The term patient noncompliance emerged in the 1970s as a tool for analyzing why people do not follow medical directives. Despite its early popularity, the term has languished in sociology while flourishing in biomedical arenas. It seems flaccid in a contemporary healthcare context as it overestimates physician authority and is tone-deaf to biomedicalization. I draw from sociological and anthropological traditions, as well as qualitative interviews with terminally ill patients (N = 26) and their caregivers (N = 16), to consider facets of a biomedicalized health experience and implications for an updated vision of compliance. First, pathways to care have proliferated under biomedicalization. With increased pathways comes increased need for understanding how treatment plans are socially constituted and assessed. Finally, increased complexity demands a more diverse vocabulary for understanding health related decisions. This paper is a call to sociologists to take the lead in transforming and updating this consequential concept.
AldridgeMelissa D.HasselaarJeroenGarraldaEduardoEerdenMarlieke van derStevensonDavidMcKendrickKarenCentenoCarlosMeierDiane E.2016. “Education, Implementation, and Policy Barriers to Greater Integration of Palliative Care: A Literature Review.” Palliative Medicine30(3):224–39.
2.
AnspachRenee R.1997. Deciding Who Lives: Fateful Choices in the Intensive-care Nursery. Berkeley: University of California Press.
3.
ArnoldElizabethFinucaneAnne M.OxenhamDavid. 2015. “Preferred Place of Death for Patients Referred to a Specialist Palliative Care Service.” BMJ Supportive and Palliative Care5(3):294–96.
4.
BarkerKristin. 2010. “The Social Construction of Illness: Medicalization and Contested Illness.” Pp. 147–62 in The Handbook of Medical Sociology, 6th ed., edited by BirdC.ConradP.FremontA.TimmermansS.Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
5.
BartonJoshDewKevinDowellAnthonySheridanNicoletteKenealyTimothyMacdonaldLindsayDochertyBarbaraTesterRachelRaphaelDebbieGrayLesleyStubbeMaria. 2016. “Patient Resistance as a Resource: Candidate Obstacles in Diabetes Consultations.” Sociology of Health and Illness38(7):1151–66.
6.
BeckerGayJanson-BjerklieSusanBennerPatriciaSlobinKathleenFerketichSandra. 1993. “The Dilemma of Seeking Urgent Care: Asthma Episodes and Emergency Service Use.” Sociology of Health and Illness37(3):305–13.
7.
BergenClaraStiversTanya. 2013. “Patient Disclosure of Medical Misdeeds.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior54(2):221–40.
8.
BerwickDonald M.NolanThomas W.WhittingtonJohn. 2008. “The Triple Aim: Care, Health, and Cost.” Health Affairs27(3):759–69.
9.
BiehlJoaoLockePeter. 2010. “Deleuze and the Anthropology of Becoming.” Current Anthropology51(3):317–51.
10.
BrownMarie T.BussellJennifer K.2011. “Medication Adherence: Who Cares?”Mayo Clinic Proceedings86(4):304–14.
11.
ClarkeAdele E.ShimJanet K.2011. “Medicalization and Biomedicalization Revisited: Technoscience and Transformations of Health, Illness, and American Medicine.” Pp. 173–99 in Handbook of the Sociology of Health, Illness, and Healing, edited by PescosolidoB. A.MartinJ. K.McLeodJ. D.RogersA.New York: Springer.
12.
ClarkeAdele E.ShimJanet K.MamoLauraFosketJennifer RuthFishmanJennifer R.2003. “Biomedicalization: Technoscientific Transformations of Health, Illness, and U.S. Biomedicine.” American Sociological Review68(2):161–94.
13.
ConradPeter. 2005. “The Shifting Engines of Medicali-zation “Journal of Health and Social Behavior46(1):3–14.
14.
ConradPeter. 1985. “The Meaning of Medications: Another Look at Compliance.” Social Science & Medicine20(1):29–37.
15.
ConradPeter. 1987. “The Noncompliant Patient in Search of Autonomy.” Hastings Center Report17(4):15–17.
16.
DavisFred. 1963. Passage through Crisis: Polio Victims and Their Families. Indianapolis, IN: Bobbs-Merrill.
17.
DuttonDiana B.1986. “Social Class, Health, and Illness.” Pp. 31–62 in Applications of Social Science to Clinical Medicine and Health Policy, edited by AikenL.MechanicD.New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
18.
FischerStacyMinSung-JoonCervantesLiliaKutnerJean. 2013. “Where Do You Want to Spend Your Last Days of Life? Low Concordance between Preferred and Actual Site of Death among Hospitalized Adults.” Journal of Hospital Medicine8(4):178–83.
19.
FreeseJeremyLutfeyKaren E.2011. “Fundamental Causality: Challenges of an Animating Concept for Medical Sociology.” Pp. 67–81 in Handbook of the Sociology of Health, Illness, and Healing, edited by PescosolidoB. A.MartinJ. K.McLeodJ. D.RogersA.New York: Springer.
20.
Gage-BouchardElizabeth A.2017. “Culture, Styles of Institutional Interactions, and Inequalities in Healthcare Experiences.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior58(2):147–65.
21.
GenglerAmanda M.2014. ““I Want You to Save My Kid!”: Illness Management Strategies, Access, and Inequality at an Elite University Research Hospital.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior55(3):342–59.
22.
GillVirginia T.PomerantzAnitaDenvirPaul. 2010. “Pre-emptive Resistance: Patients’ Participation in Diagnostic Sense-making Activities.” Sociology of Health and Illness32(1):1–20.
23.
HaynesR. BryanSackettDavid L.1979. Compliance in Health Care. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
24.
HeritageJohnMaynardDouglas W.2006. “Problems and Prospects in the Study of Physician–Patient Interaction: 30 Years of Research.” Annual Review of Sociology32(15):1–24.
25.
HeritageJohnMaynardDouglas W.2011. “After 30 Years, Problems and Prospects in the Study of Doctor–Patient Interaction.” Pp. 323–42 in Handbook of the Sociology of Health, Illness and Healing, edited by PescosolidoB. A.MartinJ. K.McLeodJ. D.RogersA.New York: Springer.
26.
HillShirley. 1995. “Taking Charge and Making Do: Childhood Chronic Illness in Low-income Black Families.” Research in the Sociology of Health Care12:141–56.
27.
KaufmanSharon R.2009. “Making Longevity in an Aging Society: Linking Ethical Sensibility and Medicare Spending.” Medical Anthropology Quarterly28(4):317–25.
28.
KaufmanSharon R.2015. Ordinary Medicine: Extraordinary Treatments, Longer Lives, and Where to Draw the Line. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
29.
KeatingPeterCambrosioAlberto. 2012. Cancer on Trial: Oncology as a New Style of Practice. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
30.
LinkBruce G.PhelanJo C.1995. “Social Conditions as Fundamental Causes of Disease.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior 35(Extra Issue):80–94.
31.
LoPrestiMelissa A.DementFritzGoldHeather T.2014. “End-of-life Care for People with Cancer from Ethnic Minority Groups: A Systematic Review.” American Journal of Hospice and Palliative Medicine33(3):291–305.
32.
LutfeyKaren E.CampbellStephen M.RenfrewMegan R.MarceauLisa D.RolandMartinMcKinlayJohn B.2008. “How Are Patient Characteristics Relevant for Physicians’ Clinical Decision Making in Diabetes? An Analysis of Qualitative Results from a Cross-national Factorial Experiment.” Social Science & Medicine67(9):1391–99.
33.
LutfeyKaren E.FreeseJeremy. 2007. “Ambiguities of Chronic Illness Management and Challenges to the Medical Error Paradigm.” Social Science & Medicine64(2):314–25.
34.
LutfeyKaren E.WishnerWilliam J.1999. “Beyond ‘Compliance’ Is ‘Adherence’: Improving the Prospect of Diabetes Care.” Diabetes Care22(4):635–39.
35.
McKinlayJohn B.MarceauLisa D.2008. “When There Is No Doctor: Reasons for the Disappearance of Primary Care Physicians in the U.S. During the Early 21st Century.” Social Science & Medicine (67):1481–91.
36.
MrigEmily HammadSpencerKaren Lutfey. 2018. “Political Economy of Hope as a Cultural Facet of Biomedicalization: A Qualitative Examination of Constraints to Hospice Utilization Among U.S. End-stage Cancer Patients.” Social Science & Medicine200:107–13.
37.
MykhalovskiyEricMcCoyLizaBresalierMichael. 2004. “Compliance/Adherence, HIV, and the Critique of Medical Power.” Social Theory and Health2(4):315–40.
38.
National Consensus Project for Quality Palliative Care. 2013. Clinical Practice Guidelines for Quality Palliative Care, 3rd ed.Pittsburgh: Author.
39.
National Hospice and Palliative Care Organization. 2015. NHPCO’s Facts and Figures: Hospice Care in America. Alexandria, VA: Author.
40.
OrtnerSherry B.1995. “Resistance and the Problem of Ethnographic Refusal.” Comparative Studies in Society and History37(1):173–93.
41.
PescosolidoBernice A.2011. “Taking ‘the Promise’ Seriously: Medical Sociology’s Role in Health, Illness, and Healing in a Time of Social Change.” Pp. 3–20 in Handbook of the Sociology of Health, Illness, and Healing, edited by PescosolidoB. A.MartinJ. K.McLeodJ. D.RogersA.New York: Springer.
42.
PeyrotMarkMcMurryJames F.HedgesR.1987. “Living with Diabetes: The Role of Personal and Professional Knowledge in Symptom and Regimen Management.” Research in the Sociology of Health Care6:107–46.
43.
RajaramShireen S.1997. “Experience of Hypoglycemia among Insulin Dependent Diabetics and Its Impact on the Family.” Sociology of Health and Illness19(3):281–96.
44.
RosenstockIrwin M.1974. “The Health Belief Model and Preventive Health Behavior.” Health Education and Behavior2(4):354–86.
45.
ShimJanet K.RussAnn J.KaufmanSharon R.2008. “Late-life Cardiac Interventions and the Treatment Imperative.” PLoS Medicine5(3):e7. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.0050007
46.
ShimJanet K.2010. “Cultural Health Capital: A Theoretical Approach to Understanding Health Care Interactions and the Dynamics of Unequal Treatment.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior51(1):1–15.
47.
SoboElisa J.2015. “Social Cultivation of Vaccine Refusal and Delay among Waldorf (Steiner) School Parents.” Medical Anthropology Quarterly29(3):381-99.
48.
SoboElisa J.2016. “Theorizing (Vaccine) Refusal: Through the Looking Glass.” Cultural Anthropology31(3):342–50.
49.
StimsonGerry V.1974. “Obeying Doctor’s Orders: A View from the Other Side.” Social Science & Medicine8(2):97–104.
50.
StiversTanya. 2006. “Treatment Decisions: Negotiations between Doctors and Parents in Acute Care Encounters.” Pp. 279–312 in Communication in Medical Care: Interaction between Primary Care Physicians and Patients, edited by HeritageJ.MaynardD. W.Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
51.
StraussRobert. 1957. “The Nature and Status of Medical Sociology.” American Sociological Review22(2):200–204.
52.
SvarstadBonnie L.1986. “Patient–Practitioner Relationships and Compliance with Prescribed Medical Regimens.” Pp. 438–59 in Applications of Social Science to Clinical Medicine and Health Policy, edited by AikenL.MechanicD.New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University.
53.
TanassiLucia M.2004. “Compliance as Strategy: The Importance of Personalised Relations in Obstetric Practice.” Social Science & Medicine59(10):2053–69.
54.
TenoJoan M.GozaloPedro L.BynumJulie P. W.LelandNatalie E.MillerSusan C.MordenNancy E.ScuppThomasGoodman, and Vincent MorDavid C.2013. “Change in End-of-life Care for Medicare Beneficiaries: Site of Death, Place of Care, and Health Care Transitions in 2000, 2005, and 2009.” Journal of the American Medical Association309(5):470–77.
55.
TimmermansStefan. 2008. “Oh Look, There Is a Doctor after All: About the Resilience of Professional Medicine: A Commentary on McKinlay and Marceau’s ‘When There Is No Doctor.’” Social Science & Medicine67(10):1492–96.
56.
TimmermansStefanAlmelingRene. 2009. “Objectification, Standardization, and Commodification in Health Care: A Conceptual Readjustment.” Social Science & Medicine69(1):21–27.
57.
TimmermansStefanTavoryIddo. 2012. “Theory Construction in Qualitative Research: From Grounded Theory to Abductive Analysis.” Sociological Theory30(3):167–86.
58.
TrostleJames A.1997. “The History and Meaning of Patient Compliance as an Ideology.” Pp. 109–24 in Handbook of Health Behavior Research: Provider Determinants, edited by GrouchmanD. S.New York: Plenum Press.
59.
VermeireEtienne.HearnshawHilaryRoyenPaul VanDenekensJ.2001. “Patient Adherence to Treatment: Three Decades of Research. A Comprehensive Review.” Journal of Clinical Pharmacy and Therapeutics26(5):331–42.
60.
WeissErica. 2016. “Refusal as Act, Refusal as Abstention.” Cultural Anthropology31(3):351–58.
61.
WeissmanDavid E.MeierDiane E.2011. “Identifying Patients in Need of a Palliative Care Assessment in the Hospital Setting: A Consensus Report from the Center to Advance Palliative Care.” Journal of Palliative Medicine14(1):17–23.
