This article examines how the union and management determine the duration of the collective agreement in a decentralized bargaining system characterized by the absence of a rule establishing a maximum duration. Based on information on a population of over 5000 collective agreements and bargaining pairs from the Canadian province of Québec, our analysis reveals that establishment-level collective agreement duration is the result of general economic conditions, but also of coercive comparisons, as well as the parties’ resources and capacities and relative bargaining power, and the characteristics of their interactions. This case shows how contract duration is a strategic issue in establishment-level negotiations where the balance of power generally favours employers.
AnnisP (2008) Work Stoppages in the Federal Private Sector: Innovative Solutions.
Ottawa:
Human Resources and Skills Development Canada.
2.
BamberGSheldonPGanB (2010) Collective bargaining: International developments and challenges. In: BanplainR (ed.) Comparative Labour Law and Industrial Relations in Industrialized Market Economies, 10th edn.
The Hague:
Kluwer Law International, pp. 609–657.
3.
Canadian Auto Workers (CAW) (1997) Discussion Paper: Long Term Agreements: The New Concession, Toronto: CAW.
4.
ChamberlainNW (1958) Labor.
New York:
McGraw-Hill.
5.
ChristofidesLNPengAC (2006)
Contract duration and indexation in a period of real and nominal uncertainty.Labour Economics13(1): 61–86.
6.
ChristofidesLNPengAC (2010)
Labor contract duration, indexation, and wage adjustment: Interdependence and inflation propagation mechanisms.Industrial Relations49(2): 226–247.
7.
CraneDP (1990) Patterns of Industrial Peace: Case Studies of Cooperative Collective Bargaining Relationships.
Atlanta:
Georgia State University Business Press.
8.
DunlopJT (1993) Industrial Relations Systems.
Boston, MA:
Harvard Business School.
9.
EatonJVermaA (2006)
Does “fighting back” make a difference? The case of the Canadian Auto Workers Union.Journal of Labour Research27(2): 187–212.
10.
Employment and Social Development Canada (ESDC) (2014)Overview of Collective Bargaining in Canada 2013.
Ottawa:
Workplace Information and Research Division.
11.
FosterGKalenkoskiCM (2010) Tobit or OLS? An Empirical Evaluation Under Different Diary Window Lengths. Research Paper No. 2010 Econ 01. Sydney: Australian School of Business, The University of New South Wales.
12.
GilesAMurrayG (1988)
Towards an historical understanding of industrial relations theory in Canada.Relations industrielles/Industrial Relations43(4): 780–812.
13.
Gouvernement du Québec (2014) Portrait Économique des Régions du Québec.
Québec:
Ministère de l’économie, de l’innovation et des exportations.
14.
GreerIHauptmeierM (2016)
Management whipsawing: The staging of labor competition under globalization.Industrial & Labor Relations Review69(1): 29–52.
15.
HayterS (ed.) (2011) The Role of Collective Bargaining in the Global Economy: Negotiating for Social Justice.
Cheltenham:
Edward Elgar Publishing.
16.
JaletteP (2011)
Relocation threats and actual relocations in Canadian manufacturing: The role of firm capacity and union concessions.American Behavioral Scientist55(7): 843–867.
17.
JaletteP (2015) Relocation of production activities and underlying social dynamics: An analytical framework based on a Canadian perspective. In: BrysonJClarkJVanchanV (ed.) Handbook of Manufacturing Industries in the World Economy.
Cheltenham:
Edward Elgar, pp. 84–99.
18.
Jalette P, Laroche M and Trudeau G (2017) Evolution of the collective agreement in Québec: Outcomes and trends. In: Jalette P, Laroche M and Trudeau G (eds) La Convention Collective au Québec, 3rd edn.
Montréal:
Chenelière Éducation, pp. 461–494 (in French).
19.
KristensenPHMorganG (2012)
From institutional change to experimentalist institutions.Industrial Relations51(1): 413–437.
20.
LabrosseA (2018) La Présence Syndicale au Québec en 2016.
Québec:
Secrétariat du travail direction de l’information sur le travail.
21.
Laroche M, Jalette P and Duguay FL (2014)
The increased duration of Quebec workers’ collective agreements over 20 years: New normal, consolidated partnership, or manifestation of corporate power?Revue de l’Institut de Recherches Économiques et Sociales (IRES)3: 63–88 (in French).
22.
LévesqueCMurrayG (2005)
Union involvement in workplace change: A comparative study of local unions in Canada and Mexico.British Journal of Industrial Relations43(3): 489–514.
23.
LongJS (1997) Regression Models for Categorical and Limited Dependent Variables.
Thousand Oaks, CA:
SAGE.
24.
MarginsonPGalettoM (2016)
Engaging with flexibility and security: Rediscovering the role of collective bargaining.Economic and Industrial Democracy37(1): 95–117.
25.
MurphyKJ (2000)
What effect does uncertainty have on the length of labor contracts?Labour Economics7: 181–201.
26.
MurrayG (2012)
Can multiple weak ties reverse the social regulation deficit? Multinational companies and labor regulation.Comparative Labor Law & Policy Journal33(4): 715–747.
27.
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) (2017) OECD Employment Outlook 2017.
Paris:
OECD Publishing.
28.
PaolucciV (2017)
The role of collective bargaining in addressing flexibility and security.European Journal of Industrial Relations23(4): 329–346.
29.
RossAM (1948) Trade Union Wage Policy.
Berkeley and Los Angeles, CA:
University of California Press.
30.
SlichterSHHealyJJLivernashER (1960) The Impact of Collective Bargaining on Management.
Washington, DC:
Brookings Institution.
31.
StieberJ (1959) Evaluation of long-term contracts. In: DaveyHWKaltembornHSRutenbergSH (eds) New Dimensions in Collective Bargaining.
New York:
Harper, pp. 137–153.
32.
WaltonRCutcher-GershenfeldJEMcKersieRB (1994) Strategic Negotiations: A Theory of Change in Labor-Management Relations.
Boston, MA:
Harvard Business School Press.
