Grievances are a contentious facet of contemporary employment relations and yet the amount of in-depth research evidence is limited. This study uses a real-time approach, following a set of New Zealand grievance cases as they proceeded through mediation. The public debate has focused on allegations of opportunist employees exploiting the system. Our findings, however, identify a group of employees who were seeking to remain with their employer, but who lacked influence and lost their jobs. In these situations the law was unable to provide employment protection, while employers had the dominant influence on these outcomes. These findings contribute to the international debate regarding the justice offered through newer grievance resolution systems.
Auckland Chamber of Commerce (2004) Cost of Employment Court Major Disincentive to Business, Media release 30 August. Available at: http://www.chamber.co.nz/contentlink.asp?page=dirmarket.asp .
2.
Bemmels B. and Foley JR ( 1996) Grievance procedure research: A review and theoretical recommendations. Journal of Management22(3): 359-384.
3.
Bingham LB ( 2004) Employment dispute resolution: The case for mediation . Conflict Resolution Quarterly22(1/2): 145-74.
4.
Bingham LB ( 2005) The Impacts of Alternative Dispute Resolution on Workplace Outcomes - Discussion. Labor and Employment Relations Association Series, Proceedings of the 57th Annual Meeting, pp. 131-3.
5.
Bingham LB ( 2007) Evaluation Dispute Resolution Programs: Traps for the Unwary. Labor and Employment Relations Association, Proceedings of the 59th Annual Meeting, Chicago, pp. 104-15.
6.
Bingham LB and Chachere DR ( 1999) Dispute resolution in employment: The need for research . In: Eaton AE and Keefe JH, eds, Employment Dispute Resolution and Worker Rights in the Changing Workplace, pp. 95-136. Champaign, IL: Industrial Relations Research Association.
7.
Blancero D. and Dyer L. ( 1996) Due process for non-union employees: The influence of system characteristics on fairness perceptions. Human Resource Management35(3): 343-59.
8.
Boroff KE ( 1991) Measuring the perceptions of the effectiveness of a workplace complaints procedure. Advances in Industrial and Labor Relations5: 207-33.
9.
Burgess S., Propper C. and Wilson D. ( 2001) Explaining the Growth in the Number of Applications to the Industrial Tribunals, 1972-1997. London: Centre for Market and Public Organisation, Department of Economics, University of Bristol.
10.
Cohen-Charash Y. and Spector P. ( 2001) The role of justice in organisations: A meta-analysis . Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes86(2): 278-321.
11.
Colquitt JA, Conlon DE, Wesson MJ, Porter Colh and Ng KY ( 2001) Justice at the millenium: A meta-analytic review of 25 years of organizational justice research. Journal of Applied Psychology86(3): 425-45.
12.
Colvin AJS ( 2003) The dual transformation of workplace dispute resolution . Industrial Relations42(4): 712-35.
13.
Colvin AJS ( 2004) Adoption and use of dispute resolution procedures in the non-union workplace. In: Lewin D and Kaufman BE, eds, Advances in Industrial and Labor Relations, Vol. 13: pp. 69-95. Bingley, UK: Emerald.
14.
Colvin AJS ( 2005) Inequalities in Access to Justice in the Workplace . Labor and Employment Relations Association Series, Proceedings of the 57th Annual Meeting, pp. 122-130.
15.
Colvin AJS, Batt R. and Keefe J. ( 2005) The Impact of Employee Voice and Compliance Mechanisms on Absenteeism, Discipline, and Turnover. Working Paper 05-14, Cornell University.
16.
Colvin AJS, Klaas B. and Mahony D. ( 2006) Research on alternative dispute resolution procedures . In: Lewin D, ed, Contemporary Issues in Employment Relations, pp. 103-47. Champaign, IL: Labor and Employment Relations Association, University of Illinois.
17.
Costantino CA and Merchant CS ( 1996) Designing Conflict Management Systems: A Guide for Creating Productive and Healthy Organisations. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
18.
Cullinane J. and Donald D. ( 2000) Personal grievances in New Zealand. Research on work, employment and industrial relations conference 2000. In: Burgess J and Strachan G , eds, Proceedings of the 14th AIRAANZ Conference . Newcastle, Australia: Association of Industrial Relations Academics of Australia and New Zealand.
19.
Denzin NK and Lincoln YS ( 2000) Introduction: The discipline and practice of qualitatitive research. In: Denzin NK and Lincoln YS, eds, Handbook of Qualitative Research , 2nd edn. pp. 1-29, SAGE.
20.
Department of Labour (2000) Survey of Employment Disputes and Disputes Resolution, 1002174. Wellington, NZ: Department of Labour-Employment Relations Service and AC Nielsen.
21.
Department of Labour (2002a) The Employment Relations Act: A Summary of the First Eighteen Months (2 October 2000 to 31 March 2002). Wellington, NZ: Department of Labour- Employment Relations Service.
22.
Department of Labour (2002b) The Employment Relations Act: A Summary of the First Two Years (2 October 2000 to 30 September 2002). Wellington, NZ: Department of Labour.
23.
Department of Labour (2002c) The Process of Dispute Resolution - A Qualitative Study Amongst Employees & Employers. Wellington, NZ: Employment Relations Service (ERS) and UMR Research.
24.
Department of Labour (2003) Evaluation of the Short-term Impacts of the Employment Relations Act 2000 . Wellington, NZ: Department of Labour.
25.
Department of Labour (2007) Personal Grievance Mediations Conducted at the Department of Labour: A Snapshot, June 2007. Wellington, NZ: Department of Labour.
26.
Eisenhardt KM ( 1989) Building theories from case study research. The Academy of Management Review14(4): 532-50.
27.
EMA (Northern) (2006a) Grievance Gravy Train Picking Up Speed. Media release, 6 June.
28.
EMA (Northern) (2006b) Most Personal Grievances Paid Off in Private: Survey. Media release , 15 December.
29.
EMA (Northern) (2007) ‘Disadvantage’ the Latest Catch Cry in Personal Grievance Industry. Media release, 2 August.
30.
EMA (Northern) (2008) Grievance Payouts Depend on Where People Live. Media statement, 10 December.
31.
EMA (Northern) (2009a) Personal Grievance Awards Analysis 2008. Auckland, New Zealand.
32.
EMA (Northern) (2009b) Personal Grievance Awards Break Records. Media release, 9 June.
33.
Feuille P. and Chachere DR ( 1995) Looking fair or being fair: Remedial voice procedures in nonunion workplaces. Journal of Management21(1): 27-42.
34.
Feuille P. and Hildebrand RL ( 1995) Grievance procedures and dispute resolution. In: Ferris GR, Rosen S and Barnum D, eds, Handbook of Human Resource Management, pp. 340-69. Cambridge, MA : Blackwell.
35.
Fryxell GE ( 1992) Perceptions of justice afforded by formal grievance systems as predictors of belief in a just workplace. Journal of Business Ethics11(8): 635-47.
36.
Fryxell GE and Gordon ME ( 1989) Workplace justice and job satisfaction as predictors of satisfaction with union and management. Academy of Management Journal32(4): 851-66.
37.
Gibbons M. ( 2007) Better Dispute Resolution: A Review of Employment Dispute Resolution in Great Britain. London: Department of Trade and Industry.
38.
Guba EG and Lincoln YS ( 1994) Competing paradigms in qualitative research. In: Denzin NK and Lincoln YS, eds, The Handbook of Qualitative Research, pp. 105-117. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
39.
Harlos KP ( 2001) When organizational voice systems fail: More on the deaf ear syndrome and frustration effects. Journal of Applied Behavioral Science37(3): 324-342.
40.
Harrison TR ( 2003) Victims, targets, protectors, and destroyers: Using disputant accounts to develop a grounded taxonomy of disputant orientations . Conflict Resolution Quarterly20(3): 307-29.
41.
Lansbury RD, Wailes N. and Yazbeck C. ( 2007) Different paths to similar outcomes? Industrial relations reform and public policy in Australia and New Zealand. Journal of Labor Research28(4): 629-41.
42.
Lewin D. ( 1999) Theoretical and empirical research on the grievance procedure and arbitration: A critical review. In: Eaton AE and O’Keefe JH, eds, Employment Dispute Resolution and Worker Rights in the Changing Workplace , pp. 187-218. Champaign, IL: Industrial Relations Research Association .
43.
Lewin D. and Petersen RB ( 1999) Behavioral outcomes of grievance activity. Industrial Relations38(4): 554-76.
44.
Lipsky DB, Seeber RL and Fincher RD ( 2003) Emerging Systems for Managing Workplace Conflict: Lessons from American Corporations for Managers and Dispute Resolution Professionals . San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
45.
Lipsky DB, Seeber RL, Avgar AC and Scanza RM ( 2007) Managing the Politics of Evaluation: Lessons from the Evaluation of ADR Programs. Labor and Employment Relations Association Series, Proceedings of the 59th Annual Meeting, pp. 116-29.
46.
Mahony DM and Klaas BS ( 2008) Comparative dispute resolution in the workplace . Journal of Labor Research29: 251-71.
47.
May R., Walsh P., Thickett G. and Harbridge R. ( 2001) Unions and union members in New Zealand: Annual review for 2000. New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations26(3): 317-28.
48.
McDermott Miller Limited ( 2007) Social and Economic Costs and Benefits of Employment Relationship Problems: Technical Report. Wellington, NZ: Department of Labour.
49.
Mesch D. and Dalton DR ( 1992) Unexpected consequences of improving workplace justice: A six year time series assessment. Academy of Management Journal35(5): 1099-114.
50.
Parliament of New Zealand (2003) Employment Relations Law Reform Bill92-1, Explanatory note.
51.
Petersen RB and Lewin D. ( 2000) Research on unionised grievance procedures: Management issues and recommendations. Human Resource Management39(4): 395-406.
52.
Pruitt DG and Kim SH ( 2004) Social Conflict: Escalation, Stalemate and Settlement , 3rd edn. Boston: McGraw-Hill.
53.
Shulruf B., Woodhams B., Howard C., Roopali J. and Yee B.(2009) ‘Grievance gravy train picking up speed’: Myths and reality around employment disputes in New Zealand. Journal of Industrial Relations51: 245-61.
54.
van Gramberg B. ( 2001a) Mediation, Structural Violence and Industrial Relations . 15th Conference of the Association of Industrial Relations Academics of Australia and New Zealand, Woollongong , New South Wales, pp. 342-8.
55.
van Gramberg B. ( 2001b) Workplace Justice and the Design of Dispute Resolution Clauses. Working Paper8, Victoria University of Technology, Victoria School of Management.
56.
van Gramberg B. ( 2006) Managing Workplace Conflict: Alternative Dispute Resolution in Australia. Sydney: Federation Press.
57.
van Gramberg B. and Menzies J. ( 2005) Grievance Procedures in Organisations - Why do they Fail?Working Paper12, Victoria University, Australia, School of Management .
58.
Walker B. ( 2009) For better or for worse: Employment relationship problems under the Employment Relations Act 2000. Unpublished PhD Dissertation, University of Canterbury.
59.
Walker B. and Hamilton RT(2010) Grievance processes: Research, rhetoric and directions for New Zealand . New Zealand Journal of Employment Relations34(3): 43-64.
60.
Wilkinson K. ( 2010) Submissions Sought on Personal Grievances. Media release, 2 March.
61.
Woodhams B. ( 2007) Employment Relationship Problems: Costs, Benefits and Choices, August 2007. Wellington: Department of Labour.
62.
Yin RK ( 2003) Case Study Research: Design and Methods, 3rd edn. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
