This paper offers an alternative framework for characterizing individualism and collectivism. This framework is constructed in terms of three dimensions of the employment relationship — who makes the rules; who is covered by the rules; and who enforces the rules. The value of the framework is demonstrated by applying it to the analysis of awards in Australia, revealing fundamental changes in the individualist/ collectivist character of awards over the last 20 years.
Australian Bureau of Statistics (2010) Survey of Employee Earnings and Hours, Cat. No. 6306.0. Canberra: ABS.
3.
Australian Industrial Relations Commission ( 2002) 2001-2 Annual Report. Canberra, Commonwealth of Australia, p. 236.
4.
Australian Industrial Relations Commission ( 2008) Decision: Award Modernisation, Commonwealth of Australia . AM2008\1-12, p. 68. Melbourne: Australian Industrial Relations Commission.
5.
Australian Industrial Relations Commission ( 2009) Aluminium Industry Modern Award 2010. Melbourne: AIRC.
6.
Bray M. and Underhill E.(2009) Industry differences in the neo-liberalist transformation of Australian industrial relations. Industrial Relations Journal40(5): 372-393.
7.
Bray M. and Waring P. ( 2005) ‘Complexity’ and ‘Congruence’ in Australian Labour Regulation. Journal of Industrial Relations47(1): 1-15.
8.
Bray M., Waring P. and Cooper R. ( 2009) Employment Relations: Theory and Practice. Melbourne: McGraw-Hill.
9.
Briggs C. and Cooper R. ( 2007) Between individualism and collectivism? Why employers choose non-union collective agreements. Labour and Industry17(2): 1-23.
10.
Brown W. ( 1999) Individualisation and union recognition in Britain in the 1990s. In: Deery S and Mitchell R, eds, Employment Relations: Individualisation and Union Exclusion - An International Study, pp. 153-171. Sydney : Federation Press.
11.
Brown W., Deakin S., Nash D. and Oxenbridge S. ( 2000) The employment contract: From collective procedures to industrial rights. British Journal of Industrial Relations38(4): 611-629.
12.
Catanzariti J. and Youl F. ( 1991) Industrial relations legislation in 1990. Journal of Industrial Relations33(1): 80-90.
13.
Colling T. ( 2006) What space for unions on the floor of rights? Trade unions and the enforcement of statutory individual rights. Industrial Law Journal35(2): 140-160.
14.
Cooper R. and Ellem B. ( 2008) The neoliberal state, trade unions and collective bargaining in Australia. British Journal of Industrial Relations46(3): 532-554.
15.
Coulthard A. ( 1997) The individualisation of Australian labour law . International Journal of Comparative Labour Law and Industrial Relations13: 95-112.
16.
Coulthard A. ( 1999) The decollectivisation of Australian industrial relations: Trade union exclusion under the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) . In: Deery S and Mitchell R, eds, Employment Relations: Individualisation and Union Exclusion - An International Study, pp. 48-68. Sydney : Federation Press.
17.
Creighton B. ( 2003) Modernising Australian labour law: Individualisation and the shift from ‘compulsory’ conciliation and arbitration to enterprise bargaining. In: Blanpain R and Weiss M, eds, Changing Industrial Relations and Modernisation of Labour Law. The Hague: Kluwer Law International.
18.
Creighton B. and Stewart A. ( 2005) Labour Law. Sydney: Federation Press.
19.
Deery S. and Mitchell R. ( 1999) Employment Relations: Individualisation and Union Exclusion - An International Study. Sydney: Federation Press.
20.
Dickens L. ( 2002) Individual statutory employment rights since 1997: Constrained expansion. Employee Relations24(6): 619-637.
21.
Dickens L. and Hall M. ( 2009) Legal regulation and the changing workplace. In: Brown W, Bryson A, Forth J and Whitfield K, eds, The Evolution of the Modern Workplace, pp. 332-352. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press.
22.
Fenwick C. ( 2006) How low can you go? Minimum working conditions under Australia’s new labour laws. Economic and Labour Relations Review16: 127-146.
23.
Fenwick C. and Howe J. ( 2009) Union security after Work Choices. In: Forsyth A and Stewart A, eds, Fair Work: The New Workplace Laws and the Work Choices Legacy , pp. 164-185. Sydney: Federation Press.
24.
Ford B. ( 2000) Being there: Changing union rights of entry under federal industrial law. Australian Journal of Labour Law13(1): 1-27.
25.
Frazer A. ( 1995) Trade unions under compulsory arbitration and enterprise bargaining: An historical perspective. In: Ronfeldt P and McCallum R, eds, Enterprise Bargaining: Trade Unions and the Law, pp. 52-83. Annandale : Federation Press.
26.
Goodwin M. and Maconachie G. ( 2005) Employer evasion of worker entitlements 1986-95: What and whose?Reworking Work: Proceedings of 19th AIRAANZ Conference. Sydney: Association of Industrial Relations Academics of Australia and New Zealand .
27.
Goodwin M. and Maconachie G. ( 2007) Unpaid entitlement recovery in the federal industrial relations system: Strategy and outcomes 1952-95. Journal of Industrial Relations49(4): 523-544.
28.
Hardy T. ( 2009) A changing of the guard: Enforcement of the workplace relations laws since Work Choices and beyond. In: Forsyth A and Stewart A, eds, Fair Work: The New Workplace Laws and the Work Choices Legacy, pp. 75-98. Sydney : Federation Press.
29.
Hardy T. and Howe J.(2009) Partners in enforcement? The new balance between government and trade union enforcement of employment standards in Australia. Australian Journal of Labour Law22(3): 306-336.
30.
Hepple B. and Morris G. ( 2002) The Employment Act 2002 and the crisis of individual employment rights. Industrial Law Journal31(3): 245-269.
31.
Higgins H. ( 1968) A New Province for Law and Order. London: Pall Mall.
32.
Holland P., Pyman A., Cooper BK and Teicher J (2009) The development of alternative voice mechanisms in Australia: The case of joint consultation. Economic and Industrial Democracy30(1): 67-92.
33.
Howell C. ( 2005) Trade Unions and the State: The Construction of Industrial Relations Institutions in Britain, 1890-2000. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
34.
Kaufman, BE and Taras, D, eds, (2000) Non-union Employee Representation: History, Contemporary Practice and Policy. New York: M.E. Sharpe.
35.
Kent J. ( 2009) Julia’s progress. The Sydney Morning Herald. Sydney, 19 September.
36.
Kessler I. and Purcell J. ( 2003) Individualism and collectivism in industrial relations . In: Edwards P, ed., Industrial Relations, pp. 313-337. Oxford: Blackwell .
37.
Lee M. ( 2006) Regulating enforcement of workers’ entitlements in Australia: The new dimension of individualism. Labour and Industry17(1): 41-60.
38.
McCallum R. ( 1994) The imperfect safety net: Enforcement of federal awards and agreements. In: McCallum R, McCarry G and Ronfeldt P, eds, Employment Security, pp. 201-226. Sydney : Federation Press.
39.
McCarry G. ( 1998) From industry to enterprise, from awards to agreement . In: Nolan D, ed., The Australasian Labour Law Reforms, pp. 52-71. Sydney : Federation Press.
40.
Martin R. ( 1960) Legal enforcement of union security in Australia . Industrial and Labor Relations Review13(2): 227-244.
41.
Murray J. and Owens R. ( 2009) The safety net: Labour standards in the new era . In: Forsyth and Stewart A, eds, Fair Work: The New Workplace Laws and the Work Choices Legacy. Sydney: Federation Press.
42.
Naughton R. ( 1997) Sailing into uncharted seas: The role of unions under the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth). Australian Journal of Labour Law10(1): 112-133.
43.
Norrington B. ( 2006) Unfinished business. In: Carter N, ed., The Howard Factor: A Decade that Changed the Nation. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press.
44.
Ostenfeld S. and Lewer J. ( 2002) Award simplification, employer pro-activity and employee resistance. In: Burgess J. and Macdonald D, eds, Developments in Enterprise Bargaining , pp. 50-66. Melbourne : Tertiary Press.
45.
Owens R. ( 2006) Working precariously: The safety net after Work Choices . Australian Journal of Labour Law19(2): 161-182.
46.
Peetz D. ( 1998) Unions in a Contrary World: The Future of the Australian Trade Union Movement. Melbourne: Cambridge University Press.
47.
Peetz D. ( 2006) Brave New Workplace. Sydney : Allen and Unwin.
48.
Pollert A. ( 2005) The unorganised worker: The decline in collectivism and new hurdles to individual employment rights. Industrial Law Journal34(3): 217-238.
49.
Smith P. and Morton G. ( 2006) Nine years of New Labour: Neoliberalism and workers’ rights. British Journal of Industrial Relations44(3): 401-420.
50.
Stewart A. ( 2008) Stewart’s Guide to Employment Law. Sydney: Federation Press.
51.
Stewart A.(2009) A question of balance: Labor’s New vision for workplace regulation . Australian Journal of Labour Law22(1): 3-50.
52.
Storey J. and Bacon N. ( 1993) Individualism and Collectivism: Into the 1990s . International Journal of Human Resource Management4(2): 665-684.
53.
Todhunter L. ( 2007) Arbitration in Constraint: The Role of the AIRC in the Award Simplification Test Case. Brisbane: Griffith University.
54.
Waring P. ( 1999) The rise of individualism in Australian industrial relations . New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations24(3): 291-318.
55.
Waring P. and Bray M. ( 2003) Human resource management and the individualisation of the employment relationship. In: Weisner R and Millett B, eds, Human Resource Management. Sydney: Jacaranda Wiley Press.
56.
Waring P., De Ruyter A. and Burgess J. ( 2006) The Australian Fair Pay Commission: Rationale, operation, antecedents and implications. Economic and Labour Relations Review16: 127-146.
57.
Weeks P. ( 1995) Trade Union Security Law: A Study of Preference and Compulsory Unionism. Sydney: Federation Press .
