The Differential Effects of Regulatory Reform: Evidence from the Australian Luxury Hotel Industry

Abstract

Australia's industrial relations framework has undergone substantial change since the 1980s. This has involved a series of distinct phases including: award restructuring, the introduction of enterprise and individual bargaining, and award simplification. Notably, the federal award for the hotel industry formed the Test Case for award simplification, forming the first simplified award in Australia. Exploratory research analysing the Test Case processes suggested that the simplified award favours employers and leads to disadvantageous outcomes for employees. This study builds on the extant evidence by analysing the implications of award simplification in the context of actual hotel workplaces. Its purpose is to examine the effects of award simplification and compare them with the outcomes associated with enterprise bargaining, focusing in particular on working time arrangements in the Australian hotel industry. The study adopts a qualitative approach, involving multiple case studies. Overall, the findings suggest that hotel employers are adopting bifurcated employment strategies, reflecting their respective bargaining arrangements. At a more subtle level, the effects of regulatory reform differed both within and between workplaces, highlighting rather distinctive and varied implications for many different employees. Importantly, this revealed the diverse needs and preferences of the parties involved and illustrated the complex outcomes associated with regulatory reform. These outcomes appear to be substantially more nuanced than indicated previously.

Keywords

award simplifiration enterprise bargaining hotel indsty working time

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) (1994) Hospitality Industies Australia, I99I-I992. Cat. No. 8674. Canberra: AGPS .

Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) (1998) Tourist Accommodation, Australia. Cat. No. 8635. Canberra: AGPS .

Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) (2000a) Employee Earnings and Hours. Cat. No. 6306. Canberra: AGPS .

Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) (2000b) Tourivm Indicators. Cat. No. 8634. Canberra: AGPS .

Australian Centre for Industrial Relations Research and Training (ACIRRT) (1996) Casual Workers, Employment Security and Economic Competitiveness in the Australian Hospitality Industry. Recent Developments and Implicationsfor Policy. Sydney: ACIRRT .

Australian Industrial Relations Commission (AIRC) (1992) Sheraton Towers Southgate Employee RelationsAgreement, S3000 CAS M Doc K5041.

AIRC (1995) The Hospitality Industry-Hotels, Accommodation, Resorts and Gaming Award 1995, H0008 L L, Print K3966.

AIRC (1997)AwardSimplfication Decision, December, Print P7500.

AIRC (1998) The Hospitality Industry Hotels, Accommodation, Res and Gaming Award i998, H0008, Print P0138.

10.

Barnes, A. , and Fieldes, D. (2000) ‘Monday I've Got Friday on My Mind: Working Time in the Hospitality Industry’ Journal ofIndustrial Relations 42(4): 535-550 .

11.

Blake Dawson Waldron (in conjunction with Arthur Andersen) (1994) The Hotel Workplace Reform Study. A study commissioned by the Tourism Task Force. Sydney: Tourism Task Force .

12.

Bryman, A. (2000) Research Methods and Organisation Studies. London: Routledge .

13.

Buchanan, J. and Callus, R. (1993) ‘Efficiency and Equity at Work: The Need for Labour Market Regulation in Australia’ Journal oflndustrial Relations 35(4): 515-537 .

14.

Business Council of Australia (BCA) (1988) Towards More Flexible Working TimeArrangements. Economic Planning and Advisory Council Discussion Paper 88/02. Canberra: AGPS .

15.

Business Council of Australia (BCA) (1989) Enterprise-based Bargaining Units: A Better Way of Working. Melbourne: BCA .

16.

Charlesworth, S. (1997) ‘Enterprise Bargaining and Women Workers: The Seven Perils of Flexibility’ Labour and Industy 8(2): 101-115 .

17.

Dabscheck, B. (1993) ‘The Coalition's Plan to Regulate Industrial Relations’ Economic and Labour Relations Review 4(1): 1-26 .

18.

Deery, S. , Plowman, D. , Walsh, J. , Brown, M. (2001) Industrial Relations: A Contemporary Analysis. Sydney: McGraw-Hill .

19.

Department of Employment, Vocational Education, Training and Industrial Relations (DEVETIR) (1993) Women and Enterprise Bargaining. Brisbane: DEVETIR .

20.

Department of Employment and Workplace Relations and the Office of the Employment Advocate (DEWR and OEA) (2002) Agreement making in Australia under the Workplace RelationsAct 200I and 2002. Canberra: AGPS .

21.

Flick, U. (1998) An Introduction to Qualitative Research. London: SAGE Publications .

22.

Industry Commission (1996) Tourism Accommodation and Training. Melbourne: AGPS .

23.

Keating, P. (1994) Working Nation: Polkies and Programs. Canberra: AGPS .

24.

Knox, A. and Walsh, J. (2005) ‘Organisational Flexibility and HRM in the Hotel Industry: Evidence from Australia’,Human Resource ManagementJournal 15(1): 57-75 .

25.

Kruegar, R. (1994) Focus Groups: A Practical Guide forApplied Research. California: SAGE Publications .

26.

Junor, A. (1988) ‘Permanent PartTime Work’ ; Labour and Industry 8(3): 77-95 .

27.

Lucas, R. (1996) ‘Industrial Relations in Hotels and Catering: Neglect and Paradox?’ British Journal oflndustnial Relations 34(2): 267-286 .

28.

Norris, K. , Stromback, T. and Dockery, A. (1995) How Tourism Labour Markets Work. Canberra: AGPS .

29.

Patton, M. (1990) Qualitative Evaluation and Research Methods. New York: SAGE Publications .

30.

Price, L. (1994) ‘Poor Personnel Practice in the Hotel and Catering Industry: Does it Matter?’ , Human Resource Management Journal 4(4): 44-62 .

31.

Probert, B. (1995) Part Time Work and Managerial Strategies: Flexibility in the New Industrial Relations Framework. Canberra: Department of Employment, Education and Training .

32.

Timo, N. (1999) ‘Contingent and Retentive Employment in the Australian Hotel Industry: Reformulating the Core-Periphery Model’ Australian Journal of Labour Economias 3(1): 47-64 .

33.

Timo, N. and Davidson, M. (2005) ‘A Survey of Employee Relations Practices and Demographics of MNC Chain and Domestic Luxury Hotels in Australia’ Employee Relations 27(2): 175-192 .

34.

Walsh, J. and Deery, S. (1999) ‘Understanding the Peripheral Workforce: Evidence from the Service Sector’ Human Resource Management Journal 9(2): 5-63 .

35.

Whitehouse, G. , Lafferty, G. and Boreham, R (1997) ‘From Casual to Permanent Part Time? Non Standard Employment in Retail and Hospitality’ Labour and Industry 8(2): 33-48 .