This study leverages multiple measures of gender from a US national online survey (N = 1,508) to better assess how gender is related to self-rated health. In contrast to research linking feminine behaviors with good health and masculine behaviors with poor health, we find that masculinity is associated with better self-rated health for cisgender men, whereas femininity is associated with better self-rated health for cisgender women. The patterns are similar whether we consider self-identification or how people feel others perceive their gender, though reflected appraisals are most strongly associated with health for cisgender women. We also find that people who report they are seen as gender nonconforming report worse health, but only when this perception does not match their gender identification. Our results demonstrate that multiple measures of gender allow researchers to disentangle how health is not only shaped by gender enactments but also shapes perceptions of gender and gender difference.
AnnandaleEllenHuntKate. 1990. “Masculinity, Femininity and Sex: An Exploration of Their Relative Contribution to Explaining Gender Differences in Health.” Sociology of Health & Illness12(1):24–46.
2.
BauerGreta R.BraimohJessicaScheimAyden I.DharmaChristoffer. 2017. “Transgender-inclusive Measures of Sex/Gender for Population Surveys: Mixed-methods Evaluation and Recommendations.” PLoS ONE12(5):e0178043.
3.
BemSandra L.1974. “The Measurement of Psychological Androgyny.” Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology42(2):155–62.
4.
BirdChloe E.RiekerPatricia P.1999. “Gender Matters: An Integrated Model for Understanding Men’s and Women’s Health.” Social Science & Medicine48(6):745–55.
5.
BittnerAmandaGoodyear-GrantElizabeth. 2017. “Sex Isn’t Gender: Reforming Concepts and Measurements in the Study of Public Opinion.” Political Behavior39(4):1–23.
6.
BlairKaren L.HoskinRhea A.2014. “Experiences of Femme Identity: Coming out, Invisibility and Femmephobia.” Psychology and Sexuality6(3):229–44.
7.
BoardmanJason D.2004. “Health Pessimism among Black and White Adults: The Role of Interpersonal and Institutional Maltreatment.” Social Science & Medicine59(12):2523–33.
8.
BurkePeter J.1991. “Identity Processes and Social Stress.” American Sociological Review56(6):836–49.
9.
ConstantinopleAnne. 1973. “Masculinity-femininity: An Exception to the Famous Dictum?”Psychological Bulletin80(5):389–407.
10.
CooleyCharles H.1902. Human Nature and the Social Order. New York: Scribners.
11.
CourtenayWill H.2000. “Constructions of Masculinity and Their Influence on Men’s Well-being: A Theory of Gender and Health.” Social Science & Medicine50(10):1385–401.
12.
EmslieCarolHuntKateMacintyreSally. 2002. “How Similar Are the Smoking and Drinking Habits.” European Journal of Public Health12(1):22–28.
13.
EmslieCarolRidgeDamienZieblandSueHuntKate. 2006. “Men’s Accounts of Depression: Reconstructing or Resisting Hegemonic Masculinity?”Social Science & Medicine62(9):2246–57.
14.
Federal Interagency Working Group on Improving Measurement of Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity in Federal Surveys. 2016. “Evaluations of Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity Survey Measures: What Have We Learned?” Retrieved December30, 2018 (https://nces.ed.gov/FCSM/pdf/Evaluations_of_SOGI_Questions_20160923.pdf).
15.
FloresAndrew R.HermanJody L.GatesGary J.BrownTaylor N. T.2016. How Many Adults Identify as Transgender in the United States?Los Angeles: Williams Institute.
16.
GaldasPaul M.JohnsonJoy L.PercyMyra E.RatnerPamela A.2010. “Help Seeking for Cardiac Symptoms: Beyond the Masculine-feminine Binary.” Social Science & Medicine71(1):18–24.
17.
GeistClaudiaReynoldsMegan M.GaytánMarie S.2017. “Unfinished Business: Disentangling Sex, Gender, and Sexuality in Sociological Research on Gender Stratification.” Sociology Compass11(4):1–16.
18.
GenIUSS Group. 2014. Best Practices for Asking Questions to Identify Transgender and Other Gender Minority Respondents on Population-based Surveys. Los Angeles: Williams Institute.
19.
GormanBridget K.DenneyJustin T.DowdyHilaryMedeirosRose Anne. 2015. “A New Piece of the Puzzle: Sexual Orientation, Gender, and Physical Health Status.” Demography52(4):1357–82.
20.
Grol-ProkopczykHannaFreeseJeremyHauserRobert M.2011. “Using Anchoring Vignettes to Assess Group Differences in General Self-rated Health.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior52(2):246–61.
21.
HuntKateHannahMary KateWestPatrick. 2004. “Contextualizing Smoking: Masculinity, Femininity and Class Differences in Smoking in Men and Women from Three Generations in the West of Scotland.” Health Education Research19(3):239–49.
22.
HuntKateLewarsHeatherEmslieCarolBattyG. David. 2007. “Decreased Risk of Death from Coronary Heart Disease amongst Men with Higher ‘Femininity’ Scores: A General Population Cohort Study.” International Journal of Epidemiology36(2):269–73.
23.
JansMattGrantDavidParkRoyceWilsonBianca D. M.HermanJodyGatesGaryPonceNinez. 2016. “Putting the ‘T’ in LBGT: Testing and Fielding Questions to Identify Transgender People in the California Health Interview Survey.” Presented at the 2016 Population Association of America Conference, April 1, Washington, DC.
24.
JylhäMarja. 2009. “What Is Self-reported Health and Why Does It Predict Mortality? Towards a Unified Conceptual Model.” Social Science & Medicine69(3):307–16.
25.
KriegerNancy. 2003. “Genders, Sexes, and Health: What Are the Connections—and Why Does It Matter?”International Journal of Epidemiology32(4):652–57.
26.
LagosDanya. 2018. “Looking at Population Health beyond ‘Male’ and ‘Female’: Implications of Transgender Identity and Gender Nonconformity for Population Health.” Demography55(6):2097–117.
MarkidesKyriakos S.EschbachKarl. 2005. “Aging, Migration, and Mortality: Current Status of Research on the Hispanic Paradox.” Journals of Gerontology Series B: Psychological and Social Sciences60(2):68–72.
29.
McGuffeyC. ShawnRichB. Lindsay. 1999. “Playing in the Gender Transgression Zone: Race, Class, and Hegemonic Masculinity in Middle Childhood.” Gender & Society13(5):608–27.
30.
MeadGeorge H.1934. Mind, Self, and Society. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
31.
MillerLisa R.GrollmanEric Anthony. 2015. “The Social Costs of Gender Nonconformity for Transgender Adults: Implications for Discrimination and Health.” Sociological Forum30(3):809–31.
32.
MooreSarah E. H.2010. “Is the Healthy Body Gendered? Toward a Feminist Critique of the New Paradigm of Health.” Body & Society16(2):95–118.
33.
PascoeElizabeth A.RichmanLaura Smart. 2009. “Perceived Discrimination and Health: A Meta-analytic Review.” Psychological Bulletin135(4):531–54.
34.
PrusSteven G.2011. “Comparing Social Determinants of Self-rated Health across the United States and Canada.” Social Science & Medicine73(1):50–59.
35.
ReadJen’nan GhazalGormanBridget K.2010. “Gender and Health Inequality.” Annual Review of Sociology36(1):371–86.
36.
RiderG. NicoleMcMorrisBarbara J.GowerAmy L.ColemanEliEisenbergMarla E.2018. “Health and Care Utilization of Transgender and Gender Nonconforming Youth: A Population-based Study.” Pediatrics141(3):e20171683.
37.
RidgewayCeciliaCorrellShelley. 2006. “Consensus and the Creation of Status Beliefs.” Social Forces85(1):431–53.
38.
RismanBarbara J.2004. “Gender as a Social Structure: Theory Wrestling with Activism.” Gender & Society18(4):429–50.
39.
RubinGayle. 1984. “Thinking Sex: Notes for a Radical Theory of the Politics of Sexuality.” Pp. 267–319 in Pleasure and Danger: Exploring Female Sexuality, edited by VanceC. S.Boston: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
SchnittkerJasonBacakValerio. 2014. “The Increasing Predictive Validity of Self-reported Health.” PLoS ONE9(1):e84933.
42.
SchrockDouglasSchwalbeMichael. 2009. “Men, Masculinity, and Manhood Acts.” Annual Review of Sociology35(1):277–95.
43.
SlevinKathleen F.2010. “‘If I Had Lots of Money . . . I’d Have a Body Makeover:’ Managing the Aging Body.” Social Forces88(3):1003–20.
44.
SmithTom W.DavernMichaelFreeseJeremyHoutMichael. 2017. General Social Surveys, 1972–2016: Cumulative Codebook (National Data Program for the Social Sciences Series, no. 24). Chicago: NORC.
45.
SpenceJanet T.BucknerCamille E.2000. “Instrumental and Expressive Traits, Trait Stereotypes, and Sexist Attitudes: What Do They Signify?”Psychology of Women Quarterly24(1):44–53.
46.
SpringerKristen W.MouzonDawne M.2011. “‘Macho Men’ and Preventive Health Care: Implications for Older Men in Different Social Classes.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior52(2):212–27.
47.
SpringerKristen W.StellmanJeanne MagerJordan-YoungRebecca M.2012. “Beyond a Catalogue of Differences: A Theoretical Frame and Good Practice Guidelines for Researching Sex/Gender in Human Health.” Social Science & Medicine74(11):1817–24.
48.
SumerauJ. E.MathersLain A. B.NowakowskiAlexandra C. H.CragunRyan T.2017. “Helping Quantitative Sociology Come out of the Closet.” Sexualities20(5–6):644–56.
49.
WängnerudLenaSolevidMariaDjerf-PierreMonika. Forthcoming. “Moving beyond Categorical Gender in Studies of Risk Aversion and Anxiety.” Politics & Gender.
50.
WeinbergJillFreeseJeremyMcElhattanDavid. 2014. “Comparing Data Characteristics and Results of an Online Factorial Survey between a Population-based and a Crowdsource-recruited Sample.” Sociological Science1:292–310.
WestbrookLaurelSapersteinAliya. 2015. “New Categories Are Not Enough: Rethinking the Measurement of Sex and Gender in Social Surveys.” Gender & Society29(4):534–60.
53.
WestbrookLaurelSchiltKristen. 2014. “Doing Gender, Determining Gender: Transgender People, Gender Panics, and the Maintenance of the Sex/Gender/Sexuality System.” Gender & Society28(1):32–57.
54.
WillerRobbRogalinChristabel L.ConlonBridgetWojnowiczMichael T.2013. “Overdoing Gender: A Test of the Masculine Overcompensation Thesis.” American Journal of Sociology118(4):980–1022.
55.
WylieSarah A.CorlissHeather L.BoulangerVanessaProkopLisa A.AustinBryn S.2010. “Socially Assigned Gender Nonconformity: A Brief Measure for Use in Surveillance and Investigation of Health Disparities.” Sex Roles63(3–4):264–76.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
