarlane, I. & Jackson, A. (1980), 'Evaluating the Impact of a Communication Exercise in an Industrial Works', Industrial Relations Journal 11, 37-48.

22.

O'Sullivan, D. (1980), address to the Annual Convention, Industrial Relations Society of Western Australia, Bunbury.

23.

Playford, J. (1972), 'Who Rules Australia?', in J. Playford & D. Kirsner , eds, Australian Capitalism, Pelican Books, Ringwood, Vic.

24.

Power, J. , ed. (1968), Politics in a Suburban Community, Sydney University Press, Sydney.

25.

Sinclair, C. (1980), The Attitude of the Community Towards Trade Unions in Western Australia, unpublished paper, Department of Social Sciences, WA Institute of Technology.

26.

Thomson, D. (1971). 'Capitalism and the Mass Media'. Australian Left Review 31.

27.

Turner, H.A.T. (1969), Is Britain Really Strike-Prone? A Review of the Character and Costs of Industrial Conflict, University of Cambridge.

28.

Walsh, M. (1976), 'Bias in News Reporting', in G. Major , ed., Mass Media in Australia, Hodder & Stoughton, Sydney.

29.

Western, J.S. & Hughes, C.A. (1971), The Mass Media in Australia, University of Queensland Press, Brisbane.