Unbundling workplace conflict: Exploring the relationship between grievances and non-strike industrial actions and the moderating effect of voice mechanisms
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online February, 2023
Unbundling workplace conflict: Exploring the relationship between grievances and non-strike industrial actions and the moderating effect of voice mechanisms
Given that an understanding of the inter-relationships among workplace conflict expressions is necessary for effective dispute resolution, this study explores the moderating roles of various types of voice mechanisms in the relationship between grievances and non-strike industrial actions. Using data from the Statistics Canada's Workplace and Employee Survey, we found evidence that a positive relationship between grievances and non-strike industrial action (e.g. slowdowns, work-to-rule, etc.) is stronger in workplaces with weaker union voice, is weaker in non-union workplaces with more extensive high-involvement work systems, and was not affected by the presence of alternative dispute resolution systems. Our findings provide theoretical insights into the role of voice mechanism in the inter-relationships between individual and collective forms of conflict in both union and non-union environments. The results also have practical implications for dispute resolution in terms of the management of conflict and dispute systems design.
AngristJPischkeJS (2009) Mostly Harmless Econometrics: An Empiricist’s Companion. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
2.
AnnerMLiuX (2015) Harmonious unions and rebellious workers: A study of wildcat strikes in Vietnam. Industrial and Labor Relations Review69(1): 3–28.
3.
AselageJEisenbergerR (2003) Perceived organizational support and psychological contracts: A theoretical integration. Journal of Organizational Behavior24(5): 491–509.
4.
AustrinT (1995) Positioning resistance and resisting position: Human resource management and the politics of appraisal and grievance hearings. In: JermierJMKnightsDNordWR (eds) Resistance and Power in Organizations. London, UK: Routledge, 199–218.
5.
BarkerJR (1993) Tightening the iron cage: Concertive control in self-managing teams. Administrative Science Quarterly38(3): 408–437.
6.
BarryMWilkinsonA (2016) Pro-social or pro-management? A critique of the conception of employee voice as a pro-social behaviour within organizational behaviour. British Journal of Industrial Relations54(2): 261–284.
7.
BlauPM (1964) Exchange and Power in Social Life. New York: Wiley.
8.
BoroffKELewinD (1997) Loyalty, voice and intent to exit a union firm: A conceptual and empirical analysis. Industrial and Labor Relations Review51(1): 50–63.
9.
BoswellWROlson-BuchananJB (2004) Experiencing mistreatment at work: The role of grievance filing, nature of mistreatment, and employee withdrawal. Academy of Management Journal47(1): 129–139.
10.
BowenDEOstroffC (2004) Understanding HRM-firm performance linkages: The role of the strength of the HRM system. Academy of Management Review29(2): 203–221.
11.
BrayMMcCrystalSSpiessL (2020) Why doesn’t anyone talk about non-union collective agreements?Journal of Industrial Relations62(5): 784–807.
12.
BrocknerJTylerTRCooper-SchneiderR (1992) The influence of prior commitment to an institution and reactions to perceived unfairness: The higher they are, the harder they fall. Administrative Science Quarterly37(2): 241–261.
13.
BrysonACharlwoodAForthJ (2006) Worker voice, managerial response and labour productivity: An empirical investigation. Industrial Relations Journal37(5): 438–455.
14.
BuddJWColvinAJS (2008) Improved metrics for workplace dispute resolution procedures: Efficiency, equity, and voice. Industrial Relations47(3): 460–479.
15.
ClawsonDClawsonMA (1999) What has happened to the US labor movement? Union decline and renewal. Annual Review of Sociology25: 95–119.
16.
ColvinAJS (2003) Institutional pressures, human resource strategies, and the rise of nonunion dispute resolution procedures. Industrial and Labour Relations Review56(3): 375–392.
17.
ColvinAJS (2004) The relationship between employee involvement and workplace dispute resolution. Relations Industrielles/Industrial Relations59(4): 681–704.
18.
ColvinAJS (2013) Participation versus procedures in non-union dispute resolution. Industrial Relations: A Journal of Economy and Society52(3): 259–283.
19.
CreganC (2013) Does workplace industrial action increase trade union membership?An exchange relationship approach to union joining and leaving behaviour. International Journal of Human Resource Management24(17): 3363–3377.
DegoeyP (2000) Contagious justice: Exploring the social construction of justice in organizations. In: StawBMSuttonRI (Eds.), Research in Organizational Behavior, Greenwich, CT: JAI Press. vol. 22,51–102.
22.
EatonAEGordonMEKeefeJ (1992) The impact of quality of work life programs and grievance system effectiveness on union commitment. Industrial and Labor Relations Review45(3): 591–604.
23.
EdwardsPK (1986) Conflict at Work: A Materialist Analysis of Workplace Relations. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
24.
EdwardsPK (1995) Human resource management, union voice and the use of discipline: An analysis of WIRS3. Industrial Relations Journal26(3): 204–220.
25.
FakhfakhFRobinsonATallA (2019) Financial participation and collective conflicts: Evidence from French firms. Industrial Relations: A Journal of Economy and Society58(4): 674–703.
26.
FantasiaR (1983) The wildcat strike and industrial relations. Industrial Relations Journal14(2): 74–86.
27.
FeuillePChachereDR (1995) Looking fair or being fair: Remedial voice procedures in nonunion workplaces. Journal of Management21(1): 27–42.
28.
FoleyJR (2003) Mobilization and change in a trade union setting: Environment, structures and action. Work, Employment & Society17(2): 247–268.
29.
FreemanRB (2004) What do unions do?: The 2004 M-brane Stringtwister Edition. Journal of Labor Research26(4): 641–668.
30.
FreemanRBMedoffJL (1984) What Do Unions Do?New York: Basic Books.
31.
GahanPPekarekA (2012) Social movement theory, collective action frames and union theory: A critique and extension. British Journal of Industrial Relations51(4): 234–262.
32.
GallG (2013) New Forms and Expressions of Conflict at Work. Palgrave Macmillan.
33.
GallGHebdonRP (2008) Conflict at work. In: BlytonPHeeryEBaconNFioritoJ (eds) The SAGE Handbook of Industrial Relations. Los Angeles: Sage, 588–605.
34.
GallGKirkE (2018) Striking out in a new direction? Strikes and the displacement thesis. Capital & Class42(2): 195–203.
35.
GodardJ (2011) What has happened to strikes?British Journal of Industrial Relations49(2): 282–305.
36.
GollanPJ (2000) Non-union forms of employee representation in the United Kingdom and Australia. In: Kaufman B and Taras D (ed), Nonunion Employee Representation:History, Contemporary Practice and Policy. New York: M. E. Sharpe, 410–449.
37.
GollanPJKaufmanBETarasD. (2014) Voice and Involvement at Work: Experience with Non-Union Representation. Routledge.
38.
GuryanJ (2004) Desegregation and black dropout rates. American Economic Review94(4): 919–943.
39.
HainesVYJalettePLaroseK (2010) The influence of human resource management practices on employee voluntary turnover rates in the Canadian non-governmental sector. Industrial & Labor Relations Review63(1): 228–340.
40.
HebdonRP (2005) Toward a theory of workplace conflict: The case of US municipal collective bargaining. Advances in Industrial and Labor Relations14: 33–65.
41.
HebdonRPNohSC (2013) A theory of workplace conflict development: From grievances to strikes. In: GallG (ed) New Forms and Expressions of Conflict at Work. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 26–47.
42.
HebdonRPSternRN (1998) Tradeoffs among expressions of industrial conflict: Public sector strike bans and grievance arbitrations. Industrial and Labor Relations Review51(2): 204–221.
43.
HeckscherCMcCarthyJ (2014) Transient solidarities: Commitment and collective Action in post-industrial societies. British Journal of Industrial Relations52(4): 627–657.
44.
HeeryEConleyH (2007) Frame extension in a mature social movement: British trade unions and part-time work, 1967–2002. Journal of Industrial Relations49(1): 5–29.
45.
HodsonR (1997) Individual voice on the shop floor: The role of unions. Social Forces75(4): 1183–1212.
46.
HollandPCooperBKPymanA, et al. (2012) Trust in management: The role of employee voice arrangements and perceived managerial opposition to unions. Human Resource Management Journal22(4): 377–391.
47.
IlesPMabeyCRobertsonI (1990) HRM practices and employee commitment: Possibilities, pitfalls and paradoxes. British Journal of Management1(3): 147–157.
48.
JostJTBanajiMRNosekBA (2004) A decade of system justification theory: Accumulated evidence of conscious and unconscious bolstering of the status quo. Political Psychology25(6): 881–919.
49.
KaufmanBE (2015) Theorizing determinants of employee voice: An integrative model across disciplines and levels of analysis. Human Resource Management Journal25(1): 19–40.
50.
KaufmanBETarasDG (2010) Employee participation through non-union forms of employee representation. In: WilkinsonAGollanPMarchingtonMLewinD (eds) The Oxford Handbook of Participation in Organizations. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 258–285.
51.
KellyJE (1998) Rethinking Industrial Relations: Mobilization, Collectivism, and Long Waves. London; New York: Routledge.
52.
KellyJE (2005) Social movement theory and union revitalization in Britain. In: FernieSMetcalfD (eds) Trade Unions: Resurgence or Demise?London: Routledge, 62–82.
53.
KlaasBSWardAK (2015) Formal, justice-oriented voice in the nonunion firm: Who speaks up and when?Industrial Relations: A Journal of Economy and Society54(2): 321–356.
54.
KlaasBSOlson-BuchananJBWardAK (2012) The determinants of alternative forms of workplace voice an integrative perspective. Journal of Management38(1): 314–345.
55.
LangfordT (1996) Effects of strike participation on the political consciousness of Canadian postal workers. Relations Industrielles/Industrial Relations51(3): 563–585.
56.
LarochePSalesinaM (2017) The effects of union and nonunion forms of employee representation on high-performance work systems: New evidence from French microdata. Human Resource Management56(1): 173–189.
57.
LeungKChiuWAuY (1993) Sympathy and support for industrial actions: A justice analysis. Journal of Applied Psychology78(5): 781–787.
58.
LewinD (2005) Unionism and employment conflict resolution: Rethinking collective voice and its consequences. Journal of Labor Research26(2): 209–239.
59.
LewinDPetersonRB (1999) Behavioral outcomes of grievance activity. Industrial Relations38(4): 554–576.
60.
LidenRCWayneSJKraimerML, et al. (2003) The dual commitments of contingent workers: An examination of contingents’ commitment to the agency and the organization. Journal of Organizational Behavior24(5): 609–625.
61.
LindEAVan den BosK (2002) When fairness works: Toward a general theory of uncertainty management. In: Staw BM, and Kramer RM (eds), Research in Organizational Behavior. Boston: Elsevier, vol. 24: 181–223.
62.
LobelO (2004) Between solidarity and individualism: Collective efforts for social reform in the heterogeneous workplace. In: DiTomaso N and Post C (eds) Diversity in the Work Force (Research in the Sociology of Work, Vol. 14), Emerald Group Publishing Limited, Bingley, 131–164.
63.
MarchingtonM (2007) Employee voice systems. In: BoxallPFPurcellJWrightPM (eds) The Oxford Handbook of Human Resource Management. Oxford; New York: Oxford University Press, 231–250.
64.
MarchingtonMSuterJ (2013) Where informality really matters: Patterns of employee involvement and participation (EIP) in a non-union firm. Industrial Relations52(1): 284–313.
65.
McCabeDM (1997) Alternative dispute resolution and employee voice in nonunion employment: An ethical analysis of organizational due process procedures and mechanisms–the case of the United States. Journal of Business Ethics16(3): 349–356.
66.
McCabeDMLewinD (1992) Employee voice: A human-resource management perspective. California Management Review34(3): 112–123.
67.
McDonaldJT (2000) Industrial dispute tactics in Australian manufacturing. Industrial Relations39(1): 115–138.
68.
MooreSReadI (2006) Collective organization in small- and medium-sized enterprises: An application of mobilization theory. Human Resource Management Journal16(4): 357–375.
69.
MorrillCZaldMNRaoH (2003) Covert political conflict in organizations: Challenges from below. Annual Review of Sociology29: 391–416.
70.
NijmanTVerbeekM (1992) Nonresponse in panel data: The impact on estimates of a life cycle consumption function. Journal of Applied Econometrics7(3): 243–257.
71.
O’ReillyJAquinoKSkarlickiD (2016) The lives of others: Third parties’ responses to others’ injustice. Journal of Applied Psychology101(2): 171–196.
72.
PohlerDLuchakA (2015) Are unions good or bad for organizations? The moderating role of management’s response. British Journal of Industrial Relations53(3): 423–459.
73.
PollertACharlwoodA (2009) The vulnerable worker in Britain and problems at work. Work, Employment & Society23(2): 343–362.
74.
Schulze-ClevenT (2017) Collective action and globalization: Building and mobilizing labour power. Journal of Industrial Relations59(4): 397–419.
75.
ShoaibSBaruchY (2019) Deviant behavior in a moderated-mediation framework of incentives, organizational justice perception, and reward expectancy. Journal of Business Ethics157(3): 617–633.
76.
SkarlickiDPKulikCT (2004) Third-party reactions to employee (Mis)treatment: A justice perspective. In Staw B and Kramer R (eds), Research in Organizational Behavior. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press, vol. 26: 183–230.
77.
SkarlickiDPEllardJHKellnBRC (1998) Third-party perceptions of a layoff: Procedural, derogation, and retributive aspects of justice. Journal of Applied Psychology83(1): 119–127.
78.
StandingG (2009) Work after Globalization: Building Occupational Citizenship. Cheltenham, UK; Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar.
79.
Stepan-NorrisJZeitlinM (1991) Red unions and bourgeois contracts?American Journal of Sociology96(5): 1151–1200.
80.
SunLYAryeeSLawKS (2007) High-performance human resource practices, citizenship behavior, and organizational performance: A relational perspective. Academy of Management Journal50(3): 558–577.
81.
TanguyJ (2013) Collective and individual conflicts in the workplace: Evidence from France. Industrial Relations: A Journal of Economy and Society52(1): 102–133.
82.
TassinariAMaccarroneV (2020) Riders on the storm: Workplace solidarity among gig economy couriers in Italy and the UK. Work, Employment and Society34(1): 35–54.
83.
ThompsonSLSalmonJW (2006) Strikes by physicians: A historical perspective toward an ethical evaluation. International Journal of Health Services36(2): 331–354.
84.
UmphressEELabiancaGBrassDJ, et al. (2003) The role of instrumental and expressive social ties in employees’ perceptions of organizational justice. Organization Science14(6): 738–753.
85.
WalkerM (2021) Peer-to-peer online voice as emergent collective action. Journal of Industrial Relations63(5): 273–301.
86.
WilkinsonAFayC (2011) New times for employee voice?Human Resource Management50(1): 65–74.
87.
WilkinsonABarryMGomezR, et al. (2018) Taking the pulse at work: An employment relations scorecard for Australia. Journal of Industrial Relations60(2): 145–175.
88.
WillmanPBrysonAForthJ (2020) UK unions, collective action and the cost disease. British Journal of Industrial Relations58(2): 447–470.
WooldridgeJ (2006) Introductory Econometrics: A Modern Approach. Mason, OH: Thomson/South-Western.
91.
ZatzickCDIversonRD (2006) High-involvement management and workforce reduction: Competitive advantage or disadvantage?Academy of Management Journal49(5): 999–1021.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
