According to Bird and Rieker’s sociology of constrained choices, decisions and priorities concerning health are shaped by the contexts—including policy, community, and work/family—in which they are formulated. While each level received attention in the original and subsequent research, we contend their constrained choices theory provides a powerful multilevel framework for modeling health outcomes. We apply this framework to tobacco clean air restrictions, combining a comprehensive database of tobacco policies with the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth 1997 from ages 19 to 31. Using multilevel panel models, we find that clean air policies lower the odds of past 30 day smoking and dependence while controlling for other policy-, city-, and individual-level constraints. We also find unique between- and within-person effects, as well as gender effects, for the constraint levied by smoking bans. We argue for the theory’s broad applicability beyond commonly cited findings regarding gender and biological influences.
AltschulerAndreaSomkinCarol P.AdlerNancy E.2004. “Local Services and Amenities, Neighborhood Social Capital, and Health.”Social Science & Medicine59(6):1219–29.
2.
Astell-BurtThomasMaynardMaria J.LenguerrandErikWhitrowMelissa J.MolaodiOarabile R.HardingSeeromanie. 2013. “Effect of Air Pollution and Racism on Ethnic Differences in Respiratory Health among Adolescents Living in an Urban Environment.”Health & Place23:171–78.
3.
BachmanJerald G.WadsworthKatherine N.O’MalleyPatrick M.JohnstonLloyd D.SchulenbergJohn E.1997. Smoking, Drinking, and Drug Use in Young Adulthood: The Impacts of New Freedoms and Responsibilities. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
4.
BayerRonaldStuberJennifer. 2006. “Tobacco Control, Stigma, and Public Health: Rethinking the Relations.”American Journal of Public Health96(1):47–50.
5.
BienerLoisHamiltonWilliam L.SiegelMichaelSullivanEileen M.2010. “Individual, Social-normative, and Policy Predictors of Smoking Cessation: A Multilevel Longitudinal Analysis.”American Journal of Public Health100(3):547–54.
6.
BellKirstenSalmonAmyBowersMicheleBellJenniferMcCulloughLucy. 2010. “Smoking, Stigma, and Tobacco ‘Denormalization’: Further Reflections on the Use of Stigma as a Public Health Tool.”Social Science & Medicine70(6):795–9.
7.
BirdChloe E.1997. “Gender Differences in the Social and Economic Burdens of Parenting and Psychological Distress.”Journal of Marriage and Family59(4):809–23.
8.
BirdChloe E.RiekerPatricia P.2008. Gender and Health: The Effects of Constrained Choices and Social Policies. New York: Cambridge University Press.
9.
BoardmanJason D.BlalockCasey L.PampelFred C.2010. “Trends in the Genetic Influences on Smoking.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior51(1):108–23.
10.
BrandtAllan M.1998. “Blow Some My Way: Passive Smoking, Risk, and American Culture.” Pp. 164–87 in Ashes to Ashes: The History of Smoking and Health, edited by LockS.ReynoldsL.TanseyE. M.Amsterdam: Rodopi.
11.
BrownSusan L.RinelliLauren N.2010. “Family Structure, Family Processes, and Adolescent Smoking and Drinking.”Journal of Research on Adolescence20(2):259–73.
12.
BrowningChristopher R.CagneyKathleen A.2002. “Neighborhood Structural Disadvantage, Collective Efficacy, and Self-rated Physical Health in an Urban Setting.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior43(4):383–99.
13.
BrowningChristopher R.SollerBrianGardnerMargoBrooks-GunnJeanne. 2013. “‘Feeling Disorder’ as a Comparative and Contingent Process: Gender, Neighborhood Conditions, and Adolescent Mental Health.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior54(3):296–314.
14.
CarpianoRichard. 2006. “Towards a Neighborhood Resource-based Theory of Social Capital for Health: Can Bourdieu and Sociology Help?” Social Science & Medicine62(1):165–75.
15.
ChahineTeresaSubramanianS. V.LevyJonathan I.2011. “Sociodemographic and Geographic Variability in Smoking in the U.S.: A Multilevel Analysis of the 2006–2007 Current Population Survey, Tobacco Use Supplement.”Social Science & Medicine73(5):752–8.
16.
CullatiStephaneCourvoisierDelphine S.Burton-JeangrosClaudine. 2014. “Mental Health Trajectories and Their Embeddedness in Work and Family Circumstances: A Latent State-trait Approach to Life-course Trajectories.”Sociology of Health & Illness36(7):1077–94.
17.
DedobbeleerNicoleBélandFrançoisContandriopoulosAndré-PierreAdrianManuella. 2004. “Gender and the Social Context of Smoking Behavior.”Social Science & Medicine58(1):1–12.
18.
DupéréVéroniqueLeventhalTamaVitaroFrank. 2012. “Neighborhood Processes, Self-efficacy, and Adolescent Mental Health.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior53(2):183–98.
19.
EnnettSusan T.FlewellingRobert L.LindroothRichard C.NortonEdward C.1997. “School and Neighborhood Characteristics Associated with School Rates of Alcohol, Cigarette, and Marijuana Use.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior38(1):55–71.
20.
EvensonRanae J.SimonRobin W.2005. “Clarifying the Relationship between Parenthood and Depression.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior46(4):341–58.
21.
EwingReidMeakinsGailHamidiShimaNelsonArthur C.2014. “Relationship between Urban Sprawl and Physical Activity, Obesity, and Morbidity—Update and Refinement.”Health & Place26:118–26.
22.
FanWenLamJackMoenPhyllisKellyErinKingRosalindMcHaleSusan. 2015. “Constrained Choices? Linking Employees’ and Spouses’ Work Time to Health Behaviors.”Social Science & Medicine126:99–109.
23.
FichtenbergCaroline M.GlantzStanton A.2002. “Effect of Smoke-free Workplaces on Smoking Behaviour: Systematic Review.”British Medical Journal325:1–7.
24.
FlemingCharles B.WhiteHelene R.CatalanoRichard F.2010. “Romantic Relationships and Substance Use in Early Adulthood: An Examination of the Influences of Relationship Type, Partner Substance Use, and Relationship Quality.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior51(2):153–67.
25.
FloodSarah M.MoenPhyllis. 2015. “Health Time Use in the Encore Years: Do Work, Resources, Relations, and Gender Matter?” Journal of Health and Social Behavior56(1):74–97.
26.
FriendKaren B.Lipperman-KredaSharonGrubeJoel W.2011. “The Impact of Local U.S. Tobacco Policies on Youth Tobacco Use: A Critical Review.”Open Journal of Preventative Medicine1(2):34–43.
27.
FriestadChristinePirkisJaneBiehlMichaelIrwinCharles E.2003. “Socioeconomic Patterning of Smoking, Sedentary Lifestyle, and Overweight Status among Adolescents in Norway and the United States.”Journal of Adolescent Health33(4):275–8.
28.
FrohlichKatherine L.AbelThomas. 2014. “Environmental Justice and Health Practices: Understanding How Health Inequalities Arise at the Local Level.”Sociology of Health & Illness36(2):199–212.
29.
GoldsteinHarvey. 1999. Multilevel Statistical Models. London: Institute of Education.
30.
GormanBridget K.ReadJen’nan GhazalKruegerPatrick M.2010. “Gender, Acculturation, and Health among Mexican Americans.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior51(4):440–57.
31.
HankivskyOlena. 2012. “Women’s Health, Men’s Health, and Gender and Health: Implications of Intersectionality.”Social Science & Medicine74(11):1712–20.
32.
HillTerrence D.NeedhamBelinda L.2013. “Rethinking Gender and Mental Health: A Critical Analysis of Three Propositions.”Social Science & Medicine92:83–91.
33.
HoJessica Y.FenelonAndrew. 2015. “The Contribution of Smoking to Educational Gradients in U.S. Life Expectancy.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior56(3):307–22.
34.
JohnsonMonica Kirkpatrick. 2004. “Further Evidence on Adolescent Employment and Substance Use: Differences by Race and Ethnicity.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior45(2):187–97.
35.
JohnsonRobert A.HoffmannJohn P.2000. “Adolescent Cigarette Smoking in U.S. Racial/Ethnic Subgroups: Findings from the National Education Longitudinal Study.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior41(4):392–407.
36.
KellyBrian C.2009. “Smoke-free Air Policy: Subcultural Shifts and Secondary Health Effects among NYC Club-going Youth.”Sociology of Health & Illness31(4):569–82.
37.
KilloranAmandaOwenLesleyBauldLinda. 2006. “Smoking Cessation: An Evidence-based Approach to Tackling Health Inequalities?” Pp. 341–62 in Public Health Evidence: Tackling Health Inqualities, edited by KilloranA.SwannC.KellyM. P.New York: Oxford.
38.
KleinElizabeth G.ForsterJean L.EricksonDarin J.LytleLeslie A.SchilloBarbara. 2009. “The Relationship between Local Clean Indoor Air Policies and Smoking Initiation in Minnesota Youth.”Tobacco Control18(2):132–7.
39.
KnutssonAnders. 2003. “Health Disorders of Shift Workers.”Occupational Medicine43(2):103–08.
40.
LeclereFelicia B.RogersRichard G.PetersKimberley. 1998. “Neighborhood Social Context and Racial Differences in Women’s Heart Disease Mortality.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior39(2):91–107.
41.
LevyDavid T.RomanoEduardoMumfordElizabeth. 2005. “The Relationship of Smoking Cessation to Sociodemographic Characteristics, Smoking Intensity, and Tobacco Control Policies.”Nicotine & Tobacco Research7(3):387–96.
42.
LinkBruce G.PhelanJo. 1995. “Social Conditions as Fundamental Causes of Disease.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior35(Extra Issue):80–94.
43.
MargolisRachel. 2013. “Educational Differences in Healthy Behavior Changes and Adherence among Middle-aged Americans.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior54(3):353–68.
44.
MastersRyan K.LinkBruce G.PhelanJo C.2015. “Trends in Education Gradients of ‘Preventable’ Mortality: A Test of Fundamental Cause Theory.”Social Science & Medicine127:19–28.
45.
McMullenKathleen M.BrownsonRoss C.LukeDouglasChriquiJamie. 2005. “Strength of Clean Indoor Air Laws and Smoking Related Outcomes in the USA.”Tobacco Control14(1):34–48.
46.
MeijerMathaisRohlJeanetteBloomfieldKimGrittnerUlrike. 2012. “Do Neighborhoods Affect Individual Mortality? A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Multilevel Studies.”Social Science & Medicine74(8):1204–12.
47.
MortimerJeylan T.HarleyCarolynStaffJeremy. 2002. “The Quality of Work and Youth Mental Health.”Work and Occupations29(2):166–97.
48.
NeedhamBelindaHillTerrence D.2010. “Do Gender Differences in Mental Health Contribute to Gender Differences in Physical Health?” Social Science & Medicine71(8):1472–9.
49.
PampelFred C.2001. “Cigarette Diffusion and Sex Differences in Smoking.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior42(4):388–404.
50.
PampelFred C.2008. “Racial Convergence in Cigarette Use from Adolescence to the Mid-Thirties.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior49(4):484–98.
51.
PampelFred C.MollbornStefanieLawrenceElizabeth M.2014. “Life Course Transitions in Early Adulthood and SES Disparities in Tobacco Use.”Social Science Research43:45–59.
52.
PayneSarah. 2014. “Constructing the Gendered Body? A Critical Discourse Analysis of Gender Equality Schemes in the Health Sector in England.”Current Sociology62(7):956–74.
53.
ReadJen’nanGormanBridget K.2010. “Gender and Health Inequality.”Annual Review of Sociology36:371–86.
54.
RobertStephanie A.1999. “Socioeconomic Position and Health: The Independent Contribution of Community Socioeconomic Context.”Annual Review of Sociology25:489–516.
55.
RossCatherine E.MirowskyJohn. 2009. “Neighborhood Disorder, Subjective Alienation, and Distress.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior50(1):49–64.
56.
RossCatherine E.MirowskyJohnGoldsteenKaren. 1990. “The Impact of the Family on Health: The Decade in Review.”Journal of Marriage and the Family52(4):1059–78.
57.
SampsonRobert J.MorenoffJeffrey D.Gannon-RowleyThomas. 2002. “Assessing ‘Neighborhood Effects’: Social Processes and New Directions in Research.”Annual Review of Sociology28:443–78.
58.
SchulenbergJohn E.BachmanJerald G.O’MalleyPatrick M.JohnstonLloyd D.1994. “High School Educational Success and Subsequent Substance Use: A Panel Analysis Following Adolescents into Young Adulthood.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior35(1):45–62.
ShipanCharles R.VoldenCraig. 2006. “Bottom-up Federalism: The Diffusion of Antismoking Policies from U.S. Cities to States.”American Journal of Political Science50(4):825–43.
61.
SiegelMichaelAlbersAlison B.ChengDebbie M.BienerLoisRigottiNancy A.2004. “Effect of Local Restaurant Smoking Regulations on Environmental Tobacco Smoke Exposure among Youths.”American Journal of Public Health94(2):321–5.
62.
SoteriadesElpidoforos S.DiFranzaJoseph R.2003. “Parents’ Socioeconomic Status, Adolescents’ Disposable Income, and Adolescents’ Smoking Status in Massachusetts.”American Journal of Public Health93(7):1155–60.
63.
SwanGary E.JavitzHarold S.JackLisa M.CurrySusan J.McAfeeTim. 2004. “Heterogeneity in 12-month Outcome among Female and Male Smokers.”Addiction99(2):237–50.
64.
TaylorShelley E.RepettiRena L.1997. “Health Psychology: What Is an Unhealthy Environment and How Does It Get under the Skin?” Annual Review of Psychology48:411–47.
65.
UmbersonDebraWilliamsKristiPowersDaniel A.LiuHuiNeedhamBelinda. 2006. “You Make Me Sick: Marital Quality and Health over the Life Course.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior47(1):1–16.
66.
UmbersonDebraWilliamsKristiThomasPatricia A.LiuHuiThomeerMieke Beth. 2014. “Race, Gender, and Chains of Disadvantage: Childhood Adversity, Social Relationships, and Health.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior55(1):20–38.
67.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. 2010. How Tobacco Smoke Causes Disease: The Biology and Behavioral Basis for Smoking-Attributable Disease: A Report of the Surgeon General. Rockville, MD: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
68.
VuoloMike. 2012. “Placing Deviance in a Legal and Local Context: A Multilevel Analysis of Cigarette Use in the European Union.”Social Forces90(4):1377–402.
69.
WarrMark. 2002. Companions in Crime: The Social Aspects of Criminal Conduct. New York: Cambridge University Press.
70.
WenMingBrowningChristopher R.CagneyKathleen A.2003. “Poverty, Affluence, and Income Inequality: Neighborhood Economic Structure and Its Implications for Health.”Social Science & Medicine57(5):843–60.
71.
WillsThomas AshbyReskoJody A.AinetteMichael G.MendozaDon. 2004. “Smoking Onset in Adolescence: A Person-centered Analysis with Time-varying Predictors.”Health Psychology23(2):158–67.
72.
YangYang. 2010. “Aging, Cohorts, and Methods.” Pp. 17–30 in Handbook of Aging and the Social Sciences. 7th ed., edited by BinstockR. H.GeorgeL. K.New York: Academic Press.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
