Laing Versus Szasz: Antagonists,Kindred Spirits,or a Misconstrued Rivalry?

Abstract

In the mid-1970s, as the role of institutional psychiatry was being debated, Thomas S. Szasz directed a severe and unexpected critique at the work of Ronald D. Laing, after which there arose an acrimonious debate between Szasz and supporters of Laing in the Philadelphia Association (PA). (Laing himself conspicuously declined to respond to Szasz). This clash of views was initiated by Szasz in The New Review (TNR), which prompted a series of rebuttals from those working alongside Laing in the PA. Pivotal to this dispute were contrasting ideas on how to guide people from breakdown to sanity and the roles to be played by professionals and institutions in engaging with them. The main purpose of this article is to evaluate whether Laing (seen through lens of his then-associates in the PA) and Szasz were “antagonists,” whether they shared a kindred spirit in their view of the psychiatric establishment, or whether their perceived differences on how to treat psychic sufferers stemmed from misrepresentations created by themselves or others. My conclusion is that, even though Laing and Szasz shared an interest in changing conventional psychiatric practice and the mode of understanding and treating psychic suffering, each side misconstrued the position of the other.

Keywords

Laing Szasz antipsychiatry mental illness schizophrenia Philadelphia Association

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Barnes

Berke

(1971). Mary barnes: Two accounts of a journey through madness. Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.

Berke

(1977). Anti-psychiatry. [Letter]. The New Review, 3(34/35), 58–59.

Beyer

(1912). Die Bestrebungen zur Reform des Irrenwesens. Material zu einem Reichs-Irrengesetz, Für Laien und Ärzte. Halle a. S.: Marhold.

Burston

(2020). Psychoanalysis, politics and the Postmodern University. Palgrave, Macmillan.

Chapman

(2016). Re-Coopering anti-psychiatry: David Cooper, revolutionary critic of psychiatry. Critical and Radical Social Work, 4(3), 421–432.

Clare

(1976). Anti-psychiatry. An alternative view. The New Review, 3(33), 25–30.

Cooper

(1967). Psychiatry and anti-psychiatry. Tavistock.

Davidson

Rakfeldt

Strauss

(2010). The roots of the recovery movement in psychiatry: Lessons learned. John Wiley.

Double

D. B.

(2006). Historical perspectives on anti-psychiatry. In Double

D. B.

(Ed.), Critical psychiatry: The limits of madness (pp. 19–39). Palgrave MacMillan.

10.

Gale

(2001, September 8). Far out. The Guardian. http://www.theguardian.com/theguardian/2001/sep/08/weekend7.weekend

11.

Gans

Redler

(2001). Just listening: Ethics and therapy. XLibris, Random House.

12.

Haldipur

C. V.

Knoll

J. L.

IV , Luft

E. v. d.

(Eds.). (2019). Thomas Szasz. An appraisal of his legacy. Oxford University Press.

13.

Kirsner

(2015). Laing’s the divided self and the politics of experience: Then and now. In Thompson

M. G.

(Ed.), The Legacy of R. D. Laing: An appraisal of his contemporary relevance (pp. 69–79). Routledge.

14.

Kotowicz

(1997). R. D. Laing and the paths of anti-psychiatry. Routledge.

15.

Laing

R. D.

(1960). The divided self: An existential study in sanity and madness. Tavistock Publications.

16.

Laing

R. D.

(1967). The politics of experience and the bird of paradise. Penguin.

17.

Laing

R. D.

(1979, July 20). Round the bend. New Statesman, 96–97.

18.

Lothane

H. Z.

(1992). In defense of schreber: Soul murder and psychiatry. Analytic Press.

19.

Martin

(1973). Tracts against the times. Lutterworth.

20.

Mullan

(1995). Mad to be normal: Conversations with R. D. Laing. Free Association Books, 2017.

21.

Nasser

(1995). The rise and fall of anti-psychiatry. Psychiatric Bulletin, 19, 743–746.

22.

Ophir

(2015). Psychosis, psychoanalysis and psychiatry in postwar USA: On the borderland of madness. Routledge.

23.

PA (1971–1984) Philadelphia Association Leaflet. MS Laing L259/1.

24.

Redler

(1976). Anti-psychiatry [Letter]. The New Review, 3(32), 71–72.

25.

Roberts

Itten

(2012). Laing and Szasz revisited. In Itten

Young

(Eds.), R. D. Laing. 50 years since the divided self (pp. 260–279). PCCS Books.

26.

Schaler

J. A.

Lothane

H. Z.

Vatz

R. E.

(Eds.). (2017). Thomas S. Szasz: The Man and his ideas. Routledge.

27.

Schatzman

(1969). Madness and morals. In Berke

(Ed.), Counter-culture, the creation of an alternative society (pp. 288–313). Peter Owen.

28.

Sedgwick

(1982). Psycho politics. Pluto Press.

29.

Siegler

Osmond

Mann

(1971). Laing’s models of madness. Salmagundi Nº, 16, 84–104.

30.

Szasz

T. S.

(1961). The myth of mental illness. Harper & Row.

31.

Szasz

T. S.

(1974). The second sin. Anchor Press.

32.

Szasz

T. S.

(1976a). Anti-psychiatry: The paradigm of the plundered mind. The New Review, 2(29), 3–14.

33.

Szasz

T. S.

(1976b). Anti-psychiatry [Letter]. The New Review, 3(33), 38.

34.

Szasz

T. S.

(1976c). Schizophrenia: The sacred symbol of psychiatry. Syracuse University Press.

35.

Szasz

T. S.

(1977). The theology of medicine: The Political-philosophical foundations medical ethics. Oxford University Press, 1979.

36.

Szasz

T. S.

(1979). Myth of psychotherapy: Mental healing as religion, rhetoric and repression. Oxford University Press.

37.

Szasz

T. S.

(2004). “Knowing what ain’t so” R. D. Laing and Thomas Szasz. Psychoanalytic Review, 91(3), 331–346.

38.

Szasz

T. S.

(2008). Debunking antipsychiatry: Laing, law and largactil. Current Psychology, 27, 79–101.

39.

Szasz

T. S.

(2009). Antipsychiatry: Quackery squared. Syracuse University Press.

40.

Tantam

(1991). The anti-psychiatry movement. In Berrios

G. E.

Freeman

(Eds.), 150 years of British psychiatry, 1841-1991 (pp. 333–347). Gaskell.

41.

Thompson

M. G.

(2015). Laing and the myth of mental illness redux. In Thompson

M. G.

(Ed.), The Legacy of R. D. Laing. An appraisal of his contemporary relevance (pp. 25–39). Routledge.

42.

Trilling

(1972). Sincerity and authenticity. Harvard University Press.

43.

Wall

(2013). The birth and death of Villa 21. History of Psychiatry, 24(3), 326–340.

44.

Wall

(2018). The British Anti-psychiatrists: From institutional psychiatry to the counter-culture, 1960-1971. Routledge.