Pioneering scholarship links retrospective childhood conditions to mature adult health. We distinctively provide critical evidence with prospective state-of-the-art measures of parent income observed multiple times during childhood in the 1970s to 1990s. Using the Panel Study of Income Dynamics, we analyze six health outcomes (self-rated health, heart attack, stroke, life-threatening chronic conditions, non-life-threatening chronic conditions, and psychological distress) among 40- to 65-year-olds. Parent relative income rank has statistically and substantively significant relationships with five of six outcomes. The relationships with heart attack, stroke, and life-threatening chronic conditions are particularly strong. Parent income rank performs slightly better than alternative prospective and retrospective measures. At the same time, we provide novel validation on which retrospective measures (i.e., father’s education) perform almost as well as prospective measures. Furthermore, we inform several perennial debates about how relative versus absolute income and other measures of socioeconomic status and social class influence health.
AdlerNancy E.BoyceThomasChesneyMargaret A.CohenSheldonFolkmanSusanKahnRobert L.SymeLeonard S.1994. “Socioeconomic Status and Health: The Challenge of the Gradient.” American Psychologist49(1):15–24.
2.
AvendanoMauricio. 2012. “Correlation or Causation? Income Inequality and Infant Mortality in Fixed Effects Models in the Period 1960–2008 in 34 OECD Countries.” Social Science & Medicine75(4):754–60.
3.
AvendanoMauricioGlymourM. Maria. 2008. “Stroke Disparities in Older Americans: Is Wealth a More Powerful Indicator of Risk than Income and Education?” Stroke39(5):1533–40.
4.
BartfeldJudithGundersenCraigSmeedingTimothy M.ZiliakJames P., eds. 2015. SNAP Matters: How Food Stamps Affect Health and Well-Being. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
5.
BenyaminiYaelIdlerEllen L.1999. “Community Studies Reporting Association between Self-Rated Health and Mortality: Additional Studies, 1996–1998.” Research on Aging21(3):392–401.
6.
BlauDavid M.1999. “The Effect of Income on Child Development.” The Review of Economics and Statistics81(2):261–76.
7.
BradyDavidFinniganRyanKohlerUlrichLegewieJoscha. 2020. “The Inheritance of Race Revisited: Childhood Wealth and Income, and Black–White Disadvantages in Adult Life Chances.” Sociological Science7(25):599–627.
8.
BradyDavidGiesselmanMarcoKohlerUlrichRadenackerAnke. 2018. “How to Measure and Proxy Permanent Income: Evidence from Germany and the U.S.” Journal of Economic Inequality16(3):321–45.
9.
BradyDavidParolinZachary. 2020. “The Levels and Trends in Deep and Extreme Poverty in the U.S., 1993–2016.” Demography57(6):2337–60.
10.
CaseAnneLubotskyDarrenPaxsonChristina. 2002. “Economic Status and Health in Childhood: The Origins of the Gradient.” American Economic Review92(5):1308–34.
ChettyRajStepnerMichaelAbrahamSarahLinShelbyScuderiBenjaminTurnerNicholasBergeronAugustinCutlerDavid. 2016. “The Association between Income and Life Expectancy in the United States, 2001–2014.” Journal of the American Medical Association315(16):1750–66.
13.
CloustonSean A. P.LinkBruce G.2021. “A Retrospective on Fundamental Cause Theory: State of the Literature and Goals for the Future.” Annual Review of Sociology47:131–56.
14.
DalyMary C.DuncanGreg J.McDonoughPeggyWilliamsDavid R.2002. “Optimal Indicators of Socioeconomic Status for Health Research.” American Journal of Public Health92(7):1151–57.
15.
DeatonAngus. 2013. The Great Escape. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
16.
DuncanGreg J.MagnusonKatherineKalilArielZiol-GuestKathleen M.2012. “The Importance of Early Childhood Poverty.” Social Indicators Research108(1):87–98.
17.
DuncanGreg J.PetersenEric. 2001. “The Long and Short of Asking Questions about Income, Wealth, and Labor Supply.” Social Science Research30(2):248–63.
18.
DuncanGreg J.Ziol-GuestKathleen M.KalilAriel. 2010. “Early Childhood Poverty and Adult Attainment, Behavior and Health.” Child Development81(1):306–25.
19.
DupreMatthew E.GeorgeLinda K.LiuGuangyaPetersonEric D.2012. “The Cumulative Effect of Unemployment on Risks for Myocardial Infarction.” Archives of Internal Medicine172(22):1731–37.
20.
EasterlinRichard A.McVeyLaura A.SwitekMalgorzataSawangfaOnnichaZweigJacqueline S.2010. “The Happiness–Income Paradox Revisited.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences107(52):22463–68.
21.
EloIrma. 2009. “Social Class Differentials in Health and Mortality: Patterns and Explanations in Comparative Perspective.” Annual Review of Sociology35:553–72.
22.
FerraroKenneth F.SchaferMarkus H.WilkinsonLindsay R.2015. “Childhood Disadvantage and Health Problems in Middle and Later Life.” American Sociological Review81(1):107–33.
23.
FoxLianaTorcheFlorenciaWaldfogelJane. 2016. “Intergenerational Mobility.” Pp. 528–54 in The Oxford Handbook of the Social Science of Poverty, edited by BradyD.BurtonL. M.New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
24.
FrickJoachim R.JenkinsStephen P.LillardDean R.LippsOliverWoodenMark. 2007. “The Cross-National Equivalent File (CNEF) and Its Member Country Household Panel Studies.” Schmoller’s Jahrbuch127(4):627–54.
25.
GeyerSiegfriedHemströmOrjanPeterRichardVågeröDenny. 2006. “Education, Income, and Occupational Class Cannot Be Used Interchangeably in Social Epidemiology: Empirical Evidence against a Common Practice.” Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health60(9):804–10.
26.
GilmanStephen E.KawachiIchiroFitzmauriceGarrett M.BukaStephen L.2002. “Socioeconomic Status in Childhood and the Lifetime Risk of Major Depression.” International Journal of Epidemiology31(2):359–67.
27.
GundersenCraigZiliakJames P.2003. “The Role of Food Stamps in Consumption Stabilization.” Journal of Human Resources38(Suppl.):1051–79.
28.
Hamil-LukerJenniferO’RandAngela M.2007. “Gender Differences in the Link between Childhood Socioeconomic Conditions and Heart Attack Risk in Adulthood.” Demography44(1):137–58.
29.
HardtJochenRutterMichael. 2004. “Validity of Adult Retrospective Reports of Adverse Childhood Experiences: Review of Evidence.” Journal of Child Psychology & Psychiatry45(2):260–73.
30.
HaywardMark D.GormanBridget K.2004. “The Long Arm of Childhood: The Influence of Early-Life Social Conditions on Men’s Mortality.” Demography41(1):87–107.
31.
HerdPamelaGoeslingBrianHouseJames S.2007. “Socioeconomic Position and Health: The Differential Effects of Education Versus Income on the Onset Versus Progression of Health Problems.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior48(3):223–38.
32.
HouseJames S.LepkowskiJames M.KinneyAnn M.MeroRichard P.KesslerRonald C.HerzogA. Regula. 1994. “The Social Stratification of Aging and Health.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior35(3):213–34.
33.
HoynesHilarySchanzenbachDiane WhitmoreAlmondDouglas. 2016. “Long Run Impacts of Childhood Access to the Safety Net.” American Economic Review106(4):903–34.
34.
JefferisBarbara J. M. H.PowerChrisHertzmanClyde. 2002. “Birth Weight, Childhood Socio-economic Environment, and Cognitive Development in the 1958 British Birth Cohort Study.” BMJ325(7359):305–10.
35.
JohnsonRucker C.SchoeniRobert F.2011. “Early-Life Origins of Adult Disease: National Longitudinal Population-Based Study of the United States.” American Journal of Public Health101(12):2317–24.
36.
KauhanenLauraLakkaHanna-MaariaLynchJohn W.KauhanenJussi. 2006. “Social Disadvantages in Childhood and Risk of All-Cause Death and Cardiovascular Disease in Later Life: A Comparison of Historical and Retrospective Childhood Information.” International Journal of Epidemiology35(4):962–68.
37.
KesslerR. C.AndrewsG.ColpeL. J.HiripiE.MroczekD. K.NormandL. T.WaltersE. E.ZaslavskyA. M.2002. “Short Screening Scales to Monitor Population Prevalences and Trends in Non-specific Psychological Distress.” Psychological Medicine32:959–76.
38.
KuhDianaHardyRebeccaLangenbergClaudiaRichardsMarcusWadsworthMichael E. J.2002. “Mortality in Adults Aged 25–64 Years Related to Socioeconomic Conditions in Childhood and Adulthood: Post War Birth Cohort Study.” BMJ325(7372):1076–80.
39.
LadinKerenDanielsNormanKawachiIchiro. 2010. “Exploring the Relationship between Absolute and Relative Position and Late-Life Depression: Evidence from 10 European Countries.” Gerontologist50(1):48–59.
40.
LaditkaSarah B.LaditkaJames N.2019. “An Enduring Health Risk of Childhood Adversity: Earlier, More Severe, and Longer Lasting Disability in Adult Life.” Journal of Gerontology, Series B: Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences74(1):136–47.
41.
LeeChiounRyffCarol D.2019. “Pathways Linking Combinations of Early-Life Adversities to Adult Mortality: Tales That Vary by Gender.” Social Science & Medicine240:112566. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2019.112566.
42.
LillardDean R.BurkhauserRichard V.HahnMarkus H.WilkinsRoger. 2015. “Does Early-Life Income Inequality Predict Self-Reported Health Later in Life?: Evidence from the United States.” Social Science & Medicine128:347–55.
43.
LinkBruce G.PhelanJo. 1995. “Social Conditions as Fundamental Causes of Disease.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior Special Issue:80–94.
44.
LinkBruce G.SusserEzra S.Factor-LitvakPamMarchDanaKeziosKatrina L.LovasiGina S.RundleAndrew G., et al2017. “Disparities in Self-Rated Health across Generations and Through the Life Course.” Social Science & Medicine174:17–25.
45.
LuoYeWaiteLinda J.2005. “The Impact of Childhood and Adult SES on Physical, Mental, and Cognitive Well-Being in Later Life.” Journal of Gerontology, Series B: Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences60(2):S93–101.
46.
MarmotMichael. 2005. “Social Determinants of Health Inequalities.” The Lancet365(9464):19–25.
47.
MartikainenPekkaEloIrmaTarkiainenLasseMikkonenJanneMyrskyläMikkoMoustgaardHeta. 2020. “The Changing Contribution of Childhood Social Characteristics to Mortality: A Comparison of Finnish Cohorts Born in 1936–50 and 1960–75.” International Journal of Epidemiology49(3):896–907.
48.
MazumderBhashkar. 2016. “Estimating the Intergenerational Elasticity and Rank Association in the United States: Overcoming the Current Limitations of Tax Data.” Pp. 83–129 in Inequality: Causes and Consequences, Research in Labor Economics, edited by PolachekS.TatsiramosK.Bingley, UK: Emerald Group Publishing Limited.
49.
McLeodJane D.ShanahanMichael J.1996. “Trajectories of Poverty and Children’s Mental Health.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior37(3):207–20.
50.
MelchiorMariaMoffittTerrie E.MilneBarry J.PoultonRichieCaspiAvshalom. 2007. “Why Do Children from Socioeconomically Disadvantaged Families Suffer from Poor Health When They Reach Adulthood?: A Life Course Study.” American Journal Epidemiology166(8):966–74.
51.
MontezJennifer K.BrombergerJoyce T.HarlowSiobán D.KravitzHoward M.MatthewsKaren A.2016. “Life-Course Socioeconomic Status and Metabolic Syndrome among Midlife Women.” Journals of Gerontology, Series B: Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences71(6):1097–107.
52.
MontezJennifer K.HaywardMark D.2014. “Cumulative Childhood Adversity, Educational Attainment, and Active Life Expectancy among U.S. Adults.” Demography51(2):413–35.
53.
MoormanSara M.GreenfieldEmily A.GarciaSarah. 2019. “School Context in Adolescence and Cognitive Functioning 50 Years Later.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior60(4):493–508.
54.
MortonPatricia M.FerraroKenneth F.2020. “Early Social Origins of Biological Risks for Men and Women in Later Life.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior61(4):503–22.
55.
MortonPatricia M.MustilloSarah A.FerraroKenneth F.2014. “Does Childhood Misfortune Raise the Risk of Acute Myocardial Infarction in Adulthood?” Social Science & Medicine104:133–41.
56.
Panel Study of Income Dynamics. 2013. “Panel Study of Income Dynamics” [Data set]. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan.
57.
PoultonRichieCaspiAvshalomMilneBarry J.ThomsonW. MurrayTaylorAlanSearsMalcolm R.MoffittTerrie E.2002. “Association between Children’s Experience of Socioeconomic Disadvantage and Adult Health: A Life Course Study.” The Lancet360(9346):1640–45.
58.
RainwaterLeeSmeedingTimothy M.2003. Poor Kids in a Rich Country. New York, NY: Russell Sage Foundation.
59.
RobinsLee N.SchoenbergSandra P.HolmesSandra J.RatcliffKathryn S.BenhamAlexandraWorksJane. 1985. “Early Home Environment and Retrospective Recall: A Test of Concordance between Siblings with and without Psychiatric Disorders.” American Journal of Orthopsychiatry55(1):27–41.
60.
SchacterDaniel L.2001. The Seven Sins of Memory: How the Mind Forgets and Remembers. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin Company.
61.
SchaferMarkus H.FerraroKenneth F.2011. “Childhood Misfortune as a Threat to Successful Aging: Avoiding Disease.” The Gerontologist52(1):111–20.
62.
SchaferMarkus H.FerraroKenneth F.MustilloSarah A.2011. “Children of Misfortune: Early Adversity and Cumulative Inequality in Perceived Life Trajectories.” American Journal of Sociology116(4):1053–91.
63.
SchnittkerJason. 2004. “Education and the Changing Shape of the Income Gradient in Health.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior45(3):286–305.
64.
SchnittkerJasonBacakValerio. 2014. “The Increasing Predictive Validity of Self-Rated Health.” PLOS One9(1):e84933. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0084933.
65.
ShueyKim M.WilsonAndrea E.2014. “Economic Hardship in Childhood and Adult Health Trajectories: An Alternative Approach to Investigating Life-Course Processes.” Advances in Life Course Research22:49–61.
66.
SmeedingTimothy M.WeinbergDaniel H.2003. “Toward a Uniform Definition of Household Income.” Review of Income & Wealth47(1):1–24.
67.
SongXiMareRobert D.2014. “Retrospective Versus Prospective Approaches to the Study of Intergenerational Social Mobility.” Sociological Methods & Research44(4):555–84.
68.
StevensonBetseyWolfersJustin. 2013. “Subjective Well-Being and Income: Is There Any Evidence of Satiation?” American Economic Review103(3):598–604.
69.
TurnerR. JayThomasCourtney S.BrownTyson H.2016. “Childhood Adversity and Adult Health: Evaluating Intervening Mechanisms.” Social Science & Medicine156:114–24.
70.
United Nations Economic Commission for Europe. 2011. Canberra Group Handbook on Household Income Statistics. 2nd ed.Geneva: United Nations.
71.
VanHeuvelenTomBradyDavid. 2021. “Labor Unions and American Poverty.” ILR Review. doi:10.1177/00197939211014855.
72.
VartanianThomas P.HouserLinda. 2010. “The Effects of Childhood Neighborhood Conditions on Self-Reports of Adult Health.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior51(3):291–306.
73.
VeenhovenRuut. 1991. “Is Happiness Relative?” Social Indicators Research24:1–34.
74.
WarnerDavid F.HaywardMark D.2006. “Early-Life Origins of the Race Gap in Men’s Mortality.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior47(3):209–26.
75.
WilsonAndrea E.ShueyKim M.ElderGlenn H.Jr.2007. “Cumulative Advantage Processes as Mechanisms of Inequality in Life Course Health.” American Journal of Sociology112(6):1886–924.
76.
YangYang C.SchorppKristenBoenCourtneyJohnsonMoiraHarrisKathleen M.2020. “Socioeconomic Status and Biological Risks for Health and Illness across the Life Course.” Journals of Gerontology, Series B: Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences75(3):613–24.
77.
ZhengHuiDirlamJonathanEchavePaola. 2021. “Divergent Trends in the Effects of Early Life Factors on Adult Health.” Population Research and Policy Review40(5):1119–48.
78.
Ziol-GuestKathleen M.DuncanGreg J.KalilAriel. 2009. “Early Childhood Poverty and Adult Body Mass Index.” American Journal of Public Health99(3):527–32.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
